This article explores the link between coalition politics and Israel's policies toward the peace process. Although the field of international relations has increasingly turned to domestic politics to explain international behavior, current treatments of domestic politics focus on state-society relations and often ignore the bargaining and decision-making processes within governments. These processes, I argue, are crucial for explaining states' policies in international negotiations. A complete understanding of Israeli policy in the Arab-Israeli peace process requires attention to coalition politics — the negotiations between the participating political parties in a ruling coalition. Specifically, this study investigates the conditions under which junior partners in Israeli coalition cabinets have been influential in Israeli peace policy. Conditions related to the parties' positions, the public's support and the decision-making process are hypothesized to explain junior partner influence. These hypotheses are examined in four cases — two in which the junior partner was influential and two in which it was not. Variables such as party unity, the prime minister's position, and influence strategy emerge as important in these cases. These specific conclusions are discussed as well as more general lessons from this study on the interaction of domestic and international politics.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Akzin, B.
(1979) `The Likud', in Howard R. Penniman (ed.) Israel at the Polls. Washington: American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research.
2.
Arian, A.
(1989) Politics in Israel. Chatham, New Jersey: Chatham House Publishers.
3.
Arian, A.
(1991) `Toward the 1990s in Israeli Politics', in B. Reich and G. R. Kieval (eds) Israeli Politics in the 1990s, pp. 45-54. New York: Greenwood Press.
4.
Arian, A.
(1992) `Security and Political Attitudes in Israel: 1986-1991', Public Opinion Quarterly56: 116-128.
5.
Arian, A.
, Shamir, M. and Ventura, R. (1992) `Public Opinion and Political Change', Comparative Politics24: 317-334.
6.
Arian, A.
, Talmud, I. and Hermann, T. (1988) National Security and Public Opinion in Israel. Boulder: Westview Press.
7.
Barnett, M.
(1990) `High Politics is Low Politics', World Politics42: 529-562.
8.
Baylis, T. A.
(1989) Governing By Committee. New York: State University of New York Press.
9.
Ben Meir, Y.
(1986) National Security Decisionmaking: The Israeli Case. Boulder: Westview Press.
10.
Blondel, J.
and Müller Rommel, F. (eds) Governing Together. New York: St Martin's Press.
11.
Browne, E. C.
(1982) `Conclusion: Considerations on the Construction of a Theory of Cabinet Coalition Behavior', in Eric C. Browne and John Dreijmanis (eds) Government Coalitions in Western Democracies, pp. 335-357. New York: Longman.
12.
Browne, E. C.
and Franklin, M. N. (1973) `Aspects of Coalition Payoffs in European Parliamentary Democracies', American Political Science Review68: 453-469.
13.
Budge, I.
and Laver, M. J. (1992) `Coalition Theory, Government Policy and Party Policy', in M. J. Laver and I. Budge (eds) Party Policy and Government Coalitions, pp. 1-14. New York: St Martin's Press.
14.
Clark, R. D. III
and Maass, A. (1988) `Social Categorization in Minority Influence: The Case of Homosexuality', European Journal of Social Psychology18: 347-364.
15.
Dayan, M.
(1981) Breakthrough. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.
16.
DeSwaan, A.
(1974) Coalition Theories and Cabinet Formation. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
17.
Deutsch, M.
and Shichman, S. (1986) `Conflict: A Social Psychological Perspective', in M. G. Hermann (ed.) Political Psychology, pp. 219-250. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
18.
Diskin, A.
and Galnoor, I. (1990) `Political Distances between Knesset Members and Coalition Behaviour: The Peace Agreements with Egypt', Political Studies38: 710-717.
19.
Doms, M.
and Van Avermaet, E. (1985) `Social Support and Minority Influence: The Innovation Effect Reconsidered', in S. Moscovici, G. Mugny and E. Van Avermaet (eds) Perspectives on Minority Influence, pp. 53-74. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
20.
Eichenberg, R. C.
(1993) `Dual Track and Double Trouble: The Two-Level Politics of INF', in P. B. Evans, H. K. Jacobson and R. D. Putnam (eds) Double-Edged Diplomacy, pp. 45-76. Berkeley: University of California Press.
21.
Elazar, D. J.
