Bridging research in social psychology with scholarship on racialized organizations, this article shows how individual bias and organizational demographic composition can operate together to shape the degree of discrimination in schools. To understand Black and Latino boys’ higher rates of discipline that persist net of differences in behavior, I combine an original video experiment involving 1,339 teachers in 295 U.S. schools with organizational data on school racial/ethnic and socioeconomic composition. In the experiment, teachers view and respond to a randomly assigned video of a White, Black, or Latino boy committing identical, routine classroom misbehavior. I find that, compared to White boys, Black and Latino boys face a double jeopardy. They experience both (1) individual-level teacher bias, where they are perceived as being more “blameworthy” and referred more readily for identical misbehavior, and (2) racialized organizational climates of heightened blaming, where students of all races/ethnicities are perceived as being more “blameworthy” for identical misbehavior in schools with large minority populations versus in predominantly White schools. This study develops a more comprehensive understanding of the production of racial/ethnic inequality in school discipline by empirically identifying a dual process that involves both individual teacher bias and heightened blaming that is related to minority organizational composition.
AngristJoshua D.PischkeJörn-Steffen. 2008. Mostly Harmless Econometrics: An Empiricistś Companion. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
2.
AnyonYolandaGregoryAnneStoneSusanFarrarJordanJensonJeffrey M.McQueenJeanetteDowningBarbaraGreerEldridgeSimmonsJohn. 2016. “Restorative Interventions and School Discipline Sanctions in A Large Urban School District.” American Educational Research Journal53(6):1663–97.
3.
AnyonYolandaJensonJeffrey M.AltschulInnaFarrarJordanMcQueenJeanetteGreerEldridgeDowningBarbaraSimmonsJohn. 2014. “The Persistent Effect of Race and the Promise of Alternatives to Suspension in School Discipline Outcomes.” Children and Youth Services Review44:379–86.
BoboLawrence D.CharlesCamille Z.KrysanMariaSimmonsAlicia D.2012. “The Real Record on Racial Attitudes.” In Social Trends in American Life: Findings from the General Social Survey since 1972, edited by MarsdenP.Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
6.
BradshawCatherine P.MitchellMary M.O’BrennanLindsey M.LeafPhilip J.2010. “Multilevel Exploration of Factors Contributing to the Overrepresentation of Black Students in Office Disciplinary Referrals.” Journal of Educational Psychology102(2):508–20.
7.
CardDavidMasAlexandreRothsteinJesse. 2008. “Tipping and the Dynamics of Segregation.” The Quarterly Journal of Economics123(1):177–218.
8.
ChiricosTedWelchKellyGertzMarc. 2004. “Racial Typification of Crime and Support for Punitive Measures.” Criminology42(2):358–90.
9.
CoburnCynthia E.SteinMary Kay. 2006. “Communities of Practice Theory and the Role of Teacher Professional Community in Policy Implementation.” Pp. 25–46 in New Directions in Education Policy Implementation: Confronting Complexity, edited by HonigM. I.Albany: SUNY Press.
10.
CollinsPatricia Hill. 2015. “Intersectionality’s Definitional Dilemmas.” Annual Review of Sociology41:1–20.
11.
EdwardsLinsey. 2016. “Homogeneity and Inequality: School Discipline Inequality and the Role of Racial Composition.” Social Forces95(1):55–76.
12.
ElliottSinikkaReidMegan. 2019. “Low-Income Black Mothers Parenting Adolescents in the Mass Incarceration Era: The Long Reach of Criminalization.” American Sociological Review84(2):197–219.
13.
EwingEve L.2018. Ghosts in the Schoolyard: Racism and School Closings on Chicago’s South Side. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
14.
FergusonAnn A.2001. Bad Boys: Public Schools in the Making of Black Masculinity. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
15.
FielJeremy E.ZhangYongjun. 2019. “With All Deliberate Speed: The Reversal of Court-Ordered School Desegregation, 1970–2013.” American Journal of Sociology124(6):1685–719.
16.
FishRachel E.2019. “Standing Out and Sorting In: Exploring the Role of Racial Composition in Racial Disparities in Special Education.” American Educational Research Journal56(6):2573–608.
17.
GarlandDavid. 2012. Punishment and Modern Society: A Study in Social Theory. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
18.
GilliamWalter S.MaupinAngela N.ReyesChin R.AccavittiMariaShicFrederick. 2016. “Do Early Educators’ Implicit Biases Regarding Sex and Race Relate to Behavior Expectations and Recommendations of Preschool Expulsions and Suspensions?” Pp. 991–1013 in Yale Child Study Center. New Haven, CT: Yale University.
