Literature on the foreign policy behavior of economically dependent states holds that they will comply with the foreign policy preferences of the United States, particularly on cold war issues. Regional foreign policies of Mexico and Costa Rica defy this view. Despite significant economic dependence on U.S. aid and trade, both Miguel de la Madrid and Oscar Arias developed peace plans for Central America that directly countered the objectives of the Reagan policy for the area. Pressures resulting from (a) regional security threats, (b) the flow of refugees into Costa Rica and Mexico, (c) the foreign policy traditions of each country, and (d) the need to counteract the effects of dependence guided these presidents to accept the risks of a defiant foreign policy in order to satisfy local demands. Even though heavily dependent and under pressure from the U.S. government to comply with its regional foreign policy, Mexico and Costa Rica implemented policies that served their own national interests and defied Washington.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abernathy, D. (1986). Dominant-subordinate relationships: How shall we define them? How do we compare them? In Jan F. Triska (Ed.), Dominant powers and subordinate states: The United States in Latin America and the Soviet Union in Eastern Europe (pp. 103-123). Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
2.
Abrams, I. (1988). Behind the scenes: The Nobel Committee and Oscar Arias. Antioch Review, 46, 364-373.
3.
Arias at odds with Reagan . (1986). Central America Report, 13, 115-116.
4.
Arias government delivers little . (1986). Central America Report, 13, 310-311.
5.
Arias, O. (1987). A time for peace (Speech delivered at the Royal Institute of International Affairs. London, May 18). Government and Opposition, 22, 452-456.
6.
Armstrong, A. (1981). The political consequences of economic dependence. Journal of Conflict Resolution, 25, 401-428.
7.
Bagley, B. (1981). Mexico in the 1980s: A new regional power. Current History, 80, 353-356, 386.
8.
Bagley, B. (1983). Mexican foreign policy: The decline of a regional power?Current History, 82, 406-409, 437.
9.
Bagley, B. (1987). The failure of diplomacy. In Bruce Bagley (Ed.), Contadora and the diplomacy of peace in Central America Volume I: The United States, Central America, and Contadora (pp. 181-211). Boulder, CO: Westview.
10.
Bagley, B. , Alvarez, R., & Hagedorn, K. (Eds.). (1985). Contadora and the Central American peace process: Selected documents. Boulder, CO: Westview.
11.
Bagley, B. , & Tokatlian, J. (1987). Contadora: The limits of negotiation. Case #309 in Pew program in case teaching and writing in international affairs. Pittsburgh, PA: Pew Charitable Trusts.
12.
Biddle, W. , & Stephens, J. (1989). Dependent development and foreign policy: The case of Jamaica. International Studies Quarterly, 33, 411-434.
13.
Biersteker, T. (1990). Reducing the role of the state in the economy: A conceptual exploration of IMF and World Bank prescriptions. International Studies Quarterly, 34, 477-492.
14.
Booth, J. , & Walker, T. (1989). Understanding Central America. Boulder, CO: Westview.
15.
Cardoso, F. , & Faletto, E. (1979). Dependency and development in Latin America. Los Angeles: University of California Press.
16.
Caspi, D. , & Seligson, M. (1983). Toward an empirical theory of tolerance. Comparative Political Studies, 15, 385-404.
17.
Castañeda, J. (1985). Don't corner Mexico!Foreign Policy, 61(Fall), 75-90.
18.
Central American Peace Plan . (1987). Current History, 86, 430, 436-437.
19.
Child, J. (Ed.). (1986). Conflict in Central America: Approaches to peace and security. London: Hurst.
20.
Coleman, K. , & Quiros-Varela, L. (1981). Determinants of Latin American foreign policies: Bureaucratic organizations and development strategies. In E. Ferris & J. Lincoln (Eds.), Latin American foreign policies: Global and regional dimensions (pp. 39-59). Boulder, CO: Westview.
