Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2020-3
Handheld X-ray Fluorescence (XRF) Versus Wavelength Dispersive XRF: Characterization of Chinese Blue-and-White Porcelain Sherds Using Handheld and Laboratory-Type XRF Instruments
Almost all archaeometric studies on Chinese ceramics are carried out on the excavation materials. Therefore, a detailed, comparable database that defines different workshops and production periods already exists. But the masterpieces preserved at museums, art galleries, and/or private collections, which are artistically considered as genuine artifacts, also require similar scientific investigations to define their provenance and authenticity. The research on artworks is only possible with the use of portable, noninvasive techniques that are developing daily concerning their capability of detection limits, rate of measurement, and ease of use. In this study, the results obtained with a handheld X-ray fluorescence (XRF) (also called portable XRF) and wavelength dispersive XRF instrument were compared to evidence the efficiency and drawbacks of the portable model. To achieve this goal, 12 sherds, which represent blue-and-white porcelains of Yuan and Ming Dynasties (China), were analyzed and the chemical composition of the body, glaze, and blue decor were identified. The comparison of the results with the measurements carried out on the excavation materials, which are produced in both southern and northern China, revealed the authenticity of the artifacts. Even sodium cannot be detected with portable XRF, the distinction of different production centers is possible with the detection of major (Mg, Al, Si, K, Ca), minor (Fe, Ti), and trace elements (Zr, Sr, Rb).
Ch. Kiefer. “Les Céramiques Siliceuses d’Anatolie et du Moyen-Orient”. B. Soc. Fr. Ceram. 1956. 30: 3–24.
2.
Ch. Kiefer. “Les Céramiques Siliceuses d’Anatolie et du Moyen-Orient”. B. Soc. Fr. Ceram. 1956. 31: 17–34.
3.
M. Tite. “Determination of the Firing Temperature of Ancient Ceramics by Measurement of Thermal Expansion: A Reassessment”. Archaeometry. 1969. 11(1): 131–143.
4.
D.P.S. Peacock. “The Scientific Analysis of Ancient Ceramics: A Review”. World Archaeol. 1970. 1(3): 375–389.
5.
A.O. Shepard. Ceramics for the Archaeologist. Publication 609., Washington, DC: Carnegie Institution of Washington, 1985.
6.
KingeryD.W.SmithD.“Ancient Technology to Modern Science”. In: KingeryD.W.LenseE. (eds). Ceramics and Civilization. 1984. Vol 1, p. 273Columbus, OH: American Ceramic Society.
7.
KingeryW.D.BowenH.K.UhlmannD.R.Introduction to Ceramics., New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1976.
8.
KoleiniF.ColombanP.PikirayiI., et al.“Glass Beads, Markers of Ancient Trade in Sub-Saharan Africa: Methodology, State of the Art and Perspectives”. Heritage. 2019. 2(3): 2343–2369.
9.
CuevasA.M.GravieH.P.“Portable Energy Dispersive X-ray Fluorescence and X-ray Diffraction and Radiography System for Archaeometry”. Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A. 2011. 633(1): 72–78.
10.
Dominguez-VidalA.de la Torre-LopezM.J.Rubio-DomeneR., et al.“In Situ Non Invasive Raman Microspectroscopic Investigation of Polychrome Plasterworks in the Alhambra”. Analyst. 2012. 137(24): 5763–5769.
11.
HolakooeiP.TisatoF.VaccaroC., et al.“Haft Rang or Cuerda Seca? Spectroscopic Approaches to the Study of Overglaze Polychrome Tiles from Seventeenth Century Persia”. J. Archaeol. Sci. 2014. 41: 447–460.
12.
SimsekG.ColombanP.CasadioF., et al.“On-Site Identification of Early Böttger Red Stoneware Using Portable XRF/Raman Instruments: 2, Glaze and Gilding Analysis”. J. Eur. Ceram. Soc. 2015. 98(10): 3006–3013.
13.
FischbachN.NgoA.T.ColombanP., et al.“Beads Excavated from Antsiraka Boira Necropolis (Mayotte Island, 12th–13th Centuries): Colouring Agents and Glass Matrix Composition Comparison with Contemporary Southern Africa Sites”. Archeosciences-Rev A. 2016. 40: 83–102.
14.
ManciniD.Dupont-LogieC.ColombanP.“On-Site Identification of Sceaux Porcelain and Faience Using a Portable Raman Instrument”. Ceram. Int. 2016. 42(13): 14918–14927.
15.
