Existing research has failed to address the impact of subnational politics on economic adjustment. This article attempts to fill this gap by outlining theoretical reasons for anticipating policy divergences across levels of government and by offering three hypotheses to account for variation at the subnational level. The authors explore these ideas on the basis of the Argentine experience. The study traces the impact of subnational policy on Argentine economic adjustment and tests hypotheses about subnational policy variation on the basis of provincial fiscal data. The authors' findings underline the importance of subnational policy choice for national performance and suggest a revised understanding of the role of political competition in the economic adjustment process. The authors find considerable evidence that interactions between party competition and the structure of the public sector shape provincial fiscal performance and thereby condition the capacity for economic adjustment at the national level.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Alt, James E. , & Lowry, Robert C. (1994, December). Divided government, fiscal institutions, and budget deficits: Evidence from the states. American Political Science Review, 88, 811-828.
2.
And now, merge the provinces; central bank chief says eight are no longer viable. (1990, November 15). Latin American Weekly Report, p. 9.
3.
Argentina provincial protests. (1994, June 16). Latin American Weekly Report, p. 264.
4.
Artana, Daniel , Libonatti, Oscar, Moskovits, Cynthia, & Salinardi, Mario. (1995). Argentina. In Ricardo López Murphy (Ed.), Fiscal decentralization in Latin America (pp. 59-136). Washington, DC: Inter-American Development Bank.
5.
Baber, William R. , & Sen, Pradyot. (1986). The political process and the use of debt financing by state government. Public Choice, 48, 201-215.
6.
Callaghy, Thomas . (1990). Lost between state and market: The politics of economic adjustment in Ghana, Zambia, and Nigeria. In Joan M. Nelson (Ed.), Economic crisis and policy choice: The politics of adjustment in the third world (pp. 257-319). Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
7.
Cavallo, Domingo . (1997). El peso de la verdad: Un impulso a la transparencia en la Argentina de los 90 [The weight of the truth: An impulse toward transparency in the Argentina of the 90s]. Buenos Aires, Argentina: Planeta.
8.
Centro de Estudios para La Nueva Mayoría. (1997, October). La Alianza UCR-Frepaso. Mimeo.
9.
The challenge of the provinces. (1995, June 15). Latin American Weekly Report, p. 260.
10.
Clingermayer, James C. , & Wood, B. Dan. (1995, March). Disentangling patterns of state debt financing. American Political Science Review, 89, 108-120.
11.
Conaghan, Catherine M. , & Malloy, James M. (1995). Unsettling statecraft: Democracy and neoliberalism in the Central Andes. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.
12.
The downslide is getting steeper. (1995, November 16). Latin American Weekly Report, p. 527.
13.
Economic Commission for Latin America . (1992-1997). Preliminary overview of the economy of Latin America and the Caribbean. Santiago, Chile: United Nations.
14.
El gobierno corta gastos frente a la crisis asiática [The government cuts expenditures in response to the Asian crisis]. (1998, June 17). La Nación, p. 1.
15.
“Extortion” forces Angeloz to resign . (1995, July 20). Latin American Weekly Report, p. 323.
16.
Eyes on unrest in northern Jujuy. (1995, December 14). Latin American Weekly Report, p. 568.
17.
Fernandez, Raquel , & Rodrick, Dani. (1991, December). Resistance to reform: Status quo bias in the presence of individual-specific uncertainty. American Economic Review, 81, 1146-1155.
18.
Fox, Jonathan . (1996). National electoral choices in rural Mexico. In Laura Randall (Ed.), Reforming Mexico's agrarian reform (pp. 185-210). New York: M. E. Sharpe.
19.
Fraga, Rosendo . (1989). Argentina en las urnas, 1916-1989 [Argentina at the polls, 1916-1989]. Buenos Aires, Argentina: Editorial Centro de Estudios Unión para la Nueva Mayoría.
20.
Fraga, Rosendo . (1992). Argentina en las urnas, 1931-1991 [Argentina at the polls, 1931-1991]. Buenos Aires, Argentina: Editorial Centro de Estudios Unión para la Nueva Mayoría.
21.
Fraga, Rosendo . (1995). Aregentina en las urnas, 1916-1994 [Argentina at the polls, 1916-1994]. Buenos Aires, Argentina: Editorial Centro de Estudios Unión para la Nueva Mayoría.
22.
Fundación de Investigaciones Económicas Latinoamericanas . (1991). El sistema impositivo argentino [The Argentine tax system]. Buenos Aires, Argentina: Ediciones Manantial.
23.
Fundación de Investigaciones Económicas Latinoamericanas . (1995). La convertibilidad y las crisis provinciales [Convertability and the provincial crisis]. FIDE: Coyuntura y Desarrollo, 202, 27-37.
24.
Geddes, Barbara . (1994). Politician's dilemma: Building state capacity in Latin America. Berkeley: University of California Press.
