This article presents the contending narratives of the failure of the
Israeli-Palestinian peace process. The narratives refer to the
‘Oslo’ peace process of 1993-2000, the negotiations at Camp
David (July 2000) and Taba (January 2001), and the ongoing asymmetrical war between
Israel and the Palestinians since September 2000.They encompass the
‘official’ social reconstructions of how the Israeli government
and the Palestinian Authority (PA) and the PLO present the facts and interpret the
attitudes of both parties. Moreover, those narratives are almost identical in their
logic, though diametrically opposed to each other. Each party blames, totally and
unconditionally, the failure of the peace process upon the malign intentions of
political destruction and annihilation of the other.The rationale for the paper is
that narratives, which are ‘stories with a plot’, do matter,
since they shape our identity and our norms, which are crucial components of our
reconstruction of social reality. In other words, narratives help to recreate
self-perpetuating processes of wishful thinking and self-fulfilling prophecies by
providing us with a moral and practical justification, ex post facto, for
our acts.
Adler, E.
(2002) ‘Constructivism and International
Relations’, in
W. Carlsnaes
,
T. Risse
and
B. A. Simmons
(eds) Handbook of International Relations, pp.
95-118.
London: Sage
.
2.
Aggestam, K.
(1999) Reframing and Resolving Conflict: Israeli-Palestinian
Negotiations, 1988-1998.
Lund: Lund University Press
.
3.
Agha, H.
and
Malley, R.
(2002)
‘Camp David and After: An Exchange (Reply to Barak)’
, New York Review of Books (13 June).
4.
Akutagawa, R.
(1952) Rashomon and Other Stories.
New York: Liveright Publishing Corporation
.
5.
Arafat, Y.
(2002)
‘The Palestinian Vision of Peace’
, New York Times (3 February).
6.
Barghutti, M.
(2001) ‘The Israelis Must Leave the
Territories’, in
W. Lacqueur
and
Barry Rubin
(eds) The Israel-Arab Reader, pp. 565-566.
New York: Penguin
.
7.
Barnett, M.
(2002) ‘The Israeli Identity and the Peace
Process: Re/creating the Un/thinkable’, in
S. Telhami
and
M. Barnett
(eds) Identity and Foreign Policy in the Middle East, pp.
58-87.
Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press
.
8.
Bar-Tal, D.
(2002)
‘Camp David, Oslo, and the Future: Interview with Dan Meridor’
, Palestine-Israel Journal9:
61-69
.
9.
Bates, R.
,
Grief, A.
,
Levi, M.
,
Rosenthal, J.-L.
and
Weingast, B. R.
(1998) Analytic Narratives.
Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
.
10.
Ben, Aluf
(2002)
‘Grasping for Peace’
, Foreign Policy (January-February), pp.
549-551
.
11.
Buttu, Diana
(2002)
‘The Palestinian View of the Camp David and Taba Talks’
. Public lecture, Georgetown University,
Washington, DC, USA (19 November).
12.
Chazan, N.
(2002)
‘The War of the Occupation’
, Jerusalem Post (October). Available at: http://info.jpost.com/C002/Supplements/Intifada.
13.
Clinton, W.
(2001) ‘The Clinton Plan’, in
W. Lacqueur
and
B. Rubin
(eds) The Israel-Arab Reader, pp. 562-564.
New York: Penguin
.
14.
Cordesman, A.
(2002)
‘Escalating to Nowhere: The Israeli and Palestinian Strategic Failure’
, CSIS Papers (12 April).
15.
Dowty, A.
(2001)
‘Israel under Sharon: The Tunnel at the End of the Light’
, Kroc Policy Briefs6 (June):
1-3
.
16.
Dowty A.
(2003) ‘A Question that Outweights all Others:
Israel and the Palestinians in Broad Perspective’.
University of Notre Dame, Department of Government
(manuscript).
17.
Dowty, A.
and
Gawerc, M.
(2001) ‘The Al-Aqsa Intifada: Revealing the
Chasm’.
University of Notre Dame, Department of Government
(manuscript).
18.
