This study investigates the normative dimension of emotions within domestic politics for international issues. Focusing on Turkish–Greek relations during a period of heightened tension (June–November 2022), we examine how pro-government media constructs hostility towards Greece as a central emotion norm linked to national identity. Employing corpus-assisted discourse analysis within the framework of the subjective group dynamics model, we analyse how opposition figures are portrayed as deviants who do not embody this emotion norm and marginalized as external to the nation. Our findings highlight the powerful role of emotions in both unifying and dividing domestic politics on foreign policy issues and regarding international actors. Furthermore, the study contributes to understanding of the media’s role in populist polarization and political contestation surrounding the emotional dimensions of national identity.
AbramsDTravaglinoGA (2018) Immigration, political trust, and Brexit – Testing an aversion amplification hypothesis. British Journal of Social Psychology57: 310–326.
2.
AbramsDMarquesJMBownN, et al. (2000) Pro-norm and anti-norm deviance within and between groups. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology78(5): 906–912.
3.
AbramsDMarquesJMRandsleydeMouraG, et al. (2006) The maintenance of entitativity: A subjective group dynamics approach. In: YzerbytVJuddCMCorneilleO (eds) The Psychology of Group Perception: Perceived Variability, Entitativity and Essentialism. Psychology Press, pp. 361–380.
4.
AbramsDTravaglinoGAMarquesJM, et al. (2022) Collective deviance: Scaling up subjective group dynamics to superordinate categories reveals a deviant ingroup protection effect. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology123(2): 353–372.
5.
AgiusC (2024) Weak, immoral, naïve: Gendered representations of neutrality and the emotional politics of peace and security. Cooperation and Conflict59(2): 266–289.
6.
AhmedS (2004) Affective economies. Social Text22(2): 117–139.
7.
AkhrifHKoschutS (2024) Emotion and norms in international shaming practices. In: OrchardPWienerA (eds) Contesting the World: Norm Research in Theory and Practice. Cambridge University Press, pp. 101–114.
AkserMBaybarsB (2023) Repressed media and illiberal politics in Turkey: The persistence of fear. Southeast European and Black Sea Studies23(1): 159–177.
10.
BauvoisGPyrhönenNPyysiäinenJ (2022) Underdogs shepherding the flock – Discursive outgrouping of ‘the internal enemy’ in online discussions. In: PettersonKNortioE (eds) The Far-Right Discourse of Multiculturalism in Intergroup Interactions. Springer, pp. 51–84.
11.
BerezinM (2001) Emotions and political identity: Mobilizing affection for the polity. In: GoodwinJJasperJMPollettaF (eds) Passionate Politics: Emotions and Social Movements. University of Chicago Press, pp. 83–98.
12.
BerndtRM (1962) Excess and Restraint: Social Control Among a New Guinea Mountain People. University of Chicago Press.
13.
BeyerMVon ScheveCIsmerS (2014) The social consequences of collective emotions: National identification, solidarity and out-group derogation. In: SullivanG (ed.) Understanding Collective Pride and Group Identity. Routledge, pp. 67–79.
14.
BliucAMMcGartyCReynoldsK, et al. (2007) Opinion-based group membership as a predictor of commitment to political action. European Journal of Social Psychology37(1): 19–32.
15.
BodenhausenGVMussweilerTGabrielS, et al. (2012) Affective influences on stereotyping and intergroup relations. In: ForgasJP (ed.) Handbook of Affect and Social Cognition. Psychology Press, pp. 339–364.
16.
BrauerMChekrounP (2005) The relationship between perceived violation of social norms and social control: Situational factors influencing the reaction to deviance. Journal of Applied Social Psychology35(7): 1519–1539.
17.
CairnsERoeMD (2003) Introduction: Why memories in conflict? In: CairnsERoeMD (eds) The Role of Memory in Ethnic Conflict. Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 3–8.
18.
CervoneCAugoustinosMMaassA (2021) The language of derogation and hate: Functions, consequences, and reappropriation. Journal of Language and Social Psychology40(1): 80–101.
19.
