This article is a first attempt to investigate into and report on the People's Republic of China police law reform effort — objectives, process and result — since 1978. In so doing, the article catalogues the past, describes the present, and speculates on the future. It argues that police law reform in China is a reaction to a growing police legitimacy crisis attenuating the relationship between police and the public.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ChenS.T. (1995). Qiantan dangqian gongan jingli xianzhuang yu duice (A brief discussion of current state of public security manpower and response). In TianJ.C. (Ed.), Lun gongan duiwu jianshe (Discussion on public security troop building) Guangdong, China: Guangdong renmin chubanshe.
2.
ChengH. (1996). Shehui zhuanxing shiqi de jingcha zhifa quanwei (Police law enforcement authority during social transformation).Gongan daxue xuebao (Journal of Chinese People's Public Security University), 59, 52–3.
3.
ChenJ.S. (2001). On the authority of police enforcement.Gongan Yanjiu (Public Security Studies), 76, 66–70.
China to intensify supervision over customs. (2000, April 26). People's Daily, online version. Retrieved January 1, 2004, from web site.
6.
China to regulate grass roots legal service sector. (2000, April 27). People's Daily, online version. Retrieved January 1, 2004, from web site.
7.
Chinese people have enhanced legal awareness, NPC & CPCC sessions. (2001, March 14). People's Daily, online version. Retrieved January 1, 2004, from web site.
8.
Chinese Police Studies Association. (1996). Zhongguo teshe gongan zhi yanjiu (Research into public security with distinctive Chinese characteristics).Beijing, China: Qunzhong chubanshe.
9.
Clearing of extended detention, remove the obstacle to judicial justice (2003, October 30). Retrieved October 30, 2003, from http://www.legaldaily.com
10.
Coastal city protects media rights. (2000, July 30). Renmin Gongan Boo (RMGAB; People's Public Security Post), Internet version available at http://www.cpd.com.cn
11.
Congyan zhijing, bixu congyan zhichang (Strict control of police must be continuous). (1995, November 14). Renmin Gongan Bao (RMGAB; People's Public Security Post), p. 1.
12.
Constitution of the People's Republic of China (Adopted on the Fifth Session of the Fifth National People's Congress and promulgated by the Proclamation of the National People's Congress on December 4, 1982). Available at http://english.peopledaily.com.cn/constitution/constitution.html
13.
CuY.D. (2000). A few points of reflection on how to handle crowd incidences appropriately.Journal of Chinese People's Public Security University, 88, 19–22.
14.
DaiG. (2000). The thoughts over the way to deal with Xin Hua Xi He massive accident, Journal of Chinese People's Public Security University, 87, 34–39
15.
Decree No. 40 by the President of the PRC. (1995). (The ‘Law on People's Police of the PRC was adopted by the 12th Session of the Eighth NPC Standing Committee of the PRC on February 28, 1995 and promulgated in Gazette of the State Council of the PRC (Zhonghua Renmin Gongheguo Guowuyuan Gongbao), 8, (1995, April 10).
16.
Draft central and local budgets for 2000. (2000, January 15). People's Daily, p. 2. Retrieved May 1, 2003, from web site.
17.
DuG.J. (1992). Cong zhuanzheng dao xianzheng (From dictatorship to constitutionalism).Zhejian xuekan, 3, 36–40.
18.
DuanLinping (2004). Inquiry into site inspection concept (Dui xianchang ducha gailian de tantao).Journal of Chinese People's Public Security University, 107, 140–2.
19.
Editorial Committee. (1992). Contemporary China public security work.Beijing, China: Dangdai Zhongguo chubanshe.
20.
GaoD.Y. (1995). Yifa congyan zhijing (Strict control of police by law). In TianJ.C. (Ed.), Lun gongan duiwu jianshe (Discussion on public security troop building).Guangdong, China: Guangdong renmin chubanshe.
21.
GaoX.R. (1991). Lue lun jingcha fa de gainian ji qi zai shehui zhuyi falu tixi zhong de diwei (A brief discussion of the concept of police law and its position in the socialist legal system).Public Security Studies, 4, 6–30.
22.
Gongmin, qing shenchu nin de shou (People, please lend your helping hand). (1995, November 30). RMGAB (People's Public Security Post), p. 2.
23.
HanJ.G. (2001). A preliminary discussion of public order incidents and a general plan to handle such incidents.Public Security Studies, 80, 72–3.
24.
HuangY. (1986). Luo Ruiqing zhuanlue (A biographical sketch of Luo Ruiqing).Zhonggong dangshi zhiliao (Communist party historical materials), 36, 171–223; 37, 154-204. Beijing, China: Zhonggong dangshi zhiliao chubanshe.
