This article should be seen as a contribution to the new pluralistic debate on integration theory focusing on the problem of political change in integration systems. It departs from the assumption that no single integration theory can account for all aspects of European Community (EC) development. There would seem to be a considerable complementarity between individual integration theories; not only do they often study different dimensions of integration, it could be argued that they also focus on problems relating to different stages in the evolution of an integration system. Viewing the EC as a political system, the author elaborates on Lindberg and Scheingold's observations in Europe's Would-Be Polity (1970) regarding patterns of political change in the Community. The article suggests a wider set of categories of political change, distinguishing between the nature of integration dynamics (directed/undirected) and the degree of change (marginal/incremental/dramatic). A second section looks in more detail at the category of system transformation, stressing the importance of the international environment in explaining such transformations. A final section examines the extent to which the adoption of the Single European Act can be said to have constituted a system transformation.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Colchester, Nicholas
and Buchan, David (1990) Europe Relaunched. Truths and Illusions on the Way to 1992. London: Economist Books.
2.
De Schoutheete, Philippe
(1990) `The European Community and Its Subsystems', in W. Wallace (1990).
3.
Delors, Jacques
(1990) `Inaugural Address to CEPS Sixth Annual Conference'. Governing Europe. 1989 Annual Conference Proceedings, Vol. 1 CEPS.
4.
Deutsch, Karl W.
(1957) Political Community in the North Atlantic Area. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
5.
Easton, David
(1953) The Political System. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.
6.
Ehlermann, Claus Dieter
(1990) `The Institutional Development of the EC under the Single European Act'. Aussenpolitik. II.
7.
Etzioni, Amitai
(1965) Political Unification. London: Reinhardt Holt and Winston.
8.
Etzioni, Amitai
(1968) The Active Society. New York.
9.
Frei, Daniel
(1984) `Integrations Prozesse', in W. Weidenfeld (ed.) Die Identität Europas. Munich: C. Hauser Verlag.
10.
Gazzo, Marina
(1985) Towards European Union. Luxembourg; Agence Europe.
11.
Genco, Stephen
(1980) `Integration Theory and System Change in Western Europe: The Neglected Role of Systems Transformation Episodes', in O. Holsti, R. Siverson and A. George (eds) Change in the International System. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
12.
George, Stephen
(1989) Politics and Policies in the European Communities. Oxford: Clarendon.
13.
Ginsberg, Roy H.
(1989) `Foreign Policy Actions of the European Community'. The Politics of Scale. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers.
14.
Haahr, Jens Henrik
(1991) European Integration and Interventionist Political Forces in Britain and Denmark. Aarhus: Institut for Statskundskab.
15.
Haas, Ernest B.
(1961) `International Integration: The European and the Universal Process', International Organization15: 366-392.
16.
Haywood, Elizabeth Z.
(1989) `The French Socialists and European Institutional Reform', Journal of European Integration12 (2-3).
17.
Heraclides, Alexis
(1990) `From Autonomy to Secession: Building Down', in A. J. R. Groom and P. Taylor (eds) Frameworks for International Cooperation. London: Pinter.
18.
Hodges, Michael
(1972) European Integration. Harmondsworth: Penguin.
19.
Hoffmann, Stanley
(1966) `Obstinate or Obsolete? The Fate of the Nation-state and the Case of Western Europe', Daedalus95: 862-915.
20.
Holsti, K. J.
(1980) `Change in the International System: Interdependence, Integration and Fragmentation', in Holsti et al. (1980) Change in the International System. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
21.
Huntington, Samuel P.
(1971) `The Change to Change. Modernization, Development and Politics', Comparative Politics3 (April).
22.
Jacob, Philip E.
and Toscano, James V. (eds) (1964) The Integration of Political Communities. Philadelphia: J. B. Lipincott.
23.