(1991) `The Balance of Political Power and Israel's Political Future', in B. Reich and G. R. Kieval, Israeli Politics in the 1990s, pp. 29-43. New York: Greenwood Press.
22.
Elazar, D. J.
and Kalchheim, C. (eds) (1988) Local Government in Israel. Lanham, MD: University Press of America.
23.
Elazar, D. J.
and Sandler, S. (1990) `Introduction: The Two-Bloc System — a New Development in Israeli Politics', in D. J. Elazar and S. Sandler (eds) Israel's Odd Couple, pp. 11-24. Detroit: Wayne State University Press.
24.
Elazar, D. J.
and Sandler, S. (1992a) `Forging a New Political Center', in D. J. Elazar and S. Sandler (eds) Who's the Boss in Israel, pp. 13-41. Detroit: Wayne State University Press.
25.
Elazar, D. J.
and Sandler, S. (1992b) `Who is the Boss Today? Coalition Government in Israel and the Need for Electoral Reform', in D. J. Elazar and S. Sandler (eds) Who's the Boss in Israel, pp. 277-304. Detroit: Wayne State University Press.
26.
Evans, P. B.
(1993) `Building an Integrative Approach to International and Domestic Politics: Reflections and Projections', in P. B. Evans, H. K. Jacobson and R. D. Putnam (eds) Double-edged Diplomacy, pp. 397-430. Berkeley: University of California Press.
27.
Evans, P. B.
, Jacobson, H. K. and Putnam, R. D. (eds) (1993) Double-Edged Diplomacy. Berkeley: University of California Press.
28.
Falk, G. H.
(1988) `Israeli Public Opinion on Peace Issues', in B. Reich and G. R. Kieval (eds) Israeli National Security Policy, pp. 169-205. New York: Greenwood Press.
29.
Ferguson, Y. H.
and Mansbach, R. W. (1991) `Between Celebration and Despair: Constructive Suggestions for Future International Theory', International Studies Quarterly4: 363-386.
30.
Foreign Broadcast Information Service. Selected articles.
31.
Freedman, R. O.
(1982) `Moscow, Jerusalem, and Washington in the Begin Era', in R. O. Freedman (ed.) Israel in the Begin Era, pp. 151-200. New York: Praeger.
32.
Friedlander, M. A.
(1983) Sadat and Begin: The Domestic Politics of Peacemaking. Boulder, Westview Press.
33.
Goldberg, G.
(1992) `The Likud: Moving Toward the Center', in D. J. Elazar and S. Sandler (eds) Who's the Boss in Israel, pp. 45-66. Detroit: Wayne State University Press.
34.
Goldberg, G.
and Tzabag, S. (1992) `The 1989 Histadrut Elections: Thunder Before the Storm?' in D. J. Elazar and S. Sandler (eds) Who's the Boss in Israel, pp. 251-276. Detroit: Wayne State University Press.
35.
Goldmann, K.
(1989) `The Line in Water: International and Domestic Politics', Cooperation and Conflict24: 103-116.
36.
Greenstein, F. I.
(1969) Personality and Politics. Chicago: Markham.
37.
Habeeb, W. M.
(1988) Power and Tactics in International Negotiation. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
38.
Hagan, J. D.
(1989) `Domestic Political Regime Changes and Foreign Policy Restructuring in Western Europe: A Conceptual Framework and Initial Empirical Analysis', Cooperation and Conflict24: 141-162.
39.
Hagan, J. D.
(1993) Political Opposition and Foreign Policy in Comparative Perspective. Boulder: Lynne Rienner Publishers.
40.
Hermann, M. G.
(1976) `When Leader Personality Will Affect Foreign Policy: Some Propositions', in J. N. Rosenau (ed.) In Search of Global Patterns, pp. 326-333. New York: The Free Press.
41.
Hermann, M. G.
and Hermann, C. F. (1989) `Who Makes Foreign Policy Decisions and How: An Empirical Inquiry', International Studies Quarterly33: 361-387.
42.
Hermann, M. G.
, Hermann, C. F. and Hagan, J. D. (1987) `How Decision Units Shape Foreign Policy Behavior', in C. F. Hermann, C. W. Kegley Jr., and J. N. Rosenau (eds) New Directions in the Study of Foreign Policy, pp. 309-336. Boston: Allen and Unwin.
