Suspended sentences, although controversial, are used in most jurisdictions across Australia in some form, with most states and territories having introduced this sentencing option in the 1980s and 1990s. However, South Australia's legislation concerning suspended sentences is much older (having been introduced in 1969) and is also based on sentencing legislation that existed in the Victorian and Edwardian eras. This article will argue that because the legislation concerning suspended sentences in South Australia is much older (and based on even older legislation), the way that this sentencing option operates is much different from other Australian jurisdictions. Based on Victorian probation legislation, suspended sentences have a flexibility in South Australia, which has meant that other forms of alternative sentencing (such as community orders and home detention) are not used in the State.
ABS. (2011). Criminal Courts Australia 2009–10, 4513.0.
3.
ABS. (2013). Criminal Courts Australia 2011–12, 4513.0.
4.
ABS. (2014a). Criminal Courts Australia 2012–13, 4513.0.
5.
ABS. (2014b). Prisoners in Australia 2013, 4517.0.
6.
AllenJ. (1990) Sex & secrets: Crime involving Australian women since 1880, Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
7.
Australian Law Reform Commission. (1987). Sentencing: Penalties, Discussion Paper no. 3.0.
8.
BartelsL. (2007) The use of suspended sentences in Australia: Unsheathing the sword of Damocles. Criminal Law Journal31: 113–132.
9.
BartelsL. (2009a) Suspended sentences—A judicial perspective. Queensland University of Technology Law and Justice Journal9(1): 44–63.
10.
BartelsL. (2009b) The weight of the sword of Damocles: A reconviction analysis of suspended sentences in Tasmania. Australian & New Zealand Journal of Criminology42(1): 72–100.
11.
BartelsL. (2009c) ‘Sword or butter knife? A breach analysis of suspended sentences in Tasmania. Current Issues in Criminal Justice21(2): 219–241.
12.
BartelsL. (2009d) To suspend or not to suspend: A qualitative analysis of sentencing decisions in the supreme court in Tasmania. University of Tasmania Law Review28: 23–62.
13.
BartelsL. (2010) An examination of the arguments for and against the use of suspended sentences. Flinders Law Journal12(1): 119–172.
14.
Criminal Law and Penal Methods Reform Committee of South Australia (1973) First report: Sentencing and corrections, Adelaide, Australia: South Australian Government.
15.
Daunton-FearM. (1980a) Sentencing in South Australia: Emerging principles. Adelaide Law Journal7(1): 41–65.
16.
Daunton-FearM. (1980b) Sentencing in South Australia, London, UK: Law Book Co.
17.
DengateC. (1978) The use of suspended sentences in South Australia, Adelaide, Australia: Department of Correctional Services.
18.
FoucaultM. (1991) Discipline and punish: The birth of the prison, Harmondsworth, UK: Penguin.
19.
FreiburgA.MooreV. (2009) Disbelieving suspense: Suspended sentences of imprisonment and public confidence in the criminal justice system. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology42(1): 101–122.
20.
FreiburgA.RossS. (1999) Sentencing reform and penal change: The Victorian experience, Leichhardt, NSW: Federation Press.
21.
Hansard, House of Assembly, 6 October 1953, p. 894.
22.
Hansard, House of Assembly, 5 June 2013, p. 5888.
23.
Hansard, House of Assembly, 5 June 2013, p. 5889.
24.
Hansard, House of Assembly, 24 July 2013, p. 6605.
25.
Hansard, House of Commons (UK), 8 May 1907, col. 296.
26.
Hansard, Legislative Council, 6 September 1887, p. 701.
27.
Hansard, Legislative Council, 6 September 1887, p. 702.
28.
Hansard, Legislative Council, 6 September 1887, p. 696.
29.
Hansard, Legislative Council, 9 September 1913, p. 201.
30.
Hansard, Legislative Council, 23 October 1969, p. 2449.
31.
Hansard, Legislative Council, 4 November 1969, p. 2653.
32.
Hansard, Legislative Council, 5 November 1969, p. 2732.
33.
Hansard, Legislative Council, 9 February 1988, p. 2556.
34.
Hansard, Legislative Council, 10 February, 1988, p. 2627.
35.
HodgeD. (2014) Don Dunstan: Intimacy & liberty – A political biography, Adelaide, Australia: Wakefield Press.
36.
MackenzieG. (2002) An enduring influence: Sir Samuel Griffith and his contribution to criminal justice in Queensland. Queensland University of Technology Law and Justice Journal2(1): 53–63.
37.
LulhamR. (2009) The recidivism of offenders given suspended sentences: A comparison with full-time imprisonment. Crime and Justice Bulletin.136.
38.
McDonnellM.FarrellJ. (2012) Tough, tougher, toughest? A new government's approach to sentencing laws in Victoria. Alternative Law Journal37(3): 238–243.
39.
PoyntonS. (2014) Good behaviour bonds and re-offending: The effect of bond length. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology47(1): 25–43.
Rinaldi, F. (1976). Essays in Australian Penology, Penology Monograph no. 7, ANU Law School.
42.
SarreR. (1999) Destructuring and criminal justice reforms: Rescuing diversionary ideas from the waste-paper basket. Current Issues in Criminal Justice10(3): 259–272.
43.
SwainS. (2010) Birth and death in a New Land: Attitudes to infant death in Colonial Australia. History of the Family15(1): 25–33.
44.
TulettJ. (1991) The changing role of probation in South Australia. In: StrangH.Gerull SS. (eds) Keeping people out of prisons, Canberra, Australia: AIC, pp. 119–132.
45.
VanstoneM. (2008) The international origins and initial development of probation: An early example of policy transfer. British Journal of Criminology48(6): 735–755.
Warner, K. (2002) Sentencing Laws in Tasmania Leichhardt. NSW: Federation Press.
48.
WarnerK.SpiranovicC. (2014) Jurors' views of suspended sentences. Australian & New Zealand Journal of Criminology47(1): 141–159.
49.
WeatherburnD.BartelsL. (2008) The recidivism of offenders given suspended sentences in New South Wales, Australia. British Journal of Criminology48(5): 667–683.
50.
WhiteS. (1983) The pitfalls of imitation: The New South Wales first offenders probation act of 1894. Victoria University of Wellington Law Review13: 137–149.
51.
WhitelockD. (2000) Adelaide: Sense of difference, Melbourne, Australia: Australian Scholarly Publishing.
