This article presents the case for a comprehensive and multidimensional security concept, including a prioritized environmental component. Following a brief overview of the current state of the security debate, two very different lines of criticism against the notion of linking environment and security are presented and critiqued. The `orthodox' view argues that a relatively restrictive definition of security should be maintained in order to protect the conceptual and substantive integrity of security studies as a discipline. The `radical' view reflects a distaste for the normative and ontological implications of the security discourse and argues that it is inappropriate to `securitize' non-military social or environmental issues. In the last part of the article, the advantages of a comprehensive security concept are outlined, in a context emphasizing the desirability of an intellectual partnership between academics and practitioners geared towards the generation of more balanced, integrated and environmentally sound security policy-making.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Andrén, N.
(1968) `In Search of Security', Cooperation and Conflict4: 217-239.
2.
Atteh, S.
(1992) `The Political Economy of Environmental Degradation: The Dumping of Toxic Wastes in West Africa', paper presented at the ISA West, Phoenix, 5-7 November.
3.
Baldwin, D.
(1985) Economic Statecraft. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
4.
Blight, J.
(1990) The Shattered Crystal Ball: Fear and Learning in the Cuban Missile Crisis. Savage, MD: Rowman and Littlefield.
5.
Booth, K.
(1991) `Security in Anarchy: Utopian Realism in Theory and Practice', International Affairs67(3): 527-545.
6.
Brecher, M.
(1977) `India's Devaluation of 1966: Linkage Politics and Crisis Decision-Making', British Journal of International Relations (April).
7.
Brown, N.
(1989) `Climate, Ecology, and International Security', Survival31(6): 519-532.
8.
Buzan, B.
(1983) People States and Fear: The National Security Problem in International Relations. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
9.
Buzan, B.
(1991) People States and Fear: An Agenda for International Security Studies in the Post-Cold War Era, 2nd edn.Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner.
10.
Buzan, B.
, Kelstrup, M., Lemaitre, P. and Waever, O. (1933) Identity, Migration, and the New Security Agenda in Europe. London: Pinter.
11.
Caldwell, L.
(1991) `International Responses to Environmental Issues: Retrospect and Prospect', International Studies Notes16(1): 3-8.
12.
Comfort, L.
(ed.) (1988) Managing Disaster: Strategies and Policy Perspectives. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
13.
Conca, K.
(1993) `In the Name of Sustainability: Peace Studies and Environmental Discourse', paper presented at the Conference on Environmental Change and Security', UBC, Vancouver.
14.
Crawford, N. C.
(1991) `Once and Future Security Studies', Security Studies1(2): 283-316.
15.
Dalby, S.
(1992) `Security, Modernity, Ecology: The Dilemmas of the Post-Cold War Security Discourse', Alternatives17: 95-134.
16.
D'Antonio, M.
(1993) Atomic Harvest: Hanford and the Lethal Toll of America's Nuclear Arsenal. New York: Crown.
17.
Davis, Z. and Frankel, B. (eds) (1993) The Proliferation Puzzle: Why Nuclear Weapons Spread (and What Results). Special issue of Security Studies2(3-4).
18.
Deibert, R.
and K. Guttieri (1993) `Lense Adjustment: Focusing Military Satellites on the Environment', paper presented at the Conference on Environmental Change and Security, UBC, Vancouver.
19.
Deudney, D.
(1990) `The Case against Linking Environmental Degradation and National Security', Millennium19(3): 461-476.
20.
Deudney, D.
and Matthew, R. (eds) (forthcoming) Contested Ground: Security and Conflict in the New Environmental Politics. Albany, NY: SUNY Press.
21.
Dewey, J.
(1929/1989) Experience and Nature. Lassalle, IL: Open Court.
22.
Dror, Y.
(1986) Policy Making under Adversity. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction.
23.
Drof, Y.
(1988) `Decisionmaking under Disaster Conditions', in L. Comfort (ed.) Managing Disaster: Strategies and Policy Perspectives, pp. 255-273. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
24.
Edelman, M.
(1988) Constructing the Political Spectacle. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
25.
