Context: Though reasonable suspicion serves as the standard threshold for when to report suspected child abuse, there is little guidance how to interpret the term. Objective: To examine how experts on child abuse interpret reasonable suspicion using 2 probability frameworks. Participants: Anonymous survey of clinical and research experts on child abuse. Main outcome measures: Responses on ordinal and visual analog scales quantifying the probability needed for “suspicion of child abuse” to rise to reasonable suspicion. Results: A total of 81 of 117 experts completed the survey (69% response rate, mean age 47 years, 69% female). On both the ordinal probability scale (rank order on a differential diagnosis) and the estimated probability scale (1% to 99% likelihood), experts demonstrated wide variability in defining reasonable suspicion, with no statistically significant differences found for age, race, gender, professional training, seniority, or prior education on reasonable suspicion. Conclusions: This study found no consensus in how experts on child abuse interpret reasonable suspicion.
Finkelhor D.The international epidemiology of child sexual abuse. Child Abuse Negl. 1994;18:409-417.
2.
Freeman M, ed. Overcoming Child Abuse: A Window on a World Problem. Sydney, Australia: Ashgate; 2000.
3.
Hoyano L., Keenan C.Child Abuse: Law and Policy Across Boundaries. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press;2007.
4.
Lalor K.Child sexual abuse in sub-Saharan Africa: a literature review. Child Abuse Negl. 2004;28:439-460.
5.
Lampe A.The prevalence of childhood sexual abuse, physical abuse and emotional neglect in Europe [in German]. Z Psychosom Med Psychother . 2002;48:370-380.
6.
Gaudiosi JAChild Maltreatment 2007. US Department of Health and Human Services; 2009.
7.
Gateway CWIMandatory Reporters of Child Abuse and Neglect: State Statutes Series. US Department of Health and Human Services; 2008.
8.
Myers JEB.Medicolegal aspects of suspected child abuse . In: Reece RM, Ludwig S, eds. Child Abuse: Medical Diagnosis and Treatment . Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins;2001:545-563.
9.
Saul Ornelas and Ismael Ornelas-Ledesma v United States, 571 US 690 ( 1996).
10.
Appelbaum PSChild abuse reporting laws: time for reform ? Psychiatr Serv. 1999;50:27-29.
11.
Deisz R., Doueck H., George N.Reasonable cause: a qualitative study of mandated reporting. Child Abuse Negl. 1996;20:275-287.
12.
Kalichman SCMandated Reporting of Suspected Child Abuse: Ethics, Law, & Policy. 2nd ed. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association ; 1999.
13.
Levi BH, Brown G.Reasonable suspicion: a study of Pennsylvania pediatricians regarding child abuse. Pediatrics. 2005;116:e5-e12.
14.
Levi BH, Loeben G.Index of suspicion: feeling not believing. Theor Med Bioeth . 2004;25(4):1-34.
15.
Singley SJFailure to report suspect child abuse: civil liability of mandated reporters . J Juv Law. 1998;19: 236-271.
16.
Alvarez KM, Kenny MC, Donohue B., Carpin KMWhy are professionals failing to intiate mandated reports of child maltreatment ? Aggress Violent Behav. 2004 ;9: 563-579.
17.
Blacker DMReporting of Child Sexual Abuse: The Effects of Varying Definitions of Reasonable Suspicion on Psychologists’ Reporting Behavior [dissertation] . Berkeley/Alameda, CA: California School of Professional Psychology; 1998.
18.
Flieger CLReporting Child Physical Abuse: The Effects of Varying legal Definitions of Reasonable Suspicion on Psychologists’ Child Abuse Reporting [dissertation] . Berkeley/Alameda, CA: California School of Professional Psychology, 1998.
19.
Foreman T., Bernet W.A misunderstanding regarding the duty to report suspected abuse. Child Maltreat. 2000;5:190-196.
20.
