A recurring theme in sociological research is the tradeoff between fitting in and standing out. Prior work examining this tension tends to take either a structural or a cultural perspective. We fuse these two traditions to develop a theory of how structural and cultural embeddedness jointly relate to individual attainment within organizations. Given that organizational culture is hard to observe, we develop a novel approach to assessing individuals’ cultural fit with their colleagues based on the language expressed in internal e-mail communications. Drawing on a unique dataset that includes a corpus of 10.24 million e-mail messages exchanged over five years among 601 employees in a high-technology firm, we find that network constraint impedes, whereas cultural fit promotes, individual attainment. More importantly, we find evidence of a tradeoff between the two forms of embeddedness: cultural fit benefits individuals with low network constraint (i.e., brokers), whereas network constraint promotes attainment for people with low cultural fit.
AralSinanVan AlstyneMarshall W.2011. “The Diversity-Bandwidth Tradeoff.”American Journal of Sociology117(1):90–171.
2.
BaronJames N.KrepsDavid M.2014. “Employment as an Economic and a Social Relationship.” Pp. 315–41 in The Handbook of Organizational Economics, edited by R. Gibbons and J. Roberts. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
3.
BearmanPeter S.MoodyJames. 2004. “Suicide and Friendships among American Adolescents.”American Journal of Public Health94(1):89–95.
4.
BiancaniSusanMcFarlandDaniel A.DahlanderLinus. 2014. “The Semiformal Organization.”Organization Science25(5):1306–1324.
5.
BonacichPhillip. 1987. “Power and Centrality: A Family of Measures.”American Journal of Sociology92(5):1170–82.
6.
BrewerMarilynn B.1991. “The Social Self: On Being the Same and Different at the Same Time.”Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin17(5):475–82.
7.
BurtRonald S.1992. Structural Holes: The Social Structure of Competition. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
8.
BurtRonald S.1997. “The Contingent Value of Social Capital.”Administrative Science Quarterly42(2):339–65.
9.
BurtRonald S.2005. Brokerage and Closure. New York: Oxford University Press.
10.
BurtRonald S.KilduffMartinTasselliStefano. 2013. “Social Network Analysis: Foundations and Frontiers on Advantage.”Annual Review of Psychology64(1):527–47.
11.
BurtRonald S.MerluzziJennifer. Forthcoming. “Network Oscillation.”Academy of Management Discoveries. doi:10.5465/amd.2015.0108.
12.
CarleyKathleen. 1991. “A Theory of Group Stability.”American Sociological Review56(3):331–54.
13.
CarleyKathleenPalmquistMichael. 1992. “Extracting, Representing, and Analyzing Mental Models.”Social Forces70(3):601–636.
14.
ChanCindyBergerJonahVan BovenLeaf. 2012. “Identifiable but Not Identical: Combining Social Identity and Uniqueness Motives in Choice.”Journal of Consumer Research39(3):561–73.
15.
ChatmanJennifer A.1991. “Matching People and Organizations: Selection and Socialization in Public Accounting Firms.”Administrative Science Quarterly36(3):459–84.
16.
ColemanJames S.1988. “Social Capital in the Creation of Human Capital.”American Journal of Sociology94(S1):S95–S120.
17.
CoxDavid R.1972. “Regression Models and Life Tables.”Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B34(2):187–202.
18.
Danescu-Niculescu-MizilCristianLeeLillianPangBoKleinbergJon. 2012. “Echoes of Power: Language Effects and Power Differences in Social Interaction.” Pp. 699–708 in Proceedings of the 21st International Conference on World Wide Web. Lyon, France: ACM.
19.
Danescu-Niculescu-MizilCristianWestRobertJurafskyDanLeskovecJurePottsChristopher. 2013. “No Country for Old Members: User Lifecycle and Linguistic Change in Online Communities.” Pp. 307–318 in Proceedings of the 22nd International Conference on World Wide Web. Rio de Janeiro, Brazil: International World Wide Web Conferences Steering Committee.
20.
DavisJames A.1963. “Structural Balance, Mechanical Solidarity, and Interpersonal Relations.”American Journal of Sociology68(4):444–62.
21.
de VaanMathijsStarkDavidVedresBalazs. 2015. “Game Changer: The Topology of Creativity.”American Journal of Sociology120(4):1144–94.
22.
DellaPostaDanielShiYongrenMacyMichael. 2015. “Why Do Liberals Drink Lattes?”American Journal of Sociology120(5):1473–1511.
23.
DiMaggioPaul. 1997. “Culture and Cognition.”Annual Review of Sociology23:263–88.
24.
DoughertyDeborah. 1992. “Interpretive Barriers to Successful Product Innovation in Large Firms.”Organization Science3(2):179–202.
25.
DouglasMary. 1986. How Institutions Think. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press.
26.
