The effect of generous welfare benefits on unemployment is highly contested. The dominant perspective contends that benefits provide disincentive to work, whereas others portray benefits as job-search subsidies that facilitate better job matches. Despite many studies of welfare benefits and unemployment, the literature has neglected how this relationship might vary across institutional contexts. This article investigates how unemployment benefits and minimum income benefits affect unemployment across levels of the institutional insider/outsider divide. I analyze the moderating role of the disparity in employment protection for holders of permanent and temporary contracts and of the configuration of wage bargaining. The analysis combines data from 20 European countries and the United States using the European Union Labour Force Survey and the Current Population Survey 1992–2009. I use a pseudo-panel approach, including fixed effects for sociodemographic groups within countries and interactions between benefits and institutions. The results indicate that unemployment benefits and minimum income benefits successfully subsidize job search and reduce unemployment in labor markets with a moderate institutional insider/outsider divide. However, when there is greater disparity in employment protection and when bargaining either combines low unionization with high centralization or high unionization with low centralization, generous benefits create a disincentive to work, plausibly because attractive job opportunities are scarce.
156 Congressional Record. 2010. Statement of Senator Jon Kyl speaking for the Tax Extenders Act of 2009 on March 1, 2010, to the U.S. Senate, H.R. 4213, 111th Cong., 2nd sess. Congressional Record v. 156, pt. 27:845. (https://www.congress.gov/crec/2010/03/01/CREC-2010-03-01-senate.pdf).
AmableBruno. 2003. The Diversity of Modern Capitalism. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
4.
AtkinsonAnthonyMicklewrightB., and John. 1991. “Unemployment Compensation and Labor Market Transitions: A Critical Review.” Journal of Economic Literature29(4):1679–1727.
5.
AvdagicSabinaSalardiPaola. 2013. “Tenuous Link: Labour Market Institutions and Unemployment in Advanced and New Market Economies.” Socio-Economic Review11(4):739–69.
6.
BaccaroLucioReiDiego. 2007. “Institutional Determinants of Unemployment in OECD Countries: Does the Deregulatory View Hold Water?”International Organization61(3):527–69.
7.
BakerDeanGlynAndrewHowellDavid R.SchmittJohn. 2005. “Labor Market Institutions and Unemployment: A Critical Assessment of the Cross-Country Evidence.” Pp. 72–118 in Fighting Unemployment: The Limits of Free Market Orthodoxy, edited by HowellD.New York: Oxford University Press.
8.
BarbieriPaolo. 2009. “Flexible Employment and Inequality in Europe.” European Sociological Review25(6):621–28.
9.
BarbieriPaoloCutuliGiorgio. 2016. “Employment Protection Legislation, Labour Market Dualism, and Inequality in Europe.” European Sociological Review32(4):501–516.
10.
BassaniniAndreaDuvalRomain. 2009. “Unemployment, Institutions, and Reform Complementarities: Re-Assessing the Aggregate Evidence for OECD Countries.” Oxford Review of Economic Policy25(1):40–59.
11.
BelotMichèlevan OursJan C.2004. “Does the Recent Success of Some OECD Countries in Lowering Their Unemployment Rates Lie in the Clever Design of Their Labor Market Reforms?” Oxford Economic Papers56(4):621–42.
12.
BentolilaSamuelCahucPierreDoladoJuan J.Le BarbanchonThomas. 2012. “Two-Tier Labour Markets in the Great Recession: France versus Spain.” The Economic Journal122(562):F155–F187.
13.
BertolaGiuseppeBlauFrancine D.KahnLawrence M.2007. “Labor Market Institutions and Demographic Employment Patterns.” Journal of Population Economics20(4):833–67.
14.
BiegertThomas. 2014. “On the Outside Looking In? Transitions out of Non-Employment in the United Kingdom and Germany.” Journal of European Social Policy24(1):3–18.
15.
BlythMark. 2002. Great Transformations: Economic Ideas and Institutional Change in the Twentieth Century. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
16.
BonoliGiuliano. 2010. “The Political Economy of Active Labor-Market Policy.” Politics & Society38(4):435–57.
17.
BradyDavidBakerRegina S.FinniganRyan. 2013. “When Unionization Disappears: State-Level Unionization and Working Poverty in the United States.” American Sociological Review78(5):872–96.
18.
CardDavidJohnstonAndrewLeungPaulineMasAlexandrePeiZhuan. 2015. “The Effect of Unemployment Benefits on the Duration of Unemployment Insurance Receipt: New Evidence from a Regression Kink Design in Missouri, 2003–2013.” American Economic Review105(5):126–30.
