A New Technique for the Quantification of Peripheral Edema with Application in Both Unilateral and Bilateral Cases

Abstract

Current noninvasive techniques for the routine and frequent quantification of peripheral lymphedema in patients are total limb volume measurement (by water immersion or by circumferential measurements) and bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA). However both of these techniques require standardizing the measurement using a contralateral measurement from the unaffected limb. Hence these techniques are essentially restricted to unilateral lymphedema. This paper describes the results from a preliminary study to investigate an alter native approach to the analysis of the data from multiple frequency BIA to produce an index of lymphedema without the need for normalization to another body segment. Twenty patients receiving surgical treatment for breast cancer were monitored prior to surgery and again after diagnosis with unilateral lymphedema. The data recorded were total limb volume, by circumferential measurements; and BIA measurements of both limbs. From these measure ments total limb volumes and extracellular fluid volumes were calculated and expressed as ratios of the affected limb to that of the unaffected limb. An index of the ratio of the extra cellular fluid volume to the intracellular fluid volume was determined. This ECW/ICW index was calculated for both the affected and unaffected limbs at both measurement times. Results confirmed that the established techniques of total limb volume and extracellular fluid volume normalized to the unaffected contralateral limb were accurate in the detection of lymphedema (p < 10^-6). Comparison of the ECW/ICW index from the affected limb after diagnosis with that from the pre-surgery measurement revealed a significant (p < 10^-6) and considerable (75%) increase. The results of this pilot study suggest that by using multiple frequency bioelectrical impedance analysis, an index of the ECW/ICW ratio can be obtained and this index appears to have an equal, or better, sensitivity than the other techniques in detecting lymphedema. More importantly, this index does not require normalization to another body segment and can be used to detect all types of peripheral edema including both unilateral and bilateral lymphedema.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Casley-Smith JR : Discussion of the definition, diagnosis and treatment of lymphoedema (lymphostatic disorder). In Progress in Lymphology, X. Int Congr Lymphol 1:5, 1985.

Casley-Smith JR , Casley-Smith JR : Physical therapy for lymphoedema . Med J Aust 150:542-543, 1989.

Tobin MB , Lacey HJ , Meyer L. , et al: The psychosocial morbidity of breast cancer-related arm swelling . Cancer 72:3248-3252, 1993 .

Petrek JA , Heelan MC : Incidence of breast carcinoma-related lymphedema. Cancer 83:2776-2781, 1998.

Barns MD , Mani R. , Barrett DF , et al: How to measure changes in oedema in patients with chronic venous ulcers. Phlebology 7:31-35, 1992.

Petlund CF : Volumetry of limbs. In: Lymph Stasis: Pathophysiology, Diagnosis and Treatment, ed. by Olszewski WL. London: Chemical Rubber Co, 1991 , pp 443-451.

Perrin M. , Guex JJ : Edema and leg volume: Methods of assessment. Angiology 51:9-12, 2000.

Stanton Awb , Badger C. , Sitzia J. : Non-invasive assessment of the lymphoedatous limb. Lymphology 33:122-135, 2000.

Piller N. , Cornish BH : Bioimpedance and tonometry: Benefits and limitations as diagnostic tools in lymph and other oedemas. Third Aust Lymphol Conf 49:58, 2000.

10.

Cornish BH , Bunce IH , Ward LC , et al: Bioelectrical impedance for monitoring the efficacy of lymphoedema treatment programmes. Breast Cancer Res Treat 38:169-176, 1996.

11.

Cornish BH , Chapman M. , Thomas BJ , et al: Early diagnosis of lymphoedema in postsurgery breast cancer patients. Ann NY Acad Sci 904:571-575, 2000.

12.

Cornish BH , Chapman M. , Hirst C. , et al: Early diagnosis of lymphoedema using multiple frequency bioimpedance . Lymphology (submitted for publication).

13.

Mikes DM , Cha BA , Dym CI , et al: Bioelectrical impedance analysis revisited. Lymphology 32:157-165, 1999.

14.

Cornish BH , Thomas BJ , Ward LC : Improved prediction of extracellular and total body water using impedance loci generated by multiple frequency bioelectrical impedance analysis. Phys Med Biol 38 :337-346,1993.

15.

Kaulesar Sukul Dmks , den Hoed PT , Johannes EJ , et al: Direct and indirect methods for the quantification of leg volume: Comparison between water displacement volumetry, the disk model method and the frustum sign model method, using the correlation coefficient and the limits of agreement. J Biomed Engl 15:477-480, 1993.

16.

Thomas BJ , Ward LC , Cornish BH : Bioimpedance spectrometry in the determination of body water compartments: Accuracy and clinical significance. J Appl Radioisotopes 49:447-455, 1998.

17.

Hanai T. : Electrical properties of emulsions. In: Emulsion Science , ed. by Sherman PH. London: Academic, 1968, pp 354,477.

18.

van Loan MD , Withers P. , Matthie J. , et al: Use of bioimpedance spectroscopy to determine extracellular fluid, intracellular fluid, total body water and fat-free mass. Basic Life Sci 60:67-70, 1993.

19.

Aburahma AF , Woodruff BA , Lucente FC : Edema after femoropopliteal surgery: Lymphatic and venous theories of causation. J Vasc Surg 11:461-467, 1990.