Security studies has been slow to accept critical challenges to its problematic, and these have often been met with hostility and deliberately marginalized. This article responds to some of the critiques, and outlines the main elements of a critical engagement with security studies. It discusses the intellectual and `disciplining' power of rationalist and neorealist security studies scholarship, and highlights some of the practices that marginalize critical scholarship. It then overviews the rich and diverse threads of current research within `critical security studies', and emphasizes the central themes of its research agenda: how threats and appropriate responses are constructed; how the `objects' of security are constructed; and what the possibilities are for the transformation of `security dilemmas'. It summarizes the six central claims (concerning the constitution of the actors of world politics, its dynamic and constructed nature, the concomitant epistemological claims and methodological tools, and the purpose of theorizing) that are the hallmark of a critical approach to security studies. Finally, it clarifies what these claims do and do not entail for research and practice in international security studies.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adler, Emanuel
(1992a) `Europe's New Security Order: A Pluralistic Security Community', in B. Crawford (ed.) The Future of European Security, pp. 287-326. Berkeley: University of California, Center for German and European Studies.
2.
Adler, Emanuel
(1992b) `The Emergence of Cooperation: National Epistemic Communities and the International Evolution of the Idea of Nuclear Arms Control', International Organization46(1): 101-146.
Adler, Emanuel
(1997) `Seizing the Middle Ground: Constructivism in World Politics', European Journal of International Relations3(3): 319-363.
5.
Adler, Emanuel
and Barnett, Michael (1996) `Governing Anarchy: A Research Agenda for the Study of Security Communities', paper presented at the annual conference of the International Studies Association, San Diego.
6.
Adler, Emanuel
and Barnett, Michael (1998) Security Communities. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
7.
Ayoob, Mohammed
(1997) `Defining Security: A Subaltern Realist Perspective', in K. Krause and M. C. Williams (eds) Critical Security Studies, pp. 121-146. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
8.
Bagby, Laurie
(1994) `The Use and Abuse of Thucydides in International Relations', International Organization48(1): 131-153.
9.
Baldwin, David
(1995) `Security Studies and the End of the Cold War', World Politics48(1): 117-141.
10.
Baldwin, David
(1997) `The Concept of Security', Review of International Studies23(1): 5-26.
11.
Barkin, J. Samuel
and Cronin, Bruce (1994) `The State and the Nation: Changing Norms and the Rules of Sovereignty in International Relations', International Organization48(1): 107-130.
12.
Biersteker, Thomas
and Weber, Cynthia (eds) (1996) The Social Construction of Sovereignty. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
13.
Booth, Ken
(1997) `Security and Self: Reflections of a Fallen Realist', in K. Krause and M. C. Williams (eds) Critical Security Studies, pp. 83-119. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
14.
Buzan, Barry
(1991) People, States and Fear, 2nd ed.London: Harvester Wheatsheaf.
15.
Campbell, David
(1992) Writing Security: United States Foreign Policy and the Politics of Identity. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
16.
Chilton, Paul
(ed.) (1985) Language and the Nuclear Arms Debate. London: Pinter.
17.
Chilton, Paul
(1987) `Metaphor, Euphemism and the Militarization of Language', Current Research on Peace and Violence10(1): 7-19.
18.
Chilton, Paul
(1996) Security Metaphors: Cold War Discourse from Containment to Common House. New York: Peter Lang.
19.
Chilton, Paul
and Llyin, M. (1993) `Metaphor in Political Discourse: The Case of the “Common European House” ', Discourse and Society4(1): 7-31.
20.
Christensen, Thomas
and Snyder, Jack (1990) `Chain Gangs and Passed Bucks: Predicting Alliance Patterns in Multipolarity', International Organization44(2): 137-168.
21.
Cohn, Carol
(1987) `Sex and Death in the Rational World of Defense Intellectuals', Signs12(4): 687-718.
22.
Cohn, Carol
(1996) `Gender Studies in International Relations', unpublished paper.