19.
CalmforsLarsDriffillJohn. 1988. “Centralization of Wage Bargaining.” Economic Policy3(6):13–61.
20.
DavidssonJohan BoEmmeneggerPatrick. 2013. “Defending the Organisation, Not the Members: Unions and the Reform of Job Security Legislation in Western Europe.” European Journal of Political Research52(3):339–63.
21.
DeatonAngus. 1985. “Panel Data from Time Series of Cross-Sections.” Journal of Econometrics30(1–2):109–26.
22.
DiPreteThomas A.McManusPatricia A.2000. “Family Change, Employment Transitions, and the Welfare State: Household Income Dynamics in the United States and Germany.” American Sociological Review65(3):343–70.
23.
DoeringerPeter B.PioreMichael J.1971. Internal Labor Markets and Manpower Analysis. Lexington, MA: D.C. Heath and Co.
24.
EichhorstW.MarxP.2011. “Reforming German Labour Market Institutions: A Dual Path to Flexibility.” Journal of European Social Policy21(1):73–87.
25.
EmmeneggerPatrickHäusermannSiljaPalierBrunoSeeleib-KaiserMartin. 2012. The Age of Dualization: The Changing Face of Inequality in Deindustrializing Societies. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
26.
Estevez-AbeMargaritaIversenTorbenSoskiceDavid. 2001. “Social Protection and the Formation of Skills: A Reinterpretation of the Welfare State.” Pp. 145–83 in Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage, edited by HallP. A.SoskiceD.Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
27.
FerversLukasSchwanderHanna. 2015. “Are Outsiders Equally Out Everywhere? The Economic Disadvantage of Outsiders in Cross-National Perspective.” European Journal of Industrial Relations21(4):369–87.
28.
FloodSarahKingMiriamRugglesStevenWarrenJ. Robert. 2015. Integrated Public Use Microdata Series, Current Population Survey: Version 4.0. [Machine-readable database]. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota.
29.
FreemanRichard B.MedoffJames L.1984. What Do Unions Do?New York: Basic.
30.
GanglMarkus. 2003. “The Only Way Is Up? Employment Protection and Job Mobility among Recent Entrants to European Labour Markets.” European Sociological Review19(5):429–49.
31.
GanglMarkus. 2004. “Welfare States and the Scar Effects of Unemployment: A Comparative Analysis of the United States and West Germany.” American Journal of Sociology109(6):1319–64.
32.
GanglMarkus. 2006. “Scar Effects of Unemployment: An Assessment of Institutional Complementarities.” American Sociological Review71(6):986–1013.
33.
GebelMichaelGieseckeJohannes. 2011. “Labor Market Flexibility and Inequality: The Changing Skill-Based Temporary Employment and Unemployment Risks in Europe.” Social Forces90(1):17–40.
34.
GebelMichaelGieseckeJohannes. 2016. “Does Deregulation Help? The Impact of Employment Protection Reforms on Youths’ Unemployment and Temporary Employment Risks in Europe.” European Sociological Review32(4):486–500.
35.
GoldthorpeJohn H.1984. “The End of Convergence: Corporatist and Dualist Tendencies in Modern Western Societies.” Pp. 315–43 in Order and Conflict in Contemporary Capitalism, edited by GoldthorpeJ. H.Oxford, UK: Clarendon Press.
36.
GornickJanet C.MeyersMarcia K.RossKatherin E.1997. “Supporting the Employment of Mothers: Policy Variation across Fourteen Welfare States.” Journal of European Social Policy7(1):45–70.
37.
HallPeter A.SoskiceDavid. 2001. “An Introduction to Varieties of Capitalism.” Pp. 1–68 in Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage, edited by HallP. A.SoskiceD.Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
38.
HäusermannSiljaSchwanderHanna. 2012. “Varieties of Dualization? Labor Market Segmentation and Insider-Outsider Divides Across Regimes.” Pp. 27–51 in The Age of Dualization: The Changing Face of Inequality in Deindustrializing Societies, edited by EmmeneggerP.HäusermannS.PalierB.Seeleib-KaiserM.Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
39.
HicksAlexanderKenworthyLane. 1998. “Cooperation and Political Economic Performance in Affluent Democratic Capitalism.” American Journal of Sociology103(6):1631–72.
40.