21.
de la Madrid, M. (1984). Speech to U.S. Congress. In Vecinidad Digna, Amistad Duradera (pp. 43-61). (Commemorative publication, no publisher)
22.
DeRouen, K. , & Mintz, A. (1991, April). Economic dependence and foreign policy compliance: A survey of problems and evidence. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Midwest Political Science Association in Chicago, IL.
23.
Ehrenreich, Frederick . (1984). National security. In Harold D. Nelson (Ed.), Costa Rica: A country study (pp. 241-276). Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
24.
Fagen, R. (1987). Forging peace: The challenge of Central America. New York: Basil Blackwell.
25.
Farer, T. (1985). Contadora: The hidden agenda. Foreign Policy, 61(Summer), 59-72.
26.
Ferguson, Y. (1984). Cooperation in Latin America: The politics of regional integration. In Jennie K. Lincoln & Elizabeth G. Ferris (Eds.), The dynamics of Latin American foreign policies: Challenges for the 1980s (pp. 37-55). Boulder, CO: Westview.
27.
Ferris, E. (1984). Mexico's foreign policy: A study in contradictions. In Jennie K. Lincoln & Elizabeth G. Ferris (Eds.), The dynamics of Latin American foreign policies: Challenges for the 1980s (pp. 213-228). Boulder, CO: Westview.
28.
Foreign aid harder to get . (1986). Central America Report, 13, 61.
29.
Galtung, J. (1980). The true worlds. New York: Free Press.
30.
Going olive green . (1986). Central America Report, 13, 134-135.
31.
González, Heliodoro . (1982). The Caribbean Basin Initiative: Toward a permanent dole. Interamerican Economic Affairs, 36(Summer), 23-47.
32.
Grabendorff, W. (1978). Mexico's foreign policy: Indeed a foreign policy?Journal of Interamerican Studies and World Affairs, 2(February), 85-91.
33.
Grabendorff, W. (1984). The role of regional powers in Central America: Mexico, Venezuela, Cuba and Colombia. In H. Muñoz & J. Tulchin (Eds.), Latin American nations in world politics (pp. 83-100). Boulder, CO: Westview.
34.
Griffith, W. (1990). CARICOM countries and the Caribbean Basin Initiative. Latin American Perspectives, 17(1), 33-54.
35.
Gudmundson, L. (1987). Costa Rica's Arias at midterm. Current History, 86, 417-420, 431-432.
36.
Harrison, M. (1981). Reagan's world. Foreign Policy, 44(Summer), 3-16.
37.
Herrera Zuñiga, R. , & Ojeda, M. (1982). Mexican foreign policy and Central America. In R. Feinberg (Ed.), Central America: International dimensions of the crisis (pp. 160-186). New York: Holmes & Meier.
38.
Hopmann, T. (1989). Esquipulas II: Multilateral negotiations on peace in Central America. Unpublished paper.
39.
Hurtado, O. (1990). Política Democrática. Quito, Ecuador: Corporación Editora Nacional.
40.
International Monetary Fund . (1985). Directions of trade statistics yearbook. Washington, DC: Author.
41.
International Monetary Fund . (1989). Directions of trade statistics yearbook. Washington, DC: Author.
Kaufman, R. (1985). Democratic and authoritarian responses to the debt issue: Argentina, Brazil, Mexico. International Organization, 39, 474-503.
44.
Kearney, R. (1988). Political responsiveness and neutral competence in the developing countries. Review of Public Personnel Administration, 8(Spring), 66-80.
45.
Kegley, C. , & Hook, S. (1991). U.S. foreign aid and U.N. voting: Did Reagan's linkage strategy buy deference or defiance?International Studies Quarterly, 35, 295-312.
46.
Kenworthy, E. (1987). United States policy in Central America. Current History, 86(December), 401-404, 432.
47.
Lauderdale, P. (1986). Social and economic instability in Costa Rica: Pre-conditions for militarization?Policy Studies Review, 5, 236-244.
48.
Lewis, N. (1987, September 13). Reagan sees fatal flaws in Central American pact. New York Times, p. A24.