23.
Cox, Robert
(1986) `Social Forces, States and World Orders: Beyond International Relations Theory', in R. Keohane (ed.) Neorealism and its Critics, pp. 204-254. New York: Columbia University Press.
24.
Crawford, Beverly
and Lipschutz, Ronnie (1997) `Discourses of War: Security and the Case of Yugoslavia', in K. Krause and M. C. Williams (eds) Critical Security Studies, pp. 149-185. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
25.
Dalby, Simon
(1990) Creating the Second Cold War: The Discourse of Politics. London: Pinter.
26.
Der Derian, James
(1992) Antidiplomacy. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
27.
Der Derian, James
(1993) `The Value of Security: Hobbes, Marx, Nietzsche, and Baudrillard', in D. Campbell and M. Dillon (eds) The Political Subject of Violence, pp. 94-113. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
28.
Der Derian, James
(1994) `The Pen, The Sword, and the Smart Bomb: Criticism in the Age of Video', Alternatives19: 133-140.
29.
Der Derian, James
(forthcoming) Virtual Security. New York: Free Press.
30.
Deudney, Daniel
(1990) `The Case Against Linking Environmental Degradation and National Security', Millennium19(3): 161-176.
31.
Deudney, Daniel
(1995) `The Philadelphian System: Sovereignty, Arms Control, and Balance of Power in the American States-Union, circa 1787-1861', International Organization49(2): 191-228.
32.
Deutsch, Karl
, et al. (1957) Political Community and the North Atlantic Area. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
33.
Dewitt, David
(1994) `Common, Comprehensive and Cooperative Security', The Pacific Review7(1): 1-15.
34.
Diebert, Ronald
(1996) `Typographica: The Medium and the Medieval-to-Modern Transformation', Review of International Studies22(1): 29-56.
35.
Dillon, G. M.
(1989) `Modernity, Discourse and Deterrence', Current Research on Peace and Violence12(2): 90-104.
36.
Dorff, Robert
(1994) `A Commentary on Security Studies for the 1990s As a Model Core Curriculum', International Studies Notes19: 23-31.
37.
Doty, Roxanne
(1993) `Foreign Policy as Social Construction: A Post-positivist Analysis of U.S. Counterinsurgency Policy in the Philippines', International Studies Quarterly37(3): 297-320.
38.
Elman, Colin
and Elman, Miriam Fendius (1995) `Correspondence: History vs. Neo-realism: A Second Look', International Security, 20(1): 182-193.
39.
Elshtain, Jean
(1987) Women and War. New York: Basic Books.
40.
Elshtain, Jean Bethke
(1992) `Sovereignty, Identity, Sacrifice', in V. Spike Peterson (ed.) Gendered States, pp. 141-154. Boulder: Lynne Reinner.
41.
Enloe, Cynthia
(1989) Bananas, Beaches and Bases: Making Feminist Sense of International Politics. London: Pandora.
42.
Enloe, Cynthia
(1993) The Morning After: Sexual Politics at the End of the Cold War. Berkeley: University of California Press.
43.
Falk, Jim
(1989) `The Discursive Shaping of Nuclear Militarism', Current Research on Peace and Violence, 12(2): 53-76.
44.
Fay, Brian
(1975) Social Theory and Political Practice. London: George Allen and Unwin.
45.
Fierke, Karin
(1997) `Changing Worlds of Security Studies', in K. Krause and M. C. Williams (eds) Critical Security Studies, pp. 223-252. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
46.
Fierke, Karin
(1998) Dismantling the Cold War. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
47.
Gaddis, John Lewis
(1982) Strategies of Containment. New York: Oxford University Press.
48.
Gat, Azar
(1989) The Origins of Military Thought. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
49.
Gat, Azar
(1992) The Development of Military Thought: The Nineteenth Century. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
50.
Gizewski, Peter
and Homer-Dixon, Thomas (1995) Urban Growth and Violence: Will the Future Resemble the Past? Project on Environment, Population and Security. Toronto: University of Toronto.