EmirbayerMustafaGoodwinJeff. 1994. “Network Analysis, Culture, and the Problem of Agency.”American Journal of Sociology99(6):1411–54.
27.
EricksonBonnie H.1996. “Culture, Class, and Connections.”American Journal of Sociology102(1):217–51.
28.
FergusonJohn-PaulHasanSharique. 2013. “Specialization and Career Dynamics: Evidence from the Indian Administrative Service.”Administrative Science Quarterly58(2):233–56.
29.
FineGary Alan. 1979. “Small Groups and Culture Creation: The Idioculture of Little League Baseball Teams.”American Sociological Review44(5):733–45.
30.
FlemingLee. 2001. “Recombinant Uncertainty in Technological Search.”Management Science47(1):117–32.
FosterJacob G.RzhetskyAndreyEvansJames A.2015. “Tradition and Innovation in Scientists’ Research Strategies.”American Sociological Review80(5):875–908.
33.
GoffmanErving. 1986. Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity. New York: Simon & Schuster.
34.
GoldbergAmir. 2011. “Mapping Shared Understandings Using Relational Class Analysis: The Case of the Cultural Omnivore Reexamined.”American Journal of Sociology116(5):1397–1436.
35.
GoldbergAmirHannanMichael T.KovácsBalázs. 2016. “What Does It Mean to Span Cultural Boundaries? Variety and Atypicality in Cultural Consumption.”American Sociological Review81(2):215–41.
36.
GranovetterMark S.1973. “The Strength of Weak Ties.”American Journal of Sociology78(6):1360–80.
37.
GranovetterMark S.1985. “Economic Action and Social Structure: The Problem of Embeddedness.”American Journal of Sociology91(3):481–510.
38.
HansenMorten T.1999. “The Search-Transfer Problem: The Role of Weak Ties in Sharing Knowledge across Organization Subunits.”Administrative Science Quarterly44(1):82–111.
39.
HarrisonJ. RichardCarrollGlenn R.2006. Culture and Demography in Organizations. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
40.
HartnellChad A.OuAmy YiKinickiAngelo. 2011. “Organizational Culture and Organizational Effectiveness: A Meta-Analytic Investigation of the Competing Values Framework’s Theoretical Suppositions.”Journal of Applied Psychology96(4):677–94.
41.
HofstedeGeertNeuijenBramOhayvDenise DavalSandersGeert. 1990. “Measuring Organizational Cultures: A Qualitative and Quantitative Study across Twenty Cases.”Administrative Science Quarterly35(2):286–316.
42.
HsuGretaHannanMichael T.2005. “Identities, Genres, and Organizational Forms.”Organization Science16(5):474–90.
43.
HsuGretaHannanMichael T.KoçakÖzgecan. 2009. “Multiple Category Memberships in Markets: An Integrative Theory and Two Empirical Tests.”American Sociological Review74(1):150–69.
44.
JackendoffRay. 2002. Foundations of Language: Brain, Meaning, Grammar, Evolution. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
45.
JacobsDavid. 1981. “Toward a Theory of Mobility and Behavior in Organizations: An Inquiry Into the Consequences of Some Relationships between Individual Performance and Organizational Success.”American Journal of Sociology87(3):684–707.
46.
KleinbaumAdam M.2012. “Organizational Misfits and the Origins of Brokerage in Intrafirm Networks.”Administrative Science Quarterly57(3):407–452.
47.
KleinbaumAdam M.StuartToby E.TushmanMichael L.2013. “Discretion within Constraint: Homophily and Structure in a Formal Organization.”Organization Science24(5):1316–36.
48.
KossinetsGueorgiWattsDuncan J.2006. “Empirical Analysis of an Evolving Social Network.”Science311(5757):88–90.
49.
KossinetsGueorgiWattsDuncan J.2009. “Origins of Homophily in an Evolving Social Network.”American Journal of Sociology115(2):405–450.
50.
KrackhardtDavid. 1999. “Ties that Torture: Simmelian Tie Analysis in Organizations.”Research in the Sociology of Organizations16:183–210.
51.
KrackhardtDavidKilduffMartin. 1990. “Friendship Patterns and Culture: The Control of Organizational Diversity.”American Anthropologist92(1):142–54.
52.
KrippnerGreta R.AlvarezAnthony S.2007. “Embeddedness and the Intellectual Projects of Economic Sociology.”Annual Review of Sociology33(1):219–40.
53.
Kristof-BrownAmy L.ZimmermanRyan D.JohnsonErin C.2005. “Consequences of Individuals’ Fit at Work: A Meta-Analysis of Person-Job, Person-Organization, Person-Group, and Person-Supervisor Fit.”Personnel Psychology58(2):281–342.
54.
KundaGideon. 2006. Engineering Culture: Control and Commitment in a High-Tech Corporation. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
55.
