Populism and criminal justice policy: An Australian case study of non-punitive responses to alcohol-related violence

Abstract

Populism is widely regarded in the literature as a negative and inherently punitive influence on criminal justice policy. This article challenges this view and highlights the ways in which populism can produce forms of citizen engagement in the criminal justice context that are new and progressive. These possibilities are illustrated through a close analysis of the responses to a single instance of ‘random’ fatal violence: the killing of Thomas Kelly in King’s Cross, Sydney, in 2012. This case study shows how a populist campaign powerfully realigned political allegiances to call for, and achieve, real and enduring action from the New South Wales Government in addressing alcohol-related violence.

Keywords

Alcohol crime populism reform violence

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Allen

Hough

(2008) Does it matter? Reflections on the effectiveness of institutionalised public participation in the development of sentencing policy. In: Freiberg

Gelb

(eds) Penal populism, sentencing councils and sentencing policy, Annandale, NSW: Hawkins, pp. 224–239.

Alexander, C. (2013). The party’s over: Which clubs have the most members? Retrieved from Crikey: http://www.crikey.com.au/2013/07/18/the-partys-over-which-clubs-have-the-most-members/?wpmp_switcher=mobile.

Arditi

(2007) Politics on the edges of liberalism: Difference, populism, revolution, agitation, Edinburgh, Scotland: Edinburgh University Press.

Blair, N. (2012). New South Wales Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Council, 15 August 2012, p. 13705.

Bottoms

(1995) The philosophy and politics of punishment and sentencing. In: Clarkson

Morgan

(eds) The politics of sentencing reform, Oxford, England: Clarendon, pp. 17–50.

Brookes, G. (2012). New South Wales Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Assembly, 24 October 2012, p. 16368.

Brown

(2013) Criminalisation and normative theory. Current Issues in Criminal Justice 25(2): 605–625.

Burgess, M., & Moffatt, S. (2011). The association between alcohol outlet density and assaults on and around licensed premises. Crime and Justice Bulletin, No 147.

Burke

(2010) One punch can start moral panic: An analysis of news items about fatal assaults in Queensland between 23 September 2006 and 28 February 2009. Queensland University of Technology LJJ 10(87–105.

10.

Callinan, I. A. C. (2013, July). Review of the parole system in Victoria. Department of Justice, Victoria: Melbourne.

11.

Canovan

(1981) Populism, London, England: Junction Books.

12.

Canovan

(1999) Trust the people! Populism and the two faces of democracy. Political Studies, XLVII. 2–16.

13.

Canovan

(2005) The people, Cambridge, England: Polity.

14.

Chambers, G. & Klein, N. (2011). Crackdown on weapon of cowards. The Daily Telegraph (Sydney), 12 August 2011, p. 18.

15.

Christie

(1986) The ideal victim. In: Fattah

(ed) From crime policy to victim policy, Basingstoke, England: Macmillan, pp. 17–30.

16.

Clark, A. (2012). Battle for the soul of Sydney. The Australian Financial Review, 21 July 2012, p. 48.

17.

Coalition of Concerned Emergency Services Workers. (2010). Last drinks: A coalition of concerned emergency services workers. Retrieved from Keep Our Cops: http://www.keepourcops.org.au/Media/Police_alcohol_report_mar2010.pdf.

18.

Cullen

Fisher

Applegate

(2000) Public opinion about punishment and corrections. Crime and Justice 27: 1–79.

19.

Davies, L. (2012). Curb on Trading Key to Cutting Violence – Expert. The Sydney Morning Herald (Sydney), 19 July 2012, p. 1.

20.

Davies, L. (2013). Slain teen’s family slam hoteliers’ probe. The Sydney Morning Herald (Sydney), 25 August 2013. Accessible at http://www.smh.com.au/nsw/slain-teens-family-slam-hoteliers-probe-20130824-2siei.html.

21.

Donnelly, N., Poynton, S., Weatherburn, D., Bamford, E., & Nottage, J. (2006). Liquor outlet concentrations and alcohol-related neighbourhood problems. Alcohol Studies Bulletin, No. 8.

22.

Dzur

(2010) The myth of penal populism: Democracy, citizen participation, and American Hyperincarceration. The Journal of Speculative Philosophy 24: 354–379.

23.

Dzur

(2012) Punishment, participatory democracy, and the jury, New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

24.