Eldar, A.
(2002)
‘Unofficial EU Documents Shows Israel Agrees to Pre-1967 Borders:
The Taba Talks (according to Miguel Moratinos)’
, Haaretz (14 February).
19.
Eldar, A.
(2003)
‘They Just Can’t Hear Each One’
, Haaretz (11 March).
20.
Eldar, A.
(2004)
‘Military Intelligence Presented Erroneous Assumptions on Palestinians’
, Haaretz (10 June).
21.
Gilad, A.
(2004) ‘Evaluation of Developments in the
Israeli-Palestinian Conflict’, in
Yaacov Bar-Siman-Tov
(ed.) As The Generals See It: The Collapse of the Oslo Process and the
Violent Israeli-Palestinian Conflict, pp. 47-58.
Jerusalem: Leonard Davis Institute for
International Relations
(March).
22.
Gold, D.
(2002)
‘Operation Justice Recovered’
, The Jerusalem Post (October). Available at: http://info.jpost.com/Coo2/Supplements/Intifada.
23.
Grossman, D.
(2002)
‘Fictions Embraced by an Israel at War’
, New York Times (1 October).
24.
Hass, A.
(2003)
‘Completing the Circle of Proof’
, Haaretz (5 March).
25.
Heradstveit, D.
(1974) Arab and Israeli Elite Perceptions.
Oslo: Universitetsforlaget
.
26.
Heradstveit, D.
(1979) The Arab-Israeli Conflict: Psychological Obstacles to
Peace.
Oslo: Universitetsforlaget
.
27.
Herman, D.
(2002) Story Logic: Problems and Possibilities of
Narrative.
Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press
.
28.
Israel, Ministry of Foreign Affairs
(2000) ‘The Conclusion of the Camp David Summit:
Key Points’ (25 July). Available at: www.mfa.gov.il/mfa/go.asp.
29.
Israel, Ministry of Foreign Affairs
(2001) ‘Israeli Position on Three Main Points at
Taba’ (21 January). Available at: www.mfa.gov.il/mfa/go.asp
30.
Israel, Ministry of Foreign Affairs
(2002) ‘Answers to Frequently Asked
Questions’.
Jerusalem: Ministry of Foreign Affairs
(August).
31.
Jervis, R.
(1970) The Logic of Images in International Relations.
Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
.
32.
Jervis, R.
(1976) Perception and Misperception in International
Politics.
Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
.
33.
Krauthammer, C.
(2001)
‘Arafat’s War’
, The Weekly Standard (3 September):
25-29
.
34.
Kupperwasser, Y.
(2004) ‘The Identity of “the
Other”: The Complex Structure of Palestinian
Society’, in
Yaacov Bar-Siman-Tov
(ed.) As The Generals See It: The Collapse of the Oslo Process and the
Violent Israeli-Palestinian Conflict, pp. 35-46.
Jerusalem: Leonard Davis Institute for
International Relations
(March).
35.
Kurtzner, D.
(2002) ‘Middle East
Assessment’, Peace in Brief.
Tami Steinmetz Center for Peace, Tel-Aviv University
(April).
36.
Kuttab, D.
(2002)
‘The War for a Palestinian Land’
, Jerusalem Post (October). Available at: http://info.jpost.com/C002/Supplements/Intifada.
37.
Malka, A.
(2004) ‘The Regional Arena Under the Test of
Stability’, in
Yaacov Bar-Siman-Tov
(ed.) As The Generals See It: The Collapse of the Oslo Process and the
Violent Israeli-Palestinian Conflict, pp. 19-33.
Jerusalem: Leonard Davis Institute for
International Relations
(March).
38.
Malley, R.
(2001)
‘Fictions about the Failure at Camp David’
, New York Times (8 July).
39.
Malley, R.
and
Agha, H.
(2001)
‘Camp David: The Tragedy of Errors’
, New York Review of Books (9 August).
40.
Marcus, Y.
(2001) ‘If They Want It, They’ll Take
It’, in
W. Lacqueur
and
B. Rubin
(eds) The Israel-Arab Reader, pp. 565-567.
