This article details a moral panic in 1998–2000 about “ethnic gangs” in Sydney's south-western suburbs and analyses its ideological construction of the links between ethnicity, youth and crime. It documents the racisms of labelling and targeting of immigrant young people which misread, oversimplify and misrepresent complex and class-related social realities as racial, and the common-sense1 sharing of these understandings, representations and practices by “mainstream” media, police and vocal representatives in state, local and “ethnic” politics. The data used in this analysis are largely comprised of English-language media extracts, press, radio, television — both commercial and government-funded; and national, state and local in circulation, supplemented by interview material, from an ethnographic pilot study, with Lebanese-Australian youth, Lebanese immigrant parents, ethnic community workers, community leaders and police.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Australian (1998, 3November). Police search for shooting witness. Australian, p. 1.
2.
BearupG. (1998a, 2November). Fight to restore confidence. Sydney Morning Herald, p. 4.
3.
BearupG. (1998b, 2November). Under Fire Sydney Morning Herald, pp. 33,43.
4.
BearupG. (1998c, 4November). Police hit gang wall of silence. Sydney Morning Herald, p. 1.
5.
BearupG. (1999, 18September). Another day in Telopea Street: “We see nothing”. Sydney Morning Herald, p. 6.
6.
BraithwaiteJ.BarkerM. (1978), Bodgies and widgies: Folk devils of the fifties. InWilson &P.R.BraithwaiteJ.(Eds.), Two faces of deviance: Crimes of the powerless and the powerful (pp. 26–45). St Lucia: Queensland University Press.
7.
CaseyM. (1998, 2November). Community in crisis as tension turns to gunfire. Daily Telegraph, p. 4.
8.
CaseyM.OggM. (1998, 3November). Dial-a-Gun: Gang says it's easier than buying a pizza. Daily Telegraph, pp. 1,4.
9.
ChanJ. (1997), Changing police culture: Policing in a multicultural society. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
10.
CharltonP. (1998, 3November). A grim echo of Beirut. The Courier-Mail.
11.
ClarkM. (1987). A short Instory of Australia (3rd ed). New York: Mentor Books.
12.
ClarkeJ., (1976). Subcultures, culture and class: A theoretical overview. InHall &S.JeffersonT.(Eds.), Resistance Through Rituals. London: Unwin Hyman.
13.
ClennellA.KennedyL. (1998, 19October). Kneecappings may be linked to boy's murder. Sydney Morning Herald, p. 3.
14.
CohenS. (1987). Folk devils and moral panics: The creation of the Mods and Rockers (3rd ed.). Basil Blackwell: Oxford.
15.
CollinsJ. (1994). John Newman and John Chinaman: Challenging Asians stereotypingAustralian Quarterly66, 27–48.
Commonwealth Immigration Advisory Council (1952). [First] Report of Committee Established to Investigate Conduct of Migrants (Typed report), cited in Mukherjee, S. (1999, p. 3.)
18.
ConnellR.W.IrvingT. (1980). Class structure in Australian history. Melbourne: Longman Cheshire.
19.
CornfordP. (1998, 2November). Lakemba was vulnerable and easy to get away from Sydney Morning Herald, p. 4.
20.
CrawfordB. (1998, 2November). Terror Australis: police in the firing line. The Australian, p.1.
21.
CrosweilerA. (1998, 4November). Blast rocks police station: Arrests after new attack. Daily Telegraphy p.l.
22.
CunneenC. (1995). Ethnic minority youth and juvenile justice: Beyond the stereotype of ethnic gangs. InGuerra &C.WhiteR., Ethnic minority youth in Australia (pp. 111–120). Hobart: National Clearinghouse for Youth Studies.
23.
CunneenC.SpiersM. (1995). Police and justice. InAntoniosZ.(Ed.), State of the Nation: A report on people of non-English speaking background. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service.
24.
Daily Telegraph (1998a, 2November), Two weeks of tension, threats and violence, Daily Telegraphy p. 5
25.
Daily Telegraphy (1998b, 2November) Anarchy pulls the trigger. Daily Telegraphy p. 10.
26.
