Regulatory Visions and the State in E. Asia: The Irrational Investor Problem in the Comparative Politics of Finance

Abstract

Despite the marked transformation in E. Asia’s financial systems, regulators continue to employ hard paternalistic approaches to their stock markets that are viewed as counterproductive to their development. This article argues that the persistence of hard paternalistic regulatory practices can be explained by a regulatory vision—a common analytical framework to order complex uncertain environments that serve as regulatory first principles—centered on an irrational investor. A regulatory vision works alongside pressures emanating from foreign investment, state capitalism, and state-business relations. This understanding of investor rationality is in marked contrast to a liberal market variant, which emphasizes a rational investor, and thus provides a distinctive comparative lens to understand regulatory behavior in a moment of global financial hybridization. The study draws on over 90 elite interviews of senior regulators, stock exchange officers, and market practitioners conducted in China, Japan, Korea, and Taiwan, from 2015 to 2019.

Keywords

stock market developmental state financial regulation paternalism ideational politics

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abdelal

Blyth

Parsons

(Eds.), (2015). Constructing the international economy. Cornell University Press.

Abdul Rahman

Ertürk

Froud

(2020). Financial citizenship and nation-building in Malaysia: Elites' and citizens' perspectives. Journal of Economic Geography, 20(1), 225–248.

Allen

Qian

Shan

Zhu

J. L.

(2020). 11. The Development of the Chinese Stock Market. In The handbook of China's financial system. (pp. 283-313). Princeton University Press.

Avgouleas

(2009). The global financial crisis and the disclosure paradigm in european financial regulation: The case of reform. European Company and Financial Law Review, 6(4), 440–475.

Barber

B. M.

Lee

Y. T.

Liu

Y. J.

Odean

(2009). Just how much do individual investors lose by trading? Review of Financial Studies, 22(2), 609–632. https://doi.org/10.1093/rfs/hhn046

Benveniste

L. M.

Busaba

W. Y.

(1997). Bookbuilding vs. fixed price: An analysis of competing strategies for marketing IPOs. Journal of Financial and quantitative analysis, 32(4), 383–403.

Blyth

(2002). Great transformations: Economic ideas and institutional change in the twentieth century. Cambridge University Press.

BNY Mellon (2021). The rise of retail traders. Insights.

Champion

(1997). The Great Taiwan Bubble: The Rise and fall of an emerging stock market. Pacific View press.

10.

Chan

(2008). Investors protest at China bourse as stocks dive. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/article/china-stocks-protest-idCNTSHA36049320080612

11.

Chen

(2018). IPO fupindiquqiye guohuilu geng gao? MeiriJingjiXinwen. http://finance.sina.com.cn/stock/newstock/xgpl/2018-01-31/doc-ifyremfz2342329.shtml?cre=tianyi&mod=pcpager_fin&loc=37&r=9&doct=0&rfunc=100&tj=none&tr=9

12.

Chen

Ito

Yamada

Zhang

(2018). The BOJ large-scale purchases of equity index ETFS: Float reduction and its impact on market frictions. CFA Institution Working Paper.

13.

Chun

(2016). Investor protection in Korean capital market through disclosures and litigation. Journal of Korean Law, 16(1), 193–232.

14.

Chung

(2019). KRX eyes tougher regulations on algorithmic trading. Yonhap News Agency. https://en.yna.co.kr/view/AEN20191210006800320#:∼:text=High%2Dfrequencytradingisnot,drivenbytheiralgorithmicsystems

15.

Chung

Song

Kim

(2022). Discovering the South Korea IPO market. IFLR Review. https://www.iflr.com/article/2a647e1ubbp4geniccmbk/discovering-the-south-korean-ipo-market

16.

Chwieroth

(2007). Neoliberal economists and capital account liberalization in emerging markets. International Organization, 61(02), 443–463. https://doi.org/10.1017/s0020818307070154

17.

De La Cruz

Medina

Tang

(2019). Owners of the world’s listed companies. OECD Capital Market Series.

18.

Deloitte (2022). Q1-Q3 2022 review and Outlook for Chinese Mainland and Hong Kong IPO markets. Deloitte Market Insights.

19.

Dickson

(Ed.), (2015). The asset management review. Law Business Research Ltd.

20.

Eichengreen

(2014). Financial development and economic growth: The long view. In Financial development and Cooperation in Asia and the Pacific (pp. 11–28). Routledge.

21.

FSC (2020). New Board Proposed by the TWSE and TPEx for innovative enterprises to be launched in the 3^rd quarter, 2021. FSC Press Release.

22.

Gruin

Knaack

(2020). Not just another shadow bank: Chinese authoritarian capitalism and the ‘developmental’promise of digital financial innovation. New Political Economy, 25(3), 370–387. https://doi.org/10.1080/13563467.2018.1562437

23.

