This study investigates the complex roles of the social environment and genes in the multigenerational transmission of educational attainment. Drawing on genome-wide data and educational attainment measures from the Framingham Heart Study (FHS) and the Health and Retirement Study (HRS), I conduct polygenic score analyses to examine genetic confounding in the estimation of parents’ and grandparents’ influences on their children’s and grandchildren’s educational attainment. I also examine social genetic effects (i.e., genetic effects that operate through the social environment) in the transmission of educational attainment across three generations. Two-generation analyses produce three important findings. First, about one-fifth of the parent-child association in education reflects genetic inheritance. Second, up to half of the association between parents’ polygenic scores and children’s education is mediated by parents’ education. Third, about one-third of the association between children’s polygenic scores and their educational attainment is attributable to parents’ genotypes and education. Three-generation analyses suggest that genetic confounding on the estimate of the direct effect of grandparents’ education on grandchildren’s education (net of parents’ education) may be inconsequential, and I find no evidence that grandparents’ genotypes significantly influence grandchildren’s education through non-biological pathways. The three-generation results are suggestive, and the results may change when different samples are used.
AldousJoan. 1995. “New Views of Grandparents in Intergenerational Context.” Journal of Family Issues16(1):104–122.
2.
BaileyMartha J.DynarskiSusan M.2011. “Inequality in Postsecondary Education.” Pp. 117–31 in Whither Opportunity? Rising Inequality, Schools, and Children’s Life Chances, edited by DuncanG. J.MurnaneR. J.New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
3.
BarbanNicolaJansenRickVlamingRonald deVaezAhmadMandemakers, et alJornt J.et al. 2016. “Genome-Wide Analysis Identifies 12 Loci Influencing Human Reproductive Behavior.” Nature Genetics48(12):1462–72.
4.
BarnesJ. C.WrightJohn P.BoutwellBrian B.SchwartzJoseph A.ConnollyEric J.NedelecJoseph L.BeaverKevin M.2014. “Demonstrating the Validity of Twin Research in Criminology.” Criminology52(4):588–626.
5.
BelskyDaniel W.MoffittTerrie E.CorcoranDavid L.DomingueBenjaminHarringtonHonaLeeHoganSeanHoutsRenateRamrakhaSandhyaSugdenKarenWilliamsBenjamin S.PoultonRichieCaspiAvshalom. 2016. “The Genetics of Success: How Single-Nucleotide Polymorphisms Associated with Educational Attainment Relate to Life-Course Development.” Psychological Science27(7):957–72.
6.
BengtsonVern L.1975. “Generation and Family Effects in Value Socialization.” American Sociological Review40(3):358–71.
7.
BlauPeter M.DuncanOtis D.1967. The American Occupational Structure. New York: Wiley.
8.
BlossfeldHans-PeterShavitYossi. 1993. “Persisting Barriers: Changes in Educational Opportunities in Thirteen Countries.” Pp. 1–23 in Persistent Inequality: Changing Educational Attainment in Thirteen Countries, edited by ShavitY.BlossfeldH.-P.Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
9.
BoardmanJason D.BlalockCasey L.PampelFred C.2010. “Trends in the Genetic Influences on Smoking.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior51(1):108–123.
10.
BoardmanJason D.RoettgerMichael E.DomingueBenjamin W.McQueenMatthew B.HaberstickBrett C.HarrisKathleen Mullan. 2012. “Gene–Environment Interactions Related to Body Mass: School Policies and Social Context as Environmental Moderators.” Journal of Theoretical Politics24(3):370–88.
11.
BoudonRaymond. 1974. Education, Opportunity, and Social Inequality. New York: John Wiley.
12.
BourdieuPierrePasseronJean-Claude. 1977. Reproduction in Education, Society, and Culture. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
13.
BraniganAmelia R.McCallumKenneth J.FreeseJeremy. 2013. “Variation in the Heritability of Educational Attainment: An International Meta-Analysis.” Social Forces92(1):109–140.
14.
BurtCallie H.SimonsRonald L.2014. “Pulling Back the Curtain on Heritability Studies: Biosocial Criminology in the Postgenomic Era.” Criminology52(2):223–62.
15.
ChanTak WingBoliverVikki. 2013. “The Grandparents Effect in Social Mobility: Evidence from British Birth Cohort Studies.” American Sociological Review78(4):662–78.
16.
CherlinAndrew J.Furstenberg Jr.Frank F.1992. The New American Grandparent: A Place in the Family, a Life Apart. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
17.
CoallDavid A.HertwigRalph. 2010. “Grandparental Investment: Past, Present, and Future.” Behavioral and Brain Sciences33(1):1–19.
18.
ColemanJames S.1988. “Social Capital in the Creation of Human Capital.” American Journal of Sociology94(1988):S95–S120.
19.