51.
Gleick, Peter
(1993) `Water and Conflict: Fresh Water Resources and International Security', International Security18(1): 79-112.
52.
Gould, Stephen Jay
(1989) Wonderful Life. New York: Norton.
53.
Grant, Rebecca
(1992) `The Quagmire of Gender and International Relations', in V. Spike Peterson (ed.) Gendered States, pp. 83-97. Boulder: Lynne Reinner, 1992.
54.
Grant, Rebecca
(1996) `Feminist Approaches to Security', unpublished paper.
55.
Gray, Colin
(1995) Villains, Victims and Sheriffs: Security Studies and Security for an Inter-War Period. Hull: University of Hull Press.
56.
Gregory, Donna
(1989) `The Dictator's Furnace: Metaphor and Alchemy in National Security Discourse', Current Research on Peace and Violence12(2): 47-52.
57.
Grieco, Joseph
(1988) `Anarchy and the Limits of Cooperation: A Realist Critique of the Newest Liberal Institutionalism', International Organization42: 485-507.
58.
Haftendorn, Helga
(1991) `The Security Puzzle: Theory-Building and Discipline-Building in International Security', International Studies Quarterly35(1): 3-17.
59.
Hall, Rodney Bruce
and Kratochwil, Friedrich (1993) `Medieval Tales: Neo-Realist “Science” and the Abuse of History', International Organization47(4): 479-500.
60.
Hartsock, Nancy
(1989) `Masculinity, Heroism and the Making of War', in A. Harris and Y. King (eds) Rocking the Ship of State: Towards a Feminist Peace Politics, pp. 133-152. Boulder: Westview Press.
61.
Hellmann, Gunther
and Wolf, Reinhard (1993) `Neorealism, Neoliberal Institutionalism, and the Future of NATO', Security Studies3(1): 3-43.
62.
Hollis, Martin
and Smith, Steve (1991) Explaining and Understanding International Relations. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
63.
Homer-Dixon, Thomas
(1991) `On the Threshold: Environmental Changes as Causes of Acute Conflict', International Security16(2): 76-116.
64.
Homer-Dixon, Thomas
(1994) `Environmental Scarcities and Violent Conflict: Evidence from Cases', International Security19(1): 5-40.
65.
Hurrell, Andrew
(1992) `Collective Security and International Order Revisited', International Relations11(1): 37-55.
66.
Huysmans, Jef
(1995) `Migrants as a Security Problem: Dangers of “Securitizing” Societal Issues', in R. Miles and D. Thränhardt (eds) Migration and European Integration, pp. 53-72. London: Pinter, 1995.
67.
Independent Commission on Disarmament and Security Issues (Palme Commission)
(1992) Common Security: A Blueprint for Survival. New York: Simon and Schuster.
68.
Jepperson, Ronald
, Wendt, Alexander and Katzenstein, Peter (1996) `Norms, Identity, and Culture in National Security', in P. Katzenstein (ed.) The Culture of National Security: Norms and Identity in World Politics, pp. 33-75. New York: Columbia University Press.
69.
Jervis, Robert
(1978) `Cooperation Under the Security Dilemma', World Politics30(2): 167-214.
70.
Katzenstein, Peter
(ed.) (1996) The Culture of National Security: Norms and Identity in World Politics. New York: Columbia University Press.
71.
Kaufman, Robert
(1992a) `To Balance or to Bandwagon? Alignment Decisions in 1930s Europe', Security Studies1: 417-447.
72.
Kaufman, Robert
(1992b) `The Lessons of the 1930s, Alliance Theory, and U.S. Grand Strategy: A Reply to Stephen Walt', Security Studies1: 690-696.
73.
Keohane, Robert
(ed.) (1986) Neorealism and its Critics. New York: Columbia University Press.
74.
Keohane, Robert O.
