With a view to developing a future research agenda in integration studies, this
article derives five theoretical integration constellations from empirical cases
with varying combinations of economic dependence and shared identification:
symmetric and weak symmetric integration, two types of asymmetric integration and no
integration. Asymmetric integration is defined as a situation in which either
political/institutional integration is extensive amid a low degree of structural
economic integration (Type I), or, there is extensive structural economic
integration without any political/institutional integration (Type II). Type II,
represented by Taiwan/People's Republic of China, appears theoretically the
most interesting and is therefore examined in more detail for whether strong
economic dependence by itself conceivably can be a sufficient background condition
for political integration despite a lack of shared identification. Based on the
analysis, several future research questions are developed. Do structural and
institutional integration tend to converge over time, bringing about a more
symmetric integration constellation? If that is so, which constellation of initial
background conditions is more conducive to produce symmetric integration? Is
approximate symmetricity between the background conditions shared identification and
economic dependence a prerequisite for smooth integration?
Balassa, Bela
(1961) The Theory of Economic Integration.
Homewood, IL.: Richard D. Irwin, Inc.
2.
Barkawi, Tarak
and
Laffey, Mark
(1999)
‘The Imperial Peace, Democracy, Force and Globalization’
, European Journal of International Relations5:
404–434
.
3.
Brandt, Willy
(1992) My Life in Politics.
London: Penguin Books
.
4.
Cheng Kuo-tien
(1995) ‘The Political Economy of
Taiwan's Investments in China’, in
T-J. Cheng
,
C. Huang
and
S. Wu
(eds) Inherited Rivalry: Conflict Across the Taiwan Straits, pp.
153–172.
Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner
.
5.
chinaorg.cn(2003) ‘TSMC to Raise Investment in
Shanghai’, 15 September.
6.
Christiansen, Thomas
,
Jørgensen
,
Knud Erik
and
Wiener, Antje
(1999)
‘The Social Constuction of Europe’
, Journal of European Public Policy6 SI:
528–544
.
7.
Dent, Christopher
(2003) ‘New Free Trade Agreement (FTA) Projects in
the Asia-Pacific: Implications for Europe’, 19 May (available
at: www.eviangroup.org).
8.
Deutsch, Karl W.
,
Burrell, Sidney A.
,
Kann, Robert A.
,
Lee, Maurice, Jr.
,
Lichterman, Martin
,
Lindgren, Raymond E.
,
Loewenheim, Francis L.
and
Van Wagenen, Richard W.
(1957) Political Community and the North Atlantic Area.
International Organization in the Light of Historical Experience.
Westport, CT: Greenwood Press Publishers
.
9.
Diez, Tomas
(1999)
‘Riding the AM-Track through Europe; or the Pitfalls of a
Rationalist Journey through European Integration’
, Millennium — Journal of International Studies28:
355–370
.
10.
Etzioni, Amitai
(1965) Political Unification: A Comparative Study of Leaders
and Forces.
New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston
.
11.
europa.eu.int(2004) ‘EU Relations with Switzerland:
A Special Case’, October.
12.
fifoost.org(2004) ‘Statistical Data and Trade with
the EU’, 28 April.
13.
Fishlow, Albert
and
Haggard, Stephan
(1992) The United States and the Regionalization of the World
Economy.
Paris: OECD Development Centre Research Project
on Globalization and Regionalization
.
14.
Flynn, Gregory
and
Farrell, Henry
(1999)
‘Piecing Together the Democratic Peace: The CSCE, Norms, and the
“Construction” of Security in Post-Cold War Europe’
, International Organization53:
505–535
.
15.
Førland, Tor Egil
(1997)
‘Autonomy–Community–Suzerainty.
Decision-making Control and European Integration’
, Cooperation and Conflict32:
235–259
.
16.
Francis, Corinna-Barbara
(1999) ‘Bargained Property Rights: the Case of
China's High-Technology Sector’, in
A. Walder
and
J. Oi
(eds) Property Rights and Economic Reform in China, pp.
226–247.
Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press
.
17.
Fu Fengcheng (2001) ‘Jieji yongren zhengce yinggai
tiaozheng’, Jingji qianzhan (Economic Outlook Bimonthly) 73: 10–14.
18.
Galtung, Johan
(1968)
‘A Structural Theory of Integration’
, Journal of Peace Research5:
375–395
.
19.
Garrett, Geoffrey
and
Tsebelis, George
(2001)
‘The Institutional Foundations of Intergovernmentalism and
Supranationalism in the European Union’
, International Organization55:
357–390
.
20.
Gartzke, Erik
and
Li Quan
(2003)
‘War, Peace, and the Invisible Hand: Positive Political
Externalities of Economic Globalization’
, International Studies Quarterly47:
561–586
.