Editorial: Enough is enough with Kings Cross lawlessness. (2012). The Sydney Morning Herald (Sydney), 12 July 2012, p. 12.

25.

Fife-Yeomans, J. & Budd, H. (2012). Fighting against the meth monsters. The Daily Telegraph (Sydney), 12 July 2012, p. 4.

26.

Fitzgerald, J., Mason, A., & Borzycki, C. (2010). The nature of assaults recorded on licensed premises. Crime and Justice Statistics, No 43. NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research (Sydney).

27.

Fleming, J. (2008). Rules of engagement: Policing anti-social behaviour and alcohol-related violence in and around licensed premises. NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research (Sydney).

28.

Foundation for Alcohol Research & Education. (2012a). Foundation for alcohol research and education 10 point plan to reduce alcohol harms in NSW. Deakin ACT.

29.

Foundation for Alcohol Research & Education. (2012b). NSW has thirst for reforms, Media Release, 30 August 2012.

30.

Freiberg

(2001) Affective versus effective justice: Instrumentalism and emotionalism in criminal justice. Punishment and Society 3: 265–278.

31.

Freiberg

(2008) The victorian sentencing advisory council: Incorporating community views in the sentencing process. In: Freiberg

Gelb

(eds) Penal populism, sentencing councils and sentencing policy, Annandale, NSW: Hawkins Press, pp. 148–164.

32.

Freiberg

Gelb

(2008) Penal populism, sentencing councils and sentencing policy, Annandale, NSW: Hawkins Press.

33.

Gallacher, M. (2013). New South Wales Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Assembly, 19 March 2013, p. 18741.

34.

Garland

(2000) The culture of high crime societies: Some preconditions of recent “Law and Order” policies. British Journal of Criminology 40: 347–375.

35.

Garland

(2001) The culture of control, Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.

36.

Goh, D., & Moffatt, S. (2011). New South Wales recorded crime statistics 2011. NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research (Sydney).

37.

Goh, D., & Moffatt, S. (2012). New South Wales recorded crime statistics 2011. NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research (Sydney).

38.

Goh, D., & Moffatt, S. (2013). New South Wales recorded crime statistics 2011. NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research (Sydney).

39.

Gross

Moore

Threadgold

(2007) Broadcast news coverage of asylum April to October 2006: Caught between human rights and public safety, Cardiff, Wales: Cardiff School of Journalism, Media and Cultural Studies, Cardiff University.

40.

Hansen, J. (2011). Call for pub lockouts. Sunday Telegraph (Sydney), 20 November 2011, p. 25.

41.

Hogg

(2013) Punishment and “the People”: Rescuing populism form its critics. In: Carrington

Ball

O’Brien

(eds) Crime, justice and social democracy: International perspectives, Hampshire, England: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 105–119.

42.

Hogg

Brown

(1998) Rethinking law and order, Sydney, NSW: Pluto Press.

43.

Howden, S. (2011). Kings of the Cross take matters into own hands. The Sydney Morning Herald (Sydney), 1 August 2011, p. 1.

44.

Hutton

(2005) Beyond populist punitiveness? Punishment & Society 7: 243–258.

45.

Hutton

(2008) Institutional mechanisms for incorporating the public. In: Freiberg

Gelb

(eds) Penal populism, sentencing councils and sentencing policy, Annandale, NSW: Hawkins Press, pp. 205–223.

46.

Issa, T. (2013). New South Wales Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Assembly, 28 February 2013, p. 18293.

47.

Kazin

(1998) The populist persuasion – An American history, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

48.

Koziol, M. (2013). Solidarity forever: As fare the unions, so goes the ALP. Retrieved from PolitiFact Australia: http://www.politifact.com.au/truth-o-meter/article/2013/sep/30/fare-unions-so-goes-alp/.

49.

Lacey

(2008) The prisoners’ dilemma: Political economy and punishment in contemporary democracies, New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.

50.

Laclau

(2007) On populist reason, London, England: Verso.

51.

Loader

(2006) Fall of the “Platonic Guardians”: Liberalism, criminology and politics responses to crime in England and Wales. British Journal of Criminology 46: 561–586.

52.

Loughnan

(2009) The legislation we had to have? The Crimes (Criminal Organisations Control) Act (NSW). Current Issues in Criminal Justice 20: 457–465.

