This article investigates how certain doctoral practices come to count as scandalous and with what effects on universities. To do so, it engages with a number of recent media allegations that relate to doctoral practice in Australia and elsewhere. The analysis of these allegations is developed in terms of three broad categories, namely allegations of silliness in relation to thesis content, allegations of softness in relation to entry, rigour and assessment, and allegations of suspect conduct and/or credentials. The impact of such allegations on university governance is then addressed.
BeckU. (1992). Risk society: Towards a new modernity. London: Sage.
2.
BucknellJ. (2002, December 4). DBAs dogged by uneven standards [Higher Education Supplement]. The Australian, p. 33.
3.
CarmodyJ. (2003, December 29). Trivial reprimand dulls learning's light. The Australian, p. 11.
4.
ColeM. (2001, February 3). Failed students make the grade. Courier Mail, p. 1.
5.
ConsidineM.MarginsonS.SheehanP.KummickM. (2001). The comparative performance of Australia as a knowledge nation (Report to the Chifley Research Centre). Melbourne: Monash Centre for Research in International Education.
DearingR. (1997). Higher education in the learning society: The National Committee of Inquiry into Higher Education. London: HMSO.
8.
DelamontS.AtkinsonA.ParryO. (1997). Critical mass and doctoral research: Reflections on the Harris Report. Studies in Higher Education, 22(3), 319–331.
9.
Department of Education, Training and Youth Affairs. (DETYA). (2000). Higher education report for the 2000–2002 triennium. Canberra: DETYA.
10.
Department of Education, Training and Youth Affairs. (DETYA). (2001a). Research training scheme guidelines. Canberra: DETYA.
11.
Department of Education, Training and Youth Affairs. (DETYA). (2001b). Higher education: Report for the 2001–2003 triennium. Canberra: DETYA.
12.
DevineM. (2003, July 13). Super PhD loses out to blondes and vampires. Sun-Herald, p. 15.
13.
DoddT.MartinC. (2003, November 3). Dumbing-down charge denied. Australian Financial Review, p. 33.
14.
DullroyJ. (2004, January 6). Academic stripped of doctoral title. Courier Mail, p. 3.
15.
EricsonR.V.HaggertyK.D. (1997). Policing the risk society. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
16.
GallagherM. (2000, September). The emergence of the entrepreneurial public universities in Australia. Paper presented at the IMHE General Conference of the OECD Paris, Occasional Paper Series 00/E, Commonwealth of Australia, DETYA.
17.
GiddensA. (2002). Runaway world: How globalisation is reshaping our lives. London: Profile Books.
18.
HaskinsC.H. (1963). The rise of universities. Ithaca, NY: Great Seal Books, Cornell Press.
19.
HewettJ. (2003a, September 13). Are international students getting a better deal? Australian Financial Review, p. 19.
20.
HewettJ. (2003b, October 27). Lift uni standards, economists urge. Australian Financial Review, p. 1.
21.
HoareD.StanleyG.KirkbyR.CoaldrakeP. (1995). Higher education management review: The report of the committee of inquiry. Canberra: AGPS.
22.
HobartM. (Ed.). (1993). An anthropological critique of development: The growth of ignorance. London: Routledge.
23.
IllingD. (2001, June 20). Dark side to export boom. The Australian, p. 38.
24.
KaspersonR.E.RennO.SlovicP.BrownH.S.EmelJ.GobleR.. (1998). The importance of the media and the social amplification of risk. In LofstedtR.E.FrewerL. (Eds.), Risk and modern society (pp. 149–180). London: Earthscan Publications.
25.
KempD.A. (1999). Knowledge and innovation: A policy statement on research and research training. Canberra: AGPS.
26.
KenwayJ.BullenE. (2000). Education in the age of uncertainty: An eagle's eye view. Compare, 30(3), 265–273.
27.
LawnhamP. (2001, June 6). Marking inquiry exposes glitches. The Australian, p. 23.
28.
LawsonA. (1999, April 7–13). From West to waste through dirty data. Campus Review, p. 11.
29.
LivingstoneT. (2004, January 3). Unis roll out their honours. Courier Mail, p. 1.
30.
MaidenS. (2003, October 19). ‘Silly’ degrees face the chop. Sunday Herald Sun, p. 27.
31.
MaslenG. (2003, October 25). Cappuccino courses not Nelson's cup of tea. South China Morning Post, p. 2.
32.
McWilliamE.O'BrienP. (1999). Jonathan Livingstone, I presume: Teaching as a ‘high-flying’ profession. Asia-Pacific Journal of Teacher Education, 27(2), 95–105.
33.
NoonanG.ThompsonM. (2003, December 24). Professor guilty of misconduct. Sydney Morning Herald, p. 2.
34.
ProtyniakN. (2001, May 16). Students’ free ride Unis ‘favour fee-payers’. Herald Sun, p. 29.
35.
RaeI.D. (2002). False start for the PhD in Australia. Historical Records of Australian Science, 14, 129–141.
36.
ShoreC.WrightS. (1999). Audit culture and anthropology: Neo-Liberalism in British higher education. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute, 5(4), 557–576.
37.
SmithE. (2001, June 27). Unis get poor marks for evaluation practices. The Australian, p. 31.
38.
StrathernM. (1997). ‘Improving ratings’: Audit in the British University system. European Review, 5(3), 305–321.
39.
The name's Bond, Dr Bond. (2004, March 6). ShowBiz Ireland News, p. 1.
40.
Thesis preaches gay gospel on Jesus. (2003, May 29). Hobart Mercury, p. 2.
41.
Universities must act against fraud. (2002, April 17). The Australian, p. 8.
42.
WilesK. (1966). Historical and philosophical foundations of western education. Columbus, OH: Merrill Books.
43.
WilliamsT. (2001, February 10). Universities’ testing times. Advertiser, p. 67.
44.
YeungL. (2000, November 19). Higher education row over honorary doctorate. South China Morning Post, p. 1.
