The Karelian question shows signs of transforming from a divisive issue to a matter of cooperation. It seems to be shifting from a unresolved territorial issue involving the correction of borders towards a resource with strong European and integration-oriented connotations. The traditional statist stances are still to some extent there, but have become less distinct as more space has been provided for various `low policy' initiatives that reach across borders. It hence appears that the territorial determinants of political processes and social life are declining in importance in the case of the ceded Karelia, thereby promoting a return of the Karelian question in a manner beyond restitution and an adjustment of statist borders.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Blomberg, Jaakko
(1992) `Finland and Russia', Yearbook of Finnish Foreign Policy 1992. The Finnish Institute of Foreign Affairs, Helsinki.
2.
Blomberg, Jaakko
(1996) `Karjalan kysymyksestä' (On the Karelian Question). Presentation at the local Karelian Association, 3 February, Lahti.
3.
Dörrenbächer, Heike
(1991) `Sonderwirtschaftszonen — Ein Beitrag zur wirtschaftlichen Entwicklung der UdSSR', Osteuropa Wirtschaft36 (2).
4.
Engman, Max
(1995) `Karelians between East and West', in Sven Tägil (ed.) Ethnicity and Nation Building in the Nordic World, pp. 217-245. London: Hurst & Company.
5.
Eskelinen, Heikki
(1994) `Russian Karelia as a Periphery “Gateway Region” ', in Heikki Eskelinen, Jukka Oska and Daniel Austin (eds) Russian Karelia in Search of a New Role, pp. 161-172. University of Joensun: Karelian Institute.
6.
Eskelinen, Heikki
(1995) `Transport Infrastructure in a Forest Periphery: Russian Karelia as a Corridor and in a Network', in Margareta Dahlström, Heikki Eskelinen and Ulf Wiberg (eds) The East-West Interface in the European North, pp. 85-96. Nordisk Samhällsgeografisk Tidskrift. Stockholm.
7.
Eskelinen, Heikki
and Varis, Eira (1994) `Karelska republiken - problemfulld skogsperiferi mellan Östersjö- och Barentsregionerna', Nordrevy (1): 21-25.
8.
Forsberg, Tuomas
(1995) `Karelia', in Tuomas Forsberg (ed.) Contested Territory. Border Disputes at the Edge of the Former Soviet Empire, pp. 202-224. Studies in Communism in Transition. Ipswich: Elgar.
9.
Haapanen, Elisa
(1996) `Karjalan tasavalta Suomen ja Venäjän taloussuhteissa' (the Karelian Republic in the context of the Economic Relations between Finland and Russia). In: Elisa ja Haapanen and Heikki Eskelinen (eds) Puheenvuoroja Karjalan tasavallan taloudesta, pp. 19-27. University of Joensuu. Karelian Institute. Working Papers (2).
10.
Ishiwatari, Toshiyasu
(1995) `The Northern Territories', in Tuomas Forsberg (ed.) Contested Territory. Border Disputes at the Edge of the Former Soviet Empire, pp. 224-243. Studies in Communism in Transition. Aldershot: Elgar.
11.
Joenniemi, Pertti
(1996) `Kohtaamispaikkana Karjala' (Karelia as a Meeting-place). Kosmopolis (1): 85-96.
12.
The Karelian Association
(1996) `The Karelian Issue'. Helsinki.
13.
`Karjala-työryhmän raportti, 31.1.1995' (Report of a Study Group on Karelia). Karjalan Liitto/The Karelian Association. Helsinki.
14.
Katajala, Kimmo
(1995) `Eastern Finland and St. Petersburg 1809-1917: Restructuring of Infrastructure and Rural Economy in the Concentric Circles around a Metropole', in Margareta Dahlström, Heikki Eskelinen and Ulf Wiberg (eds) The East-West Interface in the European North, pp. 11-27. Nordisk Samhällsgeografisk Tidskrift. Stockholm.
