Weber argued that human suffering creates the demand for theodicies: cultural vocabularies, religious or secular, that explain perceived injustices. This article combines an interpretive analysis of rhetoric commemorating the events of September 11, 2001 with an effort to construct generalizable cultural theory, demonstrating how the Weberian concept of theodicy adds to our understanding of commemorative rhetoric. In the case of September 11 commemorations, the theodicies deployed exhibit a clear fracture. Speakers at the Pentagon and in Shanksville, Pennsylvania, have taken a dualistic approach to the problem of theodicy, while speakers in Manhattan have taken a tragic approach. This variation can be explained through a four-part model that argues theodicies are structured by (1) events, (2) carrier groups, (3) audiences, and (4) genre memory. More broadly, I argue for explicit attention to theodicy in cultural sociology, demonstrating that the quest for theodicy is a crucial driving force behind the impulse to commemorate in the first place.
AlexanderJeffrey C.2004. “From the Depths of Despair: Performance, Counterperformance, and September 11.” Sociological Theory22:88–105.
2.
AlexanderJeffrey C.2005. The Meanings of Social Life: A Cultural Sociology. New York: Oxford University Press.
3.
AlexanderJeffrey C.BreeseElizabeth Butler. 2011. “Introduction: On Social Suffering and its Cultural Construction.” Pp. xi–xxxv in Narrating Trauma: On the Impact of Collective Suffering, edited by EyermanR.AlexanderJ. C.BreeseE. Butler. Boulder, CO: Paradigm Publishers.
4.
AlexanderJeffrey C.EyermanRonGiesenBernhardSmelserNeil J.SztompkaPiotr. 2004. Cultural Trauma and Collective Identity. Berkeley: University of California Press.
5.
AlexanderJeffrey C.SmithPhilip. 1993. “The Discourse of American Civil Society: A New Proposal for Cultural Studies.” Theory and Society22:151–207.
6.
American Broadcasting Companies (ABC). 2003. “Remembering 9/11 Coverage of Ceremony at Ground Zero.” LexisNexis Academic, U.S. News.
7.
AndersonBenedict. 1991. Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism, 2nd ed. New York: Verso.
8.
AnkerElisabeth. 2005. “Villains, Victims and Heroes: Melodrama, Media, and September 11.” Journal of Communication55:22–37.
9.
BakhtinMikhail. 1986. Speech Genres and Other Late Essays. Austin: University of Texas Press.
10.
BarronJames. 2003. “Another 9/11, and a Nation Mourns Again.” New York Times, September12, p. A1.
11.
BellahRobert N.1967. “Civil Religion in America.” Daedalus96:1–21.
12.
BergerPeter L.1967. The Sacred Canopy: Elements of a Sociological Theory of Religion. Garden City, NY: Doubleday.
13.
BergerPeter L.BergerBrigitteKellnerHansfried. 1974. The Homeless Mind: Modernization and Consciousness. New York: Vintage Books.
14.
BergerPeter L.WeigelGeorgeMartinDavidSacksJonathanDavieGraceWeimingTuAn-Na’imAbdullahi A.1999. The Desecularization of the World: Resurgent Religion and World Politics. Washington, DC: Ethics and Public Policy Center.
15.
BernsteinRichard J.2006. Abuse of Evil: The Corruption of Politics and Religion since 9/11. Malden, MA: Polity.
BoltanskiLucThévenotLaurent. 1999. “The Sociology of Critical Capacity.” European Journal of Social Theory2:359–77.
18.
BoltanskiLucThévenotLaurent. 2006. On Justification: Economies of Worth. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
19.
BushGeorge W.2001a. “Address Before a Joint Session of the Congress on the United States Response to the Terrorist Attacks of September 11.” Weekly Compilation of Presidential Documents37:1347–51.
20.
BushGeorge W.2001b. “Address to the Nation on the Terrorist Attacks.” Weekly Compilation of Presidential Documents37:1301–1302.
21.
BushGeorge W.2001c. “Remarks on the Terrorist Attacks on New York City’s World Trade Center in Sarasota, Florida.” Weekly Compilation of Presidential Documents37:1300.
22.
Cable News Network (CNN). 2004. “9/11 Remembrance Ceremony in New York City.” LexisNexis Academic, U.S. News.
CalhounCraig J.PricePaulTimmerAshley S.2002. Understanding September 11. New York: The New Press.
