Rebellious collective action is rare, but it can occur when subordinates are severely discontented and other circumstances are favorable. The possibility of rebellion is a check—sometimes the only check—on authoritarian rule. Although mutinies in which crews seized control of their vessels were rare events, they occurred throughout the Age of Sail. To explain the occurrence of this form of high-risk collective action, this article holds that shipboard grievances were the principal cause of mutiny. However, not all grievances are equal in this respect. We distinguish between structural grievances that flow from incumbency in a subordinate social position and incidental grievances that incumbents have no expectation of suffering. Based on a case-control analysis of incidents of mutiny compared with controls drawn from a unique database of Royal Navy voyages from 1740 to 1820, in addition to a wealth of qualitative evidence, we find that mutiny was most likely to occur when structural grievances were combined with incidental ones. This finding has implications for understanding the causes of rebellion and the attainment of legitimate social order more generally.
AllenDouglas W.2002. “The British Navy Rules: Monitoring and Incompatible Incentives in the Age of Fighting Sail.” Explorations in Economic History39(2):204–231.
2.
ArmenianHaroutune K., ed. 1994. “Applications of the Case-Control Method.” Epidemiologic Reviews16(1):1–164.
3.
BatesRobert H.2008. When Things Fell Apart: State Failure in Late-Century Africa. New York: Cambridge University Press.
4.
BeissingerMark R.2011. “Mechanisms of Maidan: The Structure of Contingency in the Making of the Orange Revolution.” Mobilization16(1):25–43.
5.
BenfordRobertSnowDavid. 2000. “Framing Processes and Social Movements.” Annual Review of Sociology26:611–39.
6.
BergstrandKelly. 2014. “The Mobilizing Power of Grievances: Applying Loss-Aversion and Omission Biases to Social Movements.” Mobilization19(2):123–42.
7.
BlighWilliam. [1792] 1962. An Account of the Mutiny on Board H.M.S. Bounty. New York: Signet.
8.
BoswellJames. [1791] 1934–1950. Boswell’s Life of Johnson. Oxford, UK: Clarendon Press.
9.
Bowden-DanJane. 2004. “Diet, Dirt and Discipline: Medical Developments in Nelson’s Navy.” Mariner’s Mirror90(3):260–72.
10.
BrushStephen G.1996. “Dynamics of Theory Change in the Social Sciences: Relative Deprivation and Collective Violence.” Journal of Conflict Resolution40(4):523–45.
11.
ByrnJohn. 1989. Crime and Punishment in the Royal Navy: Discipline on the Leeward Islands Station, 1784–1812. Aldershot, UK: Scolar Press.
12.
CalhounCraig. 1982. The Question of Class Struggle: Social Foundations of Popular Radicalism during the Industrial Revolution. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
13.
CarrabineEamonn. 2005. “Prison Riots, Social Order and the Problem of Legitimacy.” British Journal of Criminology45(6):896–913.
14.
CedermanLars-ErikGleditschKristian SkredeBuhaugHalvard. 2013. Inequality, Grievances and Civil War. New York: Cambridge University Press.
15.
CentolaDamon. 2013. “Homophily, Networks, and Critical Mass: Solving the Start-up Problem in Large Group Collective Action.” Rationality and Society25(1):3–40.
16.
ChongDennis. 1991. Collective Action and the Civil Rights Movement. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
17.
ClaverScott. 1954. Under the Lash: A History of Corporal Punishment in the British Armed Forces. London, UK: Torchstream.
EarlePeter. 1998. Sailors: English Merchant Seamen, 1656–1775. London, UK: Meuthen.
27.
FearonJamesLaitinDavid. 2003. “Ethnicity, Insurgency, and Civil War.” American Political Science Review97(1):75–90.
28.
FrykmanNiklas. 2009. “Seamen on Late Eighteenth-Century European Warships.” International Review of Social History54(1):67–93.
29.
FrykmanNiklas. 2010. “The Mutiny on theHermione: Warfare, Revolution and Treason in the Royal Navy.” Journal of Social History44(1):159–87.
