An underlying premise of democratic politics is that protest can be an effective form of civic engagement that shapes policy changes desired by marginalized groups. But it is not certain that this premise holds up under scrutiny. This article presents a three-part argument that protest (1) signals the salience of a movement’s focal issue and expands awareness that an issue is a social problem requiring a solution, (2) empowers residents in disadvantaged communities and raises a sense of community cohesion, which together (3) raise costs and exert pressure on elites to make concessions. The empirical analysis examines the likelihood that a city will establish a civilian review board (CRB). It then compares the effects of protest and CRB presence on counts of officer-involved fatalities by race and ethnicity. Two main hypotheses about the effect of protest are supported: cities with more protest against police brutality are significantly more likely to establish a CRB, and protest against police brutality reduces officer-involved fatalities for African American and Latino (but not for White) individuals. However, the establishment of CRBs does not reduce fatalities, as some have hoped. Nonetheless, mobilizing against police brutality matters, even in the absence of civilian review boards.
AmentaEdwinAndrewsKenneth T.CarenNeal. 2019. “The Political Institutions, Processes, and Outcomes Movements Seek to Influence.” Pp. 449–65 in The Wiley Blackwell Companion to Social Movements, edited by SnowD. A.SouleS. A.KriesiH.McCammonH.Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.
AndrewsKenneth T.2001. “Social Movements and Policy Implementation: The Mississippi Civil Rights Movement and the War on Poverty, 1965 to 1971.”American Sociological Review66(1):71–95.
4.
BaumgartnerFrank R.LeechBeth L.1998. The Importance of Groups in Politics and in Political Science. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
5.
BeckCharlesUchidaCraig D.2019. “The Accuracy of Officer-Involved Shooting Data: A Response to ‘The Limitations of Government Databases for Analyzing Fatal Officer-Involved Shootings in the United States.’”Criminal Justice Policy Review30(3):359–73 (https://doi.org/10.1177/0887403417718339).
6.
BejanVladimirHickmanMatthewParkinWilliam S.PozoVeronica. 2018. “Primed for Death: Law Enforcement-Citizen Homicides, Social Media and Retaliatory Violence.”PLoS ONE13(1):e0190571 (https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0190571).
7.
BiggsMichaelAndrewsKenneth T.2015. “Protest Campaigns and Movement Success: Desegregating the U.S. South in the Early 1960s.”American Sociological Review80(2):416–43.
8.
BlackwellMatthewIacusStefanoKingGaryPorroGiuseppe. 2009. “CEM: Coarsened Exact Matching in Stata.”Stata Journal9(4):524–46.
BursteinPaulLintonApril. 2002. “The Impact of Political Parties, Interest Groups, and Social Movement Organizations on Public Policy: Some Recent Evidence and Theoretical Concerns.”Social Forces81(2):381–408.
CarmichaelJason T.KentStephanie L.2017. “The Racial Politics of Due Process Protection: Does Partisanship or Racial Composition Influence State-Level Adoption of Recorded Interrogation Policies?”Criminal Justice Review42(21):58–76 (https://doi.org/10.1177/0734016816684925).
14.
Civil Rights Congress. 1970. We Charge Genocide; The Historic Petition to the United Nations for Relief from a Crime of the United States Government against the Negro People. New York: International Publishers.
15.
CorrellJoshuaParkBernadetteJuddCharles M.WittenbrinkBerndSadlerMelody S.KeeseeTracie. 2007. “Across the Thin Blue Line: Police Officers and Racial Bias in the Decision to Shoot.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology92(6):1006–23 (http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.92.6.1006).
16.
CressDaniel M.SnowDavid A.2000. “The Outcomes of Homeless Mobilization: The Influence of Organization, Disruption, Political Mediation, and Framing.”American Journal of Sociology105:1063–104 (https://doi.org/10.1086/210399).
17.
DavenportChristian. 2010. Media Bias, Perspective, and State Repression. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
18.
DeGueSarahFowlerKatherine A.CalkinsCynthia. 2016. “Deaths Due to Lethal Force by Law Enforcement.”American Journal of Preventative Medicine51:S173–S187 (https://doi.org/10.1016/j.amepre.2016.08.027).
EberhardtJennifer L.GoffPhillip A.PurdieValerie J.DaviesPaul G.2004. “Seeing Black: Race, Crime, and Visual Processing.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology87(6):876–93 (https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.87.6.876).