HippLenaLeuzeKathrin. 2015. “Determinants of Working Time Differences within Couples in Europe and the U.S.” KZfSS Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie67(4):659–84.
41.
HowellDavid R.AzizogluBert M.2011. “Unemployment Benefits and Work Incentives: The US Labour Market in the Great Recession.” Oxford Review of Economic Policy27(2):221–40.
42.
HowellDavid R.RehmMiriam. 2009. “Unemployment Compensation and High European Unemployment: A Reassessment with New Benefit Indicators.” Oxford Review of Economic Policy25(1):60–93.
43.
ILO. 1982. “Resolution Concerning Statistics of the Economically Active Population, Employment, Unemployment and Underemployment, Adopted by the Thirteenth International Conference of Labour Statisticians.” Retrieved February2, 2016 (http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/ramon/coded_files/ecacpop_en.pdf).
44.
IversenTorben. 1998. “Wage Bargaining, Hard Money and Economic Performance: Theory and Evidence for Organized Market Economies.” British Journal of Political Science28(1):31–61.
45.
IversenTorben. 1999. Contested Economic Institutions: The Politics of Macroeconomics and Wage Bargaining in Advanced Democracies. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
46.
IversenTorben. 2005. Capitalism, Democracy, and Welfare. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
47.
JacobsDavidMyersLindsey. 2014. “Union Strength, Neoliberalism, and Inequality: Contingent Political Analyses of U.S. Income Differences since 1950.” American Sociological Review79(4):752–74.
48.
JægerMads Meier. 2013. “The Effect of Macroeconomic and Social Conditions on the Demand for Redistribution: A Pseudo Panel Approach.” Journal of European Social Policy23(2):149–63.
49.
JahnDetlef. 2014. “Changing of the Guard: Trends in Corporatist Arrangements in 42 Highly Industrialized Societies from 1960 to 2010.” Socio-Economic Review14(1):47–71.
50.
KallebergArne L.2011. Good Jobs, Bad Jobs: The Rise of Polarized and Precarious Employment Systems in the United States, 1970s to 2000s. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
51.
KallebergArne L.WallaceMichaelAlthauserRobert P.1981. “Economic Segmentation, Worker Power, and Income Inequality.” American Journal of Sociology87(3):651–83.
52.
LaliveRafael. 2007. “Unemployment Benefits, Unemployment Duration, and Post-Unemployment Jobs: A Regression Discontinuity Approach.” American Economic Review97(2):108–112.
53.
LayardRichardNickellStephen J.JackmanRichard. 2005. Unemployment: Macroeconomic Performance and the Labour Market. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
54.
LindbeckAssarSnowerDenis J.1988. The Insider-Outsider Theory of Employment and Unemployment. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
55.
MeyerBruce D.1990. “Unemployment Insurance and Unemployment Spells.” Econometrica58(4):757–82.
56.
MorelNathaliePalierBrunoPalmeJoakim. 2012. Towards a Social Investment Welfare State? Ideas, Policies and Challenges. Bristol, UK: Policy Press.
57.
NelsonKenneth. 2010. “Social Assistance and Minimum Income Benefits in Old and New EU Democracies.” International Journal of Social Welfare19(4):367–78.
58.
NelsonMoiraStephensJohn D.2012. “Do Social Investment Policies Produce More and Better Jobs?” Pp. 205–234 in Towards a Social Investment Welfare State? Ideas, Policies and Challenges, edited by MorelN.PalierB.PalmeJ.Bristol, UK: Policy Press.
59.
NeugebauerMartin. 2015. “The Introduction of Bachelor Degrees and the Under-representation of Students from Low Social Origin in Higher Education in Germany: A Pseudo-Panel Approach.” European Sociological Review31(5):591–602.
60.
NickellStephen. 1997. “Unemployment and Labor Market Rigidities: Europe versus North America.” Journal of Economic Perspectives11(3):55–74.
61.
NoelkeClemens. 2016. “Employment Protection Legislation and the Youth Labour Market.” European Sociological Review32(4):471–85.
OECD. 2006. “Reassessing the Role of Policies and Institutions for Labour Market Performance: A Quantitative Analysis.” Pp. 207–231 in Employment Outlook, edited by OECD. Paris: OECD.
64.
PalierBrunoThelenKathleen. 2010. “Institutionalizing Dualism: Complementarities and Change in France and Germany.” Politics & Society38(1):119–48.
65.
