This article extends earlier research concerning the relationship between corporate social performance and corporate financial performance, with particular emphasis on methodological inconsistencies. Research in this area is extended in three critical areas. First, it focuses on a particular industry, the chemical industry. Second, it uses multiple sources of data-two that are perceptual based (KLD Index and Fortune reputation survey), and two that are performance based (TRI database and corporate philanthropy) in order to triangulate toward assessing corporate social performance. Third, it uses the five most commonly applied accounting measures in the corporate social performance and corporate financial performance (CSP/CFP) literature to assess corporate financial performance. The results indicate that the a priori use of measures may actually predetermine the CSP/CFP relationship outcome. Surprisingly, Fortune and KLD indices very closely track one another, whereas TRI and corporate philanthropy differentiate between high and low social performers and do not correlate to the firm's financial performance.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abbott, W. F.
, and R. J. Monsen. 1979. "On the Measurement of Corporate Social Respon-sibility: Self-Reported Disclosures and a Method of Measuring Corporate Social In-volvement."Academy of Management Journal22 (3): 501-515.
2.
Alexander, G. J.
, and R. A. Buchholz. 1978. "Corporate Social Responsibility and Stock Market Performance."Academy of Management Journal21 (3): 479-486.
3.
Anderson, J. C.
, andA. W. Frankle. 1980. "Voluntary Social Reporting: An Iso-BetaPortfolio Analysis."The Accounting Review55:467-479.
4.
Arlow, P.
, and M. Gannon., 1982. "Social Responsiveness, Corporate Structure, and Eco-nomic Performance."Academy of Management Review7 (2): 235-241.
5.
Aupperle, K. E.
, A. B. Carroll, and J. D. Hatfield. 1985. "An Empirical Examination of the Relationship Between Corporate Social Responsibility and Profitability."Academy of Management Journal28 (2): 446-463.
6.
Belkaoui, A.1976. "The Impact of the Disclosure of the Environmental Effects of Organi-zational Behavior on the Market."Financial Management5 (4):26-31.
7.
Bowman, E. H.1978. "Strategy, Annual Reports, and Alchemy."California Management Review20 (3): 64-71.
8.
Bowman, E. H.
, and M. Haire. 1975. "A Strategic Posture Toward Corporate Social Responsibility."California Management Review18 (2): 49-58.
9.
Bragdon, J. H.
, and J. T. Marlin. 1972. "Is Pollution Profitable?"Risk Management19 (2): 9-18.
10.
Bromiley, P.
, and A. Marcus. 1989. "The Deterrent to Dubious Corporate Behavior: Profit-ability, Probability, and Safety Recalls."Strategic Management Journal10: 233-250.
11.
Brown, B.
, and S. Perry. 1994. "Removing the Financial Performance Halo for Fortune's 'Most Admired Companies.' "Academy of Management Journal37 (4): 1346-1359.
12.
Brown, B.
, and S. Perry.1995. "Halo-Removed Residuals of Fortune 's 'responsibility to the Community and Environment'-A Decade of Data."Business and Society34 (2): 199-215.
13.
Brown, R. L.
, and G. E. Fryxell. 1995. Changes in Toxic Air Releases and Financial Correlates: An Empirical Study of Environmental Strategies in the Petroleum Industry. Paper presented at the annual meetings of the Academy of Management, Vancouver, BC, Canada, August.
14.
Carroll, A. B.1979. "A Three-Dimensional Model of Corporate Performance."Academy of Management Review4 (4): 497-505.
15.
Carroll, A. B.1991. "Corporate Social Performance Measurement: A Commentary on Methods for Evaluating an Elusive Construct." Pp. 385-401 in J. E. Post (ed.), Research in Corporate Social Performance and Policy, vol. 12. Greenwich, CT: JAI.
16.
Carroll, A. B.1994. "Social Issues in Management Research: Experts' Views, Analysis, and Commentary."Business and Society33 (3): 497-505.
17.
Chen, K. H.
, and R. W. Metcalf. 1980. "The Relationship Between Pollution Control Record and Financial Indicators Revisited."The Accounting Review55 (1): 168-177.
18.
Cochran, P. L.
, and R. A. Wood. 1984. "Corporate Social Responsibility and Financial Performance."Academy of Management Journal27 (1): 42-56.
19.
Coffey, B. S.
, and G. E. Fryxell. 1991. "Institutional Ownership of Stock and Dimensions of Corporate Social Performance: An Empirical Examination."Journal of Business Ethics10:437-444.