ConleyDaltonDomingueBenjamin W.CesariniDavidDawesChristopherRietveldCornelius A.BoardmanJason D.2015. “Is the Effect of Parental Education on Offspring Biased or Moderated by Genotype?”Sociological Science2:82–105.
20.
ConleyDaltonFletcherJason M.2017. The Genome Factor: What the Social Genomics Revolution Reveals About Ourselves, Our History, and the Future. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
21.
DayFelix R.HelgasonHannesChasmanDaniel I.RoseLynda M.LohPo-RuScottRobert A.HelgasonAgnarKongAugustineMassonGisliMagnussonOlafur T.GudbjartssonDanielThorsteinsdottirUnnurBuringJulie E.RidkerPaul M.SulemPatrickStefanssonKariOngKen K.PerryJohn R. B.2016. “Physical and Neurobehavioral Determinants of Reproductive Onset and Success.” Nature Genetics48(6):617–23.
22.
De GraafPaul M.GanzeboomHarry B. G.1993. “Family Background and Educational Attainment in the Netherlands for the 1891–1960 Birth Cohorts.” Pp. 75–99 in Persistent Inequality: Changing Educational Attainment in Thirteen Countries, edited by ShavitY.BlossfeldH.-P.Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
23.
DeleireThomasKalilAriel. 2002. “Good Things Come in Threes: Single-Parent Multigenerational Family Structure and Adolescent Adjustment.” Demography39(2):393–413.
24.
de VlamingRonaldOkbayAysuRietveldCornelius A.JohannessonMagnusMagnussonPatrik K. E.UitterlindenAndré G.van RooijFrank J. A.HofmanAlbertGroenenPatrick J. F.ThurikA. RoyKoellingerPhilipp D.2017. “Meta-GWAS Accuracy and Power (MetaGAP) Calculator Shows that Hiding Heritability Is Partially Due to Imperfect Genetic Correlations across Studies.” PLoS Genetics13(1):e1006495. doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1006495.
25.
DickensWilliam T.FlynnJames R.2001. “Heritability Estimates versus Large Environmental Effects: The IQ Paradox Resolved.” Psychological Review108(2):346–69.
26.
DiMaggioPaul. 1982. “Cultural Capital and School Success: The Impact of Status Culture Participation on the Grades of US High School Students.” American Sociological Review47(2):189–201.
27.
DiPreteThomas A.BurkiCasperKoellingerPhilipp. 2017. “Genetic Instrumental Variable (GIV) Regression: Explaining Socioeconomic and Health Outcomes in Non-Experimental Data.” bioRxiv 134197; https://doi.org/10.1101/134197.
28.
DomingueBenjamin W.BelskyDaniel W.2017. “The Social Genome: Current Findings and Implications for the Study of Human Genetics.” PLoS Genetics13(3):e1006615. doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1006615.
29.
DomingueBenjamin W.BelskyDaniel W.ConleyDaltonHarrisKathleenBoardmanJason D.2015. “Polygenic Influence on Educational Attainment: New Evidence from the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent to Adult Health.” AERA Open1(3):1–13.
30.
DomingueBenjamin W.BelskyDaniel W.HarratiAmalConleyDaltonWeirDavid R.BoardmanJason D.2016. “Mortality Selection in a Genetic Sample and Implications for Association Studies.” International Journal of Epidemiology46(4):1285–94.
31.
DowneyDouglas B.1995. “When Bigger Is Not Better: Family Size, Parental Resources, and Children’s Educational Performance.” American Sociological Review60(5):746–61.
32.
DudbridgeFrank. 2013. “Power and Predictive Accuracy of Polygenic Risk Scores.” PLoS Genetics9(3):e1003348.
33.
EcklandBruce K.1967. “Genetics and Sociology: A Reconsideration.” American Sociological Review32(2):173–94.
34.
EcklandBruce K.1979. “Genetic Variance in the Ses-Iq Correlation.” Sociology of Education52(3):191–96.
35.
ErolaJaniMoisioPasi. 2007. “Social Mobility over Three Generations in Finland, 1950–2000.” European Sociological Review23(2):169–83.
FeathermanDavid L.HauserRobert M.1976. “Changes in the Socioeconomic Stratification of the Races, 1962–73.” American Journal of Sociology82(3):621–51.
38.
FletcherJason M.ConleyDalton. 2013. “The Challenge of Causal Inference in Gene-Environment Interaction Research: Leveraging Research Designs from the Social Sciences.” American Journal of Public Health103(1):S42–S45.
39.
GaddisS. Michael. 2012. “What’s in a Relationship? An Examination of Social Capital, Race and Class in Mentoring Relationships.” Social Forces90(4):1237–69.
40.
GaddisS. Michael. 2013. “The Influence of Habitus in the Relationship between Cultural Capital and Academic Achievement.” Social Science Research42(1):1–13.