Kelstrup, Morten
(1990) `Politologisk integrationsteori og den ny dynamik i Vest-og Østeuropa'. Fra: Morten Kelstrup (red.), Tendenser i Politologien III. Copenhagen: Politiske Studier.
24.
Keohane, Robert
and Hoffmann, Stanley (1990) `Conclusions: Community Politics and Institutional Change', in W. Wallace (1990).
25.
Laursen, Finn
(1990) `Explaining the EC's New Momentum', in Finn Laursen (ed.) EFTA and the EC: Implications of 1992. Maastricht.
26.
Lindberg, Leon
(1963) The Political Dynamics of European Economic Integration. London: Oxford University Press.
27.
Lindberg, Leon
and Scheingold, Stuart (1970) Europe's Would-Be Polity. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
28.
Lindberg, Leon
and Scheingold, Stuart (eds) (1971) Regional Integration: Theory and Research. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
29.
Lodge, Juliet
(ed.) (1989) The European Community and the Challenge of the Future. London: Pinter.
30.
Ludlow, Peter
(1989) `Beyond 1992. Europe and its Western Partners'. Centre for European Policy Studies. Brussels.
31.
May, Bernhard
(1982) Kosten und Nutzen der deutschen EG-Mitgliedschaft. Europa Union Verlag.
32.
Mitrany, David
(1943) A Working Peace System.
33.
Moravcsik, Andrew
(1991) `Negotiating the Single European Act: National Interests and Conventional Statecraft in the European Community', International Organization45(1), Winter.
34.
Nedergaard, Peter
(1990) EF's Markedsintegration. DJØF Forlag.
35.
Noel, Emile
(1989) `The Single European Act: Meaning and Perspectives', in Contemporary European Affairs1 (1-2).
36.
Nye, Joseph S.
(1968) `Comparative Regional Integration: Concepts and Measurement', International Organization22: 855-880.
37.
Nye, Joseph S.
(1971) Peace in Parts. Boston, MA: Little, Brown.
38.
Nye, Joseph S.
(1965) `Patterns and Catalysts in Regional Integration', International Organization19.
39.
Nye, Joseph
and Keohane, Robert (1975) `International Interdependence and Integration', in Grunskin and Polssy (eds) Handbook of Political Science, Vol. 8.
40.
Pedersen, Thomas
(1989) Bonn-Paris-London: Partners or Rivals?Copenhagen: SNU.
41.
Pedersen, Thomas
(1990) `Problems of Enlargement: Political Integration in a Pan-European EC'. Cooperation and Conflict25: 83-99.
42.
Pelkmans, Jacques
and Winters, Alan (1988) Europe's Domestic Market. London: Routledge and Royal Institute of International Affairs.
43.
Pentland, Charles
(1973) International Theory and European Integration. London: Faber and Faber.
44.
Reshaping Europe
(1991) A Report from the European Round Table of Industrialists. Brussels.
Rosenthal, Glenda G.
(1975) The Men Behind the Decisions. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
47.
Sandholz, Wayne
and John Zysman (1989) `1992: Recasting the European Bargain', World Politics62.
48.
Schmitter, Philippe
(1969) `Three Neo-functionalist Hypotheses about International Integration', International Organization23.
49.
Simonean, Haig
(1985) The Privileged Partnership. Oxford: Clarendon.
50.
Taylor, Paul
(1968) `The Concept of Community and the European Integration Process', Journal of Common Market Studies7(2).
51.
Tranholm-Mikkelsen, Jeppe
(1991) `Neo-functionalism: Obstinate or Obsolete? A Reappraisal in the Light of the New Dynamism of the EC', Millennium20(1).
52.
Wallace, Helen
(1985) Europe: The Challenge of Diversity. Chatham House Papers No. 29. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
53.
Wallace, William
(ed.) (1990) The Dynamics of European Integration. London: Pinter.
54.
Wallace, William
(1989) The Transformation of Western Europe. London: Pinter.
55.
Wheare, K. C.
(1946) Federal Government. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