53.

Lynch, P. (2011). New South Wales Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Assembly, 19 October 2011, p. 6711.

54.

Matthews

(2005) The myth of punitiveness. Theoretical Criminology 9(2): 175–201.

55.

MacDonald, S. (2013). New South Wales Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Council, 12 September 2013, p. 23367.

56.

McIlveen, L. (2012, July 26). Real heroes walk away: Join the fight against violence. Retrieved from news.com.au http://www.news.com.au/features/heroes-walk-away/heroes-walkaway-choose-how-your-night-ends/story-fneygm3n-1226434774642.

57.

Moore, C. (2011). New South Wales Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Assembly, 18 October 2011, p. 6711.

58.

Moore, C. (2012). Safer Sydney Forum. News, 17 August 2012. Accessible at http://www.clovermoore.com.au/safer-sydney-forum/.

59.

Moore, M. (2012). Streets get tough, laws get tougher. The Sydney Morning Herald (Sydney), 21 July 2012, p. 11.

60.

Murphy, D. & Moore, M. (2012). Chilling allure of city’s underbelly. The Sydney Morning Herald (Sydney), 14 July 2012, p. 1.

61.

Newburn

(2007) “Tough on Crime”: Penal policy in England and Wales. Crime and Justice 36: 425–470.

62.

Nicholls, S. (2011). Police to target violence hot-spots. The Sydney Morning Herald (Sydney), 2 September 2011, p. 1.

63.

Nicholls, S. (2012a). Alcohol abuse is not the only problem facing Kings Cross. The Canberra Times (Canberra), 17 July 2012, p. 2.

64.

Nicholls, S. (2012b). Cross tragedy brings drinking controls closer. The Sydney Morning Herald (Sydney), 14 July 2012, p. 15.

65.

NSW Government. (2012). NSW government response to issues in Kings Cross. Retrieved from http://www.nsw.gov.au/sites/default/files/uploads/common/Government-Response-Kings-Cross-Issues.pdf.

66.

NSW Office of Liquor, Gaming & Racing. (2013). Liquor Promotion Guidelines, NSW Office of Liquor, Gaming & Racing, Sydney, July 2013.

67.

Olding, R. (2012). It’s cheers all round for the bar tsars who think small. The Sydney Morning Herald (Sydney), 9 April 2012, p. 5.

68.

O’Connor, B. (2012). Cool heads needed to curb a bloody crisis. Herald Sun (Sydney), 22 August 2012, p. 15.

69.

O'Farrell, B. (2012a). New South Wales Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Assembly, 15 August 2012, p. 13824.

70.

O’Farrell, B. (2012b). New South Wales Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Assembly, 16 August 2012, p. 13970.

71.

O'Farrell, B. (2012c). New South Wales Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Assembly, 18 September 2012, p. 15301.

72.

O'Farrell, B. (2012d). Cleaning up the Cross. Police Transport, ID Scanners and Drugs Dogs, Media Release, 18 September 2012.

73.

O’Farrell, B. (2012e). New South Wales Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Assembly, 15 November 2012, p. 16979.

74.

Payne, J., & Gaffney, A. (2012). How much crime is drug or alcohol related? Self-reported attributions of police detainees. Trends & issues in crime and criminal justice, No 439. Australian Institute of Criminology, Canberra.

75.

Pilgrim, J., Gerostamoulos, D., & Drummer, O. (2014). “King hit” fatalities in Australia, 2000-2012: The role of alcohol and other drugs. Drug and Alcohol Dependence, 135, 119–132 Retrieved from http://ac.els-cdn.com/S0376871613004985/dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.drugalcdep.2013.11.019.

76.

Pratt

(2007) Penal populism, London, England: Routledge.

77.

Pratt

(2008) Penal scandal in New Zealand. In: Freiberg

Gelb

(eds) Penal populism, sentencing councils and sentencing policy, Annandale, NSW: Hawkins Press, pp. 31–44.

78.

Pratt

Eriksson

(2013) Contrasts in punishment: An explanation of Anglophone excess and Nordic exceptionalism, London, England: Routledge.

79.

Queensland Government, Department of Premier & Cabinet. (2013). Drink safe precincts: Evaluation update: 18 months of the trial, May 2013. Queensland Government, Brisbane.

80.