49.
Libby, R. (1990). The United States and Jamaica: Playing the American card. Latin American Perspectives, 17(1), 86-109.
50.
Lijphart, A. (1975). The comparable-cases strategy in comparative research. Comparative Political Studies, 65, 682-693.
51.
Lincoln, J. (1981). Introduction to Latin American foreign policy: Global and regional dimensions. In E. Ferris & J. Lincoln (Eds.), Latin American foreign policies: Global and regional dimensions (pp. 3-18). Boulder, CO: Westview.
52.
Lincoln, J. (1985). Neutrality Costa Rican style. Current History, 84, 118-121, 136.
53.
Looney, R. (1983). Mexican policy dilemmas during the De la Madrid presidency. Inter-American Economic Affairs, 37(Summer), 31-52.
54.
Losada, J. (1983). Escalation of the “secret” war risks U.S. hemispheric isolation. Latin American Times, 5(May), 20-22.
55.
Lowenthal, A. (1987). Partners in conflict: The United States and Latin America. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
56.
Marshall, J. , Scott, P., & Hunter, J. (1987). The Iran Contra connection: Secret teams and covert operations in the Reagan era. Boston, MA: South End.
57.
McNeil, F. (1988). War and peace in Central America. New York: Scribner.
58.
McNeil, F. (1991, April). The road to Esquipulas: How did Central America do it? Why did everyone, even Washington's closest allies, go with Arias? Paper delivered at the Latin American Studies Association Annual Meeting in Washington, DC.
59.
Menkhaus, K. , & Kegley, C. (1988). The compliant foreign policy of the dependent state revisited: Empirical linkages and lessons from the case of Somalia. Comparative Political Studies, 21, 315-346.
60.
Mexico's response to the problem of the Central American refugees. (1984). In Simon G. Hanson (Ed.), Inter-American Economic Affairs, Vol. 38, pp. 77-82.
61.
Moon, B. (1983). The foreign policy of the dependent state. International Studies Quarterly, 27, 315-340.
62.
Moon, B. (1985). Consensus or compliance? Foreign policy change and external dependence. International Organization, 39, 297-329.
63.
Moreno, D. (1991, April). Reasserting the hegemonic presumption. Paper delivered at the Latin American Studies Association Annual Meeting in Washington, DC.
64.
New government confronts old debt . (1986). Central America Report, 13, 245-246.
65.
1986 national budget bigger than ever . (1986). Central America Report, 13, 108-109.
66.
Noth, R. (1985). The economy. In James D. Rudolph (Ed.), Mexico: A country study (pp. 161-167). Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
67.
Ojeda, M. (1983). Mexican policy towards Central America in the context of U.S.-Mexican relations. In Richard Fagen & Olga Pellicer (Eds.), The future of Central America: Policy choices for the U.S. and Mexico (pp. 135-160). Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
68.
Pastor, R. (1989). Securing a democratic hemisphere. Foreign Policy, 73.(Winter), 41-59.
69.
Peeler, J. (1989). Democracy and elections in Central America: Autumn of the oligarchs. In John A. Booth & Mitchell A. Seligson (Eds.), Elections and democracy in Central America (pp. 185-200). Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
70.
Pellicer, O. (1981). Mexico's position. Foreign Policy, 44(Summer), 88-92.
71.
Pellicer, O. (1985). A note on Mexico: Expectations and reality. In George Irvín & Xabier Gorostiaga (Eds.), Towards an alternative for Central America and the Caribbean (pp. 84-92). London: Allen & Unwin.
72.
Purcell, S. (1987a). Demystifying Contadora. In Bruce Bagley (Ed.), Contadora and the diplomacy of peace in Central America. Volume 1: The United States, Central America, and Contadora (pp. 159-177). Boulder, CO: Westview.
73.
Purcell, S. (1987b). The choice in Central America. Foreign Affairs, 66(Fall), 109-128.
74.
