All-terrain vehicle (ATV) safety laws, including helmet use, vary by state and are sporadically enforced. Kentucky state laws require safety helmets only for younger riders. We hypothesized that ATV riders injured in Kentucky and seen at a Tennessee trauma center would more likely be unhelmeted, have more severe head injuries, and have higher mortality rates than those injured in Virginia or Tennessee. A Trauma Registry review of 750 injured ATV riders from June 1, 2005, through June 1, 2015 examined state location of accident, helmet use, markers of injury severity, and outcomes. Multiple logistic regression analysis examined predictors of severe head injuries and death with P < 0.05 significant. Unhelmeted ATV rider status predicted more severe head injuries (relative risk 23.5, P < 0.001) and death (relative risk 4.6, P < 0.001). ATV riders injured in the state of Kentucky were twice as numerous. In addition, they were more likely than ATVriders injured in Tennessee or Virginia to be unhelmeted, to have severe head injuries, and to sustain fatal injuries (all P < 0.001). This single trauma center study lends support for maintaining and enforcing current universal helmet laws for ATVriders of all ages in states where they are in effect and highlights the need to upgrade helmet laws that apply only to some riders.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
TestermanG.M., AndersonD.R., BeattyJ.S.All-terrain vehicle accident trends at a Tennessee trauma center in 2014.Am Surg2015; 81: E128–9.
2.
TestermanG.M., MatrischM.S., HensleyS.Increased severe all-terrain vehicle accidents at a rural Tennessee trauma center despite safety legislation.Am Surg2013; 79: E204–5.
3.
TestermanG.M.300 all-terrain vehicle crashes: an East Tennessee trauma center's experience.Tenn Med2009; 102: 45–7.
4.
HelmkampJ.C., AitkenM.E., GrahamJ.State-specific ATV-related fatality rates: an update in the new millennium.Public Health Rep2012; 127: 364–74.
5.
Specialty Vehicle Institute of America (SVIA).State All-Terrain Vehicle Requirements.SVIA Government Relations office, 2012.
6.
HanseenJ., ShinkleD.All-Terrain Vehicle Laws by State.Denver, CO: National Conference of State Legislatures, 2014.
7.
WinfieldR.D., MozingoD.W., ArmstrongJ.H.All-terrain vehicle safety in Florida: is legislation really the answer?Am Surg2010; 76: 149–53.
JinnahH., StonemanZ.Age- and gender-based patterns in youth all-terrain vehicle (ATV) riding behaviors.J Agromedicine2016; 21: 163–70.
12.
HelmkampJ.C., AitkenM.E., LawrenceB.A.ATVand bicycle deaths and associated costs in the United States, 2000-2005.Public Health Rep2009; 124: 409–18.
13.
HelmkampJ.C., BiddleE., MarshS.M.The economic burden of all-terrain vehicle related adult deaths in the U.S. workplace, 2003–2006.J Agric Saf Health2012; 18: 233–43.
14.
RaderR.Hundreds die in ATV crashes on public roads.Insurance Institute for Highway Safety Status Report, Vol 48, No 9, 2013.
15.
WilliamsA.F., OeschS.L., McCarttA.T.On-road all-terrain vehicle (ATV) fatalities in the United States.J Safety Res2014; 50: 117–23.
16.
DenningG.M., JennissenC.A.All-terrain vehicle fatalities on paved roads, unpaved roads, and off-road: evidence for informed roadway safety warnings and legislation.Traffic Inj Prev2016; 17: 406–12.
17.
BuckleyL., BinghamC.R., FlannaganC.A.Observation of motorcycle helmet use rates in Michigan after partial repeal of the universal motorcycle helmet law.Accid Anal Prev2016; 95: 178–86.
18.
RostasJ.W., DonnellanK.A., GonzalezR.P.Helmet use is associated with a decrease in intracranial hemorrhage following all-terrain vehicle crashes.J Trauma Acute Care Surg2014; 76: 201–4.
19.
ButtsC.C., RostasJ.W., LeeY.L.Larger ATV engine size correlates with an increased rate of traumatic brain injury.Injury2015; 46: 625–8.
