Democratic accountability of international organizations: Parliamentary control within the Council of Europe and the OSCE and the prospects for the United Nations
Restricted accessOtherFirst published online June, 2010
Democratic accountability of international organizations: Parliamentary control within the Council of Europe and the OSCE and the prospects for the United Nations
Many international organizations, including the United Nations, are accused of lacking democratic accountability. A variety of proposals have been made to close the gap between their extended influence and the lack of effective controlling mechanisms to prevent abuses of power. This article focuses on one specific proposal: the establishment of parliamentary assemblies. Based on the experiences of the Council of Europe and the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe, it presents the factors that enable such assemblies to exercise parliamentary control and influence towards intergovernmental decision-making bodies.The article shows how a parliamentary dimension can be introduced conceptually into the debate on the democratic accountability of international organizations and how these insights support the reflections on a United Nations parliamentary assembly.
Alger, Chadwick F. ( 2007) ‘Widening Participation’, in Thomas G. Weiss and Sam Daws (eds) The Oxford Handbook on the United Nations, pp. 701-15. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
2.
Archibugi, Daniele ( 1995) ‘From the United Nations to Cosmopolitan Democracy’ , in Daniele Archibugi and David Held (eds) Cosmopolitan Democracy: An Agenda for a New World Order, pp. 121-62. Cambridge: Polity Press.
3.
Archibugi, Daniele, Balduini, Sveva and Donati, Marco ( 2000) ‘The United Nations as an Agency of Global Democracy’ , in Barry Holden (ed.) Global Democracy: Key Debates, pp. 125-42. London: Routledge.
4.
Benoît-Rohmer, Florence and Klebes, Heinrich ( 2005) Council of Europe Law - Towards a Pan-European Legal Area . Strasbourg: Council of Europe Publishing.
5.
Boutros-Ghali, Boutros ( 1995) ‘Democracy: A Newly Recognized Imperative’ , Global Governance1: 3-11.
6.
Brühl, Tanja and Rittberger, Volker ( 2001) ‘From International to Global Governance: Actors, Collective Decision-Making, and the United Nations in the World of the Twenty-First Century’, in Volker Rittberger (ed.) Global Governance and the United Nations System, pp. 1-47. Tokyo : United Nations University Press.
7.
Buchsbaum, Thomas M. ( 1993) ‘The 1993 Session of the CSCE Parliamentary Assembly’ , Helsinki Monitor4: 26-35.
8.
Cabrera, Luis ( 2007) ‘The Inconveniences of Transnational Democracy’ , Ethics and International Affairs21: 219-38.
9.
Childers, Erskine ( 1997) ‘The United Nations and Global Institutions: Discourse and Reality’, Global Governance3: 269-76.
10.
Council of Europe (1997) ‘Monitoring of Compliance with Commitments entered into by Council of Europe Member States: An Overview’, in Council of Europe (ed.) Methodology for Implementing Mechanisms for Monitoring Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe and the OSCE. Strasbourg : Council of Europe Publishing.
11.
Dahl, Robert ( 1999) ‘Can International Institutions Be Democratic? A Skeptic’s View’, in Ian Shapiro and Casiano Hacker-Cordón (eds) Democracy’s Edges, pp. 19-36. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
12.
De Vel, Guy ( 1995) The Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe. Strasbourg: Council of Europe Publishing.
13.
Degn, Helle ( 2001) ‘The OSCE Parliamentary Assembly - Growth in Recent Years‘, in Institute of Peace Research and Security Policy at the University of Hamburg (ed.) OSCE Yearbook2001, pp. 365-72. Baden-Baden: Nomos.
14.
Ebrahim, Almoor and Herz, Steve ( 2007) ‘Accountability in Complex Organizations: World Bank Responses to Civil Society’, KSG Faculty Research Working Papers Series07-060. Harvard University.
15.
Falk, Richard ( 2002) ‘The United Nations System: Proposals for Renewal’ , in Deepak Nayyar (ed.) Governing Globalization, pp. 177-208. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
16.
Falk, Richard and Strauss, Andrew ( 2001) ‘Toward Global Parliament’, Foreign Affairs80: 212-20.
17.
Frey, Bruno S. and Stutzer, Alois ( 2006) ‘Strengthening the Citizen’s Role in International Organizations’, Review of International Organizations1: 27-43.