Daily Telegraphy (1998c, 4November) Man stabbed as tensions increase. Daily Telegraphy p. 2.
27.
DavisM. (1988). Los Angeles: Civil liberties between the hammer and the rock. New Left Review170,37–60.
28.
DixonD. (1998). Walls of silence. Paper presented to the Future of Australian Multiculturalism Conference, Research Institute for Humanities and Social Sciences, University of Sydney, 7–9 December.
29.
EnglishB. (1998, 4November). Parents told to control children. Daily Telegraph, p. 2.
30.
Ethnic Affairs Commission of New South Wales (1994). Police and ethnic communities. Sydney: Ethnic Affairs Commission of New South Wales.
31.
FinchL. (1998). On the streets — Working class youth culture in the nineteenth century. InHealeyK., (Ed), (1998) Youth and the law. Balmain: The Spinney Press, (reprinted from R. White (Ed.), (1993) Youth subcultures — Theory, history and the Australian experience. Hobart: National Clearinghouse for Youth Studies.)
32.
GarciaL.M. (1998, 13November). Prosecutor lashes new law and order push. Sydney Morning Herald, p. 8.
33.
GibbsS. (1999a, 27November) Accused shooter harassed: magistrate, Sydney Morning Heraldy p. 9.
34.
GibbsS. (1999b, 30November). O'Shane frees gunman and lashes police, Sydney Morning Herald, pp. 1,4.
35.
GilroyP. (1987). There ain't no black in the Union Jack. London: Unwin Hyman.
GoodeE.Ben-YehudaN. (1994). Moral panics: The social construction of deviance. Oxford: Blackwell.
38.
GormanQ., (Ed.). (1990). The larrikin streak: Australian writers look at the legend. Sydney: Pan Macmillan.
39.
GraboskyP.WilsonP. (1989). Journalism and justice: How crime is reported. Sydney: Pluto Press.
40.
GramsciA. (1971). Selections from the prison notebooks of Antonio Gramsci. New York: International Publishers, (ed. and trans. Q. Hoare and G. Nowell-Smith).
41.
HallS. (1988). New ethnicities. InMercerK.(Ed), Black Ftim/British Cinema. London: ICA.
42.
HallS.CritcherC.JeffersonT.ClarkeJ.RobertsB. (1978). Policing the crisis: Mugging, the state, and law and order. London: Macmillan.
43.
HarrisT.SutherlandT.WoodleyB. (1998, 4November). No let-up in attack on gangs, says, Can. The Australian.
44.
HumphriesD. (1998, 4November), Lebanese youths and police to meet. The Australian, p. 5.
45.
HumphriesD.MarshJ. (1998, 3November). Lakemba backs police: attack was un-Australian. Sydney Morning Herald, p. 1.
46.
Inner Western Suburbs Courier (1998a, 2November), Victims of crime, p. 4.
47.
Inner Western Suburbs Courier (1998b, 9November). It is not Australian, p. 4.
48.
IrvingX.MaundersD.SheringtonG. (1995). Youth in Australia: Policy administration and politics. Melbourne: Macmillan.
49.
JacksonS. (1998, 3November). Families cower under lock, key. The Australian, p. 5.
50.
JacksonS.HarrisT.NasonD. (1998, 3November). Call to community on shooting. The Australian, p. 5.
51.
JamalN. (1998, 3November). Islamic chief warns on rush to judgment. Sydney Morning Herald.
52.
JamiesonT. (1998, 2November). Take control of streets, Can told. Sydney Morning Herald, p. 4.
53.
KennedyL. (1998a, 22October). Armed escorts for officers after radio threats. Sydney Morning Herald.
54.
KennedyL. (1998b, 5November). The all know Edward's killer, but won't talk. Sydney Morning Herald, p. 1.
55.
KennedyL.BearupG.ConnollyE. (1999, 18September). Ryan claims “safe streets” as raids net 9. Sydney Morning Heraldy p. 6.
56.
LarrainJ. (1979). The concept of ideology. London: Hutchinson.
57.
LarrainJ. (1983). Marxism and ideology. London: Macmillan.
58.
