This article argues that increasingly widespread proliferation of nuclear and delivery system capabilities to smaller states represents a fundamental redistribution of power in the international system away from Great Power dominance — forever altering the traditional `power politics' relationship between states first described by Thucydides. Building upon the broader security studies literature, the rapidly evolving nuclear security relationships between states in the international system are discussed and a new theoretical framework for explaining them is proposed. This new framework outlines in detail several factors critical to shaping interstate security relationships: (1) the nuclear capabilities of the state (i.e., size, differentiation, range, and interceptibility of force structure); (2) the survivability of its arsenal (i.e., redundancy, mobility, site defense, subterfuge characteristics of forces); and (3) the credibility of its nuclear threat to the decision-makers in the target nation (i.e., perception by target of opponent's capability, survivability, control over situation, and threat to central/peripheral state interests). These characteristics combine to create a variety of nuclear security relationships between states (realpolitik, nascent/local, regional, and great power) which affect the deterrent ability, crisis stability, and available nuclear strategies of small nuclear states. Finally, both the Cuban Missile Crisis and the Gulf War are discussed in order to underscore the continuing evolution of Great Power-small state nuclear security relationships. In particular, the Gulf War is argued to provide strong support for the argument that future small nuclear states will be able to deter Great Power threats because of four critical lessons demonstrated by that conflict: (1) the effectiveness and survivability of covert nuclear weapons programs; (2) the effectiveness and survivability of small state delivery systems; (3) the ineffectiveness of strategic defense systems in intercepting potential attacks; and (4) the fact that threats of unconventional weapon use by small states are taken seriously by Great Powers.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Albright, David
and Hibbs, Mark (1992) `Iraq's Quest for the Nuclear Grail: What Can We Learn?'Arms Control Today. July/August: 3-11.
2.
Bitzinger, Richard A.
(1992) `Arms to Go: Chinese Arms Sales to the Third World', International Security17(2): 84-111.
3.
Blackwill, Robert D.
and Carter, Ashton B. (1993) `The Role of Intelligence', in R. D. Blackwill and A. Carneslae (eds) New Nuclear Nations: Consequence for U.S. Policy, pp. 216-250. New York: Council on Foreign Relations Press.
4.
Blight, James G.
(1992) The Shattered Crystal Ball: Fear and Learning in the Cuban Missile Crisis. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
5.
Bracken, Paul
(1993) `Nuclear Weapons and State Survival in North Korea', Survival35(3): 137-153.
6.
Brodie, Bernard
(1946) The Absolute Weapon. New York: Harcourt, Brace.
7.
Brodie, Bernard
(1973) War and Politics. New York: Macmillan.
8.
Bulkeley, Rip
and Spinardi, Graham (1986) Space Weapons: Deterrence or Delusion?Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
9.
Bundy, McGeorge
(1982) `Existential Deterrence and Its Consequences', in D. MacLean (ed.) The Security Gamble: Deterrence Dilemmas in the Nuclear Age, pp. 3-13. Totowa, NJ: Rowan and Allanheld.
10.
Bundy, McGeorge
(1991) `Nuclear Weapons and the Gulf', Foreign Affairs70(4): 83-94.
11.
Burke, John P.
and Greenstein, Fred I. (1991) How Presidents Test Reality: Decisions on Vietnam, 1954 and 1965. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
12.
Carle, Christophe
(1992) `Mayhem or Deterrence? Regional and Global Security from Non-Proliferation to Post-Proliferation', in S.A. Stahl and G. Kemp (eds) Arms Control and Proliferation in the Middle East and South Asia, pp. 45-60. New York: St Martin's.
13.
Chang, Laurence
and Kornbluh, Peter (1992) The Cuban Missile Crisis, 1962: A National Security Archive Documents Reader. New York: Free Press.
14.
Chellaney, Brahma
(1991) `South Asia's Passage to Nuclear Power', International Security16(1): 43-75.
15.
Cottam, Richard
(1977) Foreign Policy Motivation: A General Theory and a Case Study. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.
16.
David, Steven R.
(1992/93) `Why the Third World Still Matters', International Security17(3): 127-159.
17.
de Mesquita, Bruce
and Riker, William H. (1982) `An Assessment of the Merits of Selective Nuclear Proliferation', Journal of Conflict Resolution26(2): 283-306.
18.
de Rivera, Joseph
(1968) The Psychological Dimension of Foreign Policy. Columbus: Carles Merrill.
19.
Dunn, Lewis A.
(1982) Controlling the Bomb: Nuclear Proliferation in the 1980s. New Haven: Yale University Press.
20.
Dunn, Lewis A.
(1988) `What Difference Will It Make?' In R. Art and K. Waltz (eds) The Use of Force: Military Power and International Politics, 3rd Edn, pp. 713-725.
21.