18.
Galbreath, David J. ( 2007) The Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe . London: Routledge.
19.
Ghebali, Victor-Yves ( 1996) L’OSCE dans l’Europe Post-Communiste, 1990-1996: Vers une Identité Paneuropéenne de Sécurité. Bruxelles: Bruylant.
20.
Gramlich, Ludwig ( 2003) ‘Die legitimierende Wirkung der Parlamentarischen Versammlung im Rahmen des Europarats und der OSZE’, in Rudolf Geiger (ed.) Neuere Probleme der parlamentarischen Legitimation im Bereich der auswärtigen Gewalt, pp. 113-33. Baden-Baden : Nomos.
21.
Grant, Ruth W. and Keohane, Robert O. ( 2005) ‘Accountability and Abuses of Power in World Politics’ , American Political Science Review99: 29-43.
22.
Gstöhl, Sieglinde ( 2007) ‘Governance through Government Networks: The G8 and International Organizations’, Review of International Organizations2: 1-37.
23.
Habegger, Beat ( 2005) Parlamentarismus in der internationalen Politik: Europarat, OSZE und InterparlamentarischeUnion. Baden-Baden: Nomos.
24.
Haller, Bruno ( 2007) An Assembly for Europe: The Council of Europe’s Parliamentary Assembly 1949-1989. Strasbourg: Council of Europe Publishing.
25.
Haller, Bruno, Krüger, Hans Christian and Petzold, Herbert, eds (2000) Law in Greater Europe: Towards a Common Legal Area. The Hague: Kluwer.
26.
Haller, Gret ( 2000) ‘Der Schutz der Menschenrechte im Wirkungsfeld von Europarat und OSZE’, in Bruno Haller , Hans Christian Krüger and Herbert Petzold (eds) Law in Greater Europe: Towards a Common Legal Area, pp. 310-30. The Hague: Kluwer.
27.
Huber, Denis ( 1999) A Decade that Made History: The Council of Europe 1989-1999 . Strasbourg: Council of Europe .
28.
Jaag, Tobias and Schaerer, Corinne ( 2002) ‘Die Konventionen des Europarats’, Schweizerische Zeitschrift für internationales und europäisches Recht12: pp. 103-37.
29.
Jaskiernia, Jerzy ( 2003) The Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe. Warsaw: Information Office of the Council of Europe .
30.
Kennedy, Paul ( 2006) The Parliament of Man: The Past, Present, and Future of the United Nations. New York: Random House.
31.
Keohane, Robert O. ( 2006) ‘Accountability in World Politics’, Scandinavian Political Studies29: 75-87.
32.
Keohane, Robert O. and Nye, Joseph S. ( 2001) ‘Between Centralization and Fragmentation: The Club Model of Multilateral Cooperation and Problems of Democratic Legitimacy’ , KSG Faculty Research Working Papers Series01-004. Harvard University.
33.
Kissling, Claudia ( 2006) Die Interparlamentarische Union im Wandel. Frankfurt: Lang.
34.
Klebes, Heinrich ( 1998) ‘Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe and National Legislative Procedures’, in Ulrich Karpen and Edgar Michael Wenz (eds) National Legislation in the European Framework, pp. 289-97. Baden-Baden : Nomos.
35.
Kraft-Kasack, Christiane ( 2008) ‘Transnational Parliamentary Assemblies: A Remedy for the Democratic Deficit of International Governance?’ West European Politics31: 534-57.
36.
Lindemann, Hans-Heinrich and Walter, Christian ( 1997) ‘Parliamentary Assemblies, International’ , in Max Planck Institute for Comparative Public Law and International Law (ed.) Encyclopedia of Public International Law (Vol. 3), pp. 892-904. Amsterdam: Elsevier .
37.
McGrew, Anthony ( 2002) ‘Democratising Global Institutions: Possibilities, Limits and Normative Foundations’, in James Anderson (ed.) Transnational Democracy: Political Spaces and Border Crossings, pp. 149-70. London: Routledge.
38.
MacMullen, Andrew ( 2004) ‘Intergovernmental Functionalism? The Council of Europe in European Integration’, Journal of European Integration26: 405-29.
39.
Marschall, Stefan ( 2005) Transnationale Repräsentation in Parlamentarischen Versammlungen: Demokratie und Parlamentarismus jenseits des Nationalstaates . Baden-Baden: Nomos.
