This article describes the recidivism of 16,381 prisoners released from Western Australian Prisons between June 30 1975 and June 30 1987. Probabilities of ultimately returning to prison were estimated at 0.45, 0.76, 0.36 and 0.69 for male non-Aborigines, male Aborigines, female non-Aborigines and female Aborigines, respectively. A declining trend in recidivism over the period 1975–1980 was found to have levelled off from 1981–1985. These trends were related to important alterations in the definitions of the law, particularly to the decriminalisation of drunkenness and the introduction of mandatory prison for repeat offences of drunk driving. Recidivism also varied significantly with other demographic and institutional factors. Recidivism in this study was defined as a return to WA prisons for any offence, but varying definitions by deletion of fine defaulters made only minor differences to the estimated proportions returning.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Australian Law Reform Commission (1980) “Sentencing of Federal Offenders” 15 AGPS, Canberra.
2.
BaileyWC (1966) “Correctional Outcome: An Evaluation of 100 Reports” J of Criminal Law, Criminology and Police Science52: 153–60.
3.
BartonR RTurnbullR W (1979), “Evaluation of Recidivism Data: Use of Failure Rate Regression Models” Evaluation Quarterly3: 629–42.
4.
BerinsonJ (1987) “Reducing the Rate of Imprisonment: A Ministerial Statement”, Legislative Council, Hansard, 28October.
5.
BerksonJGageR P (1952) “Survival Curves for Cancer Patients Following Treatment” J Amer Statist Assoc47: 501–15.
6.
BlumsteinACohenJFarringtonP (1988) “Criminal Career Research: Its Value for Criminology” Criminology26: 1–36.
7.
BoagJ W (1949) “Maximum Likelihood Estimates of the Proportion of Patients Cured by Cancer Therapy” J Royal Statist. Soc Bll: 15–44.
8.
BottomsA E (1987) “Limiting Prison Use: Experience in England and Wales” J Howard League26:177–202.
9.
BroadhustR G (1987) “The Imprisonment of the Aborigine in Western Australia: 1957–85” inHazelhurstK(ed)Ivory Scales: Black Australians and the Law, Uni NSW, Sydney.
10.
BroadhurstR GMailerR AMailerM GDuffecyJ (1988) “Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal recidivism in Western Australia: A failure rate analysis” J Res Crime Deling25: 83–108.
11.
ChenW CHillB MGreenhouseJ BFayosJ V (1985) “Bayesian Analysis of Survival Curves for Cancer Patients following Treatment” inBernardoJ MDe GrootM HLindleyD VSmithA V M(eds) “Bayesian Statistics 2, North Holland, Amsterdam.
CohenS (1985) Visions of Social Control, Polity, London.
14.
Committee for the Study of Incarceration (A Von Hirsch) (1976) Doing Justice, Hill & Wang, New York.
15.
FarewellV T (1982) “The Use of Mixture Models for the Analysis of Survival Data with Long Term Survivals” Biometrics38: 1041–46.
16.
-- (1986) “Mixture Models in Survival Analysis: are they worth the risk?” Canad J Statist14: 257–62.
17.
GendreauPRossR (1987) “Revivication of Rehabilitation: Evidence from the 1980sJustice Quarterly4: 349–408.
18.
GibbonsD C (1987) “Correctional Treatment and Intervention Theory: Bringing Sociology and Criminology Back In” Int J Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology30: 255–71.
19.
GlueckSGlueckE T (1940) Juvenile Delinquents Grown Up, The Commonwealth Fund, New York.
20.
GottfredsonM R (1979) “Treatment Destruction Techniques” J Res Crime Deling16: 39–53.
21.
GottfredsonM RHirschiT (1988) “Science, Public Policy and the Career Paradigm” Criminology26:37–56.
22.
GreenbergD (1977) “The Correctional Effects of Corrections: A Survey of Evaluations” inGreenbergD, (ed)Corrections and Punishment, Sage, Beverly Hills, CA.