EdelmanLauren B.UggenChristopherErlangerHoward S.1999. “The Endogeneity of Legal Regulation: Grievance Procedures as Rational Myth.”American Journal of Sociology105(2):406–54.
23.
EdwardsBobGillhamPatrick F.2013. “Resource Mobilization Theory.” Pp. 1173–76 in The Wiley-Blackwell Encyclopedia of Social and Political Movements, edited by SnowD. A.Della PortaD.KlandermansB.McAdamD.Hoboken, NJ: Wiley-Blackwell (https://doi.org/10.1002/9780470674871.wbespm447).
EdwardsFrankLeeHedwigEspositoMichael. 2019. “Risk of Being Killed by Police Use of Force in the United States by Age, Race-Ethnicity and Sex.”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America116(34):16793–98.
26.
EppCharles R.Maynard-MoodyStevenHaider-MarkelDonald P.2014. Pulled Over: How Police Stops Define Race and Citizenship. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
27.
EnosRyan D.KaufmanAaron R.SandsMelissa. 2019. “Can Violent Protest Change Local Policy Support? Evidence from the Aftermath of the 1992 Los Angeles Riot.”American Political Science Review113(4):1012–28.
28.
FaganJeffreyGellerAmandaDaviesGarthWestValeria. 2009. “Street Stops and Broken Windows Revisited: The Demography and Logic of Proactive Policing in a Safe and Changing City.” Pp. 109–203 in Race, Ethnicity, and Policing: New and Essential Readings, edited by RiceS. K.WhiteM. D.New York: New York University Press.
29.
FairleySharon R.2020. “Survey Says? U.S. Cities Double Down on Civilian Oversight of Police Despite Challenges and Controversy.”Cardozo Law Review De Novo42:1–54.
30.
FarberJacob W.KalbfieldJessica Rose. 2019. “Complaining While Black: Racial Disparities in the Adjudication of Complaints against the Police.”City and Community18(3):1028–67 (https://doi.org/10.1111/cico.12388).
31.
FeldmanJustin M.GruskinSofiaCoullBrent A.KriegerNancy. 2019. “Police-Related Deaths and Neighborhood Economic and Racial/Ethnic Polarization, United States, 2015–2016.”American Journal of Public Health109(3):458–64.
32.
FinnPeter. 2001. Citizen Review of Police: Approaches and Implementation. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, National Institute of Justice.
FryerRoland G.Jr.2018. “Analysis of Racial Differences in Police Use of Force.”Journal of Political Economy127(3):1210–61 (https://doi.org/10.1086/701423).
35.
GamsonWilliam A.1975. The Strategy of Social Protest. Homewood, IL: Dorsey Press.
36.
GarnerJoel H.HickmanMatthew J.MalegaRonaldMaxwellChristopher D.2018. “Progress Toward National Estimates of Police Use of Force.”PLoS ONE13(2) (https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0192932).
37.
GehrkeDonnaGemoulesCraig. 1989. “Metro Hears Black Agenda, Takes No Votes.”Miami Herald, February 22, p. 1B.
38.
GelmanAndrewFaganJeffreyKissAlex.2012. “An Analysis of the New York City Police Department’s ‘Stop and Frisk’ Policy in the Context of Claims of Racial Bias.”Journal of the American Statistical Association102(479):813–23 (https://doi.org/10.1198/016214506000001040).
39.
GilbertKeonRayRashawn. 2016. “Why Police Kill Black Males with Impunity: Applying Critical Race and Public Health Theory to Address Determinants of Policing Behaviors and the Justifiable Homicides of Black Men.”Journal of Urban Health93(1):122–40.
40.
GillionDaniel Q.2013. The Political Power of Protest: Minority Activism and Shifts in Public Policy. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
GiugniMarcoMcAdamDougTillyCharles. 1999. How Social Movements Matter. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
43.
GoelSharadRaoJustin M.ShroffRavi. 2016. “Precinct or Prejudice? Understanding Racial Disparities in New York City’s Stop-and-Frisk Policy.”Journal of Applied Statistics10(1):365–94 (https://doi.org/10.1214/15-AOAS897).
44.
GreenRodney D.AldebronJillian. 2019. “In Search of Accountability: Civilian Review Boards and Department of Justice Intervention.”Python56(1/2):111–33.
45.
GrossNeilMannMarcus. 2017. “Is There a ‘Ferguson Effect’? Google Searches, Concern about Police Violence, and Crime in U.S. Cities, 2014–2016.”Socius3 (https://doi.org/10.1177/2378023117703122).
