This paper discusses Australian controversies over defences and excuses to homicide that serve partly to normalise violence in fatal conflicts between men. The ‘homosexual advance defence’ (HAD), describes a specific use of the provocation plea to seek a reduction of murder charges to a finding of manslaughter in cases of alleged male on male sexual advance. Successful uses of HAD to support claims of provocation have reflected legal acceptance of the alleged affront to masculine honour that such an advance can comprise. Likewise, the excuse of ‘accident’ has become a matter of growing debate when used to counter homicide charges arising from petty disputes or unprovoked assaults between men. The ineffective outcome of debate and the extent of this violence mirrors official resignation about this phenomenon and casts doubt on the progression of ‘civilising’ trends against social brutality. Anti-violence activists and reformers have mobilised against the use of HAD and the excuse of accident with mixed success. Reform of provocation law to abolish HAD is still incomplete, and the accident excuse continues to impact on cases involving alcohol-related violence among men. Anti-homosexual attacks and other fatal male on male conflicts have been viewed as unrelated forms of crime, yet there is a symmetry between HAD-related and ‘accidental’ killings that arise in social scenarios where sudden rage in reply to insults to male honour is a common social expectation.
ABC News (2008) Man cleared of one punch manslaughter charge. ABC online. 27 March 2008.
2.
ArcherJ (1994) Violence between me? In: ArcherJ (eds) Male Violence. London: Routledge.
3.
Berman A (2011) A gay advance is no excuse for murder. Brisbane Times 27 April 2011.
4.
CampbellA (1986) The streets and violenc? In: CampbellAGibbsJ (eds) Violent Transactions. Oxford: Blackwell.
5.
Carpenter A and McGinty J (2008) Campaign promotes tough new ‘one punch’ laws. Ministerial Media Statement. 3 August 2011.
6.
ComstockG (1992) Dismantling the homosexual panic defenc?Law and Sexuality: A Review of Gay and Lesbian Legal Issues2: 81–102.
7.
ConnellRW (1995) Masculinities. St. Leonards, NSW: Allen and Unwin.
8.
CossG (1998) Revisiting lethal violence by me?Criminal Law Journal22: 5–9.
9.
CossG (2008) Politics of reactio?Criminal Law Journal32: 329–342.
10.
DaltonD (2006) The haunting of gay subjectivity: the cases of Oscar Wilde and John Marsde?Law Text Culture10: 72–100.
11.
De PasqualeS (2002) Provocation and the homosexual advance defence: The deployment of culture as a defence strateg?Melbourne University Law Review26: 110–143.
12.
DeardonJJonesW (2008) Homicide in Australia: 2006–07 National Homicide Monitoring Program Annual Report, No 1. Canberra: Australian Institute of Criminology.
13.
DeardonJPayneJ (2009) Alcohol and Homicide in Australia Trends and Issues. No. 372. Canberra: Australian Institute of Criminology.
14.
Department of Department of Justice and Attorney-General (2007) Discussion Paper, Audit on Defences to Homicide: Accident and Provocation. Brisbane.
15.
DresslerJ (1995) When ‘heterosexual’ men kill ‘homosexual’ men: reflection on provocation law, sexual advances, and the ‘reasonable man’ standar?The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology85(3): 726–63.
16.
Fitz-GibbonKPickeringS (2012) Homicide law reform in Victoria, Australi?The British Journal of Criminology52: 159–180.
17.
FoucaultM (1978) The History of Sexuality: An Introduction vol 1. New York: Vintage.
18.
FreeMHughsonJ (2003) Settling accounts with hooligans: Gender blindness in football supporter subculture researc?Men and Masculinities6(2): 136–55.
19.
Golder, B (2004) The homosexual advance defence and the law/body nexus: Towards a poetics of law reform. Murdoch University Electronic Journal of Law 8.
20.
GrahamKHomelR (2009) Raising the Bar. Devon: Willan Publishing.
21.
Green v The Queen (1997) 148 ALR 659 (High Court).
22.
