In this paper, twenty-eight recent research studies on inquiry teaching in social studies and the social sciences are reviewed. Although a number of statistically significant results were claimed by the respective researchers, methodological deficiencies in many of the studies greatly reduce the importance of their efforts. Reference is made to a number of research deficiencies, including unsuitable evaluation instruments, lack of comparability of groups, lack of comparability of tasks and instructors for experimental and control groups and inadequate research designs. Although inquiry teaching has become widely espoused as a teaching method in schools, there are few substantial research studies to support its superiority over other teaching methods.
References
1.
BakerEugene HaroldA comparative study of textbook and simulation approaches in teaching junior high school American history. Unpublished Ed. D. dissertation, Northwestern University, 1966. (Dissertation Abstracts, 27, 3353-A.)
2.
BaylesE. E.Experiments with reflective teaching. Kansas Studies in Education. 1956, VI, No. 3.
3.
BelskyTheodore B.The development of an “expository-inquiry continuum” to measure relationships between “expository” and “inquiry” teaching methods and student cognitive characteristics in secondary social studies classes. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, University of Massachusetts, 1971. (Dissertation Abstracts International, 32, 1970-A.)
4.
BoedekerLouise C.Inquiry teaching strategies, their effects on dogmatism, critical thinking and learning in a seventh grade course. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, University of Minnesota, 1971. (Dissertation Abstracts International, 32, 6283-A.)
5.
BollerDonald H.The effects of inquiry activities on the questioning strategies of third and fifth grade students. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation. State University of New York at Buffalo, 1972. (Dissertation Abstracts International, 33, 1071-A.)
6.
CampbellDonald T.StanleyJulian C.Experimental and quasi-experimental designs for research on teaching. GageN. L. (Ed.) Handbook of Research on Teaching, Chicago: Rand McNally & Co., 1963. 176–183.
7.
ChamberlinCharles R.Differences in critical thinking skills achievement following inquiry instruction among elementary school students at three levels of intelligence, anxiety, and chronological age. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, University of Minnesota, 1971. (Dissertation Abstracts International, 32, 2544-A.)
8.
CookeGary E.Conceptual learning in young children: a comparison of the effects of rote, principle, and guided discovery strategies on conceptualization in first grade children. Unpublished Ed.D. dissertation. University of Oregon, 1971. (Dissertation Abstracts International, 32, 2904-A.)
9.
CrabtreeCharlotte, Effects of structuring on the productiveness of children's thinking. Journal of Experimental Education, 1967, XXXVI, 1, 1–13.
10.
DavidDavid W.Conditions that foster growth in children's ability to generalize in elementary school social studies. Unpublished Ed.D. dissertation, Indiana University, 1968. (Dissertation Abstracts, 29, 1805-A.)
11.
FeelyTheodoreM.Jr.The concept of “inquiry” in the social studies. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Stanford University, 1972, 168. (Dissertation Abstracts International, 32, 6790-A.)
12.
FrasierV. C.A study of students' ability to use functional imperatives as strategies of inquiry. Unpublished Ed.D. dissertation, Columbia University, 1968. (Dissertation Abstracts, 29, 3911-A.)
GoodJ. M.FarleyE.FentonE., Developing inquiry skills with an experimental social studies curriculum. Journal of Educational Research, 1969, LXIII, 31–35.
15.
GrahlfsF. LincolnThe relationship between student interest and student learning with new curricular materials. Paper presented at the American Educational Research Association, Los Angeles, Feb. 6, 1969.
16.
GrieveTarrance DonDavisJ. KentThe relationship of cognitive style and method of instruction to performance in ninth grade geography. Journal of Educational Research, 1971, 65, 137–141.
17.
GrossR. E., A Decade of doctoral research in social studies education. Social Education, 1972, XXXVI, 555–560.
18.
HermanWayne L.The use of language arts in social studies lessons. American Educational Research Journal, 1967, 4, 117–124.
19.