(1988) `International Institutions: Two Approaches', International Studies Quarterly32(3): 379-396.
75.
Khattak, Saba Gul
(1996) `Security Discourses and the State in Pakistan', Alternatives21(3): 341-362.
76.
King, Gary
, Keohane, Robert O. and Verba, Sidney (1994) Designing Social Inquiry: Scientific Inference in Qualitative Research. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
77.
Klein, Bradley
(1990) `How the West was One: Representational Politics of NATO', International Studies Quarterly34(3): 311-325.
78.
Klein, Bradley
(1994) Strategic Studies and World Order. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
79.
Krause, Keith
(1998) `Cross-Cultural Dimensions of Multilateral Non-Proliferation and Arms Control Dialogues: An Overview', Contemporary Security Policy19(1): 1-22.
80.
Krause, Keith
and Williams, Michael C. (1996) `Broadening the Agenda of Security Studies: Politics and Methods', Mershon International Studies Review40(2): 229-254.
81.
Krause, Keith
and Williams, M. C. (1997) `From Strategy to Security: Foundations of Critical Security Studies', in K. Krause and M. C. Williams (eds) Critical Security Studies, pp. 33-59. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
82.
Kupchan, Charles
and Kupchan, Clifford (1991) `Concerts, Collective Security, and the Future of Europe', International Security16(1): 114-161.
83.
Lapid, Yosef
and Kratochwil, Friedrich (1996) `Revisiting the “National”: Toward an Identity Agenda in Neorealism?' in Y. Lapid and F. Kratochwil (eds) The Return of Culture and Identity in IR Theory, pp. 105-126. Boulder: Lynne Reinner.
84.
Leffler, Melvyn P.
(1992) A Preponderance of Power. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
85.
Levy, Marc A.
(1995a) `Time for a Third Wave of Environment and Security Scholarship', Environmental Change and Security Project Report, Woodrow Wilson Center, 1: 44-46.
86.
Levy, Marc A.
(1995b) `Is the Environment a National Security Issue?'International Security20(2): 35-62.
87.
Lowi, Miriam
(1993) `Bridging the Divide: Transboundary Resource Disputes and the Case of West Bank Water', International Security18(1): 113-138.
88.
Luke, Timothy
(1989) `What's Wrong with Deterrence? A Semiotic Interpretation of National Security Policy', in J. Der Derian and M. Shapiro (eds) International/Intertextual Relations, pp. 207-229. Lexington: Lexington Books.
89.
Lynn-Jones, Sean
(1995) `Offense-Defense Theory and its Critics', Security Studies4(4): 660-691.
McSweeney, Bill
(1996) `Identity and Security: Buzan and the Copenhagen School', Review of International Studies22(1): 81-93.
92.
Mearsheimer, John
(1990) `Back to the Future: Instability in Europe after the Cold War', International Security15(1): 5-56.
93.
Mearsheimer, John
(1994/95) `The False Promise of International Institutions', International Security19(3): 5-49.
94.
Mearsheimer, John
(1995) `A Realist Reply', International Security20(1): 82-93.
95.
Mehan, Hugh
, Nathanson, Charles and Skelly James (1990) `Nuclear Discourse in the 1980s: Unravelling the Conventions of the Cold War', Discourse and Society1(2): 133-165.
96.
Milliken, Jennifer
(1998) `Identity and Intervention: Reconstructing the West in Korea', in J. Weldes, M. Laffey, H. Gusterson and R. Duvall (eds) Cultures of Insecurity: States, Communities and the Production of Danger. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
97.
Milner, Helen
(1993) `The Assumption of Anarchy in International Relations Theory: A Critique', in D. Baldwin (ed.) Neorealism and Neoliberalism: The Contemporary Debate, pp. 143-169. New York: Columbia University Press.
98.
Mische, Patricia
(1989) `Ecological Security and the Need to Reconceptualize Sovereignty', Alternatives14(4): 389-427.
99.