PfeiferMichaela. 2012. “Comparing Unemployment Protection and Social Assistance in 14 European Countries: Four Worlds of Protection for People of Working Age.” International Journal of Social Welfare21(1):13–25.
66.
Pollmann-SchultMatthiasBüchelFelix. 2005. “Unemployment Benefits, Unemployment Duration and Subsequent Job Quality: Evidence from West Germany.” Acta Sociologica48(1):21–39.
67.
RuedaDavid. 2005. “Insider–Outsider Politics in Industrialized Democracies: The Challenge to Social Democratic Parties.” American Political Science Review99(1):61–74.
68.
RuedaDavid. 2014. “Dualization, Crisis and the Welfare State.” Socio-Economic Review12(2):381–407.
69.
RuedaDavidPontussonJonas. 2000. “Wage Inequality and Varieties of Capitalism.” World Politics52(3):350–83.
70.
SchmiederJohannes F.von WaechterTill. 2016. “The Effects of Unemployment Insurance Benefits: New Evidence and Interpretation.” Annual Review of Economics8(1):547–81.
71.
SchwanderHannaHäusermannSilja. 2013. “Who Is in and Who Is Out? A Risk-Based Conceptualization of Insiders and Outsiders.” Journal of European Social Policy23(3):248–69.
72.
ScruggsLyleJahnDetlefKuittoKati. 2014. “Comparative Welfare Entitlements Dataset 2. Version 2014-03.” University of Connecticut & University of Greifswald.
73.
SjöbergOla. 2000. “Unemployment and Unemployment Benefits in the OECD 1960–1990: An Empirical Test of Neo-Classical Economic Theory.” Work, Employment & Society14(1):51–76.
74.
SørensenAage B.KallebergArne L.1981. “An Outline of a Theory of the Matching of Persons to Jobs.” Pp. 49–74 in Sociological Perspectives on Labor Markets, edited by BergI.New York: Academic Press.
75.
StreeckWolfgang. 1992. Social Institutions and Economic Performance: Studies of Industrial Relations in Advanced Capitalist Economies. London, UK: Sage.
76.
ThelenKathleen. 2004. How Institutions Evolve: The Political Economy of Skills in Comparative-Historical Perspective. New York: Cambridge University Press.
77.
ThelenKathleen. 2014. Varieties of Liberalization and the New Politics of Social Solidarity. New York: Cambridge University Press.
78.
van OursJan C.VodopivecMilan. 2006. “How Shortening the Potential Duration of Unemployment Benefits Affects the Duration of Unemployment: Evidence from a Natural Experiment.” Journal of Labor Economics24(2):351–78.
79.
van VlietOlafCaminadaKoen. 2012. “Unemployment Replacement Rates Dataset among 34 Welfare States, 1971–2009: An Update, Extension and Modification of the Scruggs’ Welfare State Entitlements Data Set.” Neujobs Special Report No.2/January2012.
80.
VennDanielle. 2009. “Legislation, Collective Bargaining and Enforcement.” Vol. No. 89. OECD Social, Employment and Migration Working Papers.
81.
VerbeekMarnoVellaFrancis. 2005. “Estimating Dynamic Models from Repeated Cross-Sections.” Journal of Econometrics127(1):83–102.
82.
ViebrockElkeClasenJochen. 2008. “Flexicurity and Welfare Reform: A Review.” Socio-Economic Review7(2):305–331.
83.
VisserJelle. 2013. ICTWSS: Database on Institutional Characteristics of Trade Unions, Wage Setting, State Intervention and Social Pacts in 34 Countries between 1960 and 2012. Amsterdam Institute for Advanced Labour Studies AIAS, Amsterdam.
84.
WesternBruce. 1998. “Institutions and the Labor Market.” Pp. 224–43 in The New Institutionalism in Sociology, edited by BrintonM. C.NeeV.New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
85.
WesternBruceRosenfeldJake. 2011. “Unions, Norms, and the Rise in U.S. Wage Inequality.” American Sociological Review76(4):513–37.
86.
WilthagenTonTrosFrank. 2004. “The Concept of ‘Flexicurity’: A New Approach to Regulating Employment and Labour Markets.” Transfer10(2):166–86.
87.
WrightErik O.2000. “Working-Class Power, Capitalist-Class Interests, and Class Compromise.” American Journal of Sociology105(4):957–1002.
88.
WulfgrammMelikeFerversLukas. 2015. “Unemployment and Subsequent Employment Stability: Does Labour Market Policy Matter?” Socio-Economic Review13(4):791–812.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