GruskyDavid B.DiPreteThomas A.1990. “Recent Trends in the Process of Stratification.” Demography27(4):617–37.
43.
GuoGuangStearnsElizabeth. 2002. “The Social Influences on the Realization of Genetic Potential for Intellectual Development.” Social Forces80(3):881–910.
44.
HauserRobert M.1971. “Socioeconomic Background and Educational Performance.” Rose Monograph Series, American Sociological Association.
45.
HeathA. C.BergK.EavesL. J.SolaasM. H.CoreyL. A.SundetJ.MagnusP.NanceW. E.1985. “Education Policy and the Heritability of Educational Attainment.” Nature314(6013):734–36.
46.
HoutMichael. 1988. “More Universalism, Less Structural Mobility: The American Occupational Structure in the 1980s.” American Journal of Sociology93(88):1358–1400.
47.
JægerMads Meier. 2012. “The Extended Family and Children’s Educational Success.” American Sociological Review77(6):903–922.
48.
JægerMads M.BreenRichard. 2016. “A Dynamic Model of Cultural Reproduction.” American Journal of Sociology121(4):1079–1115.
49.
JaffeeSara R.PriceThomas S.2007. “Gene-Environment Correlations: A Review of the Evidence and Implications for Prevention of Mental Illness.” Molecular Psychiatry12(5):432–42.
50.
JencksChristopher. 1980. “Heredity, Environment, and Public Policy Reconsidered.” American Sociological Review45(5):723–36.
51.
KingValarieElderGlen H.1997. “The Legacy of Grandparenting: Childhood Experiences with Grandparents and Current Involvement with Grandchildren.” Journal of Marriage and Family59(4):848–59.
52.
LinNan. 2001. Social Capital: A Theory of Social Structure and Action. New York: Cambridge University Press.
53.
LiuHexuanGuoGuang. 2015. “Lifetime Socioeconomic Status, Historical Context, and Genetic Inheritance in Shaping Body Mass in Middle and Late Adulthood.” American Sociological Review80(4):705–737.
54.
LiuHexuanGuoGuang. 2016. “Opportunities and Challenges of Big Data for the Social Sciences: The Case of Genomic Data.” Social Science Research59:13–22.
55.
MareRobert D.1993. “Educational Stratification on Observed and Unobserved Components of Family Background.” Pp. 351–76 in Persistent Inequality: Changing Educational Attainment in Thirteen Countries, edited by ShavitY.BlossfeldH.-P.Boulder, CO: Westview.
56.
MareRobert D.2011. “A Multigenerational View of Inequality.” Demography48(1):1–23.
57.
MareRobert D.2014. “Multigenerational Aspects of Social Stratification: Issues for Further Research.” Research in Social Stratification and Mobility35:121–28.
58.
MareRobert D.SongXi. 2012. “Social Mobility in Multiple Generations.” Presented at the Annual Meeting of the Population Association of America, San Francisco, CA.
59.
MarioniRiccardo E.RitchieStuart J.JoshiPeter K.HagenaarsSaskia P.OkbayAysuFischerKristaAdamsMark J.HillW. DavidDaviesGail, Social Science Genetic Association Consortium, NagyRekaAmadorCarmenLällKristiMetspaluAndresLiewaldDavid C.CampbellArchieWilsonJames F.HaywardCarolineEskoTõnuPorteousDavid J.GaleCatharine R.DearyIan J.2016. “Genetic Variants Linked to Education Predict Longevity.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America113(47):13366–71.
60.
NielsenFrançois. 2006. “Achievement and Ascription in Educational Attainment: Genetic and Environmental Influences on Adolescent Schooling.” Social Forces85(1):193–216.
61.
NielsenFrançois. 2008. “The Nature of Social Reproduction: Two Paradigms of Social Mobility.” In “Social Sciences and Natural Sciences – What Connection?” [symposium], edited by LucchiniM.PisatiM.Sociologica Nr 3 (November), 1–35 (http://www.sociologica.mulino.it/).
62.
NielsenFrançoisRoosJ. Micah. 2015. “Genetics of Educational Attainment and the Persistence of Privilege at the Turn of the 21st Century.” Social Forces94(2):535–61.
63.
OkbayAysuBaselmansBart M. L.RueediRicoSventoRauliKolcicIvanaet al. 2016. “Genetic Variants Associated with Subjective Well-Being, Depressive Symptoms, and Neuroticism Identified through Genome-Wide Analyses.” Nature Genetics48(6):624–33.
64.
OkbayAysuBeauchampJonathan P.FontanaMark AlanLeeJames J.PersTune H.et al. 2016. “Genome-Wide Association Study Identifies 74 Loci Associated with Educational Attainment.” Nature533(7604):539–42.
65.
PfefferFabian T.2014. “Multigenerational Approaches to Social Mobility: A Multifaceted Research Agenda.” Research in Social Stratification and Mobility35:1–12.
