Steps Scientists Can Take to Inform Aquatic Microplastics Management: A Perspective Informed by the California Experience

Abstract

Recent evidence suggests that microplastic particles are pervasive and potentially of great risk to both animal and human health. The California legislature has responded to this information by enacting two new bills that require quantification of microplastics in various media and development of new management strategies to address microplastic pollution. However, there are several scientific gaps that impede the development and implementation of necessary management strategies to address microplastic pollution. In this paper, we use the California experience as a case study to provide perspective on those science gaps, the current barriers to science affecting management, and the actions scientists can take to best ensure their efforts are of greatest value to policymakers and the management community.

Keywords

Microplastics policy management California

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Lam

C.S.

Ramanathan

Carbery

, et al. “A Comprehensive Analysis of Plastics and Microplastic Legislation Worldwide”. Water Air Soil Pollut. 2018. 229(11): 345.

Xanthos

Walker

T.R.

“International Policies to Reduce Plastic Marine Pollution from Single-Use Plastics (Plastic Bags and Microbeads): A Review”. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2017. 118(1–2): 17–26.

A. Padilla, K. de Leon, R. Lara, et al. “SB-270 Solid Waste: Single-Use Carryout Bags”. https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtml?bill_id=201320140SB270 [accessed June 26 2020].

I. Calderon, R. Bloom. “AB-1884 Food Facilities: Single-Use Plastic Straws”. https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtml?bill_id=201720180AB1884 [accessed June 26 2020].

R. Bloom. “AB-888 Waste Management: Plastic Microbeads”. https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml?bill_id=201520160AB888 [accessed June 26 2020].

State Water Resources Control Board Ocean Standards Unit. “Water Quality Control Plan: Ocean Waters of California”. 2015. https://www.waterboards.ca.gov/water_issues/programs/ocean/docs/cop2015.pdf [accessed June 19 2019].

California Ocean Protection Council and National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Marine Debris Program. “California Ocean Litter Prevention Strategy: Addressing Marine Debris from Source to Sea”. 2018. http://www.opc.ca.gov/webmaster/_media_library/2018/06/2018_CA_OceanLitterStrategy.pdf [accessed June 19 2019].

Lehner

Weder

Petri-Fink

, et al. “Emergence of Nanoplastic in the Environment and Possible Impact on Human Health”. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2019. 53(4): 1748–1765.

Besseling

Redondo-Hasselerharm

Foekema

E.M.

, et al. “Quantifying Ecological Risks of Aquatic Micro- and Nanoplastic”. Crit. Rev. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2019. 49(1): 32–80.

10.

Allen

Phoenix

V.R.

, et al. “Atmospheric Transport and Deposition of Microplastics in a Remote Mountain Catchment”. Nat. Geosci. 2019. 12(5): 339–344.

11.

Peeken

Primpke

Beyer

, et al. “Arctic Sea Ice is an Important Temporal Sink and Means of Transport for Microplastic”. Nat. Commun. 2018. 9: 1505.

12.

Waller

C.L.

Griffiths

H.J.

Waluda

C.M.

, et al. “Microplastics in the Antarctic Marine System: An Emerging Area of Research”. Sci. Total Environ. 2017. 598(15): 220–227.

13.

Sutton

Lin

Sedlak

, et al. Understanding Microplastic Levels, Pathways, and Transport in the San Francisco Bay Region, Richmond, CA: San Francisco Estuary Institute, 2019.

14.

Sharp

S.M.

Pettigrove

V.J.

, et al. “Superimposed Microplastic Pollution in a Coastal Metropolis”. Water Res. 2020. 168: 115140.

15.

Grbić

Helm

Athey

, et al. “Microplastics Entering Northwestern Lake Ontario are Diverse and Linked to Urban Sources”. Water Res. 2020. 174: 115623.

16.

Twiss

M.R.

“Standardized Methods are Required to Assess and Manage Microplastic Contamination of the Great Lakes System”. J. Great Lakes Res. 2016. 42(5): 921–925.

17.

H. Løkkegaard, S. Woldum Tordrup, M. Køcks, et al. “Partnerskab om mikroplast I spildevand [Partnership on Microplastics in Wastewater]”. Environmental Protection Agency, Odense, Denmark. 2017. https://mst.dk/media/143341/partnerskab-om-mikroplast-i-spildevand-2017.pdf [accessed June 8 2020].

18.

Rochman

C.M.

Regan

Thompson

R.C.