40.
Mathews, Jessica T. ( 1997) ‘Power Shift’, Foreign Affairs76: 50-66.
41.
Nye, Joseph S. ( 2001) ‘Globalization’s Democratic Deficit: How to Make International Institutions More Accountable’, Foreign Affairs80: 2-6.
42.
Oliver, Robert Spencer ( 1996) ‘The OSCE Parliamentary Assembly’, Helsinki Monitor7: 42-57.
43.
Patzelt, Werner J. ( 2003) ‘Parlamente und ihre Funktionen’, in Werner J. Patzelt (ed.) Parlamente und ihre Funktionen, pp. 13-49. Wiesbaden: Westdeutscher Verlag.
44.
Pöhle, Klaus ( 2003) ‘Die Interparlamentarische Union als Faktor demokratischer Legitimation im völkerrechtlichen Bereich’, in Rudolf Geiger (ed.) Neuere Probleme der parlamentarischen Legitimation im Bereich der auswärtigen Gewalt, pp. 139-53. Baden-Baden : Nomos.
45.
Šabič, Zlatko ( 2008) ‘Building Democratic and Responsible Global Governance: The Role of International Parliamentary Institutions’, Parliamentary Affairs61: 255-71.
46.
Šabič, Zlatko ( 1995) International Parliamentary Organs. Ljubljana: CIR Publications.
47.
Scharpf, Fritz W. ( 1999) Governing in Europe: Effective and Democratic?Oxford: Oxford University Press.
48.
Sheppard, Robert ( 2000) ‘Towards a UN World Parliament: UN Reform for the Progressive Evolution of an Elective and Accountable Democratic Parliamentary Process in the New Millennium’, Asian-Pacific Law & Policy Journal1: 1-20.
49.
Slaughter, Anne-Marie ( 2004) A New World Order. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
50.
Stegen, Joern ( 2000) ‘Die Rolle der Parlamentarischen Versammlung als Motor des Europarats’, in Uwe Holtz (ed.) 50 Jahre Europarat, pp. 79-90. Baden-Baden : Nomos.
51.
Thomas, Daniel C. ( 2001) The Helsinki Effect: International Norms, Human Rights, and the Demise of Communism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
52.
Trent, John E. ( 2007) Modernizing the United Nations System: Civil Society’s Role in Moving from International Relations to Global Governance. Opladen/Farmington Hills: Barbara Budrich Publishers.
53.
UNDP (2002) Deepening Democracy in a Fragmented World (Human Development Report). New York : UNDP.
54.
United Nations (1996) Agenda for Democratization (UN Document A/51/761). New York.
55.
United Nations (2004) We the Peoples: Civil Society, the United Nations and Global Governance. Report of the Panel of Eminent Persons on United Nations-Civil Society Relations (UN Document A/58/827). New York.
56.
United Nations (2005) A More Secure World: Our Shared Responsibility. Report of the High-level Panel on Threats, Challenges and Change (UN Document A/59/565). New York.
57.
Walter, Christian ( 2006) ‘Vereinte Nationen und Weltgesellschaft: Zur Forderung nach Einrichtung einer parlamentarischen Versammlung (UNPA)’, in Sabine von Schorlemer (ed.) Globale Probleme und Zukunftsaufgaben der Vereinten Nationen’ (Sonderband Nr. 1 Zeitschrift für Politik), pp. 218-37. Baden-Baden: Nomos.
58.
Wapner, Paul ( 2007) ‘Civil Society’, in Thomas G. Weiss and Sam Daws (eds) The Oxford Handbook on the United Nations, pp. 254-63. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
59.
Woods, Ngaire ( 2003) ‘Holding Intergovernmental Institutions to Account’ , Ethics and International Affairs17: 69-80.
60.
Zürn, Michael ( 2000) ‘Democratic Governance beyond the Nation-State’ , European Journal of International Relations6: 183-221.
61.
Zürn, Michael ( 2002) ‘From Interdependence to Globalization’, in Walter Carlsnaes, Thomas Risse and Beth A. Simmons (eds) Handbook of International Relations, pp. 235-54. London: SAGE.
62.
Zweifel, Thomas D. ( 2006) International Organizations and Democracy: Accountability, Politics, and Power. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner.