66.
PlominRobertDeFriesJ. C.LoehlinJohn C.1977. “Genotype-Environment Interaction and Correlation in the Analysis of Human Behavior.” Psychological Bulletin84(2):309–322.
67.
PriceAlkes L.PattersonNick J.PlengeRobert M.WeinblattMichael E.ShadickNancy A.ReichDavid. 2006. “Principal Components Analysis Corrects for Stratification in Genome-Wide Association Studies.” Nature Genetics38(8):904–909.
68.
ReardonSean F.2011. “The Widening Achievement Gap between the Rich and the Poor: New Evidence and Possible Explanations.” Pp. 91–115 in Whither Opportunity? Rising Inequality, Schools, and Children’s Life Chances, edited by DuncanG. J.MurnaneR. J.New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
69.
RietveldCornelius A.AgrawalArpanaErikssonJohan G.AlbrechtEvaAlizadehBehrooz Z.et al. 2013. “GWAS of 126,559 Individuals Identifies Genetic Variants Associated with Educational Attainment.” Science340(6139):1467–71.
70.
RobinsonGene E.GrozingerChristina M.WhitfieldCharles W.2005. “Sociogenomics: Social Life in Molecular Terms.” Nature Reviews Genetics6(4):257–70.
71.
RubinDonald B.1987. Multiple Imputation for Nonresponse in Surveys. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
72.
SakamotoArthurGoyetteKimberly A.KimChang Hwan. 2009. “Socioeconomic Attainments of Asian Americans.” Annual Review of Sociology35:255–176.
73.
ScarrSandraMcCartneyKathleen. 1983. “How People Make Their Own Environments: A Theory of Genotype → Environment Effects.” Child Development54(2):424–35.
74.
ScarrSandraWeinbergRichard A.1978. “The Influence of ‘Family Background’ on Intellectual Attainment.” American Sociological Review43(5):674–92.
75.
SchneiderBarbaraColemanJames S.1993. Parents, Their Children, and Schools. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
76.
SewellWilliam H.HallerArchibald O.PortesAlejandro. 1969. “The Educational and Early Occupational Attainment Process.” American Sociological Review34(1):83–92.
77.
SharkeyPatrickElwertFelix. 2011. “The Legacy of Disadvantage: Multigenerational Neighborhood Effects on Cognitive Ability.” American Journal of Sociology116(6):1934–81.
SobelMichael E.1982. “Asymptotic Confidence Intervals for Indirect Effects in Structural Equation Models.” Sociological Methodology13:290–312.
80.
SongXi. 2016. “Diverging Mobility Trajectories: Grandparent Effects on Educational Attainment in One- and Two-Parent Families in the United States.” Demography53(6):1905–1932.
81.
SongXiMareRobert D.2017. “Short-Term and Long-Term Educational Mobility of Families: A Two-Sex Approach.” Demography54(1):145–73.
82.
TeachmanJay D.1987. “Family Background, Educational Resources, and Educational Attainment.” American Sociological Review52(4):548–57.
83.
Tucker-DrobElliot M.2017. “Measurement Error Correction of Genome-Wide Polygenic Scores in Prediction Samples.” bioRxiv 165472; https://doi.org/10.1101/165472.
84.
Tucker-DrobElliot M.BrileyDaniel A.HardenK. Paige. 2013. “Genetic and Environmental Influences on Cognition across Development and Context.” Current Directions in Psychological Science22(5):349–55.
85.
TurkheimerEricHaleyAndreanaWaldronMaryD’OnofrioBrianGottesmanIrving I.2003. “Socioeconomic Status Modifies Heritability of IQ in Young Children.” Psychological Science14(6):623–28.
86.
U.S. Census Bureau. 2017. “2011–2015 American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates.” Retrieved May5, 2017 (https://factfinder.census.gov/).
87.
WagnerBrandonLiJiangLiuHexuanGuoGuang. 2013. “Gene-Environment Correlation: Difficulties and a Natural Experiment-Based Strategy.” American Journal of Public Health103(1):S167–73.
88.
WarrenJohn RobertHauserRobert M.1997. “Social Stratification across Three Generations: New Evidence from the Wisconsin Longitudinal Study.” American Sociological Review62(4):561–72.
89.
YangJian, SLeeHongGoddardMichael E.VisscherPeter M.2011. “GCTA: A Tool for Genome-Wide Complex Trait Analysis.” American Journal of Human Genetics88(1):76–82.
90.
ZengZhenXieYu. 2014. “The Effects of Grandparents on Children’s Schooling: Evidence from Rural China.” Demography51(2):599–617.
91.
ZiefleAndrea. 2016. “Persistent Educational Advantage across Three Generations: Empirical Evidence for Germany.” Sociological Science3:1077–1102.