HobbsDWinlowSHadfieldPListerS (2005) Violent hypocrisy: governance and the night-time econom?European Journal of Criminology2(2): 161–183.
23.
HonnethA (2001) Recognition or redistribution? Changing perspectives on the moral order of societ?Theory, Culture and Society18(2–3): 43–55.
24.
HorderJ (1992) Provocation and Responsibility. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
25.
HoweA (2001) Homosexual advances in law: murderous excuse, pluralized ignorance and the privilege of unknowin? In: StychinCHermanD (eds) Law and Sexuality. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
26.
JasperJ (1997) The Art of Moral Protest. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
27.
JennessVGrattetR (2001) Making Hate a Crime. New York: Russell Sage.
28.
Law Reform Commission of Western Australia (2007) Review of the Law of Homicide: Final Report.
29.
LeeC (2003) Murder and the Reasonable Man: Passion and Fear in the Courtroom. New York: New York University Press.
30.
Lucas P (2012) State Government to change ‘gay panic’ defence, Ministerial Media Statement. 25 January 2012.
31.
LunnyA (2003) Provocation and ‘homosexual’ advance: Masculinized subjects as threat, masculinized subjects under threa?Social and Legal Studies12(3): 311–333.
32.
McArdle M (2007) Queensland Parliamentary Debates, 9 August 2007 p.2465.
33.
McArdle M (2008) Queensland Parliamentary Debates, 13 February 2008 p.198.
34.
MesserschmidtJTomsenS (2011) Masculinitie? In: DeKeseredyWDragiewiczM (eds) The Handbook of Critical Criminology. London/New York: Routledge.
35.
MoranL (1995) Violence and the law: the case of sado-masochis?Social and Legal Studies4(2): 225–251.
36.
MorganJ (1997) Dead women tell no tales: Tales are told about the?Melbourne University Law Review21: 237–237.
37.
MullinsC (2006) Holding Your Square: Masculinities, Streetlife and Violence. Cullompton, UK: Willan.
38.
New South Wales Attorney-General’s Department (1998) Final Report of the ‘Homosexual Advance Defence’ Working Party. Sydney.
39.
PolkK (1994) When Men Kill: Scenarios of Masculine Violence. Melbourne: Cambridge University Press.
40.
R v CR [2008] NSWSC 1208.
41.
R v Green (Unreported, Supreme Court of NSW, Abadee J, 7 June 1994).
42.
R v Green (Unreported, Supreme Court of NSW, Court of Criminal Appeal, Priestley JA, Smart and Ireland JJ, 8 November 1995).
SpierenburgP (2008) A History of Murder: Personal Violence in Europe From the Middle Ages to the Present. Cambridge: Polity Press.
46.
Shine K (2007) Queensland Parliamentary Debates. 14 November 2007 p.4311.
47.
StychinC (1995) Law’s Desire: Sexuality and the Limits of Justice. London: Routledge.
48.
Sydney Morning Herald (2011) Sydney protest tonight over Kings Cross bouncers. Sydney Morning Herald. 24 January 2011.
49.
TomsenS (1990) The causes of public violence: Situational and other factors in drinking-related assault? In: ChappellD (eds) Australian Violence: Contemporary Perspectives. Canberra: Australian Institute of Criminology.
50.
TomsenS (2002) Hatred, Murder and Male Honour: Anti-Homosexual Killings in New South Wales 1980–2000. Canberra: Australian Institute of Criminology.
51.
TomsenS (2005) ‘Boozers and bouncers’: masculine conflict, disengagement and the contemporary governance of drinking-related violence and disorde?The Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology38(2): 283–97.
52.
TomsenS (2006) Homophobic violence, cultural essentialism and shifting sexual identitie?Social and Legal Studies15(3): 389–407.
53.
TomsenS (2009) Violence, Sexuality and Prejudice. New York/London: Routledge Press.
54.
TysonD (2011) Victoria’s new homicide laws: Provocative reforms or more stories of women ‘asking for it’?Current Issues in Criminal Justice23(2): 203–233.
55.
Victorian Law Reform Commission (2005) Defences to Homicide: Final Report. Melbourne.