30.
GailMitchellWilliamsRogerByarDavid P.BrownCharles. 1976. “How Many Controls?” Journal of Chronic Disease29(11):723–31.
31.
GamsonWilliamFiremanBruceRytinaSteven. 1982. Encounters with Unjust Authority. Belmont, CA: Dorsey.
32.
GilbertArthur. 1983. “The Nature of Mutiny in the British Navy in the Eighteenth Century.” Pp. 111–20 in Naval History, edited by MastersonD.Wilmington, DE: Scholarly Resources.
33.
GillConrad. 1961. Merchants and Mariners of the 18th Century. London, UK: Arnold.
34.
GoldstoneJack A.BatesRobert H.EpsteinDavid L.GurrTed RobertLustickMichael B.MarshallMonty G.UlfelderJayWoodwardMark. 2010. “A Global Model for Forecasting Political Instability.” American Journal of Political Science54(1):190–208.
35.
GoldstoneJack A.UseemBert. 1999. “Prison Riots as Micro-Revolutions: An Extension of State-Centered Theories of Revolution.” American Journal of Sociology104(4):985–1029.
36.
GoodwinJeff. 2001. No Other Way Out: States and Revolutionary Movements, 1945–1991. New York: Cambridge University Press.
37.
GossettWilliam P.1986. The Lost Ships of the Royal Navy, 1793–1900. London, UK: Mansell.
38.
GouldRoger. 1995. Insurgent Identities: Class, Community and Protest in Paris from 1848 to the Commune. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
39.
GurrTed Robert. 1970. Why Men Rebel. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
40.
GuttridgeLeonard F.1992. Mutiny: A History of Naval Insurrection. Annapolis, MD: Naval Institute Press.
41.
HaineEdgar. 1992. Mutiny on the High Seas. New York and London: Cornwall.
42.
HardinRussell. 1982. Collective Action. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
43.
HathawayJane, ed. 2001. Rebellion, Repression and Reinvention: Mutiny in Comparative Perspective. Westport, CT: Praeger.
44.
HechterMichael. 1978. “Group Formation and the Cultural Division of Labor.” American Journal of Sociology84(2):293–318.
45.
HechterMichael. 1987. Principles of Group Solidarity. Berkeley: University of California Press.
46.
HechterMichael. 1998. Internal Colonialism: The Celtic Fringe in British National Development, rev. ed. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction.
47.
HechterMichael. 2013. Alien Rule. New York: Cambridge University Press.
48.
HeckathornDouglas D.1996. “The Dynamics and Dilemmas of Collective Action.” American Sociological Review61(2):250–77.
49.
HepperDavid J.1994. British Warship Losses in the Age of Sail, 1650–1859. Rotherfield, UK: Boudriot.
50.
HorowitzDonald. 2001. The Deadly Ethnic Riot. Berkeley: University of California Press.
51.
KahnemanDaniel. 2011. Thinking Fast and Slow. New York: Farrar, Strauss & Giroux.
52.
KalyvasStathis N.KocherMatthew A.2007. “How ‘Free’ is Free Riding in Civil Wars? Violence, Insurgency and the Collective Action Problem.” World Politics59(2):177–216.
53.
KemperTheodore. 2001. “A Structural Approach to Social Movement Emotions.” Pp. 58–73 in Passionate Politics, edited by GoodwinJ.JasperJ.PollettaF.Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
54.
KerrClarkSiegalAbraham. 1954. “The Interindustry Propensity to Stike.” Pp. 189–212 in Industrial Conflict, edited by KornhauserA.DuganR.RossA.New York: McGraw-Hill.
55.
KingGaryZengLangche. 2001. “Logistic Regression in Rare Events Data.” Political Analysis9(2):137–63.
56.
KittsJames A.2000. “Mobilizing in Black Boxes: Social Networks and Participation in Social Movement Organizations.” Mobilization5(2):241–57.
57.
KlandermansBert. 1997. The Social Psychology of Protest. Oxford, UK: Blackwells.