ClémentMKoschutS (2024) Emotions in international relations. In: FlamH (ed.) Research Handbook on the Sociology of Emotion. Edward Elgar Publishing, pp. 380–399.
20.
DelvauxEMeeussenLMesquitaB (2016) Emotions are not always contagious: Longitudinal spreading of self-pride and group pride in homogeneous and status-differentiated groups. Cognition and Emotion30(1): 101–116.
21.
DilekGFilippidouE (2015) Turkey and Greece: Reconstructing a shared past. In: GuyverR (ed.) Teaching History and the Changing Nation State: Transnational and Intranational Perspectives. Bloomsbury Academic, pp. 75–94.
22.
FeinsteinY (2024) The tempest within: The origins and outcomes of intense national emotions in times of national division. Theory and Society53: 729–763.
23.
FinlayML (2007) The propaganda of extreme hostility: Denunciation and the regulation of the group. British Journal of Social Psychology46(2): 323–341.
24.
FinlayWML (2014) Denunciation and the construction of norms in group conflict: Examples from an Al-Qaeda-supporting group. British Journal of Social Psychology53(4): 691–710. DOI: 10.1111/bjso.12052.
25.
HagströmLWagnssonCLundströmM (2023) Logics of othering: Sweden as other in the time of COVID-19. Cooperation and Conflict58(3): 315–334.
26.
HallgrenKA (2012) Computing inter-rater reliability for observational data: An overview and tutorial. Tutorials in Quantitative Methods for Psychology8(1): 23–34.
27.
HeadN (2020) Contesting emotional governance–empathy under fire in the Israeli public sphere during Operation Protective Edge. In: KoschutS (ed.) The Power of Emotions in World Politics. Routledge, pp. 113–129.
28.
HeraclidesA (2010) The Greek-Turkish Conflict in the Aegean. Palgrave Macmillan.
29.
HopkinsNKahani-HopkinsV (2006) Minority group members’ theories of intergroup contact: A case study of British Muslims’ conceptualizations of Islamophobia and social change. British Journal of Social Psychology45: 245–264.
30.
HornseyMJ (2016) Dissent and deviance in intergroup contexts. Current Opinion in Psychology11: 1–5.
31.
HutchisonE (2016) Affective Communities in World Politics. Cambridge University Press.
32.
KauffMAsbrockFWagnerU, et al. (2017) (Bad) feelings about meeting them? Episodic and chronic intergroup emotions associated with positive and negative intergroup contact as predictors of intergroup behavior. Frontiers in Psychology 8: 1449, 1–11.
33.
KoschutS (2014) Emotional (security) communities: The significance of emotion norms in inter-allied conflict management. Review of International Studies40(3): 533–558.
34.
KoschutS (2017) The structure of feeling – Emotion culture and national self-sacrifice in world politics. Millennium: Journal of International Studies45(2): 174–192.
35.
KoschutS (2018) Appropriately upset? A methodological framework for tracing the emotion norms of the transatlantic security community. Politics and Governance6(4): 125–134.
36.
KoschutS (2019) Can the bereaved speak? Emotional governance and the contested meanings of grief after the Berlin terror attack. Journal of International Political Theory15(2): 148–166.
37.
KoschutS (2022) Reintegrative shaming in international relations: NATO’s military intervention in Libya. Journal of International Relations and Development25: 497–522.
38.
KoschutS (2024) Feeling European? The EU as an emotional community. Journal of European Integration46(5): 597–613.
39.
KoseMABreezeR (2024) Displays of anger in Turkish political discourse: A hard choice between cultural norms and political performance of anger. Language and Cognition16: 843–866.
40.
KostarellaI (2007) Framing the other: Turkey in the Greek press. GMI: Mediterranean Edition2(1): 23–32.
41.
LeonardDJMoonsWGMackieDM, et al. (2011) ‘We’re mad as hell and we’re not going to take it anymore’: Anger self-stereotyping and collective action. Group Processes & Intergroup Relations14(1): 99–111.
42.
LevineJMKerrNL (2007) Inclusion and exclusion: Implications for group processes. In: KruglanskiAEHigginsET (eds) Social Psychology: Handbook of Basic Principles. Guilford Press, pp. 759–784.