M. El Amraoui, M. Haddad, L. Bejjit, et al. “On-Site XRF Characterization of Archaeological Materials in CERA Center of Rissani (Morocco)”. In: XII Maghreb Days of Material Sciences JMSM'2015, Maghreb, 19-21 November 2015.
16.
ShalviG.ShovalS.BarS., et al.“On the Potential of Microbeam Analyses in Study of the Ceramics, Slip and Paint of Late Bronze Age White Slip II Ware: An Example from the Canaanite Site Tel Esur”. Appl. Clay Sci. 2019. 168: 324–339.
17.
SimsekG.Demirsar ArlıB.KayaS., et al.“On-Site portable XRF Analysis of Body, Glaze and Colouring Agents of the Tiles at the Excavation Site of Iznik Kilns”. J. Eur. Ceram. Soc. 2019. 39(6): 2199–2209.
18.
SimsekG.UnsalanO.BayraktarK., et al.“On-Site portable XRF Analysis of Glaze Composition and Colouring Agents of ‘Iznik’ Tiles at Edirne Mosques (15th and 16th Centuries)”. Ceram. Int. 2019. 45(1): 595–605.
19.
SimsekG.“P-XRF’in Kültürel Miras Eseleri Üzerine Yapilan Çalişmalarda Kullanimi [Use of p-XRF on the Studies of Cultural Heritage Objects]”. SDÜ ART-E Güzel Sanatlar Fakültesi Sanat Dergisi. 2018. 11(22): 406–415.
20.
FergusonJ.R.KeurenS.V.BenderS.“Rapid Qualitative Compositional Analysis of Ceramic Paints”. J. Archaeol. Sci. Rep. 2015. 3: 321–327.
21.
MitchellD.GraveP.MaccheroniM., et al.“Geochemical Characterisation of North Asian Glazed Stonewares: A Comparative Analysis of NAA, ICP-OES and Non-Destructive portable XRF”. J. Archaeol. Sci. 2012. 39(9): 2921–2933.
22.
YinM.RehrenT.ZhengJ.“The Earliest High-Fired Glazed Ceramics in China: The Composition of the Proto-Porcelain from Zhejiang During the Shang and Zhou Periods (c. 1700–221 BC)”. J. Archaeol. Sci. 2011. 38(9): 2352–2365.
23.
LeungP.-L.LuoH.“A Study of Provenance and Dating of Ancient Chinese Porcelain by X-ray Fluorescence Spectrometry”. X-ray Spectrom. 2000. 29(1): 34–38.
24.
TripatiS.ParthibanG.PattanJ.-N., et al.“Chemical Composition and Provenance of Chinese Porcelain Shards Recovered from Old Goa, West Coast of India”. J. Archaeol. Sci. Rep. 2017. 14: 467–478.
25.
MaH.ZhuJ.HendersonJ., et al.“Provenance of Zhangzhou Export Blue-and-White and Its Clay Source”. J. Archaeol. Sci. 2012. 39(5): 1218–1226.
26.
SimsekG.ColombanP.WongS., et al.“Toward a Fast Non-Destructive Identification of Pottery: The Sourcing of 14th–16th Century Vietnamese and Chinese Ceramic Shards”. J. Cult. Herit. 2015. 16(2): 159–172.
27.
LiW.LiJ.DengZ., et al.“Study on Ru Ware Glaze of the Northern Song Dynasty: One of the Earliest Crystalline-Phase Separated Glazes in China”. Ceram. Int. 2005. 31(3): 487–494.
28.
YangY.FengM.LingX., et al.“Microstructural Analysis of the Color-Generating Mechanism in Ru Ware, Modern Copies and Its Differentiation with Jun Ware” J. Archaeol. Sci. 2005. 32(2): 301–310.
29.
LiB.-P.GreigA.ZhaoJ.-X., et al.“ICP-MS Trace Element Analysis of Song Dynasty Porcelains from Ding, Jiexiu and Guantai Kilns, North China”. J. Archeol. Sci. 2005. 32(2): 251–259.
30.
ColombanP.TreppozF.“Identification and Differentiation of Ancient and Modern European Porcelains by Raman Macro- and Micro-Spectroscopy”. J. Raman Spectrosc. 2001. 32(2): 93–102.
31.
ColombanP.SagonG.HuyL.-Q., et al.“Vietnamese (15th Century) Blue-and-White, Tam Thai and Lustre Porcelains/Stonewares: Glaze Composition and Decoration Techniques”. Archaeometry. 2004. 46(1): 125–136.
32.
ColombanP.LiemN.Q.SagonG., et al.“Microstructure, Composition, and Processing of 15th Century Vietnamese Porcelains and Celadones”. J. Cult. Herit. 2003. 4(3): 187–197.