“On the Harmonization of Methods for Measuring the Occurrence, Fate, and Effects of Microplastics”. Anal. Methods. 2017. 2017(9): 1324–1325.

19.

Barbosa

Adeyemi

J.A.

Bocato

M.Z.

, et al. “A Critical Viewpoint on Current Issues, Limitations, and Future Research Needs on Micro- and Nanoplastic Studies: From the Detection to the Toxicological Assessment”. Environ. Res. 2020. 182: 109089.

20.

Cowger

Booth

Hamilton

, et al. “Reporting Guidelines to Increase the Reproducibility and Comparability of Research on Microplastics”. Appl Spectrosc. 74(9): 1066–1077.

21.

Koelmans

A.A.

Mohamed Nor

N.H.

Hermsen

, et al. “Microplastics in Freshwaters and Drinking Water: Critical Review and Assessment of Data Quality”. Water Res. 2019. 155: 410–422.

22.

Cadiou

J.F.

Gerigny

Koren

Š.

, et al. “Lessons Learned from an Intercalibration Exercise on the Quantification and Characterisation of Microplastic Particles in Sediment and Water Samples”. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2020. 154: 111097.

23.

Barrows

A.P.

Neumann

C.A.

Berger

M.L.

, et al. “Grab vs. Neuston Tow Net: A Microplastic Sampling Performance Comparison and Possible Advances in the Field”. Anal. Methods. 2017. 9(9): 1446–1453.

24.

Lares

Ncibi

M.C.

Sillanpää

, et al. “Intercomparison Study on Commonly Used Methods to Determine Microplastics in Wastewater and Sludge Samples”. Environ. Sci. Pollut. R. 2019. 26(12): 12109–12122.

25.

Setälä

Magnusson

Lehtiniemi

, et al. “Distribution and Abundance of Surface Water Microlitter in the Baltic Sea: A Comparison of Two Sampling Methods”. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2016. 110(1): 177–183.

26.

Song

Y.K.

Hong

S.H.

Jang

, et al. “A Comparison of Microscopic and Spectroscopic Identification Methods for Analysis of Microplastics in Environmental Samples”. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2015. 93(1–2): 202–209.

27.

Y. Michida et al. “Guidelines for Harmonizing Ocean Surface Microplastic Monitoring Methods. Ministry of the Environment Japan”. 2020. http://www.env.go.jp/en/water/marine_litter/guidelines/guidelines.pdf [accessed June 26 2020].

28.

Dehaut

Cassone

A.L.

Frere

, et al. “Microplastics in Seafood: Benchmark Protocol for their Extraction and Characterization”. Environ. Pollut. 2016. 215: 223–233.

29.

Akdogan

Guven

“Microplastics in the Environment: A Critical Review of Current Understanding and Identification of Future Research Needs”. Environ. Pollut. 2019. 254(Pt. A): 113011.

30.

Bucci

Tulio

Rochman

“What is Known and Unknown About the Effects of Plastic Pollution: A Meta-Analysis and Systematic Review”. Ecol. Appl. 2020. 30(2): e02044.

31.

World Health Organization (WHO). “Microplastics in Drinking-Water”. 2019. http://edepot.wur.nl/498693 [accessed December 16 2019].

32.

O'Connor

J.D.

Mahon

A.M.

Ramsperger

A.F.R.M.

, et al. “Microplastics in Freshwater Biota: A Critical Review of Isolation, Characterization, and Assessment Methods”. Global Challenges. 2020. 4(6): 1800118.

33.

European Center for Ecotoxicology and Toxicology of Chemicals. “An Evaluation of the Challenges and Limitations Associated with Aquatic Toxicity and Bioaccumulation Studies for Sparingly Soluble and Manufactured Particulate Substances”. Technical Report No. 132. 2018. http://www.ecetoc.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/ECETOC-TF-132-Aq-tox-particulates.pdf [accessed June 9 2020].

34.

De Ruijter

V.N.

Redondo-Hasselerharm

P.E.

Gouin

, et al. “Quality Criteria for Microplastic Effect Studies in the Context of Risk Assessment: A Critical Review”. Environ. Sci. 52(18): 10230–10240.

35.

European Chemicals Agency. “Annex XV Restriction Report Proposal for a Restriction: intentionally added microplastics. Version 1.2. (Proposal 1.2)”. 2019. https://echa.europa.eu/documents/10162/05bd96e3-b969-0a7c-c6d0-441182893720 [accessed January 2 2020].

36.