23.
GreenwoodP W (1987) “Trends and Developments in Corrections” Aust Crime Prevention Council J9: 16–23.
24.
HammondW J (1960) “A Comparison between the Effectiveness of Short-term Imprisonment and other Penalties in Scotland” inThe Report of the Scottish Advisory Council on the Treatment of Offenders: Use of Short Sentences of Imprisonment by the Courts, Edinburgh, HMSO.
25.
HamptonR E (1979) “Recidivism of Periodic Detainees in New Zealand” ANZJ Crim12: 31–6.
26.
HarrisC MMoitraS D (1978) “Improved Statistical Techniques for the Measurement of Recidivism” J Res Crime Delinq15: 194–213.
27.
HyltonJ (1982) “Rhetoric and Realty: A Critical Appraisal of a Community Correctional Program” Crime and Delinquency26: 341–73.
28.
JolinAGibbonsD C (1987) “Age Patterns in Criminal Involvement” Int J Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology30: 237–59.
29.
LiptonDMartinsonR MWilksJ (1975) The Effectiveness of Correctional Treatment: A survey of Treatment Evaluation Studies, Praeger, New York.
30.
MaltzM D (1984) Recidivism, Academic Press, London.
31.
MaltzM DMcClearyR (1977) “The Mathematics of Behavioural Change” Evaluation Quarterly1: 421–38.
32.
MartinsonR M (1974) What Works?Questions and Answers about Prison Reform, Public Interest, Spring, 22–54.
33.
MathewsR (1987) “Decarceration and Social Control: Fantasies and Realities” Int J Sociology of Law15: 39–60.
34.
PalmerT (1983) “The Effectiveness Issue Today: an Overview” Federal Probation46: 3–10.
35.
PhilpottsG JLancukeL B (1979) Previous Convictions, Sentences and Reconvictions, Report No 53, London, Home Office, HMSO.
36.
PrattJ (1987) “Dilemmas of the Alternative to Custody Concept: Implications for New Zealand Penal Policy in the Light of International Evidence and Experience” ANZJ Crim20: 148–62.
37.
PolkK (1987) “De-institutionalisation: A Description and Assessment” inPotasI(ed) “Sentencing in Australia”, AIC/ALRC, Seminar Proceedings No 13, Canberra, 247–66.
38.
SchmidtPWitteA D (1988) Predicting Recidivism Using Survival Models, Springer-Verlag, New York.
39.
SecherstLWhiteSBrownE (1979) The Rehabilitation of Criminal Offenders: Problems and Prospects, National Academy of Sciences, Washington DC.
40.
StollmackSHarrisC M (1974) “Failure Rate Analysis Applied to Recidivism Data” Operations Research22: 1192–1205.
41.
Van VoorhisP (1987) “Correctional Effectiveness: the high cost of ignoring success” Federal Probation51: 56–62.
42.
VodanovichI (1987) “Has Parole a Future?” in Potas I “Sentencing in Australia”, AIC/ALRC, Seminar Proceeding No 13, Canberra, 285–306.
43.
WalkerN (1985) Sentencing Theory, Law and Practice, Butterworths, London.
44.
WalkerJ (1988) “Adults under Supervision and Detention Orders” inWilsonP(ed)Trends and issues in Crime and Criminal Justice, CanberraAustralian Institute of Criminology,.
45.
Western Australian Government (1988) Working Together to Beat Crime — The Western Australian Government's Crime Prevention Plan, WAGP, Perth.
46.
WitteA DSchmidtP (1977) “An Analysis of Recidivism, using the Truncated Lognormal Distribution” Applied Statistics26: 302–11.
47.
WolfgangM E (1974) “Crime in a Birth Cohort” inHoodR(ed)Crime, Criminology and Public Policy, Free Press, New York.
48.
YeatmanA (1987) “The Concept of Public Management and the Australian State in the 1980s” Aust J Public Administration46(4).
