This paper examines two common critiques of ethnic quota policies in government hiring and education: that they do not benefit the target group, and that any benefits are unevenly distributed within the target group. It focuses on the effects of educational and hiring quotas for Other Backward Class (OBC) castes in India, using difference-in-difference and triple difference designs that take advantage of the gradual introduction of these quotas. The results provide little support for these critiques: affirmative action is associated with small increases in educational attainment and government employment among eligible age cohorts, though the increases in government employment may be a result of other social and political trends. These benefits extend even to poorer OBCs (though not the very poorest), and increase the chances of social contact between uneducated OBCs and government officials.
ArcidiaconoP. (2005). Affirmative action in higher education: How do admission and financial aid rules affect future earnings?Econometrica, 73(5), 1477–1524.
2.
BertrandM.HannaR.MullainathanS. (2010). Affirmative action in education: Evidence from engineering college admissions in india. Journal of Public Economics, 94(1), 16–29.
3.
BhavnaniR. R.LeeA. (2018). Local embeddedness and bureaucratic performance: Evidence from india. The Journal of Politics, 80(1), 71–87.
4.
BhavnaniR. R.LeeA. (2019). Does affirmative action worsen bureaucratic performance? Evidence from the indian administrative service. American Journal of Political Science, 65(1): 5-20.
CedermanL.-E.WimmerA.MinB. (2010). Why do ethnic groups rebel? New data and analysis. World Politics, 62(1), 87–119.
7.
ChauchardS. (2014). Can descriptive representation change beliefs about a stigmatized group? Evidence from rural india. American Political Science Review, 108(2), 403–422.
8.
ChewD. C. (1992). Civil service pay in South Asia. International Labour Organization.
9.
DesaiS.VannemanR. (2015). India human development survey-II (IHDS-II), 2011-12. ICPSR36151-v2.
10.
DeshpandeS.YadavY. (2006). Redesigning affirmative action: Castes and benefits in higher education. Economic and Political Weekly, 41(24), 2419–2424.
11.
DunningT.NilekaniJ. (2013). Ethnic quotas and political mobilization: Caste, parties, and distribution in indian village councils. American Political Science Review, 107(01), 35–56.
12.
EjdemyrS.KramonE.RobinsonA. L. (2017). Segregation, ethnic favoritism, and the strategic targeting of distributive goods. Comparative Political Studies, 51(9), 1111–1143.
13.
FrancisA. M.Tannuri-PiantoM. (2012). Using Brazil’s racial continuum to examine the short-term effects of affirmative action in higher education. Journal of Human Resources, 47(3), 754–784.
14.
GalanterM. (1984). Competing equalities: Law and the backward classes in India. University of California Press.
15.
HinrichsP. (2012). The effects of affirmative action bans on college enrollment, educational attainment, and the demographic composition of universities. Review of Economics and Statistics, 94(3), 712–722.
16.
HowardL.PrakashN. (2012). Does employment quota explain occupational choice among disadvantaged groups? A natural experiment from India. International Review of Applied Economics, 26(4), 489–513.
JenseniusF. R. (2017). Social justice through inclusion: The consequences of electoral quotas in India. Oxford University Press.
19.
Karekurve-RamachandraV.LeeA. (Forthcoming). Do gender quotas hurt less privileged groups? Evidence from india. American Journal of Political Science, 64(4), 757–772.
20.
KennedyR. (2013). For discrimination: Race, affirmative action, and the law. Pantheon.
KramonE.PosnerD. N. (2016). Ethnic favoritism in education in Kenya. Quarterly Journal of Political Science, 11(1), 1–58.
23.
KrislovS. (2012). Representative bureaucracy. Quid Pro Books.
24.
LeeA. (2019). From hierarchy to ethnicity: The politics of caste in twentieth century India. Cambridge University Press.
25.
LouryL. D.GarmanD. (1993). Affirmative action in higher education. The American Economic Review, 83(2), 99–103.
26.
MasseyD. S.MooneyM.TorresK. C.CharlesC. Z. (2006). Black immigrants and black natives attending selective colleges and universities in the united states. American Journal of Education, 113(2), 243–271.
27.
MathurM. L. (2004). Encyclopaedia of backward castes: Mandal, media and aftermath (Vol. 3). Gyan Publishing House.
SanderR. H. (2004). A systemic analysis of affirmative action in american law schools. Stanford Law Review, 57(2), 367–483.
30.
ShahG. (2006). Untouchability in rural India. Sage.
31.
SowellT. (2005). Affirmative action around the world: An empirical study. Yale University Press.
32.
SuryanarayanP. (2019). When do the poor vote for the right wing and why: Status hierarchy and vote choice in the indian states. Comparative Political Studies, 52(2), 209–245.