Environmental Change and Security Project (ECSP)
(1995) Environment and Security Debates: An Introduction1 (Spring). Washington, DC: Woodrow Wilson Center.
26.
Eriksson, J.
(1993) `Whose Security: Analytical Considerations for the Study of Neomediaeval Europe', paper presented at the Swedish Political Science Association, Gothenburg, 4-5 October.
27.
Finger, M.
(1991) `The Military, the Nation State and the Environment', The Ecologist21(5): 220-225.
28.
George, A. L.
(1980) Presidential Decisionmaking in Foreign Policy: The Effective Use of Information and Advice. Boulder, CO: Westview.
29.
George, A. L.
(1993) Bridging the Gap: Theory and Practice in Foreign Policy. Washington, DC: US Institute of Peace Press.
30.
Goldmann, K.
(1978) Det Internationella Systemet. Stockholm: Aldus.
31.
Gore, A.
(1992) Earth in the Balance: Ecology and the Human Spirit. New York: Houghton-Mifflin.
32.
Haftendorn, H.
(1991) `The Security Puzzle: Theory Building and Discipline Building in International Security', International Studies Quarterly35(1): 3-17.
33.
Hawley, T. M.
(1992) Against the Fires of Hell: The Environmental Disaster of the Gulf War. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
34.
Henig, R.
(1992) `Flu Pandemic', New York Times Magazine, 29 Nov: 28-31, 55, 64-67.
35.
Hermann, C. F.
(ed.) (1972) International Crises: Insights from Behavioral Research. New York: Free Press.
36.
Herz, J.
(1951) Political Realism and Political Idealism. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
37.
Homer-Dixon, T.
(1991) `On the Threshold: Environmental Changes as Causes of Acute Conflict', International Security16(2): 76-116.
38.
Homer-Dixon, T.
(1993) `Across the Threshold: Empirical Evidence on Environmental Scarcities as Causes of Violent Conflict', paper presented at the Conference on Environmental Change and Security, Vancouver, UBC, April.
39.
Homer-Dixon, T.
, Boutwell, J. and Rathjens, G. (1993) `Environmental Change and Violent Conflict', Scientific American (February): 38-45.
40.
Janis, I.
and Mann, L. (1977) Decision Making: A Psychological Analysis of Conflict, Choice, and Commitment. New York: Free Press.
41.
Jervis, R.
(1976) Perception and Misperception in International Politics. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
42.
Johansen, R.
(1991) `Real Security is Democratic Security', Alternatives16: 209-242.
43.
Katzenstein, P.
(1990) West Germany's Internal Security Policy: State and Violence in the 1970s and 1980s. Ithaca, NY: Cornell Western Societies Papers.
44.
Kenney, R.
(1992) Value-Focused Thinking: A Path to Creative Decisionmaking. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
45.
Klare, M.
and Thomas, D. (eds) (1994) World Security: Challenges for a New Century, 2nd edn.New York: St Martin's Press.
46.
Leahy, P.
(1993) `Landmine Moratorium: A Strategy for Stronger International Limits', Arms Control Today (Jan.-Feb.): 11-14.
47.
Lindblom, C.
(1990) Inquiry and Change. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
48.
Lodgaard, S.
(1992) `Environment, Confidence-Building, and Security', in H. af Ornäs and S. Lodgaard (eds) The Environment and International Security, pp. 11-22. Uppsala: PRIO/Uppsala University Program on Environment and International Security.
49.
Macrae, J.
and Zwi, A. (1992) `Food as an Instrument of War in Contemporary African Famines: A Review of the Evidence', Disasters16(4): 299-321.
50.
March, J.
and Olson, J. (1989) Rediscovering Institutions: The Organizational Basis of Politics. New York: Free Press.
51.
Maruyama, N.
(1990) `Economic Crisis in Japan's Foreign Policy: The 1973 Oil Crisis', paper delivered at the Annual Convention of the International Studies Association, Washington DC, 10-14 April.
52.
Mische, P.
(1989) `Ecological Security and the Need to Reconceptualize Sovereignty', Alternatives14: 389-427.
53.
Mlyn, E. J.