20.
Corporate 500: Directory of Corporate Philanthropy (10th ed.). 1991-1992. San Francisco, CA: Public Management Institute.
21.
Corporate 500: Directory of Corporate Philanthropy (11th ed.). 1992-1993. San Francisco, CA: Public Management Institute.
22.
Corporate 500: Directory of Corporate Philanthropy (12th ed.). 1993-1994. San Francisco, CA: Public Management Institute.
23.
Cowen, S. S.
, L. B. Ferreri, and D. B. Parker. 1987. "The Impact of Corporate Characteristics on Social Responsibility Disclosure: A lypology and Frequency-Based Analysis."Accounting Organizations and Society12(2): 111-122.
24.
Davidson, W. N.
, P. R. Chandy, and M. Cross. 1987. "Large Losses, Risk Management and Stock Returns in the Airline Industry."Journal of Risk and Insurance55:162-172.
25.
Davidson, W. N.
, and D. L. Worrell. 1988. "The Impact of Announcements of Corporate Illegalities on Shareholder Returns."Academy of Management Journal31 (1): 195-200.
26.
Davidson, W. N.
, and D. L. Worrell. 1990. "A Comparison and Test of the Use of Accounting and Stock Market Data in Relating Corporate Social Responsibility and Financial Performance."Akron Business and Economic Review21 (3): 7-19.
27.
Eckbo, B. E.1983. "Horizontal Mergers, Collusion, and Stockholder Wealth."Journal of Financial Economics11: 241-273.
28.
Fogler, H. R.
, and F. Nutt. 1975. "A Note on Social Responsibility and Stock Valuation."Academy of Management Journal18 (1): 155-166.
29.
Fortune. 1994, February. "America's Most Admired Corporations," p. 58-58.
30.
Freedman, M.
, and B. Jaggi. 1982. "Pollution Disclosures, Pollution Performance and Economic Performance."Omega10 (2): 167-176.
31.
Freedman, M.
, and B. Jaggi. 1986. "An Analysis of the Impact of Corporate Pollution Disclosures Included in Annual Financial Statements on Investors' Decisions." Pp. 193-212 in M. Neimark (ed.), Advances in Public InterestAccounting. Greenwich, CT: JAI.
32.
Friedman, M.1970. (reprint from 1962). "The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Increase its Profits."New York Times Magazine, September 13, pp. 122-126.
33.
Frooman, J. S.1994. "Does the Market Penalize Finrns for Socially Irresponsible Behavior?" Pp. 329-34 in D. Collins (ed.), Proceedings from the Fourth Annual International Association for Business and Society.
34.
Fry, F. L.
, and R. J. Hock. 1976. "Who Claims Corporate Responsibility? The Biggest and the Worst."Business and Society Review18:62-65.
35.
Fry, F. L.
, G. D. Keim, and R. E. Meiners. 1982. "Corporate Contributions: Altruistic or for Profit?"Academy of Management Journal25 (1):94-106.
36.
Fryxell, G. E.
, and J. Wang. 1994. "The Fortune Corporate 'Reputation' Index: Reputation for What?"Journal of Management20(1): 1-14.
37.
Graves, S. B.
, and S. A. Waddock. 1994. "Institutional Owners and Corporate Social Performance."Academy of Management Journal37 (4): 1034-1046.
38.
Griffin, J. J.1996. "The Toxics Release Inventory: Limitations and Implications." Pp. 324-329 in K. Rehbein (ed.), Proceedings from the Sixth International Association for Business and Society.
39.
Hart, S. L.
, and G. Ahuja. 1994. Does it Pay to Be Green? Paper presented at the national meetings of the Academy of Management, Dallas, TX, August.
40.
Heinze, D. C.1976. "Financial Correlates of a Social Involvement Measure."Akron Business and Economic Review7 (1): 48-51.
41.
Hill, C. W.
, P. C. Kelley, and B. R. Agle. 1990. "An Empirical Examination of the Determinants of OSHA Violations." Pp. 402-412 in D. Wood and W. E. Martello (eds.), Proceedings from the 1990 International Association for Business and Society.
42.
Hoffer, G. E.
, S. W. Pruitt, and R. J. Reilly. 1988. "The Impact of Product Recalls on the Wealth of Sellers: A Reexamination."Journal of Political Economy96 (3): 663-670.
43.
Holman, W. R.