Moran, Theodore
(1990/91) `International Economics and National Security', Foreign Affairs69(5): 74-90.
100.
Morgenthau, Hans
(1960) `Death in the Nuclear Age', in H. Morgenthau (ed.) Politics in the Twentieth Century, vol. 3, pp. 19-28. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
101.
Muppidi, Himadeep
(1998) `The Production of Insecurity in a Post-Colonial State', in J. Weldes, M. Laffey, H. Gusterson and R. Duvall (eds) Cultures of Insecurity: States, Communities and the Production of Danger. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
102.
Mutimer, David
(1997) `Reimagining Security: The Metaphors of Proliferation', in K. Krause and M. C. Williams (eds) Critical Security Studies, pp. 187-221. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
103.
Mutimer, David
(forthcoming) The Weapons State: Proliferation and the Imagination of Security. Boulder: Lynne Reinner.
104.
Myers, Norman
(1993) Ultimate Security: The Environmental Basis of Political Stability. New York: Norton.
105.
Nathanson, Charles
(1988) `The Social Construction of the Soviet Threat: A Study in the Politics of Representation', Alternatives13: 443-483.
106.
Neufeld, Mark
(1993) `Interpretation and the “Science” of International Relations', Review of International Studies19(1): 39-62.
107.
Neumann, Iver
(1998) `Europe's Others: Russia', in Iver Neumann, Uses of the Other. The “East” in European Identity Formation. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
108.
Neumann, Iver
and Welsh, Jennifer (1991) `The Other in European Self-identification', Review of International Studies17: 327-348.
109.
Nye, Joseph
and Lynn-Jones, Sean (1988) `International Security Studies: A Report of a Conference on the State of the Field', International Security12(1): 5-27.
110.
Pasha, Mustapha Kamal
(1996) `Security as Hegemony', Alternatives21(3): 283-302.
111.
Percival, Valerie
and Homer-Dixon, Thomas (1995) Environmental Scarcity and Violent Conflict: The Case of Rwanda. Project on Environment, Population and Security. Toronto: University of Toronto.
112.
Peterson, V. Spike
(ed.) (1992) Gendered States. Boulder: Lynne Reinner.
113.
Peterson, V. Spike
(1996) `Gender, Security, and Postmodernity', unpublished paper.
114.
Posen, Barry
(1993a) `The Security Dilemma and Ethnic Conflict', Survival35(1): 27-47.
115.
Posen, Barry
(1993b) `Nationalism, the Mass Army and Military Power', International Security18(2): 80-124.
116.
Ramsburg, Marty
and Morgan, Patrick (1996) `Security in International Politics and the Feminist Critique: A Debate'. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the International Studies Association, San Diego.
117.
Ricoeur, Paul
(1978) `Explanation and Understanding: On Some Remarkable Connections Among the Theory of the Text, Theory of Action, and Theory of History', in C. Reagan and D. Stewart (eds) The Philosophy of Paul Ricoeur. Boston: Beacon Press.
118.
Roberts, Brad
(1990) `Human Rights and International Security', Washington Quarterly13(2): 65-75.
119.
Ruggie, John
(ed.) (1993a) Multilateralism Matters. New York: Columbia University Press.
120.
Ruggie, John
(1993b) `Territoriality and Beyond: Problematizing Modernity in International Relations', International Organization47(1): 139-174.
121.
Schroeder, Paul
(1994) `Historical Reality vs. Neorealist Theory', International Security19(1): 108-148.
122.
Schroeder, Paul
(1995) `Correspondence: History vs. Neo-realism: A Second Look', International Security20(1): 193-195.
123.
Schultz, Richard
, Godson, Roy and Greenwood, Ted (eds) (1993) Security Studies for the 1990s. New York: Brassey's.
124.
Sharoni, Simona
(1995) Gender and the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict. Syracuse: Syracuse University Press.
125.
Shy, John
(1986) `Jomini', in P. Paret (ed.) Makers of Modern Strategy, pp. 143-185. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
126.