Gilbert R., Kemp A., Thoburn J., et al. Child maltreatment 2. Recognising and responding to child maltreatment . Lancet. 2009;373:167-180.
21.
Mitchell LM , Turbiville V., Turnbull HRReporting abuse and neglect of children with disabilities: early childhood service providers’ views. Infant Young Child. 1999;11(3):19-26.
22.
Strozier M. , Brown R., Fennell M., Hardee J., Vogel R.Experiences of mandated reporting among family therapists. Contemp Family Ther. 2005;27:175-189.
23.
Flaherty EG , Jones R., Sege R.Telling their stories: primary care practitioners’ experience evaluating and reporting injuries caused by child abuse. Child Abuse Negl. 2004;28: 939-945.
24.
Flaherty EG , Sege R., Mattson CL, Binns HJAssessment of suspicion of abuse in the primary care setting. Ambul Pediatr . 2002;2:120-126.
25.
Hickson GB, Cooper WO, Campbell PW, Altemeier WAEffects of pediatrician characteristics on management decisions in simulated cases involving apparent life-threatening events. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 1998;152: 383-387.
26.
Gateway CWI.Making and Screening Reports of Child Abuse and Neglect: Summary of State Laws. StateStatutesSeries. Washington, DC: US Department of Health and Human Services ; 2009.
27.
Hansen DJ, Bumby KM, Lundquist LM, Chandler RM, Le PT, Futa KTThe influence of case and professional variables on the identification and reporting of child maltreatment: a study of licensed psychologists and certified masters social workers. J Fam Violence. 1997 ;12: 313-332.
28.
Carter YH, Bannon MJ, Limbert C., Docherty A., Barlow J.Improving child protection: a systematic review of training and procedural interventions. Arch Dis Child. 2006;91: 740-743.
29.
Kenny MCWeb-based training in child maltreatment for future mandated reporters . Child Abuse Negl. 2007;31:671-678.
30.
Vulliamy AP , Sullivan R.Reporting child abuse: pediatricians’ experiences with the Child Protection System. Child Abuse Negl. 2000;24:1461-1470.
31.
Bonardi DJTeachers’ Decisions to Report Child Abuse: The Effects of Ethnicity, Attitudes, and Experiences [dissertation]. Palo Alto, CA : Pacific Graduate School of Psychology; 2000.
32.
Delaronde S. , King G., Bendel R., Reece R.Opinions among mandated reporters toward child maltreatment reporting policies. Child Abuse Negl. 2000;24:901-910.
33.
Flaherty EG , Sege R., Price LL, Christoffel KK, Norton DP, O’Connor KGPediatrician characteristics associated with child abuse identification and reporting: results from a national survey of pediatricians. Child Maltreat . 2006 ;11:361-369.
34.
Flaherty EG , Sege RD, Griffith J., et al. From suspicion of physical child abuse to reporting: primary care clinician decision-making . Pediatrics . 2008;122:611-619.
35.
Warner JE, Hansen DJThe identification and reporting of physical abuse by physicians: a review and implications for research. Child Abuse Negl. 1994;18:11-25.
36.
Levi BH, Brown G., Erb C.Reasonable suspicion: a pilot study of pediatric residents. Child Abuse Negl. 2006;30: 345-356.
37.
Teigen KHStudies in subjective probability III: the unimportance of alternatives . Scand J Psychol. 1983;24: 97-105.
38.
Teigen KHWhen are low-probability events judged to be "probable"? Effects of outcome-set characteristics on verbal probability estimates. Acta Pschol . 1988;68: 157-174.
39.
Gracely RH, Wolskee PJSemantic functional measurement of pain: integrating perception and language . Pain. 1983;15:389-398.
40.
Houde RWMethods for measuring clinical pain in humans. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand. 1982;72(Suppl): 25-29.
41.
Coleman D.Storming the castle to save the children: the ironic costs of a child welfare exception to the Fourth Amendment. William Mary Law Rev. 2005;47:413-540.
