As in most countries of the Western world, the number of women holding elected office in Britain is small. This article explores some reasons for the paucity of women in elected office by examining voting records for over 2,800 candidates for Scottish district elections in 1984. We found that women candidates are less likely to win election than are male candidates and they poll somewhat fewer votes. These differences can be almost entirely explained by the fact that women candidates are much less likely to enjoy personal or party incumbency, slightly more likely to run against incumbents, and less likely to be unopposed. In areas of Labour Party strength, however, Scottish women candidates fare slightly worse than comparable men candidates.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ANDERSEN, K. and S. J. THORSON (1984) “Congressional turnover and the election of women. Western Pol. Q.37: 143-156.
2.
BOCHEL, J. M. and D. T. DENVER (1974) The Scottish Elections. Dundee: University of Dundee Department of Political Science.
3.
BOCHEL, J. M. and D. T. DENVER (1977) The Scottish District Elections. Dundee: University of Dundee Department of Political Science.
4.
BOCHEL, J. M. and D. T. DENVER (1978) “The district council elections of May 1977,” in H. M. Drucker and M. G. Clarke (eds.) The Scottish Government Yearbook, 1978. Edinburgh: Paul Harris.
5.
BOCHEL, J. M. and D. T. DENVER (1979) “The regional council elections of May 1978,” in H. M. Drucker and M. L. Drucker (eds.) The Scottish Government Yearbook, 1979. Edinburgh: Paul Harris.
6.
BOCHEL, J. M. and D. T. DENVER (1980) The Scottish District Elections. Dundee: University of Dundee Department of Political Science.
7.
BOCHEL, J. M. and D. T. DENVER (1981) “Parties' progress: the district council elections of May 1980,” in H. M. Drucker and M. L. Drucker (eds.) The Scottish Government Yearbook, 1980. Edinburgh: Paul Harris.
8.
BOCHEL, J. M. and D. T. DENVER (1982) The Scottish Regional Elections. Dundee: University of Dundee Department of Political Science.
9.
BOCHEL, J. M. and D. T. DENVER (1983a) “Candidate selection in the Labour Party: what the selectors seek.”British J. of Pol. Sci.13: 45-69.
10.
BOCHEL, J. M. and D. T. DENVER (1983b) “Towards a four party system? The regional council elections of May 1982,” in D. McCrone (ed.) The Scottish Government Yearbook, 1983. Edinburgh: Unit for the Study of Government in Scotland.
11.
BRISTOW, S. L. (1980) “Women councillors—an explanation of the under-representation of women in local government.”Local Government Studies (May/June): 73-90.
12.
CURRELL, M. (1978) “The recruitment of women to the house of commons.” Delivered to the U.K. Political Studies Association Conference.
13.
DARCY, R. , S. WELCH, and J. M. CLARK (1987) Women: Elections and Representation. New York: Longmans.
14.
HAAVIO-MANNILA, E.et al. (1985) Unfinished Democracy: Women in Nordic Politics. New York: Pergamon.
15.
HILLS, J. (1981a) “Britain,” pp. 8-32 In J. Lovenduski and J. Hills (eds.) The Politics of the Second Electorate. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
16.
HILLS, J. (1981b) “Candidates, the impact of gender.”Parliamentary Affairs34: 221-228.
17.
HILLS, J. (1982) “Women local councillors—a reply to Bristow.”Local Government Studies (January/February): 61-71.
18.
HILLS, J. (1983) “Life-style constraints on formal political participation—why so few women local councillors in Britain?”Electoral Studies2, 1: 39-52.
19.
KEATING, M. and A. MIDWINTER (1983) The Government of Scotland. Atlantic Highlands, NJ: Humanities.
20.
KELLAS, J. G. (1975) The Scottish Political System. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.
21.
LOVENDUSKI, J. and J. HILLS [eds.] (1981) The Politics of the Second Electorate. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
22.
MAUD, J. (1967) Committee on the Management of Local Government, Vol. 2: The Local Government Councillor. London: HMSO.
23.
MICHELS, R. (1959) Political Parties. New York: Dover.
24.
NORRIS, P. (1985) “Women's legislative participation in Western Europe.”West European Politics8: 90-91.
25.
PUTNAM, R. (1976) The Comparative Study of Political Elites. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
26.
RANDALL, V. (1982) Women and Politics. New York: St. Martin's.
27.
RASMUSSEN, J. (1977) “The role of women in British parliamentary elections.”J. of Politics39: 1044-1054.
28.
RASMUSSEN, J. (1981a) “Female career patterns and leadership disabilities in Britain: the crucial role of gatekeepers in regulating entry to the political elite.”Polity13: 600-620.
29.
RASMUSSEN, J. (1981b) “Women candidates in British by-elections: a rational choice interpretation of electoral behavior.”Pol. Studies29: 265-274.
30.
RASMUSSEN, J. (1983a) “The electoral costs of being a woman in the 1979 British general election.”Comparative Politics15: 462-475.
31.
RASMUSSEN, J. (1983b) “The political integration of British women: the response of a traditional system to a newly emergent group.”Social Sci. History7: 61-95.
32.
RASMUSSEN, J. (1983c) “Women's role in contemporary British politics: impediments to parliamentary candidature.”Parliamentary Affairs36: 300-316.
33.
RASMUSSEN, J. (1984) “Women in Labour: the flapper vote and party system transformation in Britain.”Electoral Studies3: 47-63.
34.
Robinson Committee (1977) Report of the Committee of Inquiry into the System of Remuneration of Members of Local Authorities. London: HMSO.
35.
RULE, W. (1985) “Twenty-three democracies and women's parliamentary representation.” Delivered at the meeting of the International Political Science Association, July, Paris.
36.
SKARD, T. and E. HAAVIO-MANNILA (1984) “Equality between the sexes—myth or reality in Norden?”Daedalus113: 141-167.
37.
STOBAUGH, B. (1978) Women and Parliament. New York: Exposition.
38.
VALLANCE, E. (1979) Women in the House. London: Athlone.
39.
VALLANCE, E. (1984) “Women candidates in the 1983 general election.”Parliamentary Affairs37: 307-309.
40.
WELCH, S. (1978) “Recruitment of women to public office: a discriminant analysis.”Western Pol. Q.31: 372-380.
41.
WELCH, S. and T. BLEDSOE (1986) “Differences in campaign support for male and female candidates,” in G. Spitze and G. Moore (eds.) Research in Politics and Society. Greenwich, CT: JAI.
42.
WELCH, S. and D. T. STUDLAR (1986) “British public opinion toward women in politics.”Western Pol. Q.39: 138-154.