33.
YuK.-N.MiaoJ.-M.“Characterization of Blue and White Porcelains Using the Mn/Fe Ratio from EDXRF, with Particular Reference to Porcelains of the Xuande Period (1426 to 1435 A.D.)”. Appl. Radiat. Isotopes. 1999. 51(3): 279–283.
34.
LiemN.-Q.ThanhN.-T.ColombanP.“Reliability of Raman Micro-Spectroscopy in Analysing Ancient Ceramics: The Case of Ancient Vietnamese Porcelain and Celadon Glazes”. J. Raman Spectrosc. 2002. 33(4): 287–294.
35.
SciauP.WangT.“Full-Field Transmission X-ray Microspectroscopy (FF-XANES) Applied to Cultural Heritage Materials: The Case of Ancient Ceramics”. In: JosephD. (ed). Synchrotron Radiation: Useful and Interesting Applications., London, UK: IntechOpen, 2019. doi:10.5772/intechopen.83633.
36.
BinZ.ZhengyaoG.WeijuanZ., et al.“Mössbauer Spectroscopy and Neutron Activation Analysis of Ancient Chinese Glazes”. Appl. Clay. 2004. 25(3–4): 161–165.
37.
FigueiredoM.-O.SilvaT.-P.VeigaJ.-P.“A XANES Study of Cobalt Speciation State in Blue-and-White Glazes From 16th to 17th Century Chinese Porcelains”. Electron Spectros. Relat. Phenomena. 2012. 185(3–4): 97–102.
HouJ.PradellT.LiY., et al.“Jun Ware Glazes: Chemistry, Nanostructure and Optical Properties”. J. Eur. Ceram. Soc. 2018. 38(12): 4290–4302.
41.
LiW.LuoH.LiJ., et al.“Studies on the Microstructure of the Black-Glazed Bowl Sherds Excavated from the Jian Kiln Site of Ancient China”. Ceram Int. 2008. 34(6): 1473–1480.
42.
J. Needham. “Science and Civilisation in China” In: R. Kerr, N. Wood, editors. Volume 12: Ceramic Technology, Cambridge University Press, 2004, pp.164–181.
43.
WuJ.HouT.ZhangM., et al.“A Technical Comparison of Three Chinese White Porcelains: Ding, Shufu, and Dehua”. Stud Conserv. 2014. 59(5): 341–349.
44.
WuJ.LeungP.L.LiJ.Z., et al.“EDXRF Studies on Blue and White Chinese Jingdezhen Porcelain Samples from the Yuan, Ming and Qing Dynasties”. X-ray Spectrom. 2000. 29(3): 239–244.
45.
XuY.QinY.DingF.“Characterization of the Rare Oil Spot Glazed Bowl Excavated from the Xiao Kiln Site of North China”. Ceram Int. 2017. 43(12): 8636–8642.
46.
D.V. Hill, P. Sciau, G. Simsek, et al. “PHASE I Sample Groups 1.0–8.0 Research Protocol. Topic II, Phase I (2016–2017), Sample Groups 1.0–8.0, Topics II. The Origin of Pre-Ming Blue-and-White Research Outline Protocols”. 2018. ASET Stiftung. http://aset-stiftung.org/programmes/phase1-samplegr1-8-research-prot-topic2.php [accessed Nov 23 2019].
47.
ZhuT.-Q.ZhangY.-C.XiongH., et al.“Comparison of the Different Types of Qinghua Porcelain from Jingdezhen in the Yuan Dynasty of China (AD 1271-1368) by Micro X-ray Fluorescence Spectroscopy (μ-XRF) and Microscopy”. Archaeometry. 2106. 58(6): 966–978.
48.
CharalambidouX.KiriatziE.MüllerN.S., et al.“Eretrian Ceramic Products Through Time: Investigating the Early History of Greek Metropolis”. J. Archaeol. Sci. Rep. 2016. 7: 530–535.
49.
A. Barba, M.F. Gazulla, M.P. Gomez, et al. “Characterisation of Cobalt-Containing Ceramic Pigments by WDXRF and XRD”. X-ray Spectrom. 35(6): 383–389.
50.
GeorgakopoulouM.HeinA.MüllerN.S., et al.“Development and Calibration of a WDXRF Routine Applied to Provenance Studies on Archaeological Ceramics”. X-ray Spectrom. 2017. 46(3): 186–199.
51.