43.
Hermann, T.
(1993) `Grassroots Activism as a Factor in Foreign Policy-Making: The Case of the Israeli Peace Movement', in D. Skidmore and V. Hudson (eds) The Limits of State Autonomy, pp. 127-147. Boulder: Westview Press.
44.
Ikenberry, G. J.
(1988) `Conclusion: An Institutional Approach to American Foreign Economic Policy' in International Organization.
45.
Inbar, E.
(1991) War and Peace in Israeli Politics. Boulder: Lynne Rienner Publishers.
46.
Inbar, E.
and Goldberg, G. (1990) `Is Israel's Political Elite Becoming More Hawkish?', International Journal45: 631-660.
47.
Isaac, R. J.
(1981) Party and Politics in Israel. New York: Longman.
48.
Jerusalem Post, the. Selected articles.
49.
Kaarbo, J.
(forthcoming) `Power and Influence in Foreign Policy Decision Making: The Role of Junior Coalition Partners in German and Israeli Foreign Policy', International Studies Quarterly (December, 1996).
50.
Katzenstein, P.
(1976) `International Relations and Domestic Structures: Foreign Economic Policies of Advanced Industrialized States', International Organization30: 1-45.
51.
Keesing's Record of World Events. Selected articles.
52.
Kieval, G. R.
(1983) Party Politics in Israel and the Occupied Territories. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.
53.
Kieval, G. R.
and Reich, B. (1991) `Introduction: The Changing Center in Israeli Politics', in B. Reich and G. R. Kieval (eds) Israeli Politics in the 1990s, pp. 1-27. New York: Greenwood Press.
54.
Krasner, S.
(1978) Defending the National Interest: Raw Materials Investments and U.S. Foreign Policy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
55.
Laver, M.
and Schofield, N. (1990) Multiparty Government. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
56.
Laver, M.
and Shepsle, K. (1990) `Government Coalitions and Intraparty Politics', British Journal of Political Science20: 489-507.
57.
Lehman, H. P.
and McCoy, J. L. (1992) `The Dynamics of the Two-Level Bargaining Game', World Politics44: 600-644.
58.
Liebman, C. S.
and Don-Yehiya, E. (1984) Religion and Politics in Israel. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
59.
Lindell, U.
and Persson, S. (1986) `The Paradox of Weak State Power: A Research and Literature Overview', Cooperation and Conflict21: 79-97.
60.
Maoz, Z.
(1990) `Framing the National Interest', World Politics43: 77-110.
61.
Mény, Y.
(1990) Government and Politics in Western Europe. London: Oxford University Press.
62.
Moravcsik, A.
(1993a) `Armaments Among Allies: European Weapons Collaboration, 1975-1985', in P. B. Evans, H. K. Jacobson and R. D. Putnam (eds) Double-Edged Diplomacy, pp. 128-167. Berkeley: University of California Press.
63.
Moravcsik, A.
(1993b) `Introduction: Integrating International and Domestic Theories of International Bargaining', in P. B. Evans, H. K. Jacobson, and R. D. Putnam (eds) Double-Edged Diplomacy, pp. 3-42. Berkeley: University of California Press.
64.
Moscovici, S.
(1976) Social Influence and Social Change. London: Academic Press.
65.
Mugny, G.
(1975) `Negotiations, Image of the Other and the Process of Minority Influence', European Journal of Social Psychology5: 209-228.
66.
Müller, H.
and Risse-Kappen, T. (1993) `From the Outside In and from the Inside Out', in D. Skidmore and V. Hudson (eds) The Limits of State Autonomy, pp. 25-48. Boulder: Westview Press.
67.
New York Times, the. Selected articles.
68.
Papastamou, S.
and Mugny, G. (1985) `Rigidity and Minority Influence: The Influence of the Social in Social Influence', in S. Moscovici, G. Mugny and E. Van Avermaet (eds) Perspectives on Minority Influence, pp. 113-136. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
69.
Peleg, I.
(1987) Begin's Foreign Policy. 1977-1983. New York: Greenwood Press.
70.
Perlmutter, A.
(1985) Israel: The Partitioned State. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons.
71.
