Infanticide is an important and historically prevalent crime. It is also a “female”
crime. The challenge for feminist criminological theory is to account for infanticide
without falling into the trap of “essentialising” the offence and its
perpetrators.
Two current broad feminist theoretical positions (the androgynous approach and the
social control perspectives) are applied to infanticide. It is argued that their
explanatory usefulness is limited since both in various ways distort the “true”
dimensions of the crime. The inability of these current perspectives to account for
infanticide raises serious questions about their general applicability for feminist
criminological theory.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdlerFSimonR J(eds) (1979) The Criminology of Deviant
Women. Houghton Mifflin Company,
Boston.
2.
AllenH (1987) “Rendering Them Harmless: The
Professional Portrayal of Women Charged with Serious Violent
Crimes” Gender, Crime and Justice
(edsCarlenPWorrallA) England: Open
University Press, 5,
81.
3.
AllenJ (1982) “Octavius Beale Reconsidered:
Infanticide, Babyfarming and Abortion in NSW 1880–1939”
inWhat Rough Beast? The State and Social Order in Australian History.
Sydney Labour History Group,Sydney, Allen &
Unwin, 5, 111.
4.
(1987)
“Policing since 1880: Some Questions of Sex”,
Policing in Australia: Historical Perspectives
(edFinnaneM) 9:189.
5.
(1988)
“‘Masculinity’ of Criminality and Criminology: Interrogating Some
Impasses” inUnderstanding Crime and Criminal Justice.
London (edsFindlayMHoggR) 1,1.
6.
BadinterE (1981) The Myth of Motherhood: An Historical
View of the Maternal Instinct.
London.
7.
BakehouseC B (1984) “Desperate Women and Compassionate
Courts: Infanticide in Nineteenth Century Canada”
34University of Toronto Law Journal, No
4:447.
8.
BalfourN P (1890) Victorian Parliamentary Papers,
Infant Life Protection Act, VGPS, Vol
63.
9.
BrownB (1986) “Women and Crime: the Dark Figures
of Criminology” 15Economy and SocietyNo 3:355.
10.
BurtonB (1986) “Bad” mothers?
Infant Killing in Victoria 1885–1914unpublished Honours thesis, University of Melbourne.
11.
CainM (1986) “Realism, Feminism, Methodolgy and
Law” 14International Journal of the Sociology of Law225.
deMause, (1974) The History of ChildhoodNew York: Psychohistory
Press.
14.
GelsthorpeLMorrisA (1988) “Feminism and Criminology in
Britain” 28British Journal of Criminology2:93.
15.
GregoryJ (1986) “Sex, Class and Crime: Towards a
Non-sexist Criminology” inConfronting Crime (edsMatthewsRYoungJ), Sage Book Publications,3:53.
16.
HeidensohnF (1987) “Women and Crime: Questions for
Criminology” Gender, Crime and Justice,
(edsCarlinPWorrallA) England: Open
University Press,
1,16.
17.
HillRF (1887) What We Saw in Australia.
London:
Macmillan.
18.
HofferP CHullN E H (1981) Murdering Mothers: Infanticide in England
and New England 1558–1803. New York:
New York University Press.
19.
HutterBWilliamsG(eds) (1981) Controlling Women.
London: Croon Helm in association
with the Oxford University Women's Studies
Committee.
20.
JonesA (1980) Women Who Kill.
New York: Fawcett
Columbine.
21.
LansdowneR (1987) “Child Killing and the Offence of
Infanticide: the Development of the Offence and its Operation in New South Wales
1976–980”, unpublished Masters of Laws Thesis, University of New
South Wales.
22.
LasterK (1985) “Frances Knorr: ‘She Killed
Babies, Didn't She?”, Double Time
(edsLake and KellyF) Ringwood:
Penguin,
18,148.
23.
MacNallyM (1982) “Domestic Servants and Infanticide in
Victoria, 1910–1914”, unpublished Honours thesis, Department of
History, La Trobe University.
24.
MullinsG L (1892) “The Registration of Still-births
and the Protection of Infants”, Inter-Colonial Medical
Congress of Australasia, Third Session,
600.
25.
NaffineN (1987) Female Crime: The Construction of Women
in Criminology. Sydney:
Allen & Unwin.
26.
NewmanA (1988) The Illustrated Treasury of Medical
Curiosa. New York:
McGraw-Hill.
27.
O'DonovanK (1984) “The Medicalisation of
Infanticide” Crim L R259.
28.
OsborneJ A (1987) “The Crime of Infanticide:
Throwing out the Baby with the Bathwater” 9Canadian Journal of Family Law47.
29.
PenwillB (1979) Looking Back Looking Forward: The Story
of “Berry Street” Child and Family Care.
Victoria:
Blackburn.
30.
RoseL (1986) The Massacre of the Innocents:
Infanticide in Britain 1800–1939. London:
Routledge & Kegan Paul.
31.
Royal Commission on Charitable
Institutions (1892–3) Victorian Parliamentary
Papers, VGPS Vol 4,
311–12.
32.
RyanW B (1862) Infanticide, its Law Prevalence,
Prevention and History. London,
27.
33.
ScuttJ (1978) “Debunking the Theory of the
Female ‘Masked Criminal’” 11Australian & New Zealand Journal of Criminology23.
34.
Davies SeaborneJ (1938) “Child-Killing in English
Law” Modern Law Review203–23,
269–87.
35.
SmartC (1976) Women, Crime and Criminology: A Feminist
Critique. Routledge & Kegan
Paul.
SussexM (1973) “The Victorian Infant Life Protection Act
1890: a Study in the Passage of Social Legislation”, unpublished
Honours thesis, Department of History, University of
Melbourne.
39.
SwainS (1985) A Refuge at Kildare: The History of the
Geelong Female Refuge and Bethany Babies Home.
Geelong:
Bethany.
40.
TealeR(ed) (1978) Colonial Eve: Sources on Women in
Australia 1788–1914. Melbourne:
Oxford University Press.
41.
ThompsonPYorkeS(eds) (1980) Lives Obscurely Great.
Sydney: Society of Women Writers
(Australian). New South Wales
Branch.