Haber

Levi-Faur

(2018). The financialization of European Union citizenship: An alternative to democratic empowerment. In Democratic empowerment in the European Union (pp. 239–268). Edward Elgar Publishing.

24.

Haggard

(2018). Developmental states. Cambridge University Press.

25.

Hall

(1989). The political power of economic ideas. Princeton University Press.

26.

Hiraki

Honda

Ito

Liu

(2018). Financial conglomeration, IPO underwriting, and allocation in Japan. CFA Institute Working Paper.

27.

Howson

(2014). Quack corporate governance as traditional Chinese medicine the securities regulation cannibalization of China's corporate law and state regulator's battle against party state political economic power. Seattle University Law Review, 37(2), 667–716.

28.

Hsueh

(2012). China and India in the age of globalization: Sectoral variation in postliberalization reregulation. Comparative Political Studies, 45(1), 32–61. https://doi.org/10.1177/0010414011421305

29.

Inman

(2021). Foreign investors own 66% of UK-listed shares, analysis shows. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/business/2021/jun/07/foreign-investors-own-66-of-uk-listed-shares-analysis-shows

30.

ISDA (2021). Developing Safe, robust, and efficient derivatives markets in China. https://www.isda.org/a/nctgE/Developing-Safe-Robust-and-Efficient-Derivatives-Markets-in-China-ENG.pdf

31.

Jie

(2021). S. Korean retail investors’ stock holdings inch closer to foreign ownership. Korea Herald. https://www.koreaherald.com/view.php?ud=20210401000991

32.

Kang

D. C.

(2003). Transaction costs and crony capitalism in East Asia. Comparative Politics, 35(4), 439–458. https://doi.org/10.2307/4150189

33.

Kang

(2020). Special listing Tracks and investor protection. KCMI Capital Markets Focus.

34.

Kear

(2013). Governing homo subprimicus: Beyond financial citizenship, exclusion, and rights. Antipode, 45(4), 926–946. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8330.2012.01045.x

35.

Kingsford-Smith

Dixon

(2015). The consumer interest and the financial markets. In Moloney

Ferran

Payne

(Eds.), The Oxford Handbook of financial regulation (pp. 695–735). Oxford University Press.

36.

Kirshner

(Ed.), (2001). Monetary orders: Ambiguous economics, ubiquitous politics. Cornell University Press.

37.

Klick

Mitchell

(2006). Government regulation of irrationality: Moral and cognitive hazards. Minnesota Law Review, 90(6), 1620–1663.

38.

Koo

(2021). Foreigners’ Korean stockholdings soar 180-fold in 30 years. The Korea Economic Daily. https://www.kedglobal.com/markets/newsView/ked202112310005#:∼:text=Foreigninvestorsrampeduptheir,inthelocalstockmarket

39.

KPMG (2022). Mainland China and Hong Kong IPO markets: 2022 mid-Year review.

40.

Kushida

K. E.

Shimizu

(2013). Syncretism: The politics of Japan's financial reforms. Socio-Economic Review, 11(2), 337–369. https://doi.org/10.1093/ser/mwt003

41.

Kutsuna

Smith

J. K.

Smith

R. L.

(2009). Public information, IPO price formation, and long run returns: Japanese evidence. The Journal of Finance, 64(1), 505–546. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6261.2008.01440.x

42.

Kwong

(2011). Taiwan stock exchange plans IT upgrade. Financial Times. https://www.ft.com/content/f9803820-0fa4-11e1-a468-00144feabdc0

43.

Langevoort

D. C.

(2006). The sec as lawmaker: Choices about investor protection in the face of uncertainty. Washington University Law Review, 84(7), 1591–1626.

44.

Laurence

(2001). Money Rules: The New Politics of Finance in Britain and Japan. Cornell University Press.

45.

Lechevalier

Debanes

Shin

(2019). Financialization and industrial policies in Japan and Korea: Evolving institutional complementarities and loss of state capabilities. Structural Change and Economic Dynamics, 48, 69–85. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.strueco.2017.08.003

46.

Lee

Fujioka

(2022). A $430 Billion habit got Japan’s central bank hooked on ETFs. Bloomberg. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-04-07/a-430-billion-habit-got-japan-s-central-bank-hooked-on-etfs

47.

Lee

(2022). Retail stock traders become Key Voting Bloc in Korea’s election. Bloomberg. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-03-05/retail-stock-traders-become-key-voting-bloc-in-korea-s-election

48.

Lewis

(2019). BOJ’s stock-buying programme starts to sputter. Financial Times. https://www.ft.com/content/3c2e8952-0b72-11ea-bb52-34c8d9dc6d84

49.