19.
GolannJoanne W.2021. Scripting the Moves: Culture and Control in a “No-Excuses” Charter School. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
20.
GregoryAnneHuangFrancis L.AnyonYolandaGreerEldridgeDowningBarbara. 2018. “An Examination of Restorative Interventions and Racial Equity in Out-of-School Suspensions.” School Psychology Review47(2):167–82.
21.
GregoryAnneSkibaRussell J.NogueraPedro A.2010. “The Achievement Gap and the Discipline Gap: Two Sides of the Same Coin?” Educational Researcher39(1):59–68.
22.
HaghighatRahman. 2007. “The Development of the Brief Social Desirability Scale (BSDS).” Europe’s Journal of Psychology3(4) (https://doi.org/10.5964/ejop.v3i4.417).
23.
HarrellFrank E.2015. Regression Modeling Strategies: With Applications to Linear Models, Logistic and Ordinal Regression, and Survival Analysis. New York: Springer.
24.
HaskinsAnna R.JacobsenWade C.2017. “Schools as Surveilling Institutions? Paternal Incarceration, System Avoidance, and Parental Involvement in Schooling.” American Sociological Review82(4):657–84.
25.
ImaiKosukeKeeleLukeTingleyDustinYamamotoTeppei. 2011. “Unpacking the Black Box of Causality: Learning about Causal Mechanisms from Experimental and Observational Studies.” American Political Science Review105(4):765–89.
26.
Ispa-LandaSimone. 2013. “Gender, Race, and Justifications for Group Exclusion: Urban Black Students Bussed to Affluent Suburban Schools.” Sociology of Education86(3):218–33.
27.
JamesLoisVilaBryanDarathaKenn. 2013. “Results from Experimental Trials Testing Participant Responses to White, Hispanic and Black Suspects in High-Fidelity Deadly Force Judgment and Decision-Making Simulations.” Journal of Experimental Criminology9(2):189–212.
28.
JarvisShoshana N.OkonofuaJason A.2020. “School Deferred: When Bias Affects School Leaders.” Social Psychological and Personality Science11(4):492–98.
29.
KarlsonKristian B.HolmAndersBreenRichard. 2012. “Comparing Regression Coefficients between Same-Sample Nested Models Using Logit and Probit: A New Method.” Sociological Methodology42(1):286–313.
30.
KhmelkovVladimir T.HallinanMaureen T.1999. “Organizational Effects on Race Relations in Schools.” Journal of Social Issues55(4):627–45.
31.
KinslerJosh. 2011. “Understanding the Black–White School Discipline Gap.” Economics of Education Review30(6):1370–83.
32.
KrysanMariaCouperMick P.FarleyReynoldsFormanTyrone. 2009. “Does Race Matter in Neighborhood Preferences? Results from a Video Experiment.” American Journal of Sociology115(2):527–27.
33.
Lara-MillánArmandoVan CleveNicole Gonzalez. 2017. “Interorganizational Utility of Welfare Stigma in the Criminal Justice System.” Criminology55(1):59–84.
34.
LeBretonJames M.SenterJenell L.2008. “Answers to 20 Questions about Interrater Reliability and Interrater Agreement.” Organizational Research Methods11(4):815–52.
35.
LegewieJoscha. 2016. “Racial Profiling and Use of Force in Police Stops: How Local Events Trigger Periods of Increased Discrimination.” American Journal of Sociology122(2):379–424.
36.
LewisAmanda E.DiamondJohn B.2015. Despite the Best Intentions: How Racial Inequality Thrives in Good Schools. New York: Oxford University Press.
37.
LoebSusannaDarling-HammondLindaLuczakJohn. 2005. “How Teaching Conditions Predict Teacher Turnover in California Schools.” Peabody Journal of Education80(3):44–70.
38.
MittlemanJoel. 2018. “A Downward Spiral? Childhood Suspension and the Path to Juvenile Arrest.” Sociology of Education91(3):183–204.
39.
MorrisEdward W.PerryBrea L.2016. “The Punishment Gap: School Suspension and Racial Disparities in Achievement.” Social Problems63(1): 68–86.
40.
MorrisEdward W.PerryBrea L.2017. “Girls Behaving Badly? Race, Gender, and Subjective Evaluation in the Discipline of African American Girls.” Sociology of Education90(2):127–48.
41.
MorrisMonique. 2016. Pushout: The Criminalization of Black Girls in Schools. New York: New Press.