46.
HeadleyAndrea M.Wright IIJames E.2019. “National Police Reform Commissions: Evidence-Based Practices or Unfilled Promises?”The Review of Black Economy46(4):277–305 (https://doi.org/10.1177/0034644619873074).
47.
HickmanMatthew J.PooreJames E.2016. “National Data on Citizen Complaints about Police Use of Force: Data Quality Concerns and the Potential (Mis)Use of Statistical Evidence to Address Police Agency Conduct.”Criminal Justice Policy Review27(5):455–79 (https://doi.org/10.1177/0887403415594843).
48.
HilgartnerStephenBoskCharles L.1988. “The Rise and Fall of Social Problems: A Public Arenas Model.”American Journal of Sociology94(1):53–78.
49.
HoechleDaniel. 2007. “Robust Standard Errors for Panel Regression with Cross-Sectional Dependence.”The Stata Journal7(3):281–312.
50.
HolmesMalcom D.PainterMatthew A.IISmithBrad. 2018. “Race, Place, and Police-Caused Homicide in U.S. Municipalities.”Justice Quarterly36(5):751–86 (https://doi.org/10.1080/07418825.2018.1427782).
IacusStefano M.KingGaryPorroGiuseppe. 2011. “Multivariate Matching Methods That Are Monotonic Imbalance Bounded.”Journal of the American Statistical Association106(493):345–62.
JacobsDavidCarmichaelJason. 2002. “The Political Sociology of the Death Penalty: A Pooled Time-Series Analysis.”American Sociological Review67(1):109–31 (https://doi.org/10.2307/3088936).
55.
JacobsDavidWoodKatherine. 1999. “Interracial Conflict and Interracial Homicide: Do Political and Economic Rivalries Explain White Killings of Blacks and Black Killings of Whites?”American Journal of Sociology105:157–90 (https://doi.org/10.1086/210270).
56.
JasperJames. 2011. “Emotions and Social Movements: Twenty Years of Theory and Research.”Annual Review of Sociology37:285–303.
57.
JohnsonDavid J.TressTrevorBurkeNicoleTaylorCarleyCesarioJoseph. 2019. “Officer Characteristics and Racial Disparities in Fatal Officer-Involved Shootings.”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America116(32):15877–82 (https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1903856116).
58.
JonesStephanie. 2016. The Effect of #BlackLivesMatter: The Relevance of Communities and Collective Identity. Unpublished master’s thesis, Northern Illinois University, Dekalb, IL.
59.
KellingGeorge L.WilsonJames Q.1982. “Broken Windows: The Police and Neighborhood Safety.”The Atlantic Monthly249(3):29–38.
60.
KentStephanie L.2010. “Killings of Police in U.S. Cities since 1980: An Examination of Environmental and Political Explanations.”Homicide Studies14(1):3–23 (https://doi.org/10.1177/1088767909353258).
61.
KingBrayden G.2008. “A Political Mediation Model of Corporate Response to Social Movement Activism.”Administrative Science Quarterly53(3):395–421.
62.
KrivoLauren J.PetersenRuth D.KuhlDanielle C.2009. “Segregation, Racial Structure, and Neighborhood Violent Crime.”American Journal of Sociology114(6):1765–802 (https://doi.org/10.1086/597285).
MaskalyJonDonnerChristopherJenningsWesley G.ArielBarakSutherlandAlex. 2017. “The Effects of Body-Worn Cameras on Police and Citizen Outcomes: A State-of-the-Art Review.”Policing: An International Journal40(4):672–88 (https://doi.org/10.1108/PIJPSM-03-2017-0032).
65.
MasseyDouglas S.DentonNancy A.1988. “The Dimensions of Residential Segregation.”Social Forces67(2):281–315.
66.
MaysonSandra G.StevensonMegan T.2020. “Misdemeanors by the Numbers.”Boston College Law Review61(3):973–1044.
McAdamDougSuYang. 2002. “The War at Home: Antiwar Protests and Congressional Voting, 1965–1973.”American Sociological Review67(5):696–721.
69.
McCarthyJohn D.ZaldMayer N.1977. “Resource Mobilization and Social Movements: A Partial Theory.”American Journal of Sociology82(6):1212–41.
70.
McGregorAlecia. 2015. “Politics, Police Accountability, and Public Health: Civilian Review in Newark, New Jersey.”Journal of Urban Health93(1):5141–53 (https://doi.org/10.1007/s11524-015-9998-4).