Perlmutter, A.
(1987) The Life and Times of Menachem Begin. Garden City, NY: Doubleday and Company.
72.
Pollock, D.
(1982) `Likud in Power: Divided We Stand', in R. O. Freedman (ed.) Israel in the Begin Era, pp. 28-35. New York: Praeger.
73.
Putnam, R. D.
(1988) `Diplomacy and Domestic Politics: The Logic of Two-Level Games', International Organization42: 427-460.
74.
Putnam, R. D.
and Bayne, N. (1987) Hanging Together. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
75.
Reiser, S.
(1984) `The Politics of Leverage', Harvard Middle East Papers, Modern Series: No. 2. Cambridge, MA: Center for Middle Eastern Studies.
76.
Reiser, S.
(1988) The Religious Parties and Israel's Foreign Policy', in B. Reich and G. R. Kieval (eds) Israeli National Security Policy, pp. 105-121. New York: Greenwood Press.
77.
Riker, W.
(1962) The Theory of Political Coalitions. New Haven: Yale University Press.
78.
Roberts, S. J.
(1990) Party and Policy in Israel. Boulder: Westview Press.
79.
Sandler, S.
(1981) `The National Religious Party: Towards a New Role in Israel's Political System?' in S. N. Lehman-Wilzig and B. Susser (eds) Comparative Jewish Politics: Public Life in Israel and the Diaspora, pp. 158-170. Israel: Bar-Ilan University Press.
80.
Skidmore, D.
and Hudson, V. M. (1993) `Establishing the Limits of State Autonomy: Contending Approaches to the Study of State-Society Relations and Foreign Policy-Making', in D. Skidmore and V. Hudson (eds) The Limits of State Autonomy, pp. 1-22. Boulder: Westview Press.
81.
Snyder, S.
(1993) `East-West Bargaining Over Germany: The Search for Synergy in a Two-Level Game', in P. B. Evans, H. K. Jacobson and R. D. Putnam (eds) Double-Edged Diplomacy, pp. 105-127. Berkeley: University of California Press.
82.
Sofer, S.
(1988) Begin: An Anatomy of Leadership. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
83.
Sprinzak, E.
(1988) `Extremist Inputs into Israel's Foreign Policy: The Case of Gush Emunim', in B. Reich and G. R. Kieval (eds) Israeli National Security Policy, pp. 123-146. New York: Greenwood Press.
84.
Stein, J. G.
(1993) `The Political Economy of Security Agreements: The Linked Costs of Failure at Camp David', in P. B. Evans, H. K. Jacobson and R. D. Putnam (eds) Double-Edged Diplomacy, pp. 77-104. Berkeley: University of California Press.
85.
Steinberg, G.
(1992) `Israel Among the Nations: Foreign Policy and the Peace Process', in D. J. Elazar and S. Sandler (eds) Who's the Boss in Israel, pp. 172-192. Detroit: Wayne State University Press.
86.
Stone, R. A.
(1982) Social Change in Israel. New York: Praeger.
87.
Torgovnik, E.
(1978-79) `Accepting Camp David: The Role of Party Factions in Israeli Policy Making', Middle East Review, 18-25.
88.
Torgovnik, E.
(1992) `The Labor Party and Electoral Stalemate', in D. J. Elazar and S. Sandler (eds) Who's the Boss in Israel, pp. 67-82. Detroit: Wayne State University Press.
89.
Wall Street Journal, the. Selected articles.
90.
Yanai, N.
(1981) Party Leadership in Israel. Ramat Gan: Turtledove Publishing.
91.
Yaniv, A.
and Yishai, Y. (1981) `Israeli Settlements in the West Bank: the Politics of Intransigence', Journal of Politics43: 1105-1128.
92.
Yishai, Y.
(1970) `Party Factionalism and Foreign Policy: Demands and Responses', Jerusalem Journal of International Relations3: 53-70.
93.
Yishai, Y.
(1987) Land or Peace. Stanford: Hoover Institution Press.
94.
Zuckerman, A. S.
, Herzog, H. and Shamir, M. (1990) `The Party's Just Begun: Herut Activists in Power and After Begin', in G. S. Mahler (ed.) Israel After Begin, pp. 235-255. New York: State University of New York Press.