Dunn, Lewis A.
(1991) `Containing Nuclear Proliferation', Adelphi Papers 263. London: Brassey's for IISS.
22.
Dunn, Lewis A.
(1993) `New Nuclear Threat to U.S. Security' in R. D. Blackwill and A. Carnesale (eds) New Nuclear Nations: Consequences for U.S. Policy, pp. 20-49. New York: Council on Foreign Relations Press.
23.
Feaver, Peter D.
(1993) `Proliferation Optimism and Theories of Nuclear Operations', Security Studies2(3-4): 159-191.
24.
Feldman, Shai
(1982) Israeli Nuclear Deterrence: A Strategy for the 1980s. New York: Columbia University Press.
25.
Fetter, Steve
(1991) `Ballistic Missiles and Weapons of Mass Destruction: What is the Threat? What Should Be Done?'International Security16(1): 5-42.
26.
Flournoy, Michele A.
(1993) `Implications for U.S. Military Strategy', in R. D. Blackwill and A. Carnesale (eds) New Nuclear Nations: Consequences for U.S. Policy, pp. 135-161. New York: Council on Foreign Relations Press.
27.
Freedman, Lawrence
(1983) The Evolution of Nuclear Strategy. London: Macmillan.
28.
Freedman, Lawrence
and Karsh, Efraim (1991) `How Kuwait Was Won: Strategy in the Gulf War', International Security16(2).
29.
Gaddis, John Lewis
(1991) `Towards the Post-Cold War World', Foreign Affairs70(2): 102-122.
30.
Gallois, Pierre
(1961) The Balance of Terror. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
31.
Garthoff, Raymond L.
(1985) `American-Soviet Relations in Perspective', Political Science Quarterly100(2): 541-559.
32.
Garthoff, Raymond L.
(1985) Detente and Confrontation: American-Soviet Relations From Nixon To Reagan. Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution.
33.
George, Alexander L.
(1988) `Incentives for U.S.-Soviet Security Cooperation and Mutual Adjustment', in A. L. George, P. J. Farley, and A. Dallin (eds) U.S.-Soviet Security Co-operation: Achievements, Failures, and Lessons, pp. 644-650.
34.
George, Alexander L.
(1991) Avoiding War: Problems of Crisis Management. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
35.
Goldstein, Avery
(1992) `Robust and Affordable Security: Some Lessons from the Second-Ranking Powers During the Cold War', Journal of Strategic Studies15(4): 475-527.
36.
Hagerty, Devin T.
(1995/96) `Nuclear Deterrence in South Asia: The 1990 Indo-Pakistani Crisis', International Security20(3): 79-115.
37.
Harvey, John R.
(1992) `Regional Ballistic Missiles and Advanced Strike Aircraft: Comparing Military Effectiveness', International Security17(2): 41-83.
38.
Hermann, Margaret G.
(1980) `Explaining Foreign Policy Behavior Using Personal Characteristics of Political Leaders', International Studies Quarterly24(1): 7-46.
39.
Hersh, Seymour M.
(1991) The Samson Option: Israel's Nuclear Arsenal and American Foreign Policy. New York: Random House.
40.
Howlett, Darryl
and Simpson, John (1993) `Nuclearisation and Denuclearisation in South Africa', Survival35(3): 154-173.
41.
Jervis, Robert
(1976) Perception and Misperception in International Politics. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
42.
Jervis, Robert
(1986) The Illogic of American Nuclear Strategy. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
43.
Kaiser, Karl
(1989) `Non-proliferation and Nuclear Deterrence', Survival31(2): 123-136.
44.
Kaplan, Morton
(1957) System and Process in International Politics. New York: Krieger.
45.
Kaysen, Carl
; McNamara, Robert and Rathjens, George (1991) `Nuclear Weapons After the Cold War', Foreign Affairs70(4): 12-24.
46.
Khalilzad, Zalmay
(1983) `Nuclear Stability in Southwest Asia', in D. L. Brito, M. D. Intriligator, and A. E. Wick (eds) Strategies for Managing Nuclear Proliferation, pp. 101-116. Lexington, MA: D. C. Heath.
47.
Khong, Yuen Foong
(1992) Analogies at War: Korea, Munich, Dien Bien Phu, and the Vietnam Decisions of 1965. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
48.
Kincade, William H.
(1993) `Nuclear Weapons in Ukraine: Hollow Threat, Wasting Asset', Arms Control Today6: 13-18.
49.
Lebow, Richard Ned
(1981) Between Peace and War. Baltimore, MA: Johns Hopkins University Press.
50.
Martel, William C.
and Pendley, William T. (1994) Nuclear Coexistence: Rethinking U.S. Policy to Promote Stability in an Era of Proliferation. Maxwell Air Force Base: Air University, Air War College Studies in National Security Number One.