25.
Jingcha yishu xingxiang gai zenyang (What should be the police image in police artistic writing). (2002, January 31). RMGAB (People's Public Security Post). Internet version retrieved May 1, 2003, from http://www.cpd.com.cn.
26.
Jiu-wu gongan gongzuo gangyao (The ‘9-5’ public security work outline). (1996, February 8). RMGAB (People's Public Security Post), p. 1
27.
KleinD., & ClarkeA. (1970). Biographical dictionary of Chinese communism 1921-1965.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
28.
Legal service hotline opened in 90 percent of China's counties. (1999, November 20). People's Daily, online version. Retrieved May 1, 2003, from web site.
29.
Lei Feng paichusuo nei de gushi (The story inside Lei Feng police). (2003, July 31). Zhongguo Jingcha Wan (China Police Net). Retrieved January 1, 2004, from web site.
30.
‘Lei Feng spirit’ cherished by growing number of Chinese. (2003, March 6). People's Daily. Retrieved May 1, 2003, from web site.
31.
LiTao (2003). View the crisis in police public relations from Sun Zhi–gang's event, Journal of Chinese People's Public Security University, 106, 132–7.
32.
LoL. (1995, October 7) Yifa zhijing (Govern police by law).RMGAB (People's Public Security Post), p. 3.
33.
LuoF. (2000). Rule the police by law and enforce law strictly is the strategy of public security in the new century.Journal of Chinese People's Public Security University, 88, 1–4.
34.
LuoF. (1995, March 21). Zhiding ‘Renmin jingja de biyao xing he poqie xing’ (The necessity and urgency of promulgating ‘People's police law’).RMGAB (People's Public Security Post), p. 2.
35.
LuoR.Q. (1994). Lun renmin gongan gongzuo (Discussion on reforming public security work).Beijing, China: Qunzong chubanshe.
36.
Nation to further push legal awareness. (2001, February 1). People's Daily, online version. Retrieved May 1, 2003 from web site.
37.
NPC Chairman Li Peng on several questions by German correspondent. (1998, December 2). People's Daily. Retrieved May 1, 2003, from web site.
38.
NPC deputies strengthens supervision. (2000, March 13). People's Daily, online version. Retrieved May 1, 2003, from web site.
39.
Observing police style construction from ‘expose’ of special cases (Cong dianxing anli ‘baoguang’ kan jingfeng jiangshe). (2002, January 31). People's Public Security Bi-Monthly (Renmin Gongan Banyue Kan), p. 7.
40.
Over 44,000 Chinese police fired last year. (2004, January 17) Epoch Times. Reprinted in Association of Asian Research. Retrieved November 30, 2004, from http://www.asianresearch.org/articles/1831.html
41.
PengZhen (1946/1991). Bei-ping shi junshi guanzhi weiyuanhui guanyu gaige qu jie zhengquan zuzhi ji gonganju paichusuo de jueding (caoan) (Bei-ping city, military control committee, ‘Decision regarding reforming the political power structure of street, district, and public security stations (draft)’.Lun xin zhongguo zhengfa gongzuo (Discussion on political-legal work in new China).Beijing, China: Zhongyang wenxian chubanshe.
42.
PengZhen (1953/1991). Guanyu zhengzhi falu gongzuo de baogao (Report on political-legal work) (September 16, 1953). Lun xin zhongguo zhengfa gongzuo (Discussion on political-legal work in new China).Beijing, China: Zhongyang wenxian chubanshe.
43.
PengZhen (1956/1991). ‘Report to the whole nations’ public security department heads meeting’ (4 April 1956). Lun xin zhongguo zhengfa gongzuo (Discussion on political-legal work in new China). Beijing, China: Zhongyang wenxian chubanshe.
44.
People's Police Act of the PRC (1957). (Passed at the 76th meeting of the Standing Committee of the NPC, June 25, 1957; promulgated by the Chairman of the PRC, June 25, 1957).
45.
Regulations on the use of apparatus and weapons by People's Police in the PRC (Renmin jingcha shiyong jingxie he wuqi tiaoli’ zhengshi shixing). (1994). Passed on January 8, 1996 at the 41st meeting of the State Council and promulgated on January 16, 1996 by the Premier Li Peng as Decree No. 191 of the State Council of the People's Republic of China.
46.
Police image in art (Jingcha de yishu xingxiang). (2002b, January 31). RMGAB (People's Public Security Post). Internet version retrieved May 1, 2003, from http://www.cpd.com.cn
47.
Police law text. (1995, March 1). RMGAB (People's Public Security Post), p. 2.
48.
Police officers’ rights to be better protected. (2004, June 25). People's Daily, p. 2.