Rai, B. (1980). Foreign aid and voting in the U.N. General Assembly, 1967-1976. Journal of Peace Research, 17, 269-277.
75.
Ramirez, M. D. (1989). The social and economic consequences of the national austerity program in Mexico. In Howard Handelman & Werner Baer (Eds.), Paying the costs of austerity in Latin America (pp. 143-170). Boulder, CO: Westview.
76.
Ray, J. L. (1981). Dependence, political compliance, and economic performance: Latin America and Eastern Europe. In Charles W. Kegley & Patrick J. McGowan (Eds.), The political economy of foreign policy behavior, (pp. 111-136). Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
77.
Reding, A. (1986). Costa Rica: Democratic model in jeopardy. World Policy Journal, 3, 301-315.
78.
Reduced revenue, safer market. (1983). Latin American Regional Report (Mexico and Central America), 25(March), 5-6.
79.
Richardson, N. R. (1976). Political compliance and U.S. trade dominance. American Political Science Review, 70, 1098-1109.
80.
Richardson, N. R. (1978). Foreign policy and economic dependence. Austin: University of Texas Press.
81.
Richardson, N. R. (1981). Economic dependence and foreign policy compliance: Bringing measurement closer to conception. In Charles W. Kegley & Patrick J. McGowan (Eds.), The political economy of foreign policy behavior (pp. 87-110). Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
82.
Richardson, N. R. , & Kegley, C. W., Jr. (1980). Trade dependence and foreign policy compliance: A longitudinal analysis. International Studies Quarterly24, 191-222.
83.
Rico, F. C. (1987). Mexico and Latin America: The limits of cooperation. Current History, 86, 121-124, 133-134.
84.
Robinson, C. H. (1985). Government and politics. In James Rudolph (Ed.), Mexico: A country study (pp. 245-314). Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
85.
Robinson, L. (1988). Peace in Central America?Foreign Affairs, 66, 591-613.
86.
Roeder, P. G. (1985). The ties that bind: Aid, trade, and political compliance in Soviet-Third World relations. International Studies Quarterly, 29, 191-216.
87.
Schooley, H. (1987). Conflict in Central America. Keesing's International Studies. Essex, United Kingdom: Longman Group.
88.
Seligson, M. A. , & Gómez, M. (1989). Ordinary elections in extraordinary times: The political economy of voting in Costa Rica. In John A. Booth & Mitchell A. Seligson (Eds.), Elections and democracy in Central America (pp. 158-184). Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
89.
Tartter, J. R. (1984). Government and politics. In Harold D. Nelson (Ed.), Costa Rica: A country study (pp. 183-240). Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
90.
Tightening the screws . (1986). Central America Report, 13, 157-158.
91.
Tower, J. , Muskie, E., & Scowcroft, B. (1987). The Tower Commission report. New York: Bantam & Times.
92.
U.S. aid: Cui bono . (1987). Central America Report, 14, 131-132.
93.
Vance, Cyrus R. (1986). The human rights imperative. Foreign Policy, 63(Summer), 3-19.
94.
Wagenheim, Kal (1988, November 4). Trade with U.S. exceeds $13 billion per year. Wall Street Journal, p. B9 (special advertising section).
95.
Wallerstein, Immanuel . (1979). The capitalist world-economy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
96.
Whihtaker, Donald P. (1984). The economy. In Harold D. Nelson (Ed.), Costa Rica: A country study (pp. 131-182). Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
97.
Whitehead, Laurence . (1988). The Costa Rican initiative in Central America. Government and Opposition, 22, 457-464.
98.
Wilson, Larman C. (1991, March). The Central American peace process: The challenge to U.S. bilateralism and unilateralism and the transition to OAS-UN multilateralism, 1983-90. Paper presented at the Annual Convention of the International Studies Association, Vancouver, British Columbia.
99.
Wittkopf, Eugene R. (1973). Foreign aid and the United Nations votes: A comparative study. American Political Science Review, 67, 868-888.
