Evaluation of the Cost Effectiveness of Therapist Computerized Entry of Occupational Therapy Workload Measurement Data

Abstract

French

A study was conducted to examine the cost effectiveness of two methods of managing occupational therapy workload measurement data. The computer entry of statistical data by a clerk in a central location was compared to multi-site direct input of data by therapists. Cost effectiveness, efficiency and accuracy of each method were the primary outcomes. Ease of coordination and level of computer comfort were secondary outcomes. It was clear that clerk entry of data was more cost effective, efficient and accurate than therapist entry of data. The monitoring of monthly data entry was best facilitated by clerk entry. Therapists had a positive attitude towards direct entry but were unable to approximate the speed and accuracy of the data entry clerk. Therapists' comfort with computers increased slightly during the study. Since the prime purpose of the study was to examine cost effectiveness, it was concluded that clerk entry of workload data is the best use of resources.

Keywords

Data collection Evaluation studies Workload measurement systems

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Canadian Association of Occupational Therapists. (1989). Position statement: Workload measurement and occupational therapy in health care facilities. Toronto, ON: Author.

Edwards

Law

Mills

, (1994). Workload measurement: A survey of computerized data collection. Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy, 61, 112–116.

Health and Welfare Canada. (1988a). National hospital productivity improvement program: Occupational therapy workload measurement system. (H30-11/3-3E). Ottawa, ON: Department of National Health and Welfare.

Health and Welfare Canada. (1988b). National hospital productivity improvement program: A comprehensive audit guide for workload measurement systems — Occupational Therapy. (H30-11/3-14E). Ottawa, ON: Department of National Health and Welfare.

InfoMed Development Corporation. (1991). InfoMed-OT Canadian Occupational Therapy Information Management Program, InfoMed User's Manual, Comox, British Columbia.

Management Information Systems Group. (1993). Guidelines for management information systems in Canadian health care facilities: Diagnostic and therapeutic servicesoccupational therapy manual. Ottawa, ON: MIS Group.

Statistical Analysis Systems. (1979). SAS Users Guide. High Point, NC: Author.

Scott

Cockerill

Wright

Pallas

, (1993). A survey of workload measurement systems: The occupational therapy manager's perspective. Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy, 60, 17–22.

Wright

Scott

Cockerill

(1993). Surviving the management game: Workload measurement systems in a cost-conscious environment. Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy, 60, 23–28.