51.
Mazaar, Michael J.
(1995) `Going Just a Little Nuclear: Nonproliferation Lessons from North Korea', International Security20(2): 92-122.
52.
McNamara, Robert S.
(1983) `The Military Role of Nuclear Weapons: Perceptions and Misperceptions', Foreign Affairs, Fall59-80.
53.
Mearsheimer, John J.
(1993) `The Case for a Ukrainian Nuclear Deterrent', Foreign Affairs72(3): 50-66.
54.
Miller, Steven E.
(1993) `The Case Against a Ukrainian Nuclear Deterrent', Foreign Affairs72(3): 67-80.
55.
Morgenthau, Hans J.
(1948) Politics Among Nations: The Struggle for Power and Peace. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.
56.
Nye, Jr.
, Joseph S. (1990) Bound To Lead: The Changing Nature of American Power. New York: Basic Books.
57.
Posen, Barry R.
(1993) `The Security Dilemma and Ethnic Conflict', Survival35(1): 44-45.
58.
Post, Jerrold M.
(1991) `Saddam Hussein of Iraq: A Political Psychology Profile', Political Psychology12(2): 99-121.
59.
Postol, Theodore A.
(1991/92) `Lessons of the Gulf War Patriot Experience', International Security16(3): 119-171.
60.
Postol, Theodore A.
(1992) `Patriot Experience in the Gulf War', International Security17(1): 225-240.
61.
Powell, Robert
(1990) Nuclear Deterrence Theory: The Search for Credibility. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
62.
Preston, J. Thomas (1996) `The President and His Inner Circle: Leadership Style and the Advisory Process in Foreign Policy Making. Unpublished Dissertation. The Ohio State University.
63.
Quester, George H.
(1983) `Nuclear Proliferation and Stability', in D. L. Brito, M. D. Intriligator and A. E. Wick (eds) Strategies for Managing Nuclear Proliferation, pp. 101-116. Lexington, MA: D. C. Heath.
64.
Rhodes, Edward
(1989) Power and MADness: The Logic of Nuclear Coercion. New York: Columbia University Press.
65.
Rosen, Steven J.
(1977) `A Stable System of Mutual Nuclear Deterrence in the Arab-Israeli Conflict', American Political Science Review7(4): 1367-1383.
66.
Russett, Bruce
(1983) The Prisoners of Insecurity. San Francisco: W. H. Freeman.
67.
Sagan, Scott D.
(1994) `The Perils of Proliferation: Organization Theory, Deterrence Theory, and the Spread of Nuclear Weapons', International Security18(4): 66-107.
68.
Sagan, Scott D.
and Waltz, Kenneth N. (1995) The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: A Debate. New York: W. W. Norton.
69.
Sanders, Ben
(1990) `Avoiding the Worst of All Possible Worlds', in J. Pilat and R. Pendley (eds) Beyond 1995: The Future of the NPT. New York: Plenum Press.
70.
Sandoval, R. Robert
(1976) `Consider the Porcupine: Another View of Nuclear Proliferation', Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists32(5): 17-19.
71.
Scheineman, Lawrence
(1993) `Lessons from Post-War Iraq for the International Full-Scope Safeguards Regime', Arms Control Today, April 1993: 3-6.
72.
Schelling, Thomas C.
(1960) The Strategy of Conflict. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
73.
Schelling, Thomas C.
(1966) Arms and Influence. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
74.
Schelling, Thomas C.
(1988) `The Diplomacy of Violence', in R. Art and K. Waltz (eds) The Use of Force: Military Power and International Politics, pp. 1-26.
75.
Schneider, Barry R.
(1994) `Nuclear Proliferation and Counter-Proliferation: Policy Issues and Debates', Mershon International Studies Review38(2): 209-234.
76.
Snyder, Glenn H.
(1961) Deterrence and Defense. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
77.
Spector, Leonard S.
(1986) `Foreign-Supplied Combat Aircraft: Will They Drop the Third World Bomb?'Journal of International Affairs40(1): 143-158.
78.
Spector, Leonard S.
(1988) The Undeclared Bomb. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger.
79.
Spiers, Edward M.
(1989) Chemical Weaponry: A Continuing Challenge. London: Macmillan.
80.
Stein, Robert M.
(1992) `Patriot Experience in the Gulf War', International Security17(1): 199-225.
81.
Thucydides
(1960). The History of the Peloponnesian War. Edited by Sir Richard Livingstone. London: Oxford University Press.
82.
U.S. Office of Technology Assessment
(1986) `Strategic Defenses: Ballistic Missile Defense Technologies, Anti-Satellite Weapons, Countermeasures, and Arms Control'. Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.
83.
Van Evera, Stephen
(1990/91) `Primed for Peace: Europe After the Cold War', International Security15(3): 7-57.
84.
