The relationship between ethnicity and rates of violent, property and other offences based on self-report and parental report data was studied for a birth cohort of Christchurch born children. The results show that on the basis of report data, children of Maori ethnicity had significantly (p<.05) higher rates of offending than children of Pakeha (European) ethnicity with these rates being from 1.45 to 2.25 times higher than for Pakeha children. However, after adjustment for a series of social and contextual factors including maternal age, maternal educational levels, family socio-economic status, family living standards and early childhood environment factors, these associations reduced so that children of Maori or Pacific Island ethnicity had risks of offending which ranged from 1.08 to 1.55 times higher than children of Pakeha ethnicity. In four of the five comparisons made there was no significant relationship between ethnicity and offending after adjustment for these social and contextual factors. The implications of these findings for the interpretation of ethnic differences in rates of offending are examined with particular attention being given to labelling, socio-economic and cultural explanations of these differences.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BathgateM (1988) Housing Needs of the Maori Community, Housing Corporation of New Zealand, Wellington.
2.
BelichJ (1986) The New Zealand Wars and the Victorian Interpretation of Racial Conflict, Auckland University Press, Auckland.
3.
BentonR (1988) “Fairness in Maori Education”, Royal Commission on Social Policy, The April Report, Vol III, pt 2. Government Press, Wellington.
4.
BradleyR HCaldwellB M (1977) “Home Observation for Measurement of the Environment: a Validation Study of Screening Efficiency”. American Journal of Mental Deficiency, vol 81, pp 417–24.
5.
BrosnanD (1982) “Ethnic Origin and Income in New Zealand”, New Zealand Population Review, vol 8, pp 58–68.
6.
DaviesP (1982) “Stratification and Class”, New Zealand Sociological Perspectives, SpoonleyPPearsonDShirleyI(eds), Dunmore Press, Palmerston North.
7.
DuncanLSW (1970) “Crime by Polynesians in Auckland — an Analysis of Charges Laid Against Persons Arrested in 1966”, M A thesis, University of Auckland.
8.
ElardoRBradleyR MCaldwellB M (1977) “A Longitudinal Study of the Relation of Infant Home Environments to Language Development at Age Three”, Child Development, vol 48, pp 595–603.
9.
ElleyW BIrvingJ C (1976) “Revised Socio-economic Index for New Zealand”. New Zealand Journal of Educational Studies, vol 11, pp 25-36.
10.
FergussonD MDonnellA ASlaterS W (1975) The Effects of Race and Socio-economic Status on Juvenile Offending Statistics, Research Report No 2Government Printer, Wellington.
11.
FergussonD MHorwoodL JLloydM (1991a) “A Latent Class Model of Child Offending” Criminal Behaviour and Mental Health, vol 1, pp 90–106.
12.
FergussonD MHorwoodL JLloydM (1991b) “Confirmatory Factor Models of Attention Deficit and Conduct Disorder”. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, vol 32, pp 257–274.
13.
FergussonD MHorwoodL JShannonF T (1981) “Birth Placement and Childhood Disadvantage”, Social Science and Medicine, vol 15, pp 315–326.
14.
FergussonD MHorwoodL JShannonF TLawtonJ M (1989) “The Christchurch Child Development Study: a Review of Epidemiological Findings”, Paediatric and Perinatal Epidemiology, vol 3, pp 278–301.
15.
FergussonD MLawtonJ MHorwoodL J (1988) “Parental Views on Educational Issues”, in possession of D M Fergusson, Christchurch.
16.
FergussonD MLloydMHorwoodL J (1991) “Family Ethnicity, Social Background and Scholastic Achievement — An Eleven Year Longitudinal Study”, New Zealand Journal of Educational Studies, vol 26, pp 49–63.
17.
FifieldJ KDonnellA A (1980) Socio-economic Status, Race, and Offending in New Zealand, Research Report No 6, Government Printer, Wellington.
18.
HamptonR (1974) “The Social Construction of Statistics: Labelling Theory Applied to the Police Decision to Prosecute Juveniles”, paper presented to the 4th National Conference of the New Zealand Sociological Association, Auckland University.
19.
HillCBrosnanD (1984) “The Occupational Distribution of the Major Ethnic Groups in New Zealand”, New Zealand Population Review, vol 10, pp 33–42.
20.
JacksonM (1987) “The Maori and the Criminal Justice System: A New Perspective: He Whaipaanga Hou”, Part 1, Department of Justice, Wellington.
21.
JacksonM (1988) “The Maori and the Criminal Justice System: A New Perspective: He Whaipaanga Hou”, Part 2, Department of Justice, Wellington.
22.
LockeE (1988) Co-operation and Conflict: Pakeha and Maori in Historical Perspective, New Zealand Foundation for Peace Studies, Auckland.
23.
LovellRNorrisM (1990) “One in four: Offending from Age Ten to Twenty-four in a Cohort of New Zealand Males”, Study of Social Adjustment Research Report No 8, Department of Social Welfare, Wellington.
24.
MoffittT ESilvaP A (1988) “Self-reported Delinquency: Results from an Instrument for New Zealand”, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology, vol 21, pp 227–240.
25.
New Zealand Council for Educational Research (1988) “How Fair is New Zealand Education?”, Royal Commission on Social Policy, The April Report, Vol III, pt 2, Government Printer, Wellington.
26.
New Zealand Department of Statistics (1986) “Justice Statistics”, Department of Statistics, Wellington.
27.
NewboldG (1992) Crime and Deviance, Oxford University Press, Auckland.
28.
NorrisMLovellR (1988) “Patterns of Juvenile Offending in New Zealand: Summary Statistics for 1981-1985”, Department of Social Welfare, Wellington.
29.
PomareE Wde BoerG M (1988) “HAUORA: Maori Standards of Health: A Study of the Years 1970–1984”, Special Report 78, Department of Health, Wellington.
30.
PrattJ (1990) ‘Crime and deviance’ in New Zealand Society: A Sociological Introduction, SpoonleyPPearsonDShirleyI(eds), Dunmore Press, Palmerston North.
31.
SpoonleyP (1990) ‘Racism and ethnicity’ in New Zealand Society: A Sociological Introduction, SpoonleyPPearsonDShirleyI, Dunmore Press, Palmerston North.
32.
SutherlandO R WHippoliteJ TSmithA MGalbreathR A (1973) “Justice and Race: a Monocultural System in a Multicultural Society”, paper presented to the New Zealand Race Relations Council Annual Conference.
33.
ThornberryT PFarnworthM (1982) “Social Correlates of Criminal Involvement: Further Evidence on the Relationship Between Social Status and Criminal Behaviour”, American Sociological Review, vol 47, pp 505–518.
34.
Van DussenK TMednickS AGabrielliW FHutchingsB (1983) “Social Class and Crime in an Adoption Cohort”, Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, vol 74, pp 249–69.
35.
WadsworthM (1979) Roots of Delinquency, Martin Robertson, London
36.
WalkerR J I (1990) Ka Whawhai Tonu Matou: Struggle Without End, Penguin, Auckland.
37.
WestD JFarringtonD P (1973) Who Becomes Delinquent?Heinemann, London.
38.
YensenHHagueKMcCreanorT (1989) Honouring the Treaty, Penguin, Auckland.