HermanWayne L.PotterfieldJames E.DaytonMitchell C.AmershekKathleen G.The relationship of teacher-centred activities and pupil-centred activities to pupil achievement and interest in 18 fifth-grade social studies classes. American Educational Research Journal, 1969, 6, 227–239.
20.
HunkinsFrancis P.PhyllisShandre, Teaching critical thinking in elementary social studies. Education, 1967, LXXXVIII, 68–72.
21.
JewettRobert E.The problems approach and the senior high school. GrossR. E.MuessigR. H. (Eds.). Problem-Centred Social Studies Instruction. Washington, D.C.: National Council for the Social Studies, 1971, 61.
22.
JohnsonW. D.PayetteR. F.CoxC. B., Review of research in social studies: 1968. Social Education, 1969, XXXIII, 980–983.
23.
KaufmanBetsy B.A contemporary review of the inquiry method of teaching and learning: a study of current definitions and rationales of the inquiry method of teaching and learning—1960–1970. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation. New York University, 1972, 9–13. (Dissertation Abstracts International, 33, 223-A.)
24.
LeeMartha AliceDevelopment of inquiry skills in ungraded social studies classes in a junior high school. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Indiana University, 1967. (Dissertation Abstracts, 28, 3367-A.)
25.
LevinMalcolm A., Teaching public issues: Some evaluation data from the Harvard Project. Social Education, 1972, XXXVI, 883–889.
26.
LucasA. M.Creativity, discovery and inquiry in science education. Australian Journal of Education, 1971, 15, 185–196.
27.
MaddenJohn R.The relationship between the use of an inquiry teaching technique in a social studies classroom and the attitude of students toward the social studies course. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Syracuse University, 1970. (Dissertation Abstracts International, 31, 5940-A.)
28.
MassialasByron G.CoxC. BenjaminInquiry in Social Studies. New York: McGraw-Hill Book Co., 1966, 239.
29.
McKeownR. J.A study of affective responses to selected attitude objects encountered in synthesis and non-synthesis task oriented social studies programs. Paper presented to National Council for Social Studies, New York, Nov. 24, 1970.
30.
MerwinWilliamA Decade of Inquiry: Tempest in a Tea Cup. Wisconsin State University, Aug. 1970. E.R.I.C. Research in Education. ED. 031453.
31.
PageRobert L.An experiment to compare the effectiveness of instruction versus discovery in generalizing the strategy of a simple game. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, The Florida State University, 1970. (Dissertation Abstracts International, 31, 4628-A.)
32.
PierleoniRobert G.The affective measurement of a programmed unit on American political attitudes and positions. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, The University of Rochester, 1968. (Dissertation Abstracts, 29, 1828-A.)
33.
PrattDanielD.Effects of tolerance-intolerance of ambiguity and divergent and convergent structure upon an inquiry-discovery task. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, University of Washington, 1971. (Dissertation Abstracts International, 32, 4494-A.)
34.
SandersNorris M.TanckMarlin L., A critical appraisal of twenty-six National Social Studies Projects. Social Education, 1970, XXXIV, 386.
35.
ShaverJ. P.RichardsH. E.Open-closed mindedness and an inquiry-oriented social studies methods course. Journal of Educational Research, 1971, 65, 85–93.
36.
SpragueNancy F.Social issues classroom discourse: a study of expository, inquiry-nonprobing, and inquiry-probing classes. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, The University of Michigan, 1970. (Dissertation Abstracts International, 31, 6480-A.)
37.
TinsleyDrew C.Cognitive objectives revealed by classroom questions in process oriented and content oriented secondary social studies programs. Paper presented at the American Educational Research Association Annual Meeting, Minneapolis, March, 1970. E.R.I.C. Research in Education, ED. 040 895.
38.
TorranceE. PaulInfluence of alternate approaches to pre-primary educational stimulation and question-asking skills. Journal of Educational Research, 1972, 65, 204–206.
39.
WhitmillR. C.A study of factors associated with pupil performance at two levels of cognition in world history. Unpublished Ed.D. dissertation, Texas Technological College, 1968. (Dissertation Abstracts, 29, 1813-A.)