LeonardelliGeoffrey J.PickettCynthia L.BrewerMarilynn B.2010. “Optimal Distinctiveness Theory: A Framework for Social Identity, Social Cognition, and Intergroup Relations.” Pp. 63–113 in Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, Vol. 43, edited by MarkP. Z.JamesM. O.New York: Elsevier.
56.
LeungMing D.2014. “Dilettante or Renaissance Person? How the Order of Job Experiences Affects Hiring in an External Labor Market.”American Sociological Review79(1):136–58.
57.
LinJianhua. 1991. “Divergence Measures Based on the Shannon Entropy.”IEEE Transactions on Information Theory37(1):145–51.
58.
LiuChristopher C.SrivastavaSameer B.2015. “Pulling Closer and Moving Apart: Interaction, Identity, and Influence in the U.S. Senate, 1973 to 2009.” American Sociological Review80(1):192–217.
LizardoOmar. 2006. “How Cultural Tastes Shape Personal Networks.”American Sociological Review71(5):778–807.
61.
MartinJoanne. 1992. Cultures in Organizations: Three Perspectives. New York: Oxford University Press.
62.
McFarlandDaniel A.JurafskyDanRawlingsCraig. 2013. “Making the Connection: Social Bonding in Courtship Situations.”American Journal of Sociology118(6):1596–1649.
63.
McLeanPaul D.1998. “A Frame Analysis of Favor Seeking in the Renaissance: Agency, Networks, and Political Culture.”American Journal of Sociology104(1):51–91.
64.
MenchikDaniel A.TianXiaoli. 2008. “Putting Social Context into Text: The Semiotics of E-mail Interactions.”American Journal of Sociology114(2):332–70.
65.
O’ReillyCharles A.ChatmanJenniferCaldwellDavid F.1991. “People and Organizational Culture: A Profile Comparison Approach to Assessing Person-Organization Fit.”Academy of Management Journal34(3):487–516.
66.
PachuckiMark A.BreigerRonald L.2010. “Cultural Holes: Beyond Relationality in Social Networks and Culture.”Annual Review of Sociology36:205–224.
67.
PadgettJohn F.AnsellChristopher K.1993. “Robust Action and the Rise of the Medici, 1400–1434.”American Journal of Sociology98(6):1259–1319.
68.
PattersonOrlando. 2014. “Making Sense of Culture.”Annual Review of Sociology40:1–30.
69.
PennebakerJames W.ChungCindy K.IrelandMollyGonzalezAmyBoothRoger J.2007. The Development and Psychometric Properties of LIWC2007 (LIWC.net).
70.
PetersenTrondSaportaIshakSeidelMarc-David L.2000. “Offering a Job: Meritocracy and Social Networks.”American Journal of Sociology106(3):763–816.
71.
PhillipsDamon J.ZuckermanEzra. 2001. “Middle Status Conformity: Theoretical Restatement and Empirical Demonstration in Two Markets.”American Journal of Sociology107(2):379–429.
72.
PinkerSteven. 2007. The Stuff of Thought: Language as a Window into Human Nature. New York: Penguin Group.
73.
PodolnyJoel M.2001. “Networks as the Pipes and Prisms of the Market.”American Journal of Sociology107(1):33–60.
74.
PodolnyJoel M.BaronJames N.1997. “Resources and Relationships: Social Networks and Mobility in the Workplace.”American Sociological Review62(5):673–93.
75.
PopielarzPamela A.McPhersonJ. Miller. 1995. “On the Edge or In Between: Niche Position, Niche Overlap, and the Duration of Voluntary Association Memberships.”American Journal of Sociology101(3):698–720.
76.
PortesAlejandroSensenbrennerJulia. 1993. “Embeddedness and Immigration: Notes on the Social Determinants of Economic Action.”American Journal of Sociology98(6):1320–50.
77.
QuintaneEricKleinbaumAdam M.2011. “Matter over Mind? E-mail Data and the Measurement of Social Networks.”Connections31(1):22–46.
78.
RaoHayagreevaMoninPhilippeDurandRodolphe. 2005. “Border Crossing: Bricolage and the Erosion of Categorical Boundaries in French Gastronomy.”American Sociological Review70(6):968–91.
79.
ReagansRayMcEvilyBill. 2003. “Network Structure and Knowledge Transfer: The Effects of Cohesion and Range.”Administrative Science Quarterly48(2):240–67.
80.
RidgewayCecilia L.1981. “Nonconformity, Competence, and Influence in Groups: A Test of Two Theories.”American Sociological Review46(3):333–47.
81.
RiveraLauren A.2012. “Hiring as Cultural Matching: The Case of Elite Professional Service Firms.”American Sociological Review77(6):999–1022.
82.
