When risky decisions are not surprising: An application of prospect theory to the Israeli war decision in 2006

Abstract

On 12 July 2006, Hezbollah operatives crossed into Israel and attacked a military patrol, killing three soldiers and kidnapping two more. In retaliation to this incident Israel launched a military operation that resulted in 34 days of fighting between Hezbollah and Israel. The Israeli retaliation has been deemed to be severe and surprising. Furthermore, a public investigation commission established by the Israeli government implicated key decision-makers, and especially Prime Minister Olmert, as guilty of hasty and irresponsible decision-making. This article views this case through the lens of prospect theory, showing how the decision was made at the framing stage, and suggesting that this decision was not hasty but, rather, was consistent with the logic of loss-aversion.

Keywords

decision-making Hezbollah Israel prospect theory second Lebanon War

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ben

(2006) A Workshop on the Second Lebanon War (11/1/2006). Herzliya, Israel: Interdisciplinary Center Herzliya.

Ben-Israel

(2007) First Missiles War Israel – Hezbollah (summer 2006, policy paper). Tel Aviv, Israel: Security Studies Program, Tel Aviv University.

Berejekian

(1997) The gains debate: framing state choice. American Political Science Review 91(4): 789–805.

Beyer

Klein

McGirk

Zabriskie

Thompson

(2006) What was he thinking? Time 168(5): 38–43.

Boettcher

(1995) Context, methods, numbers, and words: prospect theory in international relations. Journal of Conflict Resolution 39(3): 561–583.

Boettcher

(2004) The prospects for prospect theory: an empirical evaluation of international relations applications of framing and loss aversion. Political Psychology 25(3): 331–362.

Boettcher

(2005) Presidential Risk Behavior in Foreign Policy: Prudence or Peril? New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

Bueno de Mesquita

(1981) The War Trap. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

Bueno de Mesquita

Morrow

Zorick

(1997) Capabilities, Perception, and Escalation. American Political Science Review 91(1): 15–27.

10.

Bueno de Mesquita

McDermott

(2004) Crossing no man’s land: cooperation from the trenches. Political Psychology 25(2): 271–287.

11.

Callaway

Esser

(1984) Groupthink: effects of cohesiveness and problem-solving procedures on group decision making. Social Behavior & Personality 12(2): 157–164.

12.

Ephron

Dickey

Chen

(2006) Sharon’s shadow. Newsweek 148(3): 30–32.

13.

Farnham

(1992) Roosevelt and the Munich crisis: insights from prospect theory. Political Psychology 13(2): 205–235.

14.

Harris

(2007) Crisis in the Levant: Lebanon at risk. Mediterranean Quarterly 18(2): 37–60.

15.

Hart

Stern

Sundelius

(1997) Beyond Groupthink: Political Group Dynamics and Foreign Policy-Making. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.

16.

Feng

(2009) Leadership, regime security, and China’s policy towards Taiwan: prospect theory and Taiwan crises. Pacific Review 22(4): 501–521.

17.

Holsti

(1991) Peace and War: Armed Conflicts and International Order 1648–1989. New York: Cambridge University Press.

18.

Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs (n.d.) Elections in Israel March 2006 (election results as posted by the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs). Available at: http://www.mfa.gov.il/mfa/aboutisrael/history/pages/elections%20in%20israel%20march%202006.aspx

19.

Ivry

(2006) A Workshop on the Second Lebanon War (11/1/2006). Herzliya, Israel: Interdisciplinary Center Herzliya.

20.

Janis

(1982) Groupthink: Psychological Studies of Policy Decisions and Fiascos. Boston, MA: Houghton Miffin.

21.

Jervis

(1968) Hypotheses on misperception. World Politics 20(3): 454–479.

22.

Jervis

(2004) The implications of prospect theory for human nature and values. Political Psychology 25(2): 163–176.

23.

Kahnman

Tversky

(1979) Prospect theory: an analysis of decision under risk. Econometrica 47(2): 263.

24.

Kameda

Sugimori

(1993) Psychological entrapment in group decision making: an assigned decision rule and a groupthink phenomenon. Journal of Personality & Social Psychology 65(2): 282–292.

25.