25.
Grindle, Merilee , & Thomas, John W. (1991). Public choices and policy change: The political economy of reform in developing countries. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins.
26.
Grindle, Merilee S. (1996). Challenging the state: Crisis and innovation in Latin America and Africa. New York: Cambridge University Press.
27.
Growing deficits alarm markets. (1996, November 7). Latin American Weekly Report, p. 512.
28.
Haggard, Stephan , & Kaufman, Robert R. (1995). The political economy of democratic transitions. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
29.
Harberger, Arnold C. (1993, May). Secrets of success: A handful of heroes. American Economic Review, 83, 343-350.
30.
Hunter, Wendy . (1997). Eroding military influence in Brazil: Politicians against soldiers. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
31.
Instituto Nacional de Estadísticas y Censos . (1995). Statistical yearbook: Republic of Argentina. Buenos Aires, Argentina: Author.
32.
Inter-American Development Bank . (1994). La descentralización fiscal en América Latina (Working Paper No. 184). Washington, DC: Author.
33.
Inter-American Development Bank . (1997). Latin America after a decade of reforms. Washington, DC: Author.
34.
International Monetary Fund . (1997). International financial statistics yearbook. Washington, DC: Author.
35.
It was not the feared “social explosion,” but unrest in Córdoba unnerved many. (1995, July 6). Latin American Weekly Report, p. 289.
36.
Johnston, J. (1984). Econometric methods (3rd ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill.
37.
Jones, Mark . (1997). Evaluating Argentina's presidential democracy. In Scott Mainwaring & Matthew Soberg Shugart (Eds.), Presidentialism and democracy in Latin America (pp. 259-299). New York: Cambridge University Press.
38.
Kahler, Miles . (1992). External influence, conditionality, and the politics of adjustment. In Stephan Haggard & Robert R. Kaufman (Eds.), The politics of economic adjustment (pp. 89-136). Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
39.
Killick, Tony . (1995). Relevance, meaning and determinants of flexibility. In Tony Killick (Ed.), The flexible economy: Causes and consequences of the adaptability of national economies (pp. 1-33). London: Routledge.
40.
Kraemer, Moritz . (1997). Intergovernmental transfers and political representation: Evidence from Argentina, Brazil and Mexico (Working Paper No. 345). Washington, DC: Inter-American Development Bank.
41.
Lall, Rajiv , & Hofman, Bert. (1995). Decentralization and the government deficit in China. In Jayanta Roy (Ed.), Macroeconomic management and fiscal decentralization (pp. 195-220). Washington, DC: World Bank.
42.
Las provincias condicionan la reforma impositiva [The provinces condition tax reform]. (1998, May 19-25). La Nación, p. 6.
43.
López Murphy, Ricardo . (Ed.). (1995). Fiscal decentralization in Latin America. Washington, DC: Inter-American Development Bank.
44.
Menem fails to break new ground . (1998, June 24). Wall Street Journal, p. A12.
45.
Menem y de la rúa pidieron austeridad [Menem and de la rua ask for austerity]. (1998, June 23-29). La Nación, pp. 1, 6.
46.
Ministerio de Economía y Obras y Servicios Públicos. 1994. Cambios estructurales en la relación nación provincias [Structural changes in national provincial relations]. Buenos Aires, Argentina: Lugar Editorial.
47.
Molinar, Juan . (1991, December). Counting the number of parties: An alternative index. American Political Science Review, 85, 1383-1391.
48.
Musgrave, Richard A. , & Musgrave, Peggy B. (1976). Public finance in theory and practice (2nd ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill.
49.
Nelson, Joan . (Ed.). (1989). Fragile coalitions: The politics of economic adjustment. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Books.
50.
Nelson, Joan . (Ed.). (1990). Economic crisis and policy choice: The politics of adjustment in the third world. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
51.
Nelson, Joan M. (1993, April). The politics of economic transformation: Is third world experience relevant to Eastern Europe?World Politics, 45, 433-463.
52.
New riots underline social vulnerability. (1995, August 10). Latin American Weekly Report, p. 358.
53.
Noll, Roger G. (1983). The political foundations of regulatory policy. Zeitschrift fur die Gesamte Staatswissenshart, 139, 377-404.
54.
Novaro, Markos . (1994). Pilotos de tormentas: Crisis de representación y personalización de la política en Argentina (1989-1993) [Pilots of storms: The crisis of representation and personalization in the politics of Argentina]. Buenos Aires, Argentina: Letra Buena.
55.
Oates, Wallace E. (1972). Fiscal federalism. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
56.
Pagan, Adrian . (1986). Two stage and related estimations and their applications. Review of Economic Studies, 53, 517-538.
57.
Pierson, Paul . (1994). Dismantling the welfare state: Reagan, Thatcher, and the politics of retrenchment. New York: Cambridge University Press.
58.