26.
CampbellColin. 2007. The Easternization of the West. Boulder, CO: Paradigm Publishing.
27.
CampbellKarlyn KohrsJamiesonKathleen Hall. 2008. Presidents Creating the Presidency: Deeds Done in Words. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
28.
CasanovaJosé. 1994. Public Religions in the Modern World. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
29.
City of New York. 2009. “Mayor Bloomberg Attends September 11th Commemoration Ceremony.” Retrieved February 2, 2011 (http://www.nyc.gov).
30.
Congressional Quarterly. 2008. “Former Gov. George Pataki Delivers Remarks on 9/11.” LexisNexis Academic, Government and Politics.
31.
DavisJoseph E.2005. Accounts of Innocence: Sexual Abuse, Trauma, and the Self. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
32.
EdelmanMurray. 1964. The Symbolic Uses of Politics. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
33.
ElsterJon. 1985. Sour Grapes: Studies in the Subversion of Rationality. New York: Cambridge University Press.
34.
EyermanRon. 2011. The Cultural Sociology of Political Assassination: From MLK and RFK to Fortuyn and Van Gogh. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
35.
Federal News Service. 2002a. “Remarks by President George W. Bush at Defense Department Ceremony Marking September 11th Terrorist Attack.” LexisNexis Academic, Government and Politics.
36.
Federal News Service. 2002b. “Remarks by Tom Ridge, Director, Office of Homeland Security, at a Ceremony Marking September 11th Anniversary.” LexisNexis Academic, Government and Politics.
37.
Federal News Service. 2003. “Remarks by Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld and Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff General Richard Myers at Memorial Ceremony for Victims of the September 11, 2001 Attack on the Pentagon.” LexisNexis Academic, Government and Politics.
38.
Federal News Service. 2005. “Prepared Remarks of Attorney General Alberto Gonzales at the Flight 93 Memorial Ceremony.” LexisNexis Academic, Government and Politics.
39.
Federal News Service. 2007. “Remarks by General Peter Pace, Chairman, Joint Chiefs of Staff, and Secretary of Defense Robert Gates.” LexisNexis Academic, Government and Politics.
40.
Federal News Service. 2008. “Remarks by Secretary of Homeland Defense Michael Chertoff on the Anniversary of the September 11th Attacks.” LexisNexis Academic, Government and Politics.
41.
Federal News Service. 2009. “Remarks by General Colin Powell, Former Secretary of State, Former Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, at a Memorial Ceremony for Flight 93.” LexisNexis Academic, Government and Politics.
42.
Federal News Service. 2010a. “Remarks by First Lady Michelle Obama at a September 11, 2001 Memorial Service.” LexisNexis Academic, Government and Politics.
43.
Federal News Service. 2010b. “Remarks by President Barack Obama at the Pentagon Memorial.” LexisNexis Academic, Government and Politics.
44.
Federal News Service. 2011. “Remarks by Vice President Joseph Biden at a September 11th Commemoration.” LexisNexis Academic, Government and Politics.
45.
FineGary Alan. 1996. “Reputational Entrepreneurs and the Memory of Incompetence: Melting Supporters, Partisan Warriors, and Images of President Harding.” American Journal of Sociology101:1159–93.
46.
FryeNorthrop. 2006. Anatomy of Criticism: Four Essays. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
47.
GeertzClifford. 1973. Interpretation of Cultures: Selected Essays. New York: Basic Books.
48.
GibbTom. 2002. “Flight 93 Ceremony Planners Put to Test.” Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, July16, p. A7.
49.
GiddensAnthony. 1991. Modernity and Self-Identity: Self and Society in the Late Modern Age. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
50.
GiesenBernhard. 2004. Triumph and Trauma. Boulder, CO: Paradigm Publishers.
51.
GlickLyzZegartDan. 2004. Your Father’s Voice. New York: St. Martin’s Press.
52.
GoffmanErving. 1959. The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life. New York: Doubleday.
53.
GoldbergAlfredPapadopoulosSarandisPutneyDianeBerlageNancyWelchRebecca. 2007. Pentagon 9/11. Washington, DC: Office of the Secretary of Defense.
54.
GriswoldWendy. 1986. Renaissance Revivals: City Comedy and Revenge Tragedy in the London Theatre, 1576–1980. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
55.