Lin

Puchniak

D. W.

(2022). Institutional investors in China: Corporate governance and policy channeling in the market within the state. Columbia Journal of Asian Law, 35(1), 74–159. https://doi.org/10.52214/cjal.v35i1.9190

50.

Lin

T. C.

(2015). Reasonable investor(s). Boston University Law Review, 95(2), 461–518.

51.

Liu

(2022). Research on the materiality standard of inside information. Modern Economy, 13(08), 1115–1125. https://doi.org/10.4236/me.2022.138058

52.

Lockett

(2021). Retail traders’ hold on China’s stock market slips as institutional investors rise. Financial Times. https://www.ft.com/content/a1aa3a25-484d-480d-83bf-8f9c90504f22

53.

Lockett

Kinder

(2021). Global holdings of Chinese stocks and bonds rise by $120bn in 2021. Financial Times.

54.

Wang

(2021). Data: IPO path narrows on China’s star market. https://www.protocol.com/china/shanghai-star-ipo-termination-data

55.

Masters

(2021). Investors in China should beware Beijing’s Unpredictability. Financial Times. https://www.ft.com/content/32b8a1c7-cd06-4628-b608-a29bd2de1eab

56.

Milhaupt

C. J.

West

M. D.

(2003). Law's dominion and the market for legal elites in Japan. Law and Policy in International Business, 34(2), 451–498.

57.

Naughton

Tsai

K. S.

(Eds.), (2015). State capitalism, institutional adaptation, and the Chinese miracle. Cambridge University Press.

58.

Nielsen

R. A.

(2016). Case selection via Matching. Sociological Methods & Research, 45(3), 569–597. https://doi.org/10.1177/0049124114547054

59.

Nippon (2021). Number of individual shareholders rising in Japan. Nippon.com. https://www.nippon.com/en/japan-data/h01074/

60.

Nunn

Kulam

(2021). Short-selling restrictions during Covid-19. Program on Financial Stability. https://som.yale.edu/blog/short-selling-restrictions-during-covid-19

61.

Petry

(2020). Financialization with Chinese characteristics? Exchanges, control and capital markets in authoritarian capitalism. Economy and Society, 49(2), 213–238. https://doi.org/10.1080/03085147.2020.1718913

62.

PI (2017). 80% of equity market cap held by institutions. Pensions & Investments. https://www.pionline.com/article/20170425/INTERACTIVE/170429926/80-of-equity-market-cap-held-by-institutions

63.

Pirie

(2018). Korea and Taiwan: The crisis of investment-led growth and the end of the developmental state. Journal of Contemporary Asia, 48(1), 133–158. https://doi.org/10.1080/00472336.2017.1375136

64.

Posner

(2005). Sources of institutional change: The supranational origins of Europe's new stock markets. World Politics, 58(1), 1–40. https://doi.org/10.1353/wp.2006.0021

65.

Puchniak

D. W.

Nakahigashi

(2012). Japan's love for derivative actions: Irrational behavior and non-economic motives as rational explanations for shareholder litigation. Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law, 45(1), 1–82.

66.

Qian

Ritter

J. R.

Shao

(2022). Initial public offerings Chinese style. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 1(1)1–73. https://doi.org/10.1017/s002210902200134x

67.

Reidy

Oda

(2020). Japan moves to limit foreign investment in Half of listed firms. Bloomberg. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-05-11/japan-moves-to-limit-foreign-investment-in-half-of-listed-firms

68.

Reidy

Oda

(2021). Trader arrested as wallstreet bets phenomenon finds echo in Japan. Bloomberg. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-03-12/trader-arrested-as-wallstreetbets-phenomenon-finds-echo-in-japan

69.

Reuters (2016). Japan to tighten regulations on high frequency traders. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/article/japan-regulations-hft/japan-to-tighten-regulations-on-high-frequency-traders-idUSL4N1CP1Y1

70.

Ripken

(2015). Paternalism and securities regulation. Stanford Journal of Law, Business & Finance, 21(1), 1–56.

71.

Rithmire

Chen

(2021). The emergence of mafia-like business systems in China. The China Quarterly, 248(1), 1037–1058. https://doi.org/10.1017/s0305741021000576

72.

Rose

A. M.

(2017). The reasonable investor of federal securities law: Insights from tort law's reasonable person & suggested reforms. Journal of Corporation Law, 43(1), 77–118.

73.

Rosenthal

Burke

(2020). Who owns US stock? Foreigners and Rich Americans. TaxVox. https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/taxvox/who-owns-us-stock-foreigners-and-rich-americans

74.

Sachs

M. V.

(2006). Materiality and social change: The case for replacing the reasonable investor with the least sophisticated investor in inefficient markets. Tulane Law Review, 81(2), 473–508.

75.

Samtani

(2020). Japan’s new foreign investment rules take effect. Regulation Asia, https://www.regulationasia.com/japans-new-foreign-investment-rules-take-effect/

76.