Taylor, Charles
(1985) Philosophical Papers, vols. 1 and 2. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
127.
Tennberg, Monica
(1995) `Risky Business: Defining the Concept of Environmental Security', Cooperation and Conflict30(3): 239-258.
128.
Thomas, Caroline
(1987) In Search of Security: The Third World in International Relations. Boulder, CO: Lynne Reinner.
129.
Tickner, J. Ann
(1992) Gender in International Relations: Feminist Perspectives on Achieving Global Security. New York: Columbia University Press.
130.
Tickner, J. Ann
(1996) `Gender and International Security: Is Dialogue Possible?' Unpublished paper.
131.
Ullman, Richard
(1983) `Redefining Security', International Security8(1): 129-153.
132.
Van Evera, Stephen
(1994) `Hypotheses on Nationalism and War', International Security18(1): 5-39.
133.
Walker, R. B. J.
(1990) `Security, Sovereignty and the Challenge of World Politics', Alternatives15(1): 3-27.
134.
Walt, Stephen M.
(1985) `Alliance Formation and the Balance of World Power', International Security9(4): 3-43.
135.
Walt, Stephen M.
(1987) The Origins of Alliances. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
136.
Walt, Stephen
(1991) `The Renaissance of Security Studies', International Studies Quarterly35: 211-239.
137.
Walt, Stephen M.
(1992) `Alliances, Threats and U.S. Grand Strategy', Security Studies1: 448-482.
138.
Waltz, Kenneth
(1959) Man, the State and War. New York: Columbia University Press.
139.
Waltz, Kenneth
(1979) Theory of International Politics. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
140.
Waltz, Kenneth
, (1986) `Reflections on Theory of International Politics: A Response to My Critics', in R. Keohane (ed.) Neorealism and its Critics, pp. 322-345. New York: Columbia University Press.
141.
Wæver, Ole
, et al. (1993) Identity, Migration and the New Security Agenda in Europe. London: Pinter.
142.
Wæver, Ole
(1995a) `Securitization and Desecuritization', in R. Lipschutz (ed.) On Security, pp. 46-86. New York: Columbia University Press, 1995.
143.
Wæver, Ole
(1995b) `Identity, Sovereignty and Security: Solving the Sovereignty Puzzle in EU Studies', Journal of International Affairs48(2): 389-431.
144.
Wæver, Ole
(1996) `European Security Identities', Journal of Common Market Studies34(1): 103-132.
145.
Weber, Cynthia
(1994) `Something's Missing: Male Hysteria and the U.S. Invasion of Panama', Genders19(2): 171-197.
146.
Weber, Cynthia
(1995) Simulating Sovereignty: Intervention, the State and Symbolic Exchange. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
147.
Weiner, Myron
(1992/93) `Security, Stability and International Migration', International Security17(3): 91-126.
148.
Weldes, Jutta
(1996) `Constructing National Interests', European Journal of International Relations2(3): 275-318.
149.
Weldes, Jutta
(1998) Constructing National Interests: The U.S. and the Cuban Missile Crisis. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
150.
Wendt, Alexander
(1994) `Collective Identity Formation and the International State', American Political Science Review88: 384-396.
151.
Wendt, Alexander
(1995) `Constructing International Politics', International Security20(1): 71-81.
152.
Whitworth, Sandra
(1994) `Gender, International Relations and the Case of the ILO', Review of International Studies20(4): 389-406.
153.
Whitworth, Sandra
(1996) `Gender, Race and the Politics of Peacekeeping', unpublished paper.
154.
Williams, Michael C.
(1989) `Rousseau, Realism and Realpolitik', Millennium18: 163-187.
155.
Williams, Michael C.
(1992) `Rethinking the “Logic” of Deterrence', Alternatives17(1): 67-93.
156.
Williams, Michael C.
(1996) `Hobbes and International Relations: A Reconsideration', International Organization, 50(2): 213-236.