49.
PotterP. (1986). Zhen Peng evolving views on party organization and law. In CaroleL., HamrinC.L., & CheekT. (Eds.), China's establishment intellectuals (pp. 21–51). Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe.
50.
Renmin jingcha fa ‘zhengshi’ dansheng (People's Police's Law formally born). (1995, March 2). RMGAB (People's Public Security Post), p. 1.
51.
Renmin jingcha fazhi jianshe de lichengbei (A milestone in police legal system building). (1995, March 2). Renmin Gongan Bao (RMGAB; People's Public Security Post), p. 1–2.
52.
Sun Zhigang's brutal killers sentenced. (2003, June 10). China Daily, p. 1.
53.
Supervised by public opinion vs. supervising ‘mass media’. (1999, April 15). People's Daily, online version. Retrieved May 1, 2003, from web site.
54.
TannerH.M. (1999). Strike hard! Anti-crime campaigns and Chinese criminal justice, 1979-1985 (Cornell East Asia Series, no. 104). Ithaca, NY: Cornell University East Asia Program.
55.
TaoS.J. (1994). Guanyu ‘Zhonghuarenmingongheguo renmin jingcha fa (caoan)’ shuo ming (Explanation regarding the ‘PRC People's Police Law (draft)’ presented by the Minister of Public Security, Tao Siju, at the eleventh meeting of the Eighth NPC Standing Committee on December 12, 1994. In PRC NPC Standing Committee Gazette (Zhonghua Renmingonheguo Quanguo Renmin Dabiao Dahui Changwu Weiyuanhui Gongbao). March 15, 1995, pp. 102–105.
56.
TianJ.C. (Ed.). (1995). Lun gongan duiwu jianshe (Discussion on public security troop building)Guangdong, China: Guangdong renmin chubanshe.
57.
Tragedy spurs end to 20-year-old rule on vagrants. (2003, June 19). China Daily, p. 1.
58.
WangJ.B. (1995, May 15). Jiakuai zhiding renmin jingchafa de peitao fagui (Expedite the establishment of complementary set of Police Law).Renmin Gongan Bao (RMGAB; People's Public Security Post), p. 3.
59.
WangX.L. (1995, November 30). Zunzhong minjing zhifa xingwei, jiushi zunzhong guojia falu (Respect people's police law enforcement activities is respect for the country's law).Renmin Gongan Bao (RMGAB; People's Public Security Post), p. 2.
60.
WongK.C. (2002). Policing in PRC: Road to reform in the 1990s.British Journal of Criminology, 42, 281–36.
61.
WongK.C. (1997). Sheltering for examination: Law, policy, and practice. In Occasional Papers/Reprints Series in Contemporary Asian Studies.Baltimore, MD: University of Maryland, School of Law.
62.
WongK.C. (1996). Police powers and control in the People's Republic of China: A case study of police detention.Columbia Journal of Asian Law.10(3), 367–390.
63.
Wuwei xian gonganjuchang zhengwei tan jingchafa (Five county police depattment chiefs and political commissars discussed Police Law). (1995, June). People's Public Security Bi-Monthly (Renmin Gongan Banyue Kan), p. 11.
64.
XuFake (1996), Treatise on China Police Law (Zhongguo jingcha fa lun).Beijing, China: Hunan Chubanshe.
65.
Yi dianxing anli lean jingfen jiangshe (Observing police practice from typical cases exposed). (2002, January 31). RMGAB (People's Public Security Post). Retrieved May 1, 2003, from http://www.cpd.com.cn
66.
ZhangP.S. (1995, January 12). Jingcha jifa yao you falu baozhang (Police should have legal guarantee in enforcing the law).RMGAB (People's Public Security Post), p. 3.
67.
Zhonguo jingcha xuehui (China Police Society). (2001). China police law study.Beijing, China; Qunzhong Chubanshe.
68.
ZhouM., & ShaoJ.X. (1990). Chronicle of major event in 40 years for new China legal system development (1949-1988). (Xin zhongguo fazhi jiance xishi nian yadian [1949-1988]).Beijing, China: Zhongguo fazhi chubanshe.
69.
ZhouR.Z., & YanM. (1991). Qiye gongan jigou de lihai duice zhengyi (Debate over the pros-cons and policy responses to enterprise public security organization) inPublic Security Studies, 65, 49–51.
70.
ZhouZ.X. (2001). Discussion on drug abuse and the possible countermeasures.Public Security Studies, 77, 68–71.
71.
Zunzhong minjing zhifa xingwei, jiushi zunzhong guojia falu (Respect people's police law enforcement activities is respect for the country's law). (1995, November 30). RMGAB (People's Public Security Post), p. 2.