LarrainJ. (1994). Ideology and cultural identity. Cambridge: Polity Press.
59.
LewisJ. (1989, 11November). Tragic community suffers trial by rumour and suspicion, Sydney Morning Herald, p. 3.
60.
LoaderI. (1996). Youth, policing and democracy. London: Macmillan.
61.
LucasX. (1998). Youth gangs and moral panics in Santa Cruz, California. InSkelton &T.ValentineG.(Eds.), Cool Place.sLondon: Routledge.
62.
LyonsJ.LewisJ.WatkinA. (1989, 7November). A night of savagery: Leigh's last hours. Sydney Morning Herald, p.1.
63.
MackenzieJ. (1998, 6November). “Lebanese” problem is Australia's. Sydney Morning Herald, p. 22.
64.
MarshJ. (1998, 7November), A question of context. Sydney Morning Heraldy p. 43.
65.
MartinB. (1998, 10November). Urban warfare The Bulletin, pp. 26–27.
66.
MilesR. (1989). Racism. London: Routledge.
67.
MilohanicS.(1998, 15November). Sydney's night of knives: Police seize 1100 weapons in four-month blitz. Daily Telegraphy p. 5.
68.
MorganG. (1997). The Bulletin and the larrikin moral panic in nineteenth century Sydney. Media International Australia85, 17–24.
69.
MukherjeeS. (1998). Crime in our society, paper presented to the “Ethnicity and Crime Under the Microscope: Dispelling the Myths' Forum of the Ethnic Communities, Council of NSW, Sydney, 2November.
70.
MukherjeeS. (1999). Ethnicity and crime. Paper presented at the 3rd National Outlook Symposium on Crime in Australia, convened by the Australian Institute of Criminology, Canberra, 22–23 March.
71.
MurphyD. (1998, 3November). Collins calls for tough laws, safety equipment. Sydney Morning Herald.
72.
MurphyD.PowerB. (1998, 20October). Agony over murdered son. Sydney Morning Herald, p. 1.
73.
New South Wales Parliament Legislative Council Standing Committee on Social Issues (1995). A Report into Youth Violence in New South Wales. Sydney: New South Wales Parliament.
74.
OggM.CaseyM. (1998a, 2November). An act of war: Gang fires 18 shots at police station. Daily Telegraphy pp. 1,4–5.
75.
OggM.CaseyM. (1998b, 2November). Police dig in against gang attack. Courier-Mail.
76.
PartridgeE. (1972). The Penguin dictionary of historical slang(abridged by J. Simpson). Harmondsworth: Penguin.
77.
PearsonG. (1983). Hooligan: A history of respectable fears. London: Macmillan.
78.
Pe-PuaR. (1999). Youth and ethnicity: Images and constructions. InWhiteR.(Ed.), Australian youth subcultures: On the margins and in the mainstream (pp. 120–126). Hobart: National Clearinghouse for Youth Studies.
79.
Pe-PuaR. (1996). “We're just like other kids”: Street-frequenting youth of non-English speaking background. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service.
80.
PetersonA. (1999, 22December). White city gunman sent to jail. Daily Telegraph.
81.
PoyntingS. (1999) When “zero tolerance” looks like racial intolerance: “Lebanese youth gangs”, discrimination and resistance. Current Issues in Criminal Justice11.
82.
PoyntingS.NobleG.TabarP. (1998). “If anyone called me a wog, they wouldn't be speaking to me alone”: Protest masculinity and Lebanese youth in Western Sydney, Journal of Interdisciplinary Gender Studies3, 6–94.
83.
PoyntingS.NobleG.TabarP. (1999). “Intersections” of masculinity and ethnicity: A study of male Lebanese immigrant youth in Western Sydney. Race, Ethnicity and Education2, 59–77.
84.
PoyntingS.CollinsJ.NobleG.TabarP. (1999). “Bankstown Boys” and “Boys in Blue”: Ethnic youth, police and the conflict of masculinities. Paper presented to the Annual Conference of the Australian Sociological Association, Monash University, 8 December.
85.