Quilter, J. (2013). Responses to the death of Thomas Kelly: taking populism seriously. Current Issues in Criminal Justice, 24(3), 439–448.

81.

Quilter, J. (2014a). The Thomas Kelly case: Why a “one punch” law is not the answer. Criminal Law Journal, 38(1), 16–37.

82.

Quilter, J. (2014b). One-punch laws, mandatory minimums and “alcohol-fuelled” as an aggravating factor: Implications for NSW criminal law. International Journal for Crime, Justice and Social Democracy, 3(1), 81–106.

83.

Ralston, N. & McKenny, L. (2012). Top cop's grim warning for Kings Cross. The Sydney Morning Herald (Sydney), 13 July 2012, p. 1.

84.

Roberts

(2008) Sentencing policy and practice: The evolving role of public opinion. In: Freiberg

Gelb

(eds) Penal populism, sentencing councils and sentencing policy, Annandale, NSW: Hawkins Press, pp. 15–30.

85.

Roberts, J. & Stalans, L. (1997). Public Opinion, Crime, and Criminal Justice. Boulder, Colorado: Westview Press.

86.

Roberts, J., & Hough, M. (2002). Changing attitudes to punishment: Public opinion, crime and justice. Willan: Cullompton.

87.

Roberts

Stalans

Indermaur

Hough

(2003) Penal populism and public opinion – Lessons from five countries, Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.

88.

Searle, A. (2011). New South Wales Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Council, 4 August 2011, p. 3606.

89.

Shakeshaft, A. (2012). We all need to act on drinking problem. The Sydney Morning Herald (Sydney), 17 July 2012, p. 9.

90.

Shakeshaft, A., Love, S., & Wood, E. (2011). Alcohol-related crime in city of Sydney local government area (National Drug & Alcohol Research Centre, UNSW Monograph No. 63). National Drug and Alcohol Research Centre, University of New South Wales, Sydney.

91.

Silmalis, L. (2012). New drinking limits put on bottle shops. Sunday Telegraph (Sydney) 8 April 2012, p. 30.

92.

Snowball, L., & Spratley, S. (2013). Is the decrease in assaults at licensed premises being driven by changes in staff reporting rates? Crime and Justice Statistics, No 87. NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research (Sydney).

93.

Souris, G. (2011). New South Wales Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Assembly, 23 November 2011, p. 7737.

94.

Souris, G. (2012a). OLGR Audits Kings Cross Licensed Venues, Media Release, 18 July 2012.

95.

Souris, G. (2012b). Audit of Kings Cross Licensed Venues Progresses Well, Media Release, 20 July 2012.

96.

Souris, G. (2012c). Govt Campaign to Fight Alcohol Abuse, Media Release, 15 August 2012.

97.

Souris, G. (2012d). New South Wales Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Assembly, 15 August 2012, p. 13826.

98.

Souris, G. (2012e). New Small Bar Law Will Promote Diversity, Media Release, 19 September 2012.

99.

Souris, G. (2012f). New South Wales Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Assembly, 24 October 2012, p. 16401.

100.

Souris, G. (2013a). Online Alcohol Education For Senior Students, Media Release, 14 February 2013.

101.

Souris, G. (2013b). New South Wales Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Assembly, 18 February 2012, p. 18293.

102.

Stoker

(2006) Why politics matters: Making democracy work, London, England: Palgrave.

103.

Taggart

(2000) Populism, Buckingham, England: Open University Press.

104.

Taylor, S. (Letters) (2012). The Newcastle Herald (Newcastle), 23 July 2012, p. 12.

105.

Tovey, J. (2012a). Action on Kings Cross. The Sydney Morning Herald (Sydney), 18 July 2012, p. 1.

106.

Tovey, J. (2012b). Audit of all licensed premises Top-level management plan. The Sydney Morning Herald (Sydney), 18 July 2012, p. 1.

107.

Upton, G. (2012). New South Wales Parliamentary Debates, Legislative Assembly, 18 September 2012, p. 15310.

108.

Urbis JHD. (2006). Kings Cross Licensed Premises Research. Prepared for the City of Sydney by Urbis JHD. Sydney City Council, Sydney.

109.

Weber, S. (2012). Time to call time on boozy violence. The Daily Telegraph (Sydney), 12 July 2012, p. 24.

110.

When innocence meets primal savagery. (2012, 15 July). Herald Sun (Sydney), p. 72.