71.
McVeighRoryWelchMichael R.BjarnasonThoroddur. 2003. “Hate Crime Reporting as a Successful Social Movement Outcome.”American Sociological Review68(6):843–67 (https://doi.org/10.2307/1519748).
72.
MeyerDavid S.2004. “Protest and Political Opportunities.”Annual Review of Sociology30:125–45.
73.
MinkoffDebra. 2016. “The Payoffs of Organizational Membership for Political Activism in Established Democracies.”American Journal of Sociology122(2):425–6.
74.
MorganStephen L.WinshipChristopher. 2015. Counterfactuals and Causal Inference: Methods and Principles for Social Research. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
75.
MuñozJohnOlzakSusanSouleSarah A.2018. “Going Green: Environmental Protest, Policy and CO2 Emission in U.S. States, 1990–2007.”Sociological Forum33(2):403–21 (https://doi.org/10.1111/socf.12422).
76.
National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders. 1968. Report of the National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
NixJustinCampbellBradley A.ByersEdward H.AlpertGeoffrey P.2017. “A Bird’s Eye View of Civilians Killed by Police in 2015.”Criminology & Public Policy16(1):309–40 (https://doi.org/10.1111/1745-9133.12269).
OlzakSusan. 1989. “Analysis of Events in the Study of Collective Action.”Annual Review of Sociology15:119–41.
81.
OlzakSusanRyoEmily. 2007. “Organizational Diversity, Vitality and Outcomes in the African American Civil Rights Movement.”Social Forces85(4):1561–92.
82.
OlzakSusanShanahanSuzanne. 2014. “Prisoners and Paupers: The Impact of Group Threat on Incarceration in Nineteenth-Century U.S. Cities.”American Sociological Review79(3):392–411.
83.
OlzakSusanSouleSarah A.2009. “Cross-Cutting Influences of Protest and Congressional Legislation in the Environmental Movement.”Social Forces88(1):201–25.
84.
PagerDevah. 2007. Marked: Race, Crime, and Finding Work in an Era of Mass Incarceration. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
85.
PaluckElizabeth L.GreenDonald P.2009. “Prejudice Reduction: What Works? A Review and Assessment of Research and Practice.”Annual Review of Psychology60:339–67.
PryorCoriBomanJohn H.IVMowenThomas J.McCammanMichael. 2019. “A National Study of Sustained Use of Force Complaints in Law Enforcement Agencies.”Journal of Criminal Justice64(September/October) (https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcrimjus.2019.101623).
88.
PutnamRobert D.2000. Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community. New York: Touchstone Press.
89.
RafailPatrickWalkerEdward T.McCarthyJohn D.2015. “Protests on the Front Page: Media Salience, Institutional Dynamics, and Coverage of Collective Action in the New York Times, 1960–1995.”Communications Research46(1):33–61.
90.
RayRayshawn. 2020. “George Floyd’s Murder Is the Twenty-first Century Emmett Till Moment: How Sociological Research Informs Police Reform.”Footnotes Special Issue on Race, Police Violence, and Justice48(4):3–5.
RossCody T.2015. “A Multi-Level Bayesian Analysis of Racial Bias in Police Shootings at the County-Level in the United States, 2011–2014.”PLosONE (https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0141854).
93.
SaltzsteinGrace H.1989. “Black Mayors and Police Policies.”Journal of Politics51(3):525–44 (https://doi.org/10.2307/2131494).
94.
SampsonRobert J.McAdamDougMacIndoeHeatherWeffer-ElizondoSimón. 2005. “Civil Society Reconsidered: The Durable Nature and Community Structure of Collective Civic Action.”American Journal of Sociology111(3):673–714.
95.
SampsonRobert J.RaudenbushStephen W.1999. “Systematic Social Observation of Public Spaces: A New Look at Disorder in Neighborhoods.”American Journal of Sociology105(3):603–51 (https://doi.org/10.1086/210356).
96.
SampsonRobert J.RaudenbushStephen W.EarlsFelton. 1997. “Neighborhoods and Crime: A Multilevel Study of Collective Efficacy.”Science277(5328):918–24 (https://doi.org/10.1126/science.277.5328.918).
97.
SampsonRobert J.WilsonWilliam J.KatzHanna. 2018. “Reassessing ‘Toward a Theory of Race, Crime, and Urban Inequality.’”Du Bois Review15(1):13–34 (https://doi.org/10.1017/S1742058X18000140).