Poterba, James M. (1994, August). State responses to fiscal crisis: The effects of budgetary institutions and politics. Journal of Political Economy, 102, 799-821.
59.
Provinces revolt against reform. (1994, January 13). Latin American Weekly Report, p. 3.
60.
Prud'homme, Rémy . (1995). The dangers of decentralization. World Bank Observer, 10, 201-220.
61.
Przeworski, Adam . (1991). Democracy and the market: Political and economic reforms in Eastern Europe and Latin America. New York: Cambridge University Press.
62.
Remmer, Karen . (1993, June). The political economy of elections in Latin America, 1980-1991. American Political Science Review, 87, 393-407.
63.
Río Negro sounds new warning. (1995, October 12). Latin American Weekly Report, p. 466.
64.
Riots . (1995, October 5). Latin American Weekly Report, p. 456.
65.
Rodrik, Dani . (1994). The rush to free trade in the developing world: Why so late? Why now? Will it last? In Stephan Haggard & Steven B. Webb (Eds.), Voting for reform: Democracy, political liberalization, and economic adjustment (pp. 61-88). Washington, DC: World Bank.
66.
Sanguinetti, Pablo , & Tommasi, Mariano. (1997). Los determinantes económicos e institucionales de los déficts en los presupuestos provinciales: Argentina 1983-1996 [The economic and institutional determinants of deficits in provincial budgets: Argentina 1983-1996] [Mimeo]. Washington, DC: Banco Interamericano de Desarrollo.
67.
Sawers, Larry . (1996). The other Argentina. Boulder, CO: Westview.
68.
Shah, Anwar . (1994). The reform of intergovernmental fiscal relations in developing and emerging market economies. Washington, DC: World Bank.
69.
Sheahan, John . (1980, January). Market-oriented policies and political repression in Latin America. Economic Development and Cultural Change, 28, 267-291.
70.
Social protests continue to spread. (1997, May 20). Latin American Weekly Report, pp. 232-233.
71.
Stallings, Barbara . (1992). International influence on economic policy: Debt, stabilization, and structural reform. In Stephan Haggard & Robert R. Kaufman (Eds.), The politics of economic adjustment (pp. 41-88). Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
72.
Stallings, Barbara . (1995). Global change, regional response. New York: Cambridge University Press.
73.
Steep warning for Menem (and the UCR) in the latest round of elections. (1995, October 19). Latin American Weekly Report, p. 469.
74.
Stein, Ernesto . (1998). Fiscal decentralization and government size in Latin America (Working Paper No. 368). Washington, DC: Inter-American Development Bank.
75.
Stigler, George . (1971, Spring). The theory of economic regulation. Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science, 2, 3-21.
76.
Unrest erupts in Argentina over austerity. (1997, May 22). New York Times, p. A3.
77.
The Wall Street Journal Americas poll . (1998, April 16). Wall Street Journal Interactive Edition.
78.
Wallich, Christine I. (1995). Russia's dilemma of fiscal federalism. In Jayanta Roy (Ed.), Macroeconomic management and fiscal decentralization (pp. 103-123). Washington, DC: World Bank.
79.
Waterbury, John . (1993). Exposed to innumerable delusions: Public enterprise and state power in Egypt, India, Mexico and Turkey. New York: Cambridge University Press.
80.
Weyland, Kurt . (1996). Risk taking in Latin American economic restructuring: Lessons from prospect theory. International Studies Quarterly, 40, 185-208.
81.
Wildasin, David E. (1997). Fiscal aspects of evolving federations. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
82.
Will Rosario be the next to blow up? (1994, February 10). Latin American Weekly Report, p. 57.
83.
Williamson, John , & Haggard, Stephan. (1994). The political conditions for economic reform. In John Williamson (Ed.), The political economy of policy reform (pp. 525-596). Washington, DC: Institute for International Economics.
84.
Winkler, Donald R. (1994). The design and administration of intergovernmental transfers: Fiscal decentralization in Latin America (World Bank Discussion Papers No. 235). Washington, DC: World Bank.
85.
World Bank . (1985). Argentina: Economic memorandum (Vol. 1). Washington, DC: Author.
86.
World Bank . (1990a). Argentina: Provincial government finances. Washington, DC: Author.
87.
World Bank . (1990b). Argentina: Reforms for price stability and growth. Washington, DC: Author.
88.
World Bank . (1990c). Argentina: Tax policy for stabilization and economic recovery. Washington, DC: Author.
89.
World Bank . (1992). Argentina: Towards a new federalism [Mimeo]. Washington, DC: Author.
90.
World Bank . (1993). Argentina: From insolvency to growth. Washington, DC: Author.
91.
World Bank . (1996a). Argentina: Provincial finances study: Selected issues in fiscal federalism (2 vols.). Washington, DC: Author.
92.
World Bank . (1996b). India: Five years of stabilization and reform and the challenges ahead. Washington, DC: Author.