RiveraLauren A.2015. “Go with Your Gut: Emotion and Evaluation in Job Interviews.”American Journal of Sociology120(5):1339–89.
83.
RossmanGabrielEsparzaNicoleBonacichPhillip. 2010. “I’d Like to Thank the Academy, Team Spillovers, and Network Centrality.”American Sociological Review75(1):31–51.
84.
ScheinEdgar H.2010. Organizational Culture and Leadership. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
85.
SeibertScott E.KramerMaria L.LidenRobert C.2001. “A Social Capital Theory of Career Success.”Academy of Management Journal44(2):219–37.
86.
SewellWilliam H.Jr.1992. “A Theory of Structure: Duality, Agency, and Transformation.”American Journal of Sociology98(1):1–29.
87.
SimmelGeorg. 1950. The Sociology of Georg Simmel. Translated by K. H. Wolff. New York: The Free Press.
88.
SmallMario LuisHardingDavid J.LamontMichèle. 2010. “Reconsidering Culture and Poverty.”Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science629(6):6–27.
89.
SmithEdward Bishop. 2011. “Identities as Lenses: How Organizational Identity Affects Audiences’ Evaluation of Organizational Performance.”Administrative Science Quarterly56(1):61–94.
90.
SørensenJesper B.2002. “The Strength of Corporate Culture and the Reliability of Firm Performance.”Administrative Science Quarterly47(1):70–91.
91.
SrivastavaSameer B.2015. “Intraorganizational Network Dynamics in Times of Ambiguity.”Organization Science26(5):1365–80.
92.
SrivastavaSameer B.BanajiMahzarin R.2011. “Culture, Cognition, and Collaborative Networks in Organizations.”American Sociological Review76(2):207–233.
93.
SrivastavaSameer B.GoldbergAmirManianV. GovindPottsChristopher. Forthcoming. “Enculturation Trajectories and Individual Attainment: An Interactional Language Use Model of Cultural Dynamics in Organizations.”Management Science.
94.
TausczikYla R.PennebakerJames W.2010. “The Psychological Meaning of Words: LIWC and Computerized Text Analysis Methods.”Journal of Language and Social Psychology29(1):24–54.
95.
TushmanMichael L.ScanlanThomas J.1981. “Characteristics and External Orientations of Boundary Spanning Individuals.”Academy of Management Journal24(1):83–98.
96.
UzziBrian. 1996. “The Sources and Consequences of Embeddedness for the Economic Performance of Organizations: The Network Effect.”American Sociological Review61(4):674–98.
97.
UzziBrian. 1997. “Social Structure and Competition in Interfirm Networks: The Paradox of Embeddedness.”Administrative Science Quarterly42(1):35–67.
98.
UzziBrian. 1999. “Embeddedness in the Making of Financial Capital: How Social Relations and Networks Benefit Firms Seeking Financing.”American Sociological Review64(4):481–505.
99.
UzziBrianMukherjeeSatyamStringerMichaelJonesBen. 2013. “Atypical Combinations and Scientific Impact.”Science342(6157):468–72.
100.
UzziBrianSpiroJarrett. 2005. “Collaboration and Creativity: The Small World Problem.”American Journal of Sociology111(2):447–504.
101.
Van den SteenEric. 2010. “Culture Clash: The Costs and Benefits of Homogeneity.”Management Science56(1):1718–38.
102.
Van MaanenJohnBarleyStephen R.1984. “Occupational Communities: Culture and Control in Organizations.” Pp. 287–365 in Research in Organizational Behavior, Vol. 6, edited by StawB. M.CummingsL.Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
103.
VedresBalázsStarkDavid. 2010. “Structural Folds: Generative Disruption in Overlapping Groups.”American Journal of Sociology115(4):1150–90.
104.
WeberRoberto A.CamererColin F.2003. “Cultural Conflict and Merger Failure: An Experimental Approach.”Management Science49(4):400–415.
105.
XiaoZhixingTsuiAnne S.2007. “When BrokersMayNot Work: The Cultural Contingency of Social Capital in Chinese High-Tech Firms.”Administrative Science Quarterly52(1):1–31.
106.
ZelizerViviana. 2011. Economic Lives: How Culture Shapes the Economy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
107.
ZerubavelEviatar. 1997. Social Mindscapes: An Invitation to Cognitive Sociology. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
108.
ZuckermanEzra W.1999. “The Categorical Imperative: Securities Analysts and the Illegitimacy Discount.”American Journal of Sociology104(5):1398–1438.
109.
ZuckermanEzra W.KimTai-YoungUkanwaKalindavon RittmannJames. 2003. “Robust Identities or Non-Entities? Typecasting in the Feature Film Labor Market.”American Journal of Sociology108(5):1018–75.
110.
ZukinSharonDiMaggioPaul. 1990. Structures of Capital: The Social Organization of the Economy. New York: Cambridge University Press.