98.
Santos SilvaJoãoTenreyroSilvana. 2010. “On the Existence of the Maximum Likelihood Estimates in Poisson Regression.”Economics Letters107(2):310–12.
99.
SapersteinAliyaPennerAndrew. 2012. “Racial Fluidity and Inequality in the United States.”American Journal of Sociology118(3):676–727 (https://doi.org/10.1086/667722).
100.
SchneiderEric C.AgeeChristopherChronopoulosThemis. 2020. “Dirty Work: Police and Community Relations and the Limits of Liberalism in Philadelphia.”Journal of Urban History46(5):961–79.
101.
SharkeyPatrick. 2018. Uneasy Peace: The Great Crime Decline, the Revival of City Life, and the Next War on Violence. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
SouleSarah A.KingBrayden G. 2008. “The Stages of the Policy Process and the Equal Rights Amendment.”American Journal of Sociology111(6):1871–909.
107.
SouleSarah A.OlzakSusan. 2004. “When Do Movements Matter? The Politics of Contingency and the Equal Rights Amendment.”American Sociological Review69(4):473–97 (http://www.jstor.org/stable/3593061).
108.
SvaraJames H.WatsonDouglas. 2010. More than Mayor or Manager: Campaigns to Change the Form of Government in America’s Largest Cities. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.
VandegriftDonaldConnorBrian J.2020. “The Effect of Police Use of Lethal Force on Murder Levels in American Cities Before and After Ferguson.”Journal of Quantitative Criminology36:235–61 (https://doi.org/10.1007/s10940-019-09429-6).
111.
VélezMaría B.LyonsChristopher J.SantoroWayne A.2015. “The Political Context of the Percent Black – Neighborhood Violence Link.”Social Problems62(1):93–119 (https://doi.org/10.1093/socpro/spu005).
112.
WalgraveStefaanVliegenthartRens. 2012. “The Complex Agenda-Setting Power of Protest: Demonstrations, Media, Parliament, Government, and Legislation in Belgium, 1993–2000.”Mobilization: An International Journal17(2):129–56.
113.
WalkerSamuelArchboldCarol A.2014. The New World of Police Accountability. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
114.
WangDan J.SouleSarah A.2012. “Social Movement Organizational Collaboration: Networks of Learning and Diffusion of Protest Tactics, 1960–1995.”American Journal of Sociology117(6):1674–722.
115.
WeaverAlice. 2014. “Does Protest Behavior Mediate the Effects of Public Opinion?”International Journal of Sociology38(3):108–25.
116.
WeisburdDavidBragaAnthony A.GroffElizabeth R.WooditchAlese. 2017. “Can Hot Spots Policing Reduce Crime in Urban Areas? An Agent-Based Simulation.”Criminology55(1):137–73 (https://doi.org/10.1111/1745-9125.12131).
WeldonLaurel S.2011. When Protest Makes Policy. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.
119.
WesternBruceMullerChristopher. 2013. “Mass Incarceration, Macrosociology, and the Poor.”The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science647(1):166–89.
120.
WiersemaBrianLoftinColinMcDowallDavid. 2000. “A Comparison of Supplementary Homicide Reports and National Vital Statistics System Homicide Estimates for U.S. Counties.”Homicide Studies4(4):317–40 (https://doi.org/10.1177/1088767900004004002).
121.
WilliamsHoward E.BowmanScott W.JungJordan Taylor. 2019. “The Limitations of Government Databases for Analyzing Fatal Officer-Involved Shootings in the United States.”Criminal Justice Policy Review30(2):201–22 (https://doi.org/10.1177/0887403416650927).
122.
WilliamsonVanessaTrumpKris-StellaEinsteinKatherine Levine. 2018. “Black Lives Matter: Evidence That Police-Caused Deaths Predict Protest Activity.”Perspectives on Politics16(2):400–415 (https://doi.org/10.1017/S1537592717004273).
123.
WinterAlixSampsonRobert J.2017. “From Lead Exposure in Early Childhood to Adolescent Health: A Chicago Birth Cohort.”American Journal of Public Health107(9):1496–501.
WoolridgeJeffrey M. 2010. Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data. Boston, MA: MIT Press.
126.
WoutersRuudWalgraveStefaan. 2017. “Demonstrating Power: How Protest Persuades Political Representatives.”American Sociological Review82(2):361–83 (https://doi.org/10.1177/0003122417690325).
127.
ZimringFranklin E.2017. When Police Kill. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