J.J. Aimers, D.J. Farthing, A.N. Shugar. “Handheld XRF Analysis of Maya Ceramics: A Pilot Study Presenting Issues Related to Quantification and Calibration”. In: A.N. Shugar, J.L. Mass, editors. Handheld XRF for Art and Archaeology. Leuven, Belgium: Leuven University Press, 2012. Chap. 13, Pp. 423–448.
52.
Al-ShormanA.El-KhouriL.“Archaeometric Characterization of the Byzantine and Umayyad Pottery at Barsinia, North Jordan”. Mediterr. Archaeol. Archaeom. 2013. 13(2): 207–220.
53.
HuntA.M.W.SpeakmanR.J.“Portable XRF Analysis of Archaeological Sediments and Ceramics”. J. Archaeol. Sci. 2015. 53: 626–638.
54.
ToffoloM.B.KleinE.ElbaumR., et al.“An Early Iron Age Assemblage of Faience Beads from Ashkelon, Israel: Chemical Composition and Manufacturing Process”. J. Archaeol. Sci. 2013. 40: 3626–3635.
55.
MeanwellJ.L.ParisE.H.AlvaradoW.C., et al.“Metallurgical Ceramics from Mayapan, Yucatan, Mexico”. J. Archaeol. Sci. 2013. 40: 4306–4318.
56.
BonizzoniL.GalliA.GondolaM., et al.“Comparison Between XRF, TXRF, and PXRF Analyses for Provenance Classification of Archaeological Bricks”. X-ray Spectrom. 2013. 42(4): 262–267.
57.
AppoloniC.R.Espinoza QuinonesF.R.AragaoP.H.A., et al.“EDXRF Study of Tupi-Guarani Archaeological Ceramics”. Radiat Phys Chem. 2001. 61(3–6): 711–712.
58.
SimsekG.CasadioF.ColombanP., et al.“On-Site Identification of Early BÖTTGER Red Stoneware Made at Meissen Using Portable XRF: 1, Body Analysis”. J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 2014. 97(9): 2745–2754.
59.
FischerC.HsiehE.“Export Chinese Blue-and-White Porcelain: Compositional Analysis and Sourcing Using Non-Invasive Portable XRF and Reflectance Spectroscopy”. J. Archaeol. Sci. 2017. 80: 14–26.
60.
ChengH.S.ZhangZ.Q.XiaH.N., et al.“Non-Destructive Analysis and Appraisal of Ancient Chinese Porcelain by PIXE”. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res., Sect. B. 2002. 190(1–4): 488–491.
61.
YapC.T.HuaY.“Raw Materials for Making Jingdezhen Porcelain from the Five Dynasties to The Qing Dynasty”. Appl. Spectrosc. 1992. 46(10): 1488–1494.
62.
YanyiG.“Raw Materials for Making Porcelain and the Characteristics of Porcelain Wares in North and South China in Ancient Times”. Archaeometry. 1987. 29(1): 3–19.
63.
ChenT.RappG.JingZ., et al.“Provenance Studies of the Earliest Chinese Protoporcelain Using Instrumental Neutron Activation Analysis”. J. Archaeol. Sci. 1999. 26(8): 1003–1015.
64.
WoodN.Chinese Glazes: Their Origins, Chemistry, and Recreation., London, UK: A and C Black Publishers, 2011.
MontanariR.MurakamiN.AlberghinaM.F., et al.“The Origin of Overglaze-Blue Enamelling in Japan: New Discoveries and a Reassessment”. J. Cult. Herit. 2019. 37: 94–102.
67.
CoentroS.MimosoJ.M.LimaA.M., et al.“Multi-Analytical Identification of Pigments and Pigment Mixtures Used in 17th Century Portuguese Azulejos”. J. Eur. Ceram. Soc. 2012. 32(1): 37–48.
68.
FischerC.HsiehE.“Export Chinese Blue-and-White Porcelain: Compositional Analysis and Sourcing Using Non-Invasive Portable XRF and Reflectance Spectroscopy”. J. Archaeol. Sci. 2017. 80: 14–26.
69.
MatinM.PollardA.M.“From Ore to Pigment: A Description of the Minerals and an Experimental Study of Cobalt Ore Processing from the Kashan Mine, Iran”. Archaeometry. 2017. 59(4): 731–746.
70.
KesslerA.T.Song Blue and White Porcelain on the Silk Road. Studies in Asian Art and Archaeology. 2012. Vol. 27Leiden, The Netherlands: Brill.
71.
WenR.WangC.S.MaoZ.W., et al.“The Chemical Composition of Blue Pigment on Chinese Blue-and-White Porcelain of the Yuan and Ming Dynasties (AD 1271–1644)”. Archaeometry. 2007. 49(1): 101–115.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
