Drawing on data collected in five private sector and two public sector prisons, this article highlights the complex relationship between prison staff culture and prisoner quality of life. Specifically, it explores the link between the attitudes of prison staff and their behaviour, particularly in terms of their use of authority, and seeks to explain the somewhat paradoxical finding that those prisons rated most positively by prisoners were those in which staff were least positive about their own working lives and most negative in their views of prisoners. The article highlights the importance of experience and competence, as well as attitudes, in determining how authority is exercised and experienced in prison. It also draws attention to the different kinds of staff cultures that exist both between and within the public and private sectors.
ArnoldH (2008) The experience of prison officer training. In: BennettJCreweBWahidinA (eds) Understanding Prison StaffCullompton: Willan, 399–418.
2.
Ben-DavidS (1992) Staff-to-inmates relations in a total institution: A model of five modes of association. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology36(3): 209–219.
3.
BottomsA (2009) Desistance and diachronic self-control. Paper presented at the Cambridge Institute of Criminology 50th Anniversary Conference, Sept 2009Cambridge, UK.
4.
Cooper C and Taylor P (2004) KPIs and lies – go directly to Kilmarnock Jail. Presentation at the Fourth Asia Pacific Interdisciplinary Research in Accounting Conference, 4–6 July, Singapore.
5.
CooperCTaylorP (2005) Independently verified reductionism: Prison privatisation in Scotland. Human Relations58(4): 497–522.
6.
CrawleyE (2004) Doing Prison Work: The Public and Private Lives of Prison OfficersCullompton: Willan.
7.
Crewe B, Liebling A, Hulley S and McLean C (under review) Prisoner quality of life in public and private prisons.
8.
CrouchBMarquantJW (1980) On becoming a prison guard. In: CrouchB (ed.) The Keepers: Prison Guards and Contemporary CorrectionsSpringfield, IL: Charles C Thomas, 63–106.
9.
GiddensA (1992) The Transformation of Intimacy: Sexuality, Love and Eroticism in Modern SocietiesCambridge: Polity.
10.
GilbertM (1997) The illusion of structure: A critique of the classical model of organization and the discretionary power of correctional officers. Criminal Justice Review22(1): 49–64.
11.
HardingR (2001) Private prisons. Crime and Justice28: 265–346.
12.
HatryHBrounsteinPLevinsonR (1993) Comparisons of privately and publicly operated corrections facilities in Kentucky and Massachusetts. In: BowmanGHakimSSeidenstatP (eds) Privatizing correctional institutionsNew Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers, 193–212.
13.
HMIP. (2002) Report on a full announced inspection of HMP & YOI Ashfield, 1 – 5 July 2002.
14.
HMIP. (2005) Report on an unannounced inspection of HMP Rye Hill, 11 – 15 April 2005.
15.
HMIP. (2007a) Report on a full unannounced inspection of HMP Rye Hill, 11–15 June 2007.
16.
HMIP. (2007b) Report on an announced inspection of HMP/YOI Peterborough (Men), 9–13 October 2006.
17.
HMIP. (2009) Report on an unannounced full follow-up inspection of HMP & YOI Parc, 7–11 July 2008.
18.
HMIP. (2010) Report on an announced inspection of HMP Wolds, 7–11 December 2009.
Home Affairs Committee (1997) Second Report: The Management of the Prison Service (Public and Private): Volume I Report together with the Proceedings of the CommitteeLondon: Stationery Office.
21.
Hulley S, Liebling A and Crewe B (under review) Re-thinking respect in prison: Results from a study of public and private sector prisons.
22.
JamesABottomleyKLieblingAClareE (1997) Privatizing Prisons: Rhetoric and RealityLondon: Sage.
23.
LieblingA (2007a) Why prison staff culture matters. In: ByrneJTaxmanFHummerD (eds) The Culture of Prison ViolenceBoston, MA: Allyn and Bacon, 105–122.
24.
LieblingA (2007b) A Report on the Outcomes of the Acacia Prison Annual Performance ReviewPerth: Western Australian Correction Services.
25.
Liebling A (in press) Distinctions and distinctiveness in the work of prison officers: Legitimacy and authority revisited. European Journal of Criminology.
26.
LieblingAassisted byArnoldH (2004) Prisons and their Moral Performance: A study of Values, Quality, and Prison LifeOxford University Press, Oxford.
27.
LieblingAHulleySCreweB (in press) Conceptualising and Measuring the Quality of Prison Life. In: GaddDKarstedtSMessnerS (eds) The Sage Handbook of Criminological Research MethodsLondon: Sage Publishing.
28.
LieblingATaitSDurieLStilesAHarveyJassisted by RoseG (2005) An Evaluation of the Safer Locals Programme, Final ReportCambridge: Cambridge Institute of Criminology, Prisons Research Centre.
29.
LoganCH (1992) Well-kept: Comparing quality of confinement in private and public prisons. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology83(3): 577–613.
30.
LombardoLGroup dynamics and the prison guard subculture: Is the subculture an impediment to helping inmates?International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology (1985) 29(1): 79–90.
31.
McLeanCLieblingA (2008) Prison staff in the public and private sector. In: BennettJCreweBWahidinA (eds) Understanding Prison StaffCullompton: Willan, 92–114.
32.
MoyleP (1994) Private Prisons and Police: Recent Australian TrendsAustralia: Pluto Press.
33.
MoyleP (1995) Private prison research in Queensland, Australia: A case study of Borallon Correctional Centre 1991. British Journal of Criminology35(1): 34–62.
34.
NAO (2003) The Operational Performance of PFI Prisons Report by the Comptroller and Auditor GeneralLondon: The Stationery Office, HC Session 2002–3: 18 June 2003.
35.
NewboldG (2007) The Problem of Prisons: Corrections Reform in New Zealand since 1840Wellington: Dunmore.
36.
RynneJHardingRWortleyR (2008) Market testing and prison riots: How public-sector commercialization contributed to a prison riot. Criminology and Public Policy7(1): 117–142.
37.
SennettR (1981) AuthorityNew York: Vintage.
38.
SheferGLieblingAPrison privatization: In search of a business-like atmosphere?Criminology and Criminal Justice (2008) 8(3): 261–278.
39.
SparksRBottomsAEHayW (1996) Prisons and the Problem of OrderOxford: Oxford University Press.
40.
StroudSTappouletC (2003) Weakness of Will and Practical IrrationalityOxford: Clarendon Press.
41.
Tait S, Gadd V, Shefer G, McLean C and Liebling A (in progress) Measuring prison staff quality of life: Implications for research on prison culture.
42.
Taylor P and Cooper C (2008) ‘It was absolute hell’: Inside the private prison. Capital and Class 96 (Autumn): 3–30.
43.
TerrillWPaolineEAIIIManningP (2003) Police culture and coercion. Criminology41(4): 1003–1034.
44.
TylerT (1998) Why People Obey The LawNew Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
45.
WachtelTMcColdP (2001) Restorative justice in everyday life. In: StrangHBraithwaiteJ (eds) Restorative Justice and Civil SocietyCambridge: Cambridge University Press, 114–129.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