, J. R. New, and D. Singer. 1990. "The Impact of Corporate Social Respon-siveness on Shareholder Wealth." Pp. 265-279 in L. E. Preston (ed.), Corporation and Society Research: Studies in Theory and Measurement. Greenwich, CT: JAI.
44.
Holmes, S. L.1977. "Corporate Social Performance: Past and Present Areas of Commit-ment."Academy of Management Journal20 (3): 433-438.
45.
Ingram, R. W.1978. "An Investigation of the Information Content of (Certain) Social Responsibility Disclosures."Journal of Accounting Research16 (2): 270-285.
46.
Ingram, R. W.
, and K. B. Frazier. 1980. "Environmental Performance and Corporate Disclosure."Journal of Accounting Research18 (2): 614-621.
47.
Ingram, R. W.
, and K. B. Frazier. 1983. "Narrative Disclosures in Annual Reports."Journal of Business Research11:49-60.
48.
Jarrell, G.
, and S. Peltzman. 1985. "The Impact of Product Recalls on the Wealth of Sellers."Journal of Political Economy93 (3): 512-536.
49.
Jick, T.1979. "Mixing Qualitative and Quantitative Methods: Triangulation in Action."Administrative Science Quarterly24:602-611.
50.
Johnson, R. A.
, and D. W. Greening. 1994. "Relationships Between Corporate Social Performance, Financial Performance, and Firm Governance." Pp. 314-3181994 Best Paper Proceedings of the Academy of Management.
51.
Jones, J.1990. "Verification of Toxic Release Inventory Data Using Other Environmental Reports."Utah Department of Health, Division of Environmental Health, August 10.
52.
Kedia, B.
, and E. C. Kuntz. 1981. "The Context of Social Performance: An Empirical Study of Texas Banks." Pp. 133-154 in L. E. Preston (ed.), Research in Corporate Social Perfiormance and Policy, vol. 3. Greenwich, CT: JAI.
53.
Kohls, J.1985. "Corporate Board Structure, Social Reporting, and Social Performance." Pp. 165-189 in L. E. Preston (ed.), Research in Corporate Social Performance and Policy, vol. 7. Greenwich, CT: JAI.
54.
Lemer, L. D.
, and G. E. Fryxell. 1988. "An Empirical Study of the Predictors of Corporate Social Performance: AMulti-Dimensional Analysis."Journal of Business Ethics7:951-959.
55.
Logsdon, J. M.1995. "The Toxics Release Inventory as a Data Source for Business and Society Studies." Pp. 648-653 in D. Collins (ed.), Proceedings from the International Association for Business and Society.
56.
Marcus, A. A.
, and R. S. Goodman. 1986. "Compliance and Performance: Toward a Contingency Theory." Pp. 193-221 in L. E. Preston and J. E. Post (eds.), Research in Corporate Social Performance and Policy, vol. 8. Greenwich, CT: JAI.
57.
McGuire, J. B.
, A. Sundgren, and T. Schneeweis. 1988. "Corporate Social Responsibility and Firm Financial Performance."Academy of Management Journal31 (4): 854-872.
58.
Mock, V. E.
, and F. Hoy. 1995. "Corporate Social Performance: A Comparison of the KLD, Aupperle, Fortune, and Self-Reported Measures." Pp. 659-664 in D. Collins (ed.), Proceedings from the International Association for Business and Society.
59.
Morris, S. A.
, K. A. Rehbein, J. C. Hosseini, and R. L. Armacost. 1990. "Building a Profile of Socially Responsive Firms." Pp. 297-303 in D. J. Wood and W. E. Martello (eds.), Proceedings of the International Association for Business and Society.
60.
Moskowitz, M.1972. "Choosing Socially Responsible Stocks."Business and Society Review10:71-75.
61.
Moskowitz, M.
.1975. "Profiles in Corporate Responsibility: The Ten Worst and the Ten Best."Business and Society Review13:28-42.
62.
Newgren, K. E.
, A. A. Rasher, M. E. LaRoe, and M. R. Szabo. 1985. "Environmental Assessment and Corporate Performance: A Longitudinal Analysis Using Market-Deter-mined Performance Measures." Pp. 153-164 in L. E. Preston (ed.), Research in Corporate Social Performance and Policy, vol. 7. Greenwich, CT:JAI.
63.
Parket, R.
, and H. Eilbert. 1975. "Social Responsibility: The Underlying Factors."Business Horizons18 (4): 5-11.
