Clinical utility of algorithms to diagnose ventilator-associated pneumonia (VAP) in surgical patients has not been established. We aimed to test the diagnostic accuracy of two established methods to reliably diagnose VAP in acutely ill and injured surgical patients. After institutional review board approval, we prospectively collected data on 508 mechanically ventilated acute care surgery patients. Microbiologic samples were taken daily from all patients. Demographics, clinical, laboratory, and radiographic data were collected. The Johanson Criteria (JC) and Clinical Pulmonary Infection Score (CPIS) were calculated and analyzed. Sensitivity, specificity, and positive predictive values (PPV) and negative predictive value (NPV) were calculated in comparison to positive respiratory cultures. Of the 508 patients, 312 (61.4%) were acutely injured; emergent general surgery was performed in 141 (27.8%) patients, and 54 (10.6%) underwent elective operation. Positive respiratory cultures were identified in 198 (39%) of the 508 patients. JC diagnosed VAP in 291 (57.3%) patients (sensitivity 82.8%, specificity 59%, PPV 56.4%, NPV 84.3%, accuracy 68.3%). The CPIS resulted in 189 (37.2%) VAP diagnoses (sensitivity 61.1%, specificity 78.1%, PPV 64%, NPV 75.9%, and accuracy 71.5%). To address the inaccuracy of the algorithms, concordance testing was performed on the data to evaluate correlation between the algorithmic VAP diagnosis criteria and respiratory culture data. Nonconcordance with culture data diagnosis was identified with both JC (rho 0.41) and CPIS (rho 0.41). Sensitivity, specificity, PPV and NPV, and accuracy of both established clinical formulas was unacceptably low in acute care surgery patients.
BirdD., ZambutoA., O'DonnellC.Adherence to ventilator-associated pneumonia bundle and incidence of ventilator-associated pneumonia in the surgical intensive care unit.Arch Surg2010; 145: 465–70.
MichettiC.P., FakhryS.M., FergusonP.L.AAST Ventilator-Associated Pneumonia Investigators. Ventilator-associated pneumonia rates at major trauma centers compared with a national benchmark: a multi-institutional study of the AAST.J Trauma2012; 72: 1165–73.
5.
ErtugrulB.M., YildirimA., AyP.Ventilator-associated pneumonia in the surgical emergency intensive care unit.Saudi Med J2006; 27: 52–7.
6.
WahlW.L., ZalewskiC., HemmilaM.R.Pneumonia in the surgical intensive care unit: is every one preventable?Surgery2011; 150: 665–72.
7.
FabregasN., EwigS., TorresA.Clinical diagnosis of ventilator associated pneumonia revisited: comparative validation using immediate post-mortem lung biopsies.Thorax1999; 54: 867–73.
8.
RichardsonJ.D., AdamsL., FlintL.M.Selective management of flail chest and pulmonary contusion.Ann Surg1982; 196: 481–7.
9.
KronerA., Van IperenE., HornJ.The low therapeutic efficacy of postoperative radiographs for surgical intensive care unit patients.Minerva Anestesiol2011; 77: 147–53.
10.
ClaridgeJ.A., GolobJ.F.Jr., LeukhardtW.H.The “fever workup” and respiratory culture practice in critically ill trauma patients.J Crit Care2010; 25: 493–500.
11.
MassardG., WihlmJ.M.Postoperative atelectasis.Chest Surg Clin N Am1998; 8: 503–28.
12.
TriulziD.J.Transfusion-related acute lung injury: current concepts for the clinician.Anesth Analg2009; 108: 770–6.
13.
WoskeH.J., RodingT., SchulzI.Ventilator-associated pneumonia in a surgical intensive care unit: epidemiology, etiology and comparison of three bronchoscopic methods for microbiological specimen sampling.Critical Care2001; 5: 167–73.
14.
JohansonW.G., PierceA.K., SanfordJ.P.Nosocomial respiratory infections with gram-negative bacilli. The significance of colonization of the respiratory tract.Ann Int Med1972; 77: 701–6.
15.
PuginJ., AuckenthalerR., MiliN.Diangosis of ventilator-associated pneumonia by bacteriologic analysis of bronchoscopic and nonbronchoscopic “blind” bronchoalveolar lavage fluid.Am Rev Respir Dis1991; 143: 112–29.
16.
ZilbergbefgM.D., ShorrA.F.Ventilator-associated pneumonia: the clinical pulmonary infection score as a surrogate for diagnostics and outcome.Clin Infect Dis2010; 51: S131–5.
17.
CelikO., KoltkaN., DevrimS.Clinical pulmonary infection score calculator in the early diagnosis and treatment of ventilator-associated pneumonia in the ICU.Critical Care2014; 18: P304.
18.
ParksN.A., MagnottiL.J., WeinbergJ.A.Use of the clinical pulmonary infection score to guide therapy for ventilator-associated pneumonia risks antibiotic overexposure in patients with trauma.J Trauma Acute Care Surg2012; 73: 52–9.
19.
WoodA.Y., DavitA.J., CirauloD.L.A prospective assessment of diagnostic efficacy of blind protective bronchial brushings compared to bronchoscope-assisted lavage, bronchoscope-directed brushings and blind endotracheal aspirates in ventilator-associated pneumonia.J Trauma2003; 55: 825–34.
20.
PieracciF., RodilM., HaenelJ.Pneumonia in the surgical intensive care unit: single-institution analysis of 1013 bronchoalveolar lavage. Abstract presented at Surgical Infections Society, 34th Annual Meeting 2014, Baltimore, MD, May 1–3, 2014.
21.
ShanJ., ChenH.L., ZhuJ.H.Diagnostic accuracy of clinical pulmonary infection score for ventilator-associated pneumonia: a meta-analysis.Respir Care2011; 56: 1087–94.
22.
CroceM.A., SwansonJ.M., MagnottiL.J.The futility of the clinical pulmonary infection score in trauma patients.J Trauma2006; 60: 523–8.
23.
SkrupkyL.P., McConnellK., DallasJ.A comparison of ventilator-associated pneumonia rates as identified according to the National Healthcare Safety Network and American College of Chest Physicians criteria.Crit Care Med2012; 40: 281–4.