Kowert

Hermann

(1997) Who takes risks? Daring and caution in foreign policy making. The Journal of Conflict Resolution 41(5): 611–637.

26.

Lambeth

(2012) Learning from Lebanon. Naval War College Review 65(3): 82–104.

27.

Levy

(1997) Prospect theory, rational choice, and international relations. International Studies Quarterly 41(1): 87–112.

28.

Levy

(2002) Prospect theory: much ado about nothing? Management Science 48(10): 1334–1349.

29.

Lobell

(2006) The international realm, framing effects, and security strategies: Britain in peace and war. International Interactions 32(1): 27–48.

30.

McDermott

(1998) Risk-Taking in International Politics. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.

31.

McDermott

(2004a) Political Psychology in International Relations. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.

32.

McDermott

(2004b) Prospect theory in political science: gains and losses from the first decade. Political Psychology 25(2): 289–312.

33.

Malca

(2006) A Workshop on the Second Lebanon War (11/1/2006). Herzliya, Israel: Interdisciplinary Center Herzliya.

34.

Mastanduno

(1992) Framing the Japan problem: the Bush administration and the structural impediments initiative. International Journal 47(2): 235–264.

35.

Mckeown

(1992) Decision processes and the co-operation in foreign policy. International Journal 47(2): 402–419.

36.

Mercer

(2005) Prospect theory and political science. Annual Review of Political Science 8: 1–21.

37.

Mintz

(2004) How do leaders make decisions? A poliheuristic perspective. Journal of Conflict Resolution 48(1): 3–13.

38.

Montgomery

Petty John

(2010) Democratization, instability, and war: Israel’s 2006 conflicts with Hamas and Hezbollah. Security Studies 19: 521–554.

39.

Neale

Bazerman

(1985) Perspectives for understanding negotiation: viewing negotiation as a judgmental process. Journal of Conflict Resolution 29(1): 33–55.

40.

Olmert

(2008) Address to the Knesset on the Winograd Committee Report Ministry of Foreign Affairs Press Room. Available at: http://www.mfa.gov.il/mfa/pressroom/2008/pages/address%20by%20pm%20ehud%20olmert%20to%20the%20knesset%20on%20the%20winograd%20committee%20report%204-feb-2008.aspx

41.

Olmert

(2014) In retrospect: the Second Lebanon War. Military and Strategic Affairs 6(1): 3–18.

42.

O’Neill

(2001) Risk aversion in international relations theory. International Studies Quarterly 45: 617–640.

43.

Ratnesar

(2006) Is Ehud Olmert feeling lucky? Time 167(16): 50–52.

44.

Richardson

(1992) Avoiding and incurring losses: decision-making in the Suez Crisis. International Journal 47(2): 370–401.

45.

Rosati

(2000) The power of human cognition in the study of world politics. International Studies Review 2(3): 45–75.

46.

Shafir

(1992) Prospect theory and political analysis: a psychological perspective. Political Psychology 13(2): 311–322.

47.

Shelah

Limor

(2007) Captive in Lebanon: The Truth about the Second Lebanon War. Tel-Aviv: Yediot Books.

48.

Sivoni

Kolic

(2009) Summary – the 2nd Lebanon War as a watershed. Strategy and Military 1(2): 5–60.

49.

Statistics Lebanon Ltd (n.d.) Public Opinion in Lebanon based on Statistics Lebanon Ltd. Company as published at www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/arabs/lebpo.html

50.

Stern

Sundelius

(1997) Sweden’s twin monetary crises of 1992: rigidity and learning in crisis decision making. Journal of Contingencies & Crisis Management 5(1): 32–48.

51.

Taliaferro

(2004) Power politics and the balance of risk: hypotheses on great power intervention in the periphery. Political Psychology 25(2): 177–211.

52.

Telhami

(2007) Lebanese identity and Israeli security in the shadows of the 2006 War. Current History 106(696): 21–26.

53.

Winograd

(2007) The Commission of Examination for the 2nd Lebanon War: Interim Report Jerusalem. Available at: http://www.vaadatwino.gov.il/index.html

54.

Winograd

(2008) The Commission of Examination for the 2nd Lebanon War: Final Report Jerusalem. Available at: http://www.vaadatwino.gov.il/index.html