21.
Golob, Stephanie R.
(2003)
‘Beyond the Policy Frontier — Canada, Mexico, and the
Ideological Origins of NAFTA’
, World Politics55:
361–398
.
22.
Grugel, Jean
(1997) ‘Latin America and the Remaking of the
Americas’, in
A. Gamble
and
A. Payne
(eds) Regionalism and World Order, pp.
131–168.
New York: Palgrave Macmillan
.
23.
Haggard, Stephan
and
Maxfield, Sylvia
(1996)
‘The Political Economy of Financial Internationalization in the
Developing World’
, International Organization50:
35–68
.
24.
Hong Mei-hua (2000) ‘Liang an guanxi wenti yu taishang —
yi 1988–1998 nian wei hexin’, in C. Zheng and Z. Zhang (eds)
Taishang yu liang an guanxi yantaohui lunwenji, pp. 348–82.
Hong Kong: Lingnan University.
25.
Hsiao Hsin-huang and Kim Yun-t'ae (2000) ‘Fujian taishang
yu Shandong hanshang de bijiao’, in C. Zheng and Z. Zhang (eds)
Taishang yu liang an guanxi yantaohui lunwenji, pp. 111–32.
Hong Kong: Lingnan University.
26.
Hsing You-tien
(1998) Making Capitalism in China: The Taiwan
Connection.
New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
27.
Hu, Fred
et al. (2002) ‘The Five Great Myths about China
and the World’ (Part 1). Goldman Sachs Greater China
Analyst, No. 2002/11, May 30.
28.
Inter Action Council(1993) ‘The Lessons of the
German Unification Process for Korea’. Paris, 17–18
February (available at: www.interactioncouncil.org/meetings/report/m932.pdf).
29.
Katzenstein, Peter J.
(1971)
‘Hare and Tortoise: The Race toward Integration’
, International Organization25:
290–295
.
30.
Keohane, Robert O.
and
Nye, Joseph Jr.
(1975) ‘International Interdependence and
Integration’, in
F. Greenstein
and
N. Polsby
(eds) Handbook of Political Science, pp.
363–377.
Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley
.
31.
Keohane, Robert O.
and
Nye, Joseph Jr.
(1977) Power and Interdependence: World Politics in
Transition.
Boston, MA: Little, Brown
.
32.
Koenig-Archibugi, Mathias
(2004)
‘Explaining Government Preferences for Institutional Change in EU
Foreign and Security Policy’
, International Organization58:
137–174
.
33.
Kuus, Merje
(2002)
‘European Integration in Identity Narratives in Estonia: A Quest
for Security’
, Journal of Peace Research39:
91–108
.
34.
Leng Tse-kang
(1998)
‘A Political Analysis of Taiwan's Economic Dependence on
Mainland China’
, Issues & Studies34:
132–154
.
35.
Lipsey, Richard G.
(1987 [1960]) ‘The Theory of Customs Unions: A
General Survey’, in
J. N. Bhagwati
(ed.) International Trade: Selected Readings, 2nd edn,
pp. 357–376.
Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
.
36.
Liu I-chou
and
Ho Szu-yin
(1999)
‘The Taiwanese/Chinese Identity of the Taiwan People’
, Issues & Studies35:
1–34
.
37.
Mainland Affairs Council
(2004) ‘Public Opinion on Cross-Strait Relations in
the Republic of China’, 18 May (available at: www.mac.gov.tw).
38.
Mansfield, Edward D.
and
Milner, Helen V.
(1999)
‘The New Wave of Regionalism’
, International Organization53:
589–627
.
39.
Mansfield, Edward D.
and
Pevehouse, Jon C.
(2000)
‘Trade Blocs, Trade Flows, and International Conflict’
, International Organization54:
775–808
.
Mattli, Walter
(1999) The Logic of Regional Integration: Europe and
Beyond.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
42.
McCall Smith, James
(2000)
‘The Politics of Dispute Settlement Design: Explaining Legalism
in Regional Trade Pacts’
, International Organization54:
137–180
.
43.
Milward, Alan S.
(1992) The European Rescue of the Nation-State.
London: Routledge
.
44.
Moravcsik, Andrew
(1998) The Choice for Europe.
Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press and ICL Press
.
45.
Naughton, Barry
(2002)
‘The Information Technology Industry and Economic Interactions
between China and Taiwan’
. Paper presented to the conference on ‘New Information
Technologies and the Reshaping of Power Relations: An Approach to Greater
China's Political Economy’, CERI,
Paris, 16–17 December.
46.
Nello, Susan Senior
(2002)
‘Preparing for Enlargement in the European Union: The Tensions
between Economic and Political Integration’
, International Political Science Review23:
291–317
.
47.