58.
LammersCornelis J.1969. “Strikes and Mutinies: A Comparative Study of Organizational Conflicts between Rulers and Ruled.” Administrative Science Quarterly14(4):558–72.
59.
LammersCornelis J.2003. “Mutiny in Comparative Perspective.” International Review of Labor History48(3):473–82.
60.
LaskyTamarStolleyPaul D.1994. “Selection of Cases and Controls.” Epidemiologic Review16(1):6–17.
61.
LaveryBrian. 1998. Shipboard Life and Organisation, 1731–1815. Aldershot, UK: Ashgate.
62.
LaveryBrian. 2010. Royal Tars: The Lower Deck of the Royal Navy, 875–1850. Annapolis, MD: Naval Institute Press.
63.
LeesonPeter. 2010. “Rational Choice, Round Robin, and Rebellion: An Institutional Solution to the Problem of Revolution.” Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization73(3):297–307.
64.
LewisMichael A.1960. A Social History of the Navy, 1793–1815. London: Allen &Unwin.
65.
LichbachMark. 1995. The Rebel’s Dilemma. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
66.
LongJ. Scott. 1997. Regression Models for Categorical and Limited Dependent Variables. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
67.
LyonDavid. 1993. The Sailing Navy List: All the Ships of the Royal Navy, Built, Purchased and Captured, 1688–1860. London, UK: Conway Maritime Press.
68.
MacDonaldJanet. 2006. Feeding Nelson’s Navy: The True Story of Food at Sea during the Georgian Era. London, UK: Chatham.
69.
MarwellGeraldOliverPamela. 1993. The Critical Mass in Collective Action. New York: Cambridge University Press.
70.
McAdamDougBoudetHilary. 2012. Putting Social Movements in Their Place. New York: Cambridge University Press.
71.
McAdamDougMcCarthyJohn D.ZaldMayer N., eds. 1996. Comparative Perspectives on Social Movements. New York: Cambridge.
72.
MeadGeorge Herbert. 1934. Mind, Self and Society. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
73.
NeafseyEdward. 2002. The All New Surnames of Ireland. Kansas City, MO: Irish Genealogical Society.
74.
NealeJonathan. 1985. The Cutlass and the Lash: Mutiny and Discipline in Nelson’s Navy. London, UK: Pluto.
75.
NewmanStephen C.2001. Biostatistical Methods in Epidemiology. New York: Wiley.
76.
OlsonMancur. 1965. The Logic of Collective Action. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
77.
ØstbyGudrun2008. “Polarization, Horizontal Inequalities and Violent Civil Conflict.” Journal of Peace Research45(2):143–62.
78.
PackS.W.C.1964. The Wager Mutiny. London, UK: Redman.
79.
PfaffSteven. 1996. “Collective Identity and Informal Groups in Revolutionary Mobilization.” Social Forces75(1):91–118.
80.
PfaffSteven. 2006. Exit-Voice Dynamics and the Collapse of East Germany. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
81.
PfaffStevenHechterMichaelCorcoranKatie E. Forthcoming. “The Problem of Solidarity in Insurgent Collective Action: The Nore Mutiny of 1797.” Social Science History.
82.
PinardMaurice. 2011. Motivational Dimensions in Social Movements and Contentious Collective Action. Montreal, Canada: McGill-Queen’s University Press.
83.
PopeDudley. 1981. Life in Nelson’s Navy. London, UK: Unwin Hyman.
84.
PopeDudley. 1987. The Devil Himself: The Mutiny of 1800. London, UK: Secker and Warburg.
85.
RaoHayagreevaDuttaSunasir. 2012. “Free Spaces as Organizational Weapons of the Weak: Religious Festivals and Regimental Mutinies in the 1857 Bengal Native Army.” Administrative Science Quarterly57(4):625–68.
86.
RedikerMarcus. 1987. Between the Devil and the Deep Blue Sea: Merchant Seamen, Pirates and the Anglo-American Maritime World, 1700–1750. New York: Cambridge University Press.