42.
NäherAnatol-FieteKrumpalIvar. 2012. “Asking Sensitive Questions: The Impact of Forgiving Wording and Question Context on Social Desirability Bias.” Quality & Quantity46(5):1601–16.
43.
National Center for Education Statistics, U.S. Department of Education. 2022. “Common Core of Data-Data Files” (https://nces.ed.gov/ccd/ccddata.asp).
44.
Office of Civil Rights, U.S. Department of Education. 2020. “2017–18 Civil Rights Data Collection.” Washington, DC: Office of Civil Rights.
45.
OkonofuaJason A.EberhardtJennifer L.2015. “Two Strikes: Race and the Disciplining of Young Students.” Psychological Science26(5):617–24.
46.
OkonofuaJason A.PauneskuDavidWaltonGregory M.2016. “Brief Intervention to Encourage Empathic Discipline Cuts Suspension Rates in Half among Adolescents.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences113(19):5221–26.
47.
OwensJayanti. 2016. “Early Childhood Behavior Problems and the Gender Gap in Educational Attainment in the United States.” Sociology of Education89(3):236–58.
48.
OwensJayantiMasseyDouglas S.2011. “Stereotype Threat and College Academic Performance: A Latent Variables Approach.” Social Science Research40(1):150–66.
49.
OwensJayantiMcLanahanSara. 2020. “Unpacking the Drivers of Racial Disparities in School Suspension and Expulsion in the U.S.” Social Forces98(4):1548–77.
50.
PagerDevah. 2007. Marked: Race, Crime, and Finding Work in an Era of Mass Incarceration. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
51.
PagerDevahShepherdHana. 2008. “The Sociology of Discrimination: Racial Discrimination in Employment, Housing, Credit, and Consumer Markets.” Annual Review of Sociology34:181–209.
52.
PegueroAnthony A.ShekarkharZahra. 2011. “Latino/a Student Misbehavior and School Punishment.” Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences33(1):54–70.
53.
PetrilliMichael J.2012. The Diverse Schools Dilemma: A Parent’s Guide to Socioeconomically Mixed Public Schools. Washington, DC: Thomas B. Fordham Institute.
54.
PodolskyAnneKiniTaraDarling-HammondLindaBishopJoseph. 2019. “Strategies for Attracting and Retaining Educators: What Does the Evidence Say?” Education Policy Analysis Archives27(38):1–44.
55.
RameyDavid M.2015. “The Social Structure of Criminalized and Medicalized School Discipline.” Sociology of Education88(3):181–201.
56.
RayVictor. 2019. “A Theory of Racialized Organizations.” American Sociological Review84(1):26–53.
57.
RayVictorPurifoyDanielle. 2019. “The Colorblind Organization.” Pp. 131–50 in Race, Organizations, and the Organizing Process, edited by WootenM. E.Bingley, UK: Emerald Publishing Limited.
58.
RiosVictor M.2011. Punished: Policing the Lives of Black and Latino Boys. New York: NYU Press.
59.
RocqueMichael. 2010. “Office Discipline and Student Behavior: Does Race Matter?” American Journal of Education116(4):557–81.
60.
RooksNoliwe. 2017. Cutting School: Privatization, Segregation, and the End of Public Education. New York: New Press.
61.
RuedaEréndira. 2015. “The Benefits of Being Latino: Differential Interpretations of Student Behavior and the Social Construction of Being Well Behaved.” Journal of Latinos and Education14(4):275–90.
62.
RuleNicholasAmbadyNalini. 2010. “First Impressions of the Face: Predicting Success.” Social and Personality Psychology Compass4(8):506–16.
63.
SchneiderBenjamin. 1987. “The People Make the Place.” Personnel Psychology40(3):437–53.
64.
SchulmanKevin A.BerlinJesse A.HarlessWilliamKernerJon F.SistrunkShyrlGershBernard J.DubeRossTaleghaniChristopher K.BurkeJennifer E.WilliamsSankey. 1999. “The Effect of Race and Sex on Physicians’ Recommendations for Cardiac Catheterization.” New England Journal of Medicine340(8):618–26.
65.
SewellGrahamBarkerJames R.2006. “Coercion versus Care: Using Irony to Make Sense of Organizational Surveillance.” Academy of Management Review31(4):934–61.
66.
SheddCarla. 2015. Unequal City: Race, Schools, and Perceptions of Injustice. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
67.