64.
Profit Whatever the Cost? The Debate Intensifies on Making Money against Making Employees Happy. Boston Globe, April 21, 1996, p. A1-A1.
65.
Pruitt, S. W.
, and D. R. Peterson. 1986. "Security Price Reactions Around Product Recall Announcements."The Journal of Financial Research9 (2): 113-122.
66.
Riahi-Belkaoui, A.1992. "Executive Compensation, Organizational Effectiveness, Social Performance and Firm Performance: An Empirical Investigation."Journal of Business Finance and Accounting19 (1): 25-38.
67.
Rockness, J.
, P. Schlachter, and H. 0. Rockness. 1986. "Hazardous Waste Disposal, Corpo-rate Disclosure, and Financial Performance in the Chemical Industry."Advances in Public InterestAccounting1:167-191.
68.
Shane, P. B.
, and B. H. Spicer. 1983. "Market Response to Environmental Information Produced Outside the Firm."The Accounting Review58 (3): 521-538.
69.
Sharfman, M.1993. "A Construct Validity Study of the KLD Social Performance Rating Data." In J. Pasquero and D. Collins (eds.), Proceedings of the International Association for Business and Society.
70.
Spencer, B. A.
, and G. S. Taylor. 1987. "A Within and Between Analysis of the Relationship Between Corporate Social Responsibility and Financial Performance."Akron Business and Economic Review18 (3): 7-18.
71.
Spicer, B. H.1978. "Investors, Corporate Social Performance and Information Disclosure: An Empirical Study."The Accounting Review531): 94-111.
72.
Strachan, J. L.
, D. B. Smith, and W. L. Beedles. 1983. "The Price Reaction to (Alleged) Corporate Crime."The Financial Review18 (2): 121-132.
73.
Sturdivant, F. D.
, and J. L. Ginter. 1977. "Corporate Social Responsiveness: Management Attitudes and Economic Performance."California Management Review19 (3): 30-39.
74.
Ullmann, A.1985. "Data in Search of a Theory: A Critical Examination of the Relationship Among Social Performance, Social Disclosure, & Economic Performance."Academy of Management Review10:450-477.
75.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
. 1993. 1991 Toxics Release Inventory: Public Data Release. Washington, DC: Author.
76.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
.1994. 1992 Toxics Release Inventory: Public Data Release. Washington, DC: Author.
77.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
.1995. "Toxics Release Inventory (TRI) Data Use Conference: Building TRI and Pollution Prevention Partnerships."Proceedings. Boston, MA, December 5-8, 1994. Washington, DC: Author.
78.
Vance, S. C.1975. "Are Socially Responsible Corporations Good Investment Risks?"Academy ofManagement Review (August): 18-24.
79.
Waddock, S. A.
, and S. B. Graves. 1994. The Corporate Social Performance-Financial Perfonnance Link. Paper presented at the national meetings of the Academy of Manage-ment, Dallas, TX, August.
80.
Waddock, S. A.
, and J. F. Mahon. 1991. "Corporate Social Performance Revisited: Dimen-sions of Efficacy, Effectiveness, and Efficiency." Pp. 231-264 in J. E. Post (ed.), Research in Corporate Social Performance and Policy, vol. 12. Greenwich, CT: JAI.
81.
Wartick, S. L.
, and P. L. Cochran. 1985. "The Evolution of the Corporate Social Performance Model."Academy of Management Review10 (4): 758-769.
82.
Wier, P1983. "The Costs of Antimerger Lawsuits: Evidence From the Stock Market."Journal of Financial Economics11: 207-224.
83.
Wokutch, R. E.
, and E. W. McKinney. 1991. "Behavioral and Perceptual Measures of Corporate Social Performance." Pp. 309-330 in J. E. Post (ed.), Research in Corporate Social Performance and Policy, vol. 12. Greenwich, CT: JAI.
84.
Wokutch, R. E.
, and B. A. Spencer. 1987. "Corporate Saints and Sinners. The Effects of Philanthropic and Illegal Activity on Organizational Performance."California Manage-ment Review29 (2): 62-77.
85.
Wood, D. J.1991. "Corporate Social Performance Revisited."Academy of Management Review6 (4):691-718.
86.
Wood, D. J.
, and R. E. Jones. 1995. "Stakeholder Mismatching: A Theoretical Problem in Empirical Research on Corporate Social Performance."International Journal of Orga-nizational Analysis3:229-267.
