In their exegesis of the sacred writings of the Old and New Testaments, Christian interpreters believed that they were uncovering other levels of meaning in the biblical text when read in the light of Jesus and of the church. In the last century, some Catholic scholars posited a distinct sense of scripture (the sensus plenior or "fuller sense") in order to explain this peculiar form of exegesis. Raymond E. Brown (1928-98) treated this subject several times during his impressive career, eventually rejecting it as too problematic. This article will discuss his definition of the theory and the difficulties he later identified with it. It will also offer some observations on the development of the idea in his thinking.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Benoit, Pierre1960 "La plénitude de sens des livres saints." Revue Biblique67: 161-96.
2.
1961Prophecy and Inspiration. New York: Desclée de Brouwer.
3.
Bierberg, Rudolph1948 "Does Sacred Scripture have a sensus plenior?" Catholic Biblical Quarterly10: 182-95.
4.
Bock, Darrell L.1985a "Evangelicals and the use of the Old Testament in the New, Part 1" Bibliotheca Sacra142: 209-23.
5.
1985b "Evangelicals and the use of the Old Testament in the New, Part 2" Bibliotheca Sacra142: 306-19.
6.
Brown, Raymond E.1953 "The history and development of the theory of a sensus plenior" Catholic Biblical Quarterly15: 141-62.
7.
1955The "Sensus Plenior" of Sacred Scripture. STD dissertation . Pontifical Theological Faculty of St. Mary's University .
8.
1963 "The sensus plenior in the last ten years" Catholic Biblical Quarterly25: 262-85.
9.
1967 "The problems of the sensus plenior" Ephemerides Theologicae Lovanienses43: 460-69.
10.
1968 "Hermeneutics" In Raymond E. Brown, Joseph A. Fitzmyer and Roland E. Murphy (eds.), The Jerome Biblical Commentary, 605-23 (art. 71). Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall. All references are to article and section number.
11.
1979The Birth of the Messiah: A Commentary on the Infancy Narratives in Matthew and Luke. Garden City: Image.
12.
1980 "The meaning of the Bible" Theology Digest28: 305-20.
13.
Brown, Raymond E. and Sandra M. Schneiders1990 "Hermeneutics" In Raymond E. Brown, Joseph A. Fitzmyer and Roland E. Murphy (eds.), The New Jerome Biblical Commentary, 1146-165 (art. 71). Englewood Cliffs: Prentice Hall. All references are to article and section number .
14.
Catholic Church1997Catechism of the Catholic Church. 2nd edition. Washington: United States Catholic Conference-Libreria Editrice Vaticana. All references are to article number.
15.
Congregation for Divine Worship1975 " General Instruction of the Liturgy of the Hours" In The Liturgy of the Hours According to the Roman Rite. Volume 1: Advent Season · Christmas Season, 21-98. New York: Catholic.
16.
Coppens, Joseph1949Les Harmonies des Deux Testaments: Essai sur les Divers Sens des Ecritures et sur l'Unité de la Révélation. Cahiers de la Nouvelle Revue Théologique, 6. Tournai - Paris: Casterman.
17.
1952a "Nouvelles réflexions sur les divers sens des Saintes Écritures." Nouvelle Revue Théologique74: 3-20.
Courtade, Gaston1950 "Les écritures ont-elles un sens 'plénier'? " Recherches de Science Religieuse37: 481-99.
20.
Daniélou, Jean1948 "Les divers sens de l'écriture dans la tradition Chrétienne primitive." Ephemerides Theologicae Lovanienses24: 119-26.
21.
1950Sacramentum Futuri: Études sur les Origines de la Typologie Biblique. Études de Théologie Historique. Paris: Beauchesne.
22.
1955 "The typological interpretation of the Bible." In Origen, 139-73. Translated by Walter Mitchell. London: Sheed and Ward.
23.
De Lubac, Henri1947 "'Typologie' et 'allégorisme.'" Recherches de Science Religieuse34: 180-226.
24.
1950Histoire et Esprit: L'Intelligence de l'Écriture d'après Origène. Théologie, 16. Paris: Aubier.
25.
1968The Sources of Revelation. Translated by Luke O'Neill. New York: Herder and Herder.
26.
De Tuya, Manuel1952 "Si es posible y en qué medida un sensus plenior a la luz del concepto teolôgico de inspiración." La Ciencia Tomista79: 369-418.
27.
Fernàndez, Andrea [Andrés] 1925 "Hermeneutica" In Albertus Vaccari (ed.), Institutiones Biblicae Scholis Accommodatae. Volume One: De S. Scriptura in Universum, 293-429. Rome: Pontifical Biblical Institute.
Fuller, R.C.1953 "The interpretation of Holy Scripture." In Bernard Orchard, Edmund F. Sutcliffe, Reginald C. Fuller and Ralph Russell (eds.), A Catholic Commentary on Holy Scripture, 53-60. New York : Thomas Nelson & Sons. All references are to section number.
31.
Ibáñez Arana, Andrés1953 "El concepto de inspiración y el porvenir del 'sensus plenior."'Lumen2: 193-219.
32.
LaSor, William Sanford1978a "Prophecy, inspiration, and the sensus plenior " Tyndale Bulletin29: 49-60.
33.
1978 b "The sensus plenior and biblical interpretation" In W. Ward Gasque and William Sanford LaSor (eds.), Scripture, Tradition, and Interpretation: Essays Presented to Everett F. Harrison by His Students and Colleagues in Honor of His Seventy-fifth Birthday, 260-77. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans.
34.
McKenzie, John L.1958 "Problems of hermeneutics in Roman Catholic exegesis ." Journal of Biblical Literature77: 197-204.
35.
Moo, Douglas J.1986 "The problem of the sensus plenior." In Hermeneutics, Authority, and Canon, 179-211. Grand Rapids : Zondervan.
36.
Murphy, Roland E.1955Review of The Sensus Plenior of Sacred Scripture, by Raymond E. Brown. Catholic Biblical Quarterly17: 502-05.
37.
Muthengi, Julius1984 "A critical analysis of the sensus plenior." East Africa Journal of Evangelical Theology3: 63-73.
38.
Osiek, Carolyn2006 "Catholic or catholic? Biblical scholarship at the center ." Journal of Biblical Literature125/1: 5-22.
39.
Oss, Douglas A.1988 "Canon as context: The function of the sensus plenior in Evangelical hermeneutics." Grace Theological Journal9: 105-27.
40.
Pontifical Biblical Commission2002 " Document on the interpretation of the Bible in the church." In Dean P. Béchard (ed. and trans.), The Scripture Documents: An Anthology of Official Catholic Teachings, 244-317 . Collegeville: Liturgical Press .
41.
Poythress, Vern S.1986 "The divine meaning of scripture" Westminster Theological Jaurnal48: 241-79.
42.
Riggs, Jack R.1986 "The 'fuller meaning' of scripture: A hermeneutical question for Evangelicals" Grace Theological Journal7: 213-27.
43.
Sutcliffe, Edmund F.1953 "The plenary sense as a principle of interpretation ." Biblica34: 333-43.
44.
Vawter, Bruce1964 "The fuller sense: Some considerations." Catholic Biblical Quarterly26: 85-96.