(1995) `Alternative Security: A Conceptual Analysis', paper presented at the ISA Annual Meeting, Chicago, 23-27 February.
54.
Myers, N.
(1989) `Environment and Security', Foreign Policy74 (Spring): 23-41.
55.
Nordenfelt, J.
(1992) `Environmental Destruction as Method of Warfare', in H. af Ornäs and S. Lodgaard (eds) The Environment and International Security, pp. 23-34. Uppsala: PRIO/Uppsala University Program on Environment and International Security.
56.
Nye, J.
and Lynn-Jones, S. (1988) `International Security Studies: A Report of a Conference on the State of the Field', International Security12(4): 5-27.
57.
Pirages, D.
(1991) `Environmental Security and Social Evolution', International Studies Notes16(1): 8-12.
58.
Ramberg, B.
(1982-83) `Attacks on Nuclear Reactors: The Implications of Israel's Strike on Osiraq', Political Science Quarterly97(4): 653-662.
59.
Report of the Independent Commission on Disarmament and Security Issues
(1982) Common Security. London: Pan.
60.
Rosenthal, U.
and 't Hart, P. (1991) `Experts and Decision Makers in Crisis Situations', Knowledge12(4): 350-372.
61.
Rowlands, I.
(1992) `The Security Challenges of Global Environmental Change', in B. Roberts (ed.) US Foreign Policy after the Cold War, pp. 207-222. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
62.
Sagan, S.
(1993) The Limits of Safety: Organizations, Accidents and Nuclear Weapons. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
63.
Steinbruner, J.
(1974) The Cybernetic Theory of Decision. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
64.
Stern, E.
(1992) `High Politics and Crisis: Military and Environmental Dimensions of Security', in A. Hjort af Ornäs and S. Lodgaard (eds) The Environment and International Security, pp. 79-94. Uppsala: PRIO/Uppsala University Program on Environment and International Security.
65.
Stern, E.
(1993) `Environmental Crisis and Security: Conceptualization and Case Application', paper presented at the Nordic International Studies Association, Oslo, August.
66.
Sundelius, B.
(1983) `Coping with Structural Security Threats', in Höll (ed.) Small States in Europe and Dependence, 281-305. Vienna: Braumüller.
67.
Sundelius, B.
(ed.) (1987) The Neutral Democracies and the New Cold War. Boulder, CO: Westview.
68.
Tuchman-Mathews, J.
(1989) `Redefining Security', Foreign Affairs68(2): 162-177.
69.
Tuchman-Mathews, J.
(1994) `The Environment and International Security', in M. Klare and D. Thomas (eds) World Security: Challenges for a New Century, pp. 274-289. New York: St Martin's Press.
70.
Tully, J.
(1988) Meaning and Context: Quentin Skinner and His Critics. Cambridge: Polity Press.
71.
Ullman, R.
(1983) `Redefining Security', International Security8(1): 129-153.
72.
Vertzberger, Y.
(1991) The World in Their Minds. Palo Alto, CA: Stanford University Press.
73.
Väyrynen, R.
(1990) `Towards a Comprehensive Definition of Security: Pitfalls and Promises', paper delivered at the Annual Convention of the International Studies Association, Washington, DC, 10-14 April.
74.
Walt, S.
(1991) `The Renaissance of Security Studies', International Studies Quarterly35(2): 211-239.
75.
Westing, A.
(ed.) (1985) Explosive Remnants of War: Mitigating the Environmental Effects. London: Taylor and Francis.
76.
Westing, A.
(1989) Comprehensive Security for the Baltic: An Environmental Approach. London: Sage.
77.
Wildavski, A.
(1988) Searching for Safety. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction.
78.
Wæver, O.
(1993) `Securitization and Desecuritization', Working paper. Copenhagen: Center for Peace and Conflict Research.
79.
Young, O.
(1989) International Cooperation: Building Regimes for Natural Resources and the Environment. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
80.
Zartman, I. W.
(1988) `Alternative Attempts at Crisis Management: Concepts and Processes', in Winham (ed.) New Issues in International Crisis Management, pp. 199-223. Boulder, CO: Westview.