15.
Kinnunen, Petri
(1995) `A Look Across the Border: The Views and Expectations of the People in Northern Finland and Northwest Russia', in Margareta Dahlström, Heikki Eskelinen and Ulf Wiberg (eds) The East-West Interface in the European North, pp. 45-56. Nordisk Samhällsgeografisk Tidskrift. Stockholm.
16.
Koivisto, Mauno
(1995) Historian tekijät (Those Making History). Helsinki: Kirjayhtymä.
17.
Koivisto, Mauno
(1997) Liikkeen suunta (The Movement's Direction). Helsinki: Kirjayhtymä.
18.
Kosonen, Riitta
(1991) `The Filling of the Economic Space of Viborg Due to the Plans for Special Economic Zone — the Case of `Imsveto-project', Working Papers, Series F (267), Helsinki School of Economics, Helsinki.
19.
Kosonen, Riitta
(1994) `Approaching the Cultural Evolution of a Frontier Town: Institutions and Indigenous Development in Vyborg', Working Papers, Series W (89), Helsinki School of Economics, Helsinki.
20.
Kuittinen, Arja
(1993) `Neuvostoliiton hajoaminen käynnisti vilkkaan Karjalakeskustelun lehdistössä', `Keskustelua Karjalasta', pp. 22-26. Helsinki: Karjalan Liitto.
21.
Laine, Anssi
(1994) `Karelia Between Two Socio-Cultural Systems', in Heikki Oksanen, Jukka Oksa and Daniel Austin (eds) Russian Karelia in Search of a New Role, pp. 13-26. Karelian Institute, University of Joensuu.
22.
Oksa, Jukka
and Varis, Eira (1994) `Karelian Republic. Population, Settlements and Administration', in Heikki Eskelinen, Jukka Oksa and Daniel Austin, Russian Karelia in Search of a New Role, pp. 57-70. Karelian Institute, University of Joensuu.
23.
Paasi, Anssi
(1995) `The Social Construction of Peripherality: the Case of Finland and the Finnish-Russian Border Area', in Heikki Eskelinen and Folke Snickars (eds) Competitive European Peripheries, pp. 235-258. Berlin: Springer.
24.
Paasi, Anssi
(1996) Territories, Boundaries and Consciousness. The Changing Geographies of the Finnish-Russian Border. Belhaven Studies in Political Geography. New York: Wiley.
25.
Penttilä, Risto, E. J.
(1993) `Geopolitiikka ja kysymys Suomen itärajasta', Keskustelua Karjalasta, pp. 13-16. Helsinki: Karjalan Liitto.
26.
Ries, Tomas
(1994) `The Republic of Karelia', Rapport fra Planleggings- og utredningsavdelningen. Oslo: Utenriksdepartementet.
27.
Security in a Changing World. Guidelines for Finland's Security Policy. Report by the Council of State to the Parliament, June 6, 1995. Helsinki.
28.
Scott, James
(1996) `Dutch-German Euroregions: A Model for Transboundary Cooperation?', in James Scott, et al. (eds) Border Regions in Functional Transition. European and American Perspectives, pp. 83-107. Regio (IRS, Berlin) (9).
29.
Suomi, Juhani
(1997) Taistern puolueettomudesta. Urho Kekkonen 1968-1972. Helsinki: Otava.
30.
Susiluoto, Ilmari
(1994) `Co-operation in the Areas Next to Finland's Eastern Border: Karelia, St. Petersburg, Murmansk'. Presentation at a Conference on Regionalism and the Europe of the Future. Copenhagen, 20 August.
31.
Wiberg, Ulf
(1995) `The Idea of Pluralistic East-West Integration and Policy-Making for the European North', in Margareta Dahlström, Heikki Eskelinen and Ulf Wiberg (eds) The East-West Interface in the European North, pp. 71-82. Nordisk Samhällsgeografisk Tidskrift. Stockholm.