RowlandsL.OggM. (1998, 30October). 24 arrests as police swoop to reclaim “their patch”. Daily Telegraphy p. 9.
86.
SafeG. (1998, –8November). Police at odds over gun links. The Weekend Australian, p. 13.
87.
SaidE. (1979). Orientalism. New York: Vintage.
88.
SchlesingerP.TumberH. (1994). Reporting crime: The media politics of criminal justice. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
89.
SercombeH. (1999). Boots, gangs and addictions: Youth subcultures and the media. InWhiteR.(Ed.), Australian youth subcultures: On the margins and in the mainstream (pp. 5–15). Hobart: Australian Clearinghouse for Youth Studies.
90.
SolomosJ.BackL. (1996). Racism and society. Basingstoke: Macmillan.
91.
StephensX. (1998, 2November). Hard questions for a horrified city: Now, hard questions for a city in terror. Sydney Mormng Herald, pp. 1,5.
92.
StevensonA. (1998, 7November). Cultural crossfire. Daily Telegraphy pp. 32–3.
93.
StrattonJ. (1993). Bodgies and widgies: Just working-class kids doing working-class things. InWhiteR.(Ed.), Youth subcultures: Theory, history and the Australian experience (pp. 87–91). Hobart: National Clearingouse for Youth Studies.
94.
Sunday Telegraph, Ethnic leaders' help on stabbing. Sunday Telegraph25October, p. 19.
95.
Sun-Herald (2000, 27February). When ethnic seems to be the hardest word. Sun-Herald Editorial.
96.
Sydney Morning Herald (1994) State MP shot dead in drive-by attack. Sydney Morning Herald6September, p. 1.
97.
Sydney Mormng Herald (1997, 5February) “Ethnic” crime. Sydney Morning Herald, p. 14.
98.
Sydney Morning Herald (1998b) Scene is from Northern Ireland, says shocked Ryan. Sydney Morning Heraldy2November, p. 5.
99.
TabarR.PoyntingS.NobleG. (1998). “They don't deserve to be Australian”: The politics of representation among a migrant community. Paper presented to the Annual Conference of the Australian Sociological Association, Queensland University of Technology, Brisbane, 1–4 December, 1998.
100.
TempleW.TruteP. (1998, 20October). Across the divide. Daily Telegraphy p. 5.
101.
The Torch (1998, 4November). Police operation targets criminals. Hie Torch, p. 7.
102.
TomsenS. (1996). Ruling men? Some comments on masculinity and juvenile justice. The Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology29, 191–4.
103.
TruteP. (1998, 21October). Mother's tears for her “precious thing”. DaUy Telegraph, p. 21.
104.
TruteP.StevensonA. (1998, 5November). Street where no one talks: Appeal for witnesses to show courage. Daily Telegraph, p. 7.
105.
UsherM. (1998, 2November). Station shootup, National Nine News.
106.
WalkerF.ChulovM. (1999, 21March). Well shame young crims: Fading Coalition plays crime card. The Sun-Herald, p. 1.
107.
WheatleyN.CottleD. (1999). Sydney's Anti-Eviction Movement: Community or conspiracy?Labour History(forthcoming).
108.
WhiteR. (1996). Racism, policing and ethnic youth gangs. Current Issues in Criminal Justice7, 302–313.
109.
WhiteR. (1996). Youth gangs. InWhiteR.(Ed.), Australian youth subcultures: On the margins and in the mainstream (pp. 36–45). Hobart: National Clearinghouse for Youth Studies.
110.
WhiteR.PerroneS.GuerraC.LampugnaniR. (1999). Ethnic youth gangs in Australia; Do they exist? Report No. 2: Turkish Young People. Melbourne: Australian Multicultural Foundation.
111.
WilkinsL.T. (1964). Social deviance: Social policy, action and research. London: Tavistock Publications.
112.
WoodcockL. G. (1956), The Lewis case and you. Sydney: Liberty Press.
113.
WynhausenE. (1994, 10July). The politics of gang warfare. The Sun-Herald, p. 29.
114.
WynhausenE.SafeG. (1998, 7–8November). Gunshots that broke our peace. The Weekend Austrahan, p. 13.