42.
Mathews B., Walsh K.Issues in mandatory reporting of child sexual abuse. Aust NZ J Law Educ. 2004;9(2):3-17.
43.
Wexler R.Take the child and run: tales from the age of ASFA. N Engl Law Rev. 2002;36:129-152.
44.
Diaz A., Simantov E., Rickert VIEffect of abuse on health. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med . 2002;156:811-817.
45.
Fein JA, Kassam-Adams N., Gavin M., Huang R., Blanchard D., Datner EMPersistence of posttraumatic stress in violently injured youth seen in the emergency department. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2002;156: 836-840.
46.
Hillis SD, Anda RF, Dube SR, Felitti VJ, Marchbanks PA, Marks JSThe association between adverse childhood experiences and adolescent pregnancy, long-term psychosocial consequences, and fetal death. Pediatrics . 2004;113: 320-327.
47.
Lansford JE , Dodge KA, Pettit GS, Bates JE, Crozier J., Kaplow J.A 12-year prospective study of the long-term effects of early child physical maltreatment on psychological, behavioral, and academic problems in adolescence . Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2002;156: 824-830.
48.
Melton GBMandated reporting: a policy without reason. Child Abuse Negl . 2005;29:9-18.
49.
Renke WNThe mandatory reporting of child abuse under the Child Welfare Act . Health Law J. 1999;7: 91-140.
50.
Richman HANeuhauser lecture. From a radiologist’s judgment to public policy on child abuse and neglect: what have we wrought?. Pediatr Radiol . 2000;30: 219-228.
51.
Saluja G., Kotch J., Lee LCEffects of child abuse and neglect: does social capital really matter ? Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2003;157:681-686.
52.
Scheid JMRecognizing and managing long-term sequelae of childhood maltreatment . Pediatr Ann. 2003; 32:391-401.
53.
Widom CSPosttraumatic stress disorder in abused and neglected children grown up. Am J Psychiatry. 1999;156: 1223-1229.
54.
Strozier M. , Brown R., Fennell M., Hardee J., Vogel R., Bizzell E.Experiences of mandated reporting among family therapists: a qualitative analysis. Contemp Family Ther. 2005;27:191-210.
55.
Trost C.Chilling child abuse reporting: rethinking the CAPTA amendments. Vanderbilt Law Rev. 1998;51: 183-215.
56.
State of Wisconsin v Richard Hurd, NW2d 42 (WI App Ct 1986).
57.
People of the State of Michigan v Alfred Cavaiani, 432 NW2d 409, 413 (MI App Ct 1988).
58.
Carl E. Gray v State of Florida, 520 So2d 584 (FL S Ct 1988).
59.
State of Minnesota v Curtis Lowell Grover. 437 NW2d 60, 63 (MN S Ct 1989).
60.
In the Matter of Kimberly S.M., an Infant, by Her Parents and Legal Guardians, Mariann D. M. et al. v Bradford Central School. NY2d, 588 (NY S Ct 1996).
61.
State of Missouri v Leslie A. Brown. 140 SW3d 51 (MO S Ct 2004).
62.
Connally v General Construction Company. 269 US 385, 391(S Ct 1926).
63.
Terry v Ohio. 392 US 1; 88 (S Ct 1968)
64.
Beyth-Marom R.How probable is probable? a numerical translation of verbal probability expressions. J Forecast. 1982;1:257-269.
65.
Hakel MDHow often is often? Am Psychol. 1968 ;23: 533-534.
66.
Levi BH, Dellasega C., Boehmer S.What is reasonable suspicion of child abuse? (submitted)
67.
Jones R., Flaherty EG, Binns HJ, et al. Clinicians’ description of factors influencing their reporting of suspected child abuse: report of the Child Abuse Reporting Experience Study Research Group. Pediatrics. 2008;122:259-266.
