Criterion-based Assessment,Grading and Reporting at Year 12 Level

Abstract

While the move towards criterion-referenced assessment in Australia represents a step in the right direction, the path is fraught with political and technical hazards. Advocates of criterion-referenced assessment tend to overdraw the distinction between norm and criterion-referenced assessment, and to play down the difficulties inherent in spelling out criteria and setting standards at the Year 12 level. Nevertheless it is a good idea to try to clarify the domains of each subject (integrated structures of knowledge and ability which underly areas of expertise) and to experiment with new tools and technologies being developed by measurement specialists. We must also recognize that we cannot hope to improve the art of assessing the quality of students' work by an infinite expansion along a scientific-technological path in all areas of the curriculum. In many areas, we will always be dependent on the expertise and judgment of connoisseurs, and judgments will always represent an uncertain blend of criteria derived from the subject and the assessors on the one hand, and norms ebbing from those being assessed on the other.

Keywords

academic achievement academic standards criterion-referenced tests norm-referenced tests student assessment Year 12

References

Archer

(1984). The implementation of an educational innovation: The introduction of ROSBA (Review of School Based Assessment) in secondary schools in Queensland. Unpublished M.Ed. thesis, University of Queensland.

Australia. Quality of Education Review Committee (1985). Quality of Education in Australia: Report (Chairman: P.H. Karmel). Canberra: AGPS.

Beazley

(Chairman). See Western Australia. Committee of Inquiry into Education in Western Australia.

Beuk

C.H.

(1984). A method for reaching a compromise between absolute and relative standards in examinations. Journal of Educational Measurement, 21, 147–52.

Biggs

Collis

(1982). Evaluating the Quality of Learning: The SOLO Taxonomy. New York: Academic Press.

Brumby

(1981). The use of problem solving in meaningful learning in biology. Research in Science Education, 11, 103–10.

Carr

(1984). Model confusion in chemistry. Research in Science Education, 14, 97–103.

Cox

C.B.

Dyson

A.E.

(Eds) (1969). Fight for Education. London: Critical Quarterly Society.

Cronbach

Gleser

Nanda

Rjaratnam

(1972). The Dependability of Behavioural Measures: Theory of Generalizability for Scores and Profiles. New York: Wiley.

10.

Ebel

R.L.

(1962). Content standard test scores. Educational and Psychological Measurement, 22, 11–17.

11.

Eisner

(1979). The Educational Imagination. New York: Macmillan.

12.

Fairbrother

R.W.

(1984). Criteria for the Award of Grades. London: Chelsea College.

13.

Fredericksen

(1984). The real test bias: Influences of testing on teaching and learning. American Psychologist, 39, 193–202.

14.

French

(1981). Measurement theory and examinations. British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology, 34, 38–49.

15.

Glaser

(1963). Instructional technology and the measurement of learning outcomes. American Psychologist, 18, 519–21.

16.

Glass

G.V.

(1978). Standards and criteria. Journal of Educational Measurement, 15, 237–61.

17.

Goldstein

Blinkhorn

(1977). Monitoring educational standards—an inappropriate model. Bulletins of the British Psychological Society, 30, 309–11.

18.

Hambletion

Swaminathan

Algina

Coulson

(1978). Criterion-referenced testing and measurement. Review of Educational Research, 48, 1–47.

19.

Karmel

P.H.

(Chairman). See Australia. Quality of Education Review Committee.

20.

Mager

R.F.

(1962). Preparing Instructional Objectives. Palo Alto, Ca: Reardon.

21.

Messick

(1984). The psychology of educational measurement. Journal of Educational Measurement, 21, 215–37.

22.

Messick

Beaton

Lord

(1983). A New Design for a New Era. Princeton: NAEP.

23.

Millman

(1974). Criterion-referenced measurement. In Popham

W.J.

(Ed.), Evaluation in Education: Current Applications. Berkeley: McCutchan.

24.

National Academy of Education (1978). Improving Educational Achievement. Washington: NAEP.

25.

Nitko

A.J.

(1980). Distinguishing the many varieties of criterion-referenced tests. Review of Educational Research, 50, 461–85.

26.

Pitman

(1985). Criterion-based assessment. Paper presented at Australasian Conference of Assessment and Certification Authorities, Adelaide, July 1985.

27.

Popham

(1978). Criterion-referenced Measurement. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.

28.

Queensland Board of Secondary School Studies (1978). A Review of School-based Assessment. Brisbane: The Board.

29.

Rowntree

(1977). Assessing Students—How shall we know them? London: Harper & Row.

30.

Sadler

D. R.

(1982). Why the explicit definition of standards is not always possible. Ideas in Education, 1 (2), 12–13.

31.

Shepard

(1980). Technical Issues in Minimum Competency Testing. (Review of Research in Education, Vol. 8). Washington: American Education Research Association.

32.

Stevenson

(1983). Pupil profiles—an alternative to conventional examinations? British Journal of Educational Studies, 31(2), 102–16.

33.

Western Australia. Committee of Inquiry into Education in Western Australia (1984). Education in Western Australia (Chairman: K. Beazley). Perth: Govt Pr.

34.

Wood

Power

(1984). An Enquiry into the Competence-performance Distinction as it relates to Assessment in Secondary and Further Education. Adelaide: Flinders University.