S. Hann, C. Sherrington, O. Jamieson, et al. “Investigating Options for Reducing Releases in the Aquatic Environment of Microplastics Emitted by (but Not Intentionally Added in) Products”. 2018. https://www.eunomia.co.uk/reports-tools/investigating-options-for-reducing-releases-in-the-aquatic-environment-of-microplastics-emitted-by-products/ [accessed June 26 2020].

37.

B. Dommergues, R. Brambini, R. Mettler, et al. “Hydrodynamics and Capture Efficiency of Plastic Cleanup Booms: Part II—2D Vertical Capture Efficiency and CFD Validation”. Presented at: ASME 2017 36th International Conference on Ocean, Offshore and Arctic Engineering, American Society of Mechanical Engineers Digital Collection. 2017.

38.

The Ocean Cleanup. “The Ocean Cleanup Unveils Plan to Address The Main Source of Ocean Plastic Pollution: Rivers”. Press Release. 2019. https://theoceancleanup.com/press/press-releases/the-ocean-cleanup-unveils-plan-to-address-the-main-source-of-ocean-plastic-pollution-rivers/ [accessed June 9 2020].

39.

The Ocean Cleanup. “The Ocean Cleanup Wins $1M Award from Benioff Ocean Initiative to Combat River Plastic Waste in Jamaica”. Press Release. 2020. https://theoceancleanup.com/press/press-releases/the-ocean-cleanup-wins-1m-award-from-benioff-ocean-initative-to-combat-river-plastic-waste-in-jamaica/ [accessed June 9 2020].

40.

Arossa

Martin

Rossbach

, et al. “Microplastic Removal by Red Sea Giant Clam (Tridacna maxima)”. Environ. Pollut. 2019. 252(Pt. B): 1257–1266.

41.

Sánchez

“Fungal Potential for the Degradation of Petroleum-Based Polymers: An Overview of Macro- and Microplastics Biodegradation”. Biotechnol. Adv. 2020. 40: 107501.

42.

Padervand

Lichtfouse

Robert

, et al. “Removal of Microplastics from the Environment. A Review”. Environ Chem Lett. 2020. 18(3): 807–828.

43.

Scopetani

Esterhuizen-Londt

Chelazzi

, et al. “Self-Contamination from Clothing in Microplastics Research”. Ecotoxicol. Environ. Saf. 2020. 189: 110036.

44.

Primpke

Christiansen

S.H.

Cowger

, et al. “Critical Assessment of Analytical Methods for the Harmonized and Cost-Efficient Analysis of Microplastics”. Appl Spectrosc. 2020. 74(9): 1012–1047.

45.

Völker

Kramm

Wagner

“On the Creation of Risk: Framing of Microplastics Risks in Science and Media”. Global Challenges. 2020. 4(6): 1900010.

46.

Environment and Climate Change Canada, Health Canada. “Draft Science Assessment of Plastic Pollution”. 2020. https://www.canada.ca/content/dam/eccc/documents/pdf/pded/plastic-pollution/Science%20Assessment%20Plastic%20Pollution.pdf [accessed June 26 2020].

47.

Vince

Hardesty

B.D.

“Governance Solutions to the Tragedy of the Commons that Marine Plastics Have Become”. Front. Mar. Sci. 2018. 5: 214.

48.

United Nations Environment. “Combating Marine Plastic Litter and Microplastics: An Assessment of the Effectiveness of Relevant International, Regional and Subregional Governance Strategies and Approaches”. 2017. https://papersmart.unon.org/resolution/uploads/unep_aheg_2018_inf3_full_assessment_en.pdf [accessed June 26 2020].

49.

Villarrubia-Gómez

Cornell

S.E.

Fabres

“Marine Plastic Pollution as a Planetary Boundary Threat: The Drifting Piece in the Sustainability Puzzle”. Mar. Policy. 2018. 96: 213–220.

50.

Black

J.E.

Kopke

O'Mahony

“A Trip Upstream to Mitigate Marine Plastic Pollution: A Perspective Focused on the MSFD and WFD”. Front. Mar. Sci. 2019. 6: 689.

51.

Adam

Walker

T.R.

Bezerra

J.C.

, et al. “Policies to Reduce Single-Use Plastic Marine Pollution in West Africa”. Mar. Policy. 2020. 116: 103928.

52.

Borja

Á.

Elliott

Carstensen

, et al. “Marine Management–Towards an Integrated Implementation of the European Marine Strategy Framework and the Water Framework Directives”. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 2010. 60(12): 2175–2186.