SkibaRussell J.ChungChoong-GeunTrachokMeganBakerTimberly L.SheyaAdamHughesRobin L.2014. “Parsing Disciplinary Disproportionality: Contributions of Infraction, Student, and School Characteristics to Out-of-School Suspension and Expulsion.” American Educational Research Journal51(4):640–70.
68.
SkibaRussell J.HornerRobert H.ChungChoong-GeunRauschM. KaregaMaySeth L.TobinTary. 2011. “Race Is Not Neutral: A National Investigation of African American and Latino Disproportionality in School Discipline.” School Psychology Review40(1):85–107.
69.
SkibaRussell J.PetersonReece. 1999. “The Dark Side of Zero Tolerance: Can Punishment Lead to Safe Schools?” The Phi Delta Kappan80(5):372–82.
70.
SkibaRussell J.PetersonReece L.WilliamsTara. 1997. “Office Referrals and Suspension: Disciplinary Intervention in Middle Schools.” Education and Treatment of Children20(3):295–315.
71.
SmolkowskiKeithGirvanErik J.McintoshKentNeseRhonda N. T.HornerRobert H.2016. “Vulnerable Decision Points for Disproportionate Office Discipline Referrals: Comparisons of Discipline for African American and White Elementary School Students.” Behavioral Disorders41(4):178–95.
72.
SpillaneJames P.ReiserBrian J.ReimerTodd. 2002. “Policy Implementation and Cognition: Reframing and Refocusing Implementation Research.” Review of Educational Research72(3):387–431.
73.
SteffensmeierDarrellUlmerJefferyKramerJohn. 1998. “The Interaction of Race, Gender, and Age in Criminal Sentencing: The Punishment Cost of Being Young, Black, and Male.” Criminology36(4):763–98.
74.
StewartEric A.MartinezRamiroJr.BaumerEric P.GertzMarc. 2015. “The Social Context of Latino Threat and Punitive Latino Sentiment.” Social Problems62(1):68–92.
75.
StewartMahala DyerGarcíaAshleyPetersenHannah. 2021. “Schools as Racialized Organizations in Policy and Practice.” Sociology Compass15(12):1–13.
76.
Tomaskovic-DeveyDonaldAvent-HoltDustin. 2019. Relational Inequalities: An Organizational Approach. New York: Oxford University Press.
77.
TurcoCatherine J.2010. “Cultural Foundations of Tokenism: Evidence from the Leveraged Buyout Industry.” American Sociological Review75(6):894–913.
78.
Van MaanenJohn E.ScheinEdgar H.1979. “Toward a Theory of Organizational Socialization.” Research in Organizational Behavior1:209–64.
79.
VavrusFrancesColeKimMarie. 2002. ‘“I Didn’t Do Nothin’: The Discursive Construction of School Suspension.” The Urban Review34(2):87–111.
80.
WallaceJohn M.GoodkindSaraWallaceCynthia M.BachmanJerald G.2008. “Racial, Ethnic, and Gender Differences in School Discipline among U.S. High School Students: 1991–2005.” The Negro Educational Review59(1–2):47–62.
81.
WeinsteinRhona S.2002. Reaching Higher: The Power of Expectations in Schooling. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
82.
WelchKellyPayneAllison A.2010. “Racial Threat and Punitive School Discipline.” Social Problems57(1):25–48.
83.
WelchKellyPayneAllison A.2018. “Latino/a Student Threat and School Disciplinary Policies and Practices.” Sociology of Education91(2):91–110.
84.
WelchKellyPayneAllison AnnChiricosTedGertzMarc. 2011. “The Typification of Hispanics as Criminals and Support for Punitive Crime Control Policies.” Social Science Research40(3):822–40.
WolfKerrin C.KupchikAaron. 2017. “School Suspensions and Adverse Experiences in Adulthood.” Justice Quarterly34(3):407–30.
87.
WootenMelissa E.CoulouteLucius. 2017. “The Production of Racial Inequality within and among Organizations.” Sociology Compass11(1):1–10.
88.
WuLawrence L.2003. “Book Review: Nonparametric Simple Regression: Smoothing Scatterplots, by John Fox.” Sociological Methods & Research31(4):550–57.
89.
WyerNatalie A.2010. “You Never Get a Second Chance to Make a First (Implicit) Impression: The Role of Elaboration in the Formation and Revision of Implicit Impressions.” Social Cognition28(1):1–19.
90.
ZerubavelEviatar. 2002. “The Elephant in the Room: Notes on the Social Organization of Denial.” Pp. 21–27 in Culture in Mind: Toward a Sociology of Culture and Cognition, edited by CeruloK. A.New York: Routledge.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