87.
RodgerN.A.M.1982. The Articles of War: The Statutes Which Governed Our Fighting Navies, 1661–1749 and 1866. Havant, UK: Mason.
88.
RodgerN.A.M.1986. The Wooden World: An Anatomy of the Georgian Navy. New York: Norton.
89.
RodgerN.A.M.2004. The Command of the Ocean: A Naval History of Britain, 1649–1815. London, UK: Penguin.
90.
RoseElihu. 1982. “The Anatomy of Mutiny.” Armed Forces and Society8(4):561–74.
91.
RudéGeorge. 1964. The Crowd in History: A Study of Popular Disturbances in France and England, 1730–1848. New York: Wiley.
92.
SchellingThomas. 1960. The Strategy of Conflict. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
93.
SchlesselmanJames. 1982. Case-Control Studies: Design, Conduct, Analysis. New York: Oxford.
94.
ShilsEdward A.JanowitzMorris. 1948. “Cohesion and Disintegration in the Wehrmacht in World War II.” Public Opinion Quarterly12(2):280–315.
95.
SirokyDavid S.2009. “Navigating Random Forests and Advances in Algorithmic Modeling.” Statistics Surveys3:147–63.
96.
StewartFrances. 2008. Horizontal Inequalities and Conflict: Understanding Group Violence in Multiethnic Societies. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
97.
TauschNicoleBeckerJuliaSpearsRussellChristOliverSaabRimSinghPurnimaSiddiquiRoomana. 2011. “Explaining Radical Group Behavior: Developing Emotion and Efficacy Routes to Normative and Nonnormative Collective Action.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology101(1):129–48.
98.
TaylorMichael. 1997. The Possibility of Cooperation. New York: Cambridge University Press.
99.
ThealGeorge McCall, ed. 1898. The Records of the Cape Colony from December 1796 to December 1799, Vol. II. London, UK: Clowes.
100.
TillyCharles. 1978. From Mobilization to Revolution. New York: McGraw-Hill.
101.
TillyCharles. 1984. “Social Movements and National Politics” Pp. 297–317 in Statemaking and Social Movements, edited by BrightC.HardingS.Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
102.
TillyCharles. 1993. “Contentious Repertoires in Great Britain, 1758–1834.” Social Science History17(2):253–80.
TwiggerRobert. 1999. “Inflation: The Value of the Pound 1750–1998.” Research Paper 99/20, House of Commons Library.
105.
UseemBert. 1998. “Breakdown Theories of Collective Action.” Annual Review of Sociology24:215–38.
106.
UseemBertGoldstoneJack A.2002. “Forging Social Order and Its Breakdown: Riot and Reform in U.S. Prisons.” American Sociological Review67(4):499–525.
107.
UseemBertKimballPeter. 1989. States of Siege: U.S. Prison Riots, 1971–1986. New York: Oxford University Press.
108.
ValleJames. 1980. Rocks and Shoals: Naval Discipline in the Age of Fighting Sail. Annapolis, MD: Naval Institute Press.
109.
Van BuurenStefOudshoornC. G.1999. Flexible Multivariate Imputation by MICE. Leiden, the Netherlands: TNO Prevention and Health, Report PG/VGZ/99.054.
110.
Van StekelenburgJacquelienKlandermansBert. 2013. “The Social Psychology of Protest.” Current Sociology6(5–6):886–905.
111.
Van ZomerenMartijnPostmesTomSpearsRussell. 2008. “Toward an Integrative Social Identity Model of Collective Action.” Psychological Bulletin134(4):504–535.
112.
WalderAndrew. 2009. “Political Sociology and Social Movements.” Annual Review of Sociology35:393–412.
113.
WalshEdward. 1981. “Resource Mobilization and Citizen Protest around Three Mile Island.” Social Problems29(1):1–21.
114.
WeberMax. [1918–21] 1978. Economy and Society. Berkeley: University of California Press.
115.
WoodmanRichard. 2005. A Brief History of Mutiny. London, UK: Robinson.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
