Epidemiologic studies of coronary heart disease are heavily dependent on national mortality rates. The diagnostic error for the coronary heart disease is substantial but unquantifiable and is conservatively at least ± 30%. When this error is superimposed on innumerable errors and omissions in the compilation of monocausal mortality rates, the reliability of such vital statistics currently precludes their use for scientific purposes.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Robb-Smith Aht: The Enigma of Coronary Heart Disease. London: Lloyd-Luke, 1967.
2.
Yerushalmy J. , Palmer CE: On the methodology of investigations of etiologic factors in chronic diseases. J Chronic Dis10:27-40, 1959.
3.
Stehbens WE: An appraisal of the epidemic rise of coronary heart disease and its decline . Lancet1:606-611, 1987.
4.
Swartout HO, Webster RG: To what degree are mortality statistics dependable?Am J Public Health30:811-815, 1940.
5.
Abramson JH, Sacks MI, Cahan E.: Death certificate data as an indication of the presence of certain common diseases. J Chronic Dis24:417-431, 1971.
6.
Beadenkopf WG , Abrams M., Daoud A., et al: An assessment of certain medical aspects of death certificate data for epidemiologic study of arteriosclerotic heart disease. J Chronic Dis16:249-262, 1963.
7.
Bourke GJ: Accuracy of death certification. Ir J Med Sci2:35-42, 1969.
8.
Briggs RC: Quality of death certificates diagnosis as compared to autopsy findings . Arizona Med32:617-619, 1975.
9.
Gwynne JF: The unreliability of death certificates. NZ Med J80:336, 1974.
10.
Feinstein AR : Clinical epidemiology. II. The identification rates of disease. Ann Int Med69:1037-1061, 1968.
11.
Cabot RC: Diagnostic pitfalls identified during a study of three thousand autopsies . JAMA59:2295-2298, 1912 .
12.
Gall EA: The necropsy as a tool in medical progress. Bull NY Acad Med44:808-829, 1968.
13.
Waldron A., Vickerstaff L.: Intimations of Quality. Ante-mortem and Post-mortem Diagnosis. London: Nuffield Provincial Hospital Trust , 1977.
14.
Goldman L., Sayson R., Robbins S., et al: The value of the autopsy in three medical eras. N Engl J Med308:1000-1005, 1983.
15.
Battle RM, Anderson RE, Key CR, et al: Factors influencing discrepancies between pre- and postmortem diagnoses . Lab Invest52:5A-6A, 1985.
16.
Levy RL, Bruenn HG, Kurtz D.: Facts on disease of the coronary arteries, based on a survey of the clinical and pathologic records of 762 cases. Am J Med Sci187:376-390, 1934.
17.
Karsner HT, Rothschild L., Crump ES: Clinical diagnosis as compared with necropsy findings. JAMA73:666-669, 1919.
18.
Levine HD, Phillips E.: An appraisal of the newer electrocardiography: Correlations in one hundred and fifty consecutive autopsied cases. N Engl J Med245:833-842, 1951.
19.
Johnson WJ, Achor Rwp, Burchell HB, et al: Unrecognized myocardial infarction. Arch Int Med103:253-261, 1959.
20.
Edwards JE: The value and limitations of necropsy studies in coronary arterial disease . Prog Cardiovasc Dis13:309-323, 1976.
21.
Yater WM, Traum AH, Brown WG, et al: Coronary artery disease in men eighteen to thirty-nine years of age. Report of eight hundred sixty-six cases, four hundred fifty with necropsy examinations. Am Heart J36:334-372, 481-526, 683-722, 1948.
22.
Lundberg GD , Voigt GE: Reliability of a presumptive diagnosis in sudden unexpected death in adults. JAMA242:2328-2330, 1979.
23.
Britton M.: Diagnostic errors discovered at autopsy. Acta Med Scand196:203-210, 1974.
24.
Britton M.: Clinical diagnostics: Experience from 383 autopsied cases. Acta Med Scand196:211-219, 1974.
25.
Cameron HM, McGoogan E.: A prospective study of 1152 hospital autopsies: I. Inaccuracies in death certification . J Pathol133:273-283, 1981.
26.
Cameron HM, McGoogan E.: A prospective study of 1152 hospital autopsies. II. Analysis of inaccuracies in clinical diagnosis and their significance. J Pathol133:285-300, 1981.
27.
Heasman MA, Lipworth L.: Accuracy of Certification of Cause of Death. London : HMSO, 1966.
28.
Holmes FF, Baker LH, Hearne EM, et al: More on reliability of death certificates. N Engl J Med304:737, 1981.
29.
Gau DW, Diehl AK: Disagreement among general practitioners regarding cause of death . Br Med J284:239-241, 1982.
30.
Walford PA: Sudden death in coronary thrombosis. J R Coll Gen Pract21:654-656, 1971.
31.
Asnaes S., Paaske F.: Uncertainty of determining cause of death in a medico-legal material without autopsy. An autopsy study. Forensic Sci Int15:103-114, 1980.
32.
Asnaes S.: The uncertainty of determining the mode and time of death without autopsy . Forensic Sci Int15:191-196, 1980.
33.
Vanatta PR, Petty CS: Limitations of the forensic external examination in determining the cause and manner of death. Hum Pathol18:170-174, 1987.
34.
Moriyama IM , Baum WS, Haenszel WM, et al: Inquiry into diagnostic evidence supporting medical certifications of death. Am J Public Health48:1376-1387, 1958.
35.
Moriyama IM , Dawber TR, Kannel WB: Evaluation of diagnostic information supporting medical certification of deaths from cardiovascular disease. National Cancer Inst Monograph19:405-419, 1966.
36.