Schmidt

V. A.

(2002). The futures of European capitalism. OUP.

77.

Schwartz

(2015). Regulating for rationality. Stanford Law Review, 67(6), 1373–1410.

78.

Segerstrom

(2020). Institutional ownership in the UK. Factset. https://insight.factset.com/institutional-ownership-in-the-uk

79.

Share Soc (2020). UK stock market Statistics: Some background information. ShareSoc. https://www.sharesoc.org/investor-academy/advanced-topics/uk-stock-market-statistics/

80.

Shen

John

(2020). Short selling tests China’s zeal for market reform. Reuters.

81.

Shih

V. C.

(2008). Factions and finance in China: Elite conflict and inflation. Cambridge University Press.

82.

Smart

(2021). Who owns stocks in America? Mostly, it’s the wealthy and white. U.S. News and World Report. https://www.usnews.com/news/national-news/articles/2021-03-15/who-owns-stocks-in-america-mostly-its-the-wealthy-and-white

83.

Song

(2013). South Korea’s derivatives decline threatens equity trade. Financial Times. https://www.ft.com/content/649dd0da-4aaa-11e3-8c4c-00144feabdc0

84.

Song

(2021). South Korea’s retail investor army declares war on short-sellers. Financial Times. https://www.ft.com/content/060b527e-8f8c-48f8-9809-8f0e6d60fc37

85.

Song

Lockett

(2021). Hedge funds chafe at extension of South Korea’s short-selling ban. Financial Times. https://www.ft.com/content/68c0d013-3d6c-4dbf-83dc-6d911c701de7

86.

Steinfeld

E. S.

(2004). Market visions: The interplay of ideas and institutions in Chinese financial restructuring. Political Studies, 52(4), 643–663. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9248.2004.00501.x

87.

Storz

Amable

Casper

Lechevalier

(2013). Bringing Asia into the comparative capitalism perspective. Socio-Economic Review, 11(2), 217–232. https://doi.org/10.1093/ser/mwt004

88.

Taipei Times (2021a). Unicorns need relaxed stock rules. Taipei Time. https://www.taipeitimes.com/News/editorials/archives/2021/09/21/2003764710

89.

Taipei Times (2021b). Young investors breathe life into stock market: TWSE. Taipei Times. https://www.taipeitimes.com/News/biz/archives/2021/02/10/2003752060

90.

Thaler

R. H.

Sunstein

C. R.

(2003). Libertarian paternalism. American Economic Review, 93(2), 175–179. https://doi.org/10.1257/000282803321947001

91.

Thurbon

(2016). Developmental mindset. Cornell University Press.

92.

Tiberghien

(2007). Entrepreneurial states: Reforming corporate governance in France, Japan, and Korea. Cornell University Press.

93.

Tokyo Stock Exchange (2020). Trading volume of TSE by investor type.

94.

Tsai

K. S.

(2017). When shadow banking can be productive: Financing small and medium enterprises in China. The Journal of Development Studies, 53(12), 2005–2028. https://doi.org/10.1080/00220388.2016.1228877

95.

TWSE (2021). Fact book 2021. Taiwan Stock Exchange.

96.

Vogel

S. K.

(2006). Japan remodeled: How government and industry are reforming Japanese capitalism. Cornell University Press.

97.

Vogel

S. K.

(2019). Japan’s ambivalent pursuit of shareholder capitalism. Politics & Society, 47(1), 117–144. https://doi.org/10.1177/0032329218825160

98.

Wade

R. H.

(2018). The developmental state: Dead or alive? Development and Change, 49(2), 518–546. https://doi.org/10.1111/dech.12381

99.

Wong

(2011). Betting on biotech. Cornell University Press.

100.

World Bank (2020). World development Indicators 2020. In Market Capitalization, Market Volatility. http://data.worldbank.org/data-catalog/world-development-indicators

101.

Huang

(2021). MSCI cuts Taiwan’s weighting in 3 indexes. CNA. https://focustaiwan.tw/business/202105120016

102.

Yang

Murdoch

(2021). Indebted South Korea retail stock buyers face reality check as short selling to resume. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/article/southkorea-shortselling-retail/indebted-south-korea-retail-stock-buyers-face-reality-check-as-short-selling-to-resume-idUSL1N2K1037

103.

Yonhap

(2022). Stock Market Stabilization fund to be launched to ease downswings. The Korea Herald. Accessed at https://www.koreaherald.com/view.php?ud=20221004000253

104.

Zhang

(2017). Chinese securities regulator slows IPO approvals to bolster market confidence. South China Morning Post. https://www.scmp.com/business/markets/article/2096962/chinese-securities-regulator-slows-ipo-approvals-bolster-market

105.

Zysman

(1983). Governments, markets, and growth. Cornell University Press.