Frontolateral Vertical Partial Laryngectomy without Tracheotomy for Invasive Squamous Cell Carcinoma of the True Vocal Cord: A 25-Year Experience

Abstract

On the basis of an inception cohort of 270 patients with a previously untreated invasive squamous cell carcinoma of the true vocal cord (232 T1N0M0, 35 T2N0M0, and 3 T3N0M0) and a minimum of 3 years of follow-up, the authors analyze the oncological and functional outcomes following frontolateral vertical partial laryngectomy without tracheotomy. The 5-year Kaplan-Meier actuarial survival estimate ranged from 83.1% for T1 tumors to 67.2% for T2 tumors (p = .005). On univariate analysis, a significant statistical relationship was noted between reduced survival and the following variables: increased age, increased Charlson comorbidity index score over grade 0, increased tobacco intake, increased alcohol intake, increased T stage, local failure, nodal failure, and development of a metachronous second primary cancer. The hospital mortality rate was 0.4%. A significant postoperative surgical complication was noted in 49 patients (18.1%). The predominant significant surgical complication was wound infection (19 patients; 7%), followed by seroma and major subcutaneous emphysema. No significant statistical relationship was noted in a comparison of each significant postoperative complication (including postoperative death) with the variables under analysis. The incidence of secondary tracheotomy was 0.4%. The incidence of completion laryngectomy due to functional problems was 0%. The 5-year Kaplan-Meier actuarial local control estimate was 91% for T1 tumors and 68.7% for T2 tumors (p < .0001). Within the T1 tumors, the 5-year Kaplan-Meier actuarial local control estimate ranged from 96.2% for tumors without anterior commissure involvement to 74.7% for tumors with anterior commissure involvement (p = .0002). On univariate analysis, a significant statistical relationship was noted between an increase in local recurrence and the following variables: increased T stage, anterior commissure involvement, and pathological margin involvement. The overall disease control rate and laryngeal preservation rate were 92.9% and 93.3%, respectively.