43.
LevineJMMorelandRL (2002) Group reactions to loyalty and disloyalty. In: ThyeSRLawlerEJ (eds) Advances in Group Processes. Emerald Group Publishing Limited, pp. 203–228.
44.
MackieDMSmithER (2017) Group-based emotion in group processes and intergroup relations. Group Processes & Intergroup Relations20(5): 658–668.
45.
MatsumotoDHwangHCFrankMG (2013) Emotional language and political aggression. Journal of Language and Social Psychology32(4): 452–468.
NiedenthalPMBrauerM (2012) Social functionality of human emotion. Annual Review of Psychology63(1): 259–285.
48.
OppenheimerL (2006) The development of enemy images: A theoretical contribution. Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology12(3): 269–292.
49.
ParkinsonB (2019) Heart to Heart: How Your Emotions Affect Other People. Cambridge University Press.
50.
ParkinsonB (2021) Heart to heart: A relation-alignment approach to emotion’s social effects. Emotion Review13(2): 78–89.
51.
ParsonsT (1951) The Social System. Free Press.
52.
PintoIRMarquesJMPaezD (2016) National identification as a function of perceived social control: A subjective group dynamics analysis. Group Processes & Intergroup Relations19(2): 236–256.
53.
ReicherSHaslamSAHopkinsN (2005) Social identity and the dynamics of leadership: Leaders and followers as collaborative agents in the transformation of social reality. The Leadership Quarterly16(4): 547–568.
54.
ReysenSBranscombeNR (2008) Belief in collective emotions as conforming to the group. Social Influence3(3): 171–188.
55.
RieberRW (2013) Manufacturing Social Distress: Psychopathy in Everyday Life. Springer Science & Business Media.
56.
RieberRWKellyRJ (1991) Substance and shadow: Images of the enemy. In: RieberWR (ed.) The Psychology of War and Peace: The Image of the Enemy. Plenum, pp. 3–39.
57.
RumeliliBStrömbomL (2022) Agonistic recognition as a remedy for identity backlash: Insights from Israel and Turkey. Third World Quarterly43(6): 1361–1379.
58.
SakkiIMartikainenJ (2021) Mobilizing collective hatred through humour: Affective–discursive production and reception of populist rhetoric. British Journal of Social Psychology60(2): 610–634.
59.
SchachterS (1951) Deviation, rejection, and communication. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology46: 190–207.
60.
SchulzAWirthWMüllerP (2020) We are the people and you are fake news: A social identity approach to populist citizens’ false consensus and hostile media perceptions. Communication Research47(2): 201–226.
61.
ShayeghJStoreyLTurnerRN, et al. (2022) A social identity approach to how elite outgroups are invoked by politicians and the media in nativist populism. Political Psychology43(6): 1009–1025.
62.
StephanWGStephanCW (1985) Intergroup anxiety. Journal of Social Issues41(3): 157–175.
63.
SuhayE (2015) Explaining group influence: The role of identity and emotion in political conformity and polarization. Political Behavior37(1): 221–251.
64.
ThoitsPA (2004) Emotion norms, emotion work, and social order. In: MansteadASFrijdaNFischerA (eds) Feelings and Emotions: The Amsterdam Symposium. Cambridge University Press, pp. 359–378.
65.
ThomasEFMcGartyCMavorKI (2009) Aligning identities, emotions, and beliefs to create commitment to sustainable social and political action. Personality and Social Psychology Review13(3): 194–218.
66.
Tolia-KellyDP (2020) Affective nationalisms and race. Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space38(4): 589–591.
67.
VersteegenPL (2024) We love, they hate: Emotions in affective polarization and how partisans may use them. Political Psychology45: 1031–1049.
68.
VishkinATamirM (2023) Emotion Norms Are Unique. Affective Science4(3): 453–457.
69.
WilliamsKDGovanCL (2005) Reacting to ostracism: Retaliation or reconciliation? In: AbramsDHoggMAMarquesJM (eds) The Social Psychology of Inclusion and Exclusion. Psychology Press, pp. 47–62.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