Niou, Emerson
(1995) ‘An Evaluation of the Republic of
China's Foreign Policy Alternatives’, in
T-J. Cheng
,
C. Huang
and
S. Wu
(eds) Inherited Rivalry: Conflict Across the Taiwan Straits, pp.
195–212.
Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner
.
48.
Nye, Joseph S.
(1968)
‘Comparative Regional Integration: Concept and Measurement’
, International Organization22:
855–880
.
49.
Ohmae, Kenichi
(2002) The Emergence of the United States of
Chunghwa(in Japanese).
PHP Publishing Co.
50.
Ojanen, Hanna
(2002) ‘Theories at a Loss? EU–NATO
Fusion and the “Low-Politicisation” of Security and Defence
in European Integration’, UPI Working Papers 35,
Finnish Institute of International Affairs
.
51.
Parsons, Craig
(2002)
‘Showing Ideas as Causes: The Origins of the European Union’
, International Organization56:
47–84
.
52.
Peterson, John
(2001)
‘The Choice for EU Theorists: Establishing a Common Framework for Analysis’
, European Journal of Political Research39:
289–318
.
53.
PRC Law on Protection of Taiwanese Compatriots’ Investments
(Zhonghua renmin gongheguo Taiwan tongbao touzi baohufa), 1999.
54.
ROC Ministry of Economic Affairs, 10 May 2004 (available at: www.moea.gov.tw).
55.
Sapir, André
(1989) ‘Does 1992 Come Before or After
1990?’, in
R. W. Jones
and
A. O. Krueger
(eds) The Political Economy of International Trade, pp.
197–222.
Oxford: Basil Blackwell
.
56.
Schelling, Thomas C.
(1960) The Strategy of Conflict.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
57.
Schimmelfennig, Frank
(2002)
‘Liberal Community and Enlargement: An Event History Analysis’
, Journal of European Public Policy9:
598–626
.
58.
Sekulic, Du.sko
,
Massey, Garth
and
Hodson, Randy
(1994)
‘Who Were the Yugoslavs — Failed Sources of a Common
Identity in the Former Yugoslavia’
, American Sociological Review59:
83–97
.
59.
Seliger, Brooke P.
(2003)
‘Unified Germany's Security Policy: Some Lessons for Korea’
, Korean Journal of Defence Analysis15:
183–200
.
60.
Smith, Heather
and
Harris, Stuart
(1997) ‘Economic Relations across the Strait.
Interdependence or Dependence?’Pacific Economic Papers, No. 264.
Canberra: Australia–Japan Research Center
.
61.
Strange, Susan
(1995) ‘Political Economy and International
Relations’, in
K. Booth
and
S. Smith
(eds) International Relations Theory Today, pp. 154
–74.
Cambridge: Polity Press
.
62.
Su Ge (1987) ‘ A Horrible Dilemma’ — The
Making of the U.S.–Taiwan Defence Treaty: 1948–1955.PhD
dissertation. Brigham Young University, Provo, Utah.
63.
taiwandocuments.orga ‘Joint Communiqué of the United
States of America and the People's Republic of China, 17 August
1982’, 7 January 2003.
64.
taiwandocuments.orgb ‘The “Six Assurances”
to Taiwan, July 1982’, 7 January 2003.
65.
Tita, James M.
(undated) ‘East and West German Trade’, 27
April 2004 (available at: www.econc10.bu.edu).
66.
Touzi Zhongguo (Invest China) (2001) Vol. 6.
67.
Trade and Industry Department Hong Kong(2003)
‘Mainland and Hong Kong Closer Economic Partnership Agreement’.
68.
Treaty on a Union between Belarus and Russia, 3 April 1997
(available at: idc.cis.lead.org).
Wallace, Helen
(2002)
‘Enlarging the European Union: Reflections on the Challenge of Analysis’
, Journal of European Public Policy9:
658–665
.
71.
Wank, David
(1999) ‘Producing Property Rights: Strategies,
Networks, and Efficiency in Urban China's Nonstate
Firms’, in
A. Walder
and
J. Oi
(eds) Property Rights and Economic Reform in China, pp.
248–272.
Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press
.
72.
Wu Jieh-min
(2001)
‘State Policy and GuanxiNetwork Adaptation in China: Local
Bureaucratic Rent-Seeking’
, Issues & Studies37:
20–48
.
73.
Yam, Denise
(2004) Cross-Strait Relations Remain Under Stress.
Morgan Stanley Equity Research Asia/Pacific
, 22 March.
74.
Yates, Stephen J.
(1999) ‘The Taiwan Relations Act after 20 Years:
Keys to Past and Future Success’,
Washington DC: Heritage Foundation Backgrounder
Executive Summary
, No. 1272, 16 April (available at: www.heritage.org).