Williams LD : Coronary disease mortality data. An assault upon their authenticity. PaMed J62:1113-1115, 1959.
Rose G., Barker Djp: What is epidemiology?Br Med J2:803-804, 1978.
39.
Alderson M.: International Mortality Statistics. Bury St. Edmunds : Edmundsbury Press, 1981.
40.
Moriyama IM, Krueger DF, Stamler J.: Cardiovascular Diseases in the United States. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press, 1971.
41.
Dorn HF, Horn JI: Reliability of certification of deaths from cancer. Am J Hyg (Sect A)34:12-23, 1941.
42.
Moine M.: Sur l'augmentation de quelques causes de décès. Bull de l'Institute National d'Hygiene. 7:279-294, 1952.
43.
Werkö L.: Diet, lipids and heart attacks. Acta Med Scand206:435-439, 1970.
44.
Carruthers M.: Fats on Trial. Tunbridge Wells: Butter Information Council, 1980.
45.
McMichael J. : French wine and death certificates. Lancet1:1186-1187, 1979.
46.
Riccitelli ML : Myocardial disease in the aged, including a review of the literature. J Am Geriatr Soc14:366-379, 1968.
47.
Engel JW, Strauchen JA, Chiazze L., et al: Accuracy on death certification in an autopsied population with specific attention to malignant neoplasms and vascular diseases. Am J Epidemiol111:99-112, 1980.
48.
Busuttil A. , Kemp IW, Heasman MA: The accuracy of medical certificates of cause of death. Health Bul39:146-152, 1981.
49.
Carter JR: The problematic death certificate. N Engl J Med13:1285-1286, 1985.
50.
Nemetz PN, Ludwig J., Kurland LT: Assessing the autopsy. Am J Pathol128:362-379, 1987.
Vlodaver Z. , Frech R., van Tassel RA, et al: Correlation of the antemortem coronary arteriogram and the postmortem specimen. Circulation47:162-169, 1973.
53.
Jacob W.: On quality control and standardization of pathoanatomic findings within the framework of an epidemiological pathology. Pathol Eur (London) 8:253-258, 1973.
54.
Adelson L., Hoffman W.: Sudden death from coronary disease related to a lethal mechanism arising independently of vascular occlusion or myocardial damage. JAMA176:131-135, 1961.
55.
Starr I.: Heart disease as a cause of death. Circulation16:1-2, 1957.
56.
Editorial: The convenient coronary. N Engl J Med262:149-150, 1960.
57.
Reid DD, Rose GA: Assessing the comparability of mortality statistics. Br Med J2:1437-1439, 1964.
58.
Phillips R. , Carson P., Haites N., et al: Variation in mortality from ischaemic heart disease between England and Scotland. Q J Med63:441-448, 1987.
59.
Keys A.: An epidemiological look at atherosclerosis. In: Atherosclerotic Vascular Disease, ed. by Brest AN, Moyer JH.New York: Meredith Publishing Company, 1967, pp 76-83.
60.
Green A., Donald KJ: Necropsy as a control of death certification. Some unexpected findings . Med J Aust2:131-132, 1976.
61.
Urano Y., Aizama S., Baba K., et al: Statistics of Intractable Diseases from the Autopsy Data in Japan. Tokyo: The Ministry of Health and Welfare of Japan, 1987.
62.
Hiyoshi Y., Omae T., Hirota Y., et al: Clinicopathological study of the heart and coronary arteries of autopsied cases from the community for Hisayama during a 10 year period. I. Ischaemic myocardial lesions. J Chronic Dis31:313-319, 1978.
63.
Davis BR, Curb JD, Tung B., et al: Standardized physician preparation of death certificates. Controlled Clin Trials8:110-120, 1987.
64.
Markush RE: National chronic respiratory disease mortality study. I. Prevalence and severity at death of a chronic respiratory disease in the United States, 1963. J Chronic Dis21:129-141, 1968.
65.
Markush RE: National chronic respiratory disease mortality study. II. Mortality associated with persistent cough and phlegm in the United States, 1963, J Chronic Dis21:737-748, 1969.
66.
Dunn HL: 1956 revisions of standard birth and death certificates. JAMA159:1184-1186, 1955.
67.
Guralnick L. : Some problems in the use of multiple causes of death. J Chronic Dis19:979-990, 1966.
68.
Battle RM, Pathak D., Humble CG, et al: Factors influencing discrepancies between premortem and postmortem diagnoses. JAMA258:339-344, 1987.
69.
Dorn HF, Moriyama IM: Uses and significance of multiple cause tabulations for mortality statistics . Am J Public Health54:400-406, 1964.
70.
Wiener L., Bellows MT, McAvoy GH, et al: Use of multiple causes in the classification of deaths from cardiovascular-renal diseases. Am J Public health45:492-501, 1955.
71.
Markush RE, Seigel DG: Prevalence at death. I. A new method for deriving death rates for specific diseases. Am J publicHealth58:544-557, 1968.
72.
Curb JD, Babcock C., Pressel S., et al: Nosological coding of cause of death. Am J Epidemiol118:122-128, 1983.
73.
World Health Statistics Annual 1985. Geneva : World Health Organization, 1985 .
74.
Epstein FH: The epidemiology of coronary heart disease. A review. J Chronic Dis18:735-774, 1965.
75.
Law EA: Some implications of mortality statistics relating to coronary artery disease . J Chronic Dis6:192-209, 1957.
76.
Klebba AJ, Maurer JD, Glass EJ: Mortality Trends for Leading Causes of Death: United States, 1950-69 . US Dept of Health, Education and Welfare, Series 20, No 16, Rockville, Maryland: National Center for Health Statistics , 1974.