New York: Penguin
.
41.
Le Monde Diplomatique (2001) ‘Refugee Papers (discussed at Taba]:
Private Israeli Draft’ (23 January).
42.
Mitchell Report
(2001) ‘Sharm-el-Sheikh Fact Finding Committee
Final Report’ (May). Available at: http://Usinfo.state.gov/regional/Mitchell/Report.
43.
Mofaz, S.
(2002)
‘Palestinian Terror in 2002’
(in Hebrew). Public lecture, Rockville, MD,
USA (2 October).
44.
Morris, B.
(2001a) Righteous Victims: A History of the Zionist-Arab
Conflict, 1881-2001.
New York: Vintage Books
.
45.
Morris, B. (2001b), ‘The Arabs are Responsible: Post-Zionist
Historian Benny Morris Clarifies His Thesis’, Yediot Hahachronot
(13 November) in MEMRI, Special Dispatch (12 December).
46.
Morris, B.
(2002)
‘Barak’s Full Interview with Ben Gurion History
Professor Benny Morris’
, New York Review of Books (13 June), pp.
42-45
.
47.
PLO (Palestinian Liberation Organization)
(2001) ‘Camp David Peace
Proposals’,
PLO Negotiations Affairs Department
(manuscript).
48.
PLO
(2002) ‘Palestinian Movement Restrictions Highlight
Israeli Apartheid’,
PLO Negotiations Affairs Department
(manuscript).
49.
Pedatzur, R.
(2004)
‘More Than a Million Bullets’
, Haaretz (30 June).
50.
Pressman, J.
(2003)
‘Visions in Collision: What Happened at Camp David and Taba?’
, International Security28:
5-43
.
51.
Pundak, R.
(2001) ‘From Oslo to Taba: What Went
Wrong?’ (June), pp. 1-26 (manuscript).
52.
Ross, D. B.
(2002a)
‘Yassir Arafat’
, Foreign Policy (July/August), pp.
18-26
.
53.
Ross, D. B.
(2002b)
‘Transcript: Dennis Ross, Former US Special Envoy to the Middle East’
, Fox News Channel (22 April).
Sher, G.
(2001) Just Beyond Reach (in Hebrew).
Tel-Aviv: Yediot Haachronot
.
56.
Slater, J.
(2001)
‘What Went Wrong? The Collapse of the Israeli-Palestinian Peace Process’
, Political Science Quarterly116:
171-199
.
57.
Sontag, D.
(2001)
‘Quest for Middle East Peace: How and Why It Failed’
, New York Times (26 July).
58.
Tarazi, M.
(2002)
‘The Palestinian View of the Camp David Negotiations’
. Public Lecture, Hebrew University of Jerusalem,
Jerusalem, Israel (28 May).
59.
Vertzberger, Y. Y. I.
(1990) The World in Their Minds: Information Processing,
Cognition, and Perception in Foreign Policy Decision-Making.
Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press
.
60.
Walzer, M.
(2002)
‘The Four Wars of Israel/Palestine’
, Dissent Magazine (Fall).
61.
Wolfsfeld, Gadi
(1993) ‘Introduction: Framing Political
Conflict’, in
A.A. Cohen
and
G.Wolfsfeld
(eds) Framing the Intifada: People and Media, pp.
xiv-xxix.
Norwood, NJ: Ablex Publishing Corporation
.
62.
Wolfsfeld, Gadi
(2001) ‘The News Media and Peace Processes: The
Middle East and Northern Ireland’, Peaceworks 37
(January).
Washington, DV: U.S. Institute of Peace
.
63.
Yaari, E.
(2002) ‘The Palestinian-Israeli War of
Attrition’, BESA Report (14 May).
Bar-Ilan University, Ramat-Gan, Israel
.
64.
Yeoshua, A. B.
(2002)
‘The War of the Borders’
, Jerusalem Post (October). Available at: http://info.jpost.com/C002/Supplements/Intifada.
65.
Zehfuss, M.
(2002) Constructivism in International Relations: The
Politics of Reality.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