Vertzberger, Yaacov Y. I.
(1990) The World in Their Minds: Information Processing, Cognition, and Perception in Foreign Policy Decisionmaking. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
85.
Waltz, Kenneth
(1988) `Toward Nuclear Peace', in R. Art and K. Waltz (eds) The Use of Force: Military Power and International Politics, 3rd Edn, pp. 684-712.
86.
Waltz, Kenneth
(1991) `The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More May Be Better', Adelphi Papers171.
87.
Weber, Steve
(1990) `Realism, Detente, and Nuclear Weapons', International Organization44(1): 55-82.
88.
White, Ralph K.
(1991) `Empathizing With Saddam Hussein', Political Psychology12(2): 291-308.
89.
Zelikow, Philip
(1993) `Offensive Military Options', in R. D. Blackwill and A. Carnesale (eds) New Nuclear Nations: Consequences for U.S. Policy, pp. 162-195. New York: Council on Foreign Relations Press.
90.
`Off-the-Record Meeting on Cuba, October 16, 1962, 11:50 a.m.-12:57 p.m.,' Presidential Recordings Transcripts, Tapes 28.2 and 28A.1, President's Office Files, Papers of John F. Kennedy, Kennedy Library.
91.
Theodore Sorensen notes of 17 October 1962, `Cuba, General 10/17/62-10/27/62' folder, Papers of Theodore Sorensen, Classified Subject Files 1961-64, Box 48, Kennedy Library. See also, Memorandum from Douglas Dillon to John F. Kennedy, 17 October 1962, in Chang and Kornbluh (1992: 116-20).
92.
`Off-the-Record Meeting on Cuba, October 18, 1962', Presidential Recordings, Tape 30.2, President's Office Files, Papers of John F. Kennedy, Kennedy Library.
93.
`Robert McNamara Notes on 21 October 1962 Meeting with the President', `NSC Meetings, 1962, No. 506, 10/21/162' folder 39, National Security Files, Meetings and Memoranda, Box 313, Kennedy Library.
94.
`Minutes of the 507th Meeting of the National Security Council on Monday, October 22, 1962, 3:00 PM, Cabinet Room', `National Security Council Meetings, 1962, No. 507, 10/22/62', folder 40, National Security File, Meetings and Memoranda, Box 313, Kennedy Library.
95.
Defense Intelligence Agency, `Defense Intelligence Assessment, Mobile Short-Range Ballistic Targeting in Operation Desert Storm', OGA 1040-23-91, December 1991, p. 9.
96.
Gulf War Air Power Survey: Operations and Effects and Effectiveness (1993) Directed by Eliot A. Cohen. Vol. II. Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.
97.
Broad, William J.
(1991) `Iraqi Atom Effort Exposes Weakness in World Controls', The New York Times, 15 July, pp. 1 and 5.
98.
Broad, William J.
(1992) `Warning on Iraq and Bomb Bid Silenced in '89', The New York Times, 20 April, p. 6.
99.
Gray, Jerry
(1991) `Baghdad Reveals It Had Plutonium Of Weapons Grade', The New York Times, 6 August, pp. 1 and 5.
100.
Lewis, Paul
(1991) `U.N. Says the Iraqis Could Have Devised A-Bombs in the 90's', The New York Times, 14 October, p. 5.
101.
Lewis, Paul
(1991) `U.N. Aides Discover Atom Arms Center Concealed By Iraq', The New York Times, 8 October, pp. 1 and 7.
102.
Miller, Mark Crispin
(1992) `Operation Desert Sham', The New York Times, 24 June, p. A15.
103.
`Saddam's Nuclear Secrets'
, Newsweek, 7 October1991, p. 34.
104.
`U.S. Lacking Solid Data On Iraqi Nuclear Threat'
, The New York Times, 11 November1990, p. 8.
105.
`Saddam's Secret Bomb'
, U.S. News & World Report, 25 November1991, pp. 34-42.
106.
`U.S. Nuclear Technology Tactics Vex Iran'
, The New York Times, 18 November1991, p. 4.
107.
`Patriots Downed Fewer Scuds, Army Admits'
, The New York Times, 4/8/92, p. A9.
108.
`Excerpts from Schwarzkopf News Conferences on Gulf War'
, The New York Times, 28 February1991, p. 8.
109.
`Preparing the Ground'
, U.S. News & World Report, 4 February1991, p. 34.
110.
`Iraq Chief, Boasting of Poison Gas, Warns of Disaster if Israelis Strike'
, The New York Times, 3 April1990, p. 1.
111.
`U.N. Inspectors Say Iraqis Hid Chemical Arms'
, The New York Times, 31 July1991, p. 1.
112.
`Outnumbered and Outgunned, Allied Forces Outfox Hussein'
, The New York Times, 28 February1991, p. 9.