GriswoldWendy. 1987. “A Methodological Framework for the Sociology of Culture.” Sociological Methodology17:1–35.
56.
HabermanClyde. 2007. “For 9/11, the Eloquence is Borrowed.” New York Times, September14, p. B1.
57.
HallJohn R.2009. Apocalypse: From Antiquity to the Empire of Modernity. Malden, MA: Polity.
58.
HarveyJohn H.OrbuchTerri L.WeberAnn L., eds. 1992. Attributions, Accounts, and Close Relationships. New York: Springer-Verlag.
59.
HuWinnie. 2003. “Mayor Says Cheney Is Appropriate Choice for 9/11 Ceremony.” New York Times, September6, p. B2.
60.
HuntLynn. 1984. Politics, Culture, and Class in the French Revolution. Berkeley: University of California Press.
61.
HunterJames Davison. 1982. “Subjectivization and the New Evangelical Theodicy.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion21:39–47.
62.
JacobsRonald N.2001. “The Problem with Tragic Narratives: Lessons from the Los Angeles Uprising.” Qualitative Sociology24:221–43.
63.
JacobsRonald N.SmithPhilip. 1997. “Romance, Irony, and Solidarity.” Sociological Theory15:60–80.
64.
KaneAnne. 1991. “Cultural Analysis in Historical Sociology: The Analytic and Concrete Forms of the Autonomy of Culture.” Sociological Theory9:53–69.
65.
LamontMichèle. 1992. Money, Morals, and Manners. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
66.
LandlerMark. 2011. “President, at Ground Zero, Pays Tribute to Victims of Bin Laden.” New York Times, May6, p. A13.
OlickJeffrey K.1999. “Genre Memories and Memory Genres: A Dialogical Analysis of May 8, 1945 Commemorations in the Federal Republic of Germany.” American Sociological Review64:381–402.
85.
OlickJeffrey K.2007. The Politics of Regret: On Collective Memory and Historical Responsibility. New York: Routledge.
86.
OlickJeffrey K.LevyDaniel. 1997. “Collective Memory and Cultural Constraint: Holocaust Myth and Rationality in German Politics.” American Sociological Review62:921–36.
87.
OlickJeffrey K.RobbinsJoyce. 1998. “Social Memory Studies: From ‘Collective Memory’ to the Historical Sociology of Mnemonic Practices.” Annual Review of Sociology24:105–140.
88.
OlickJeffrey K.Vinitzky-SeroussiVeredLevyDaniel. 2011. The Collective Memory Reader. New York: Oxford University Press.
89.
OrbuchTerri L.1997. “People’s Accounts Count: The Sociology of Accounts.” Annual Review of Sociology23:455–78.
90.
OrbuchTerri L.HarveyJohn H.DavisSusan H.MerbachNancy J.1994. “Account-Making and Confiding as Acts of Meaning in Response to Sexual Assault.” Journal of Family Violence9:249–64.
91.
OrbuchTerri L.VeroffJosephHolmbergDiane. 1993. “Becoming a Married Couple: The Emergence of Meaning in the First Years of Marriage.” Journal of Marriage and Family55:815–26.
92.
PollettaFrancescaLeeJohn. 2006. “Is Telling Stories Good for Democracy? Rhetoric in Public Deliberation after 9/11.” American Sociological Review71:699–723.
93.
PrusRobert C.1975. “Resisting Designations: An Extension of Attribution Theory into a Negotiated Context.” Sociological Inquiry45:3–14.
RieffPhilip. 1966. The Triumph of the Therapeutic: Uses of Faith After Freud. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
96.
RiveraLauren A.2008. “Managing ‘Spoiled’ National Identity: War, Tourism, and Memory in Croatia.” American Sociological Review73:613–34.
97.
RozarioKevin. 2007. The Culture of Calamity: Disaster and the Making of Modern America. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
98.
SaitoHiro. 2006. “Reiterated Commemoration: Hiroshima as National Trauma.” Sociological Theory24:353–76.
99.
SchelerMax. 1994. Ressentiment. Milwaukee, WI: Marquette University Press.
100.
SchwartzBarry. 1991. “Social Change and Collective Memory: The Democratization of George Washington.” American Sociological Review56:221–36.
101.
SchwartzBarry. 1996a. “Memory as a Cultural System: Abraham Lincoln in World War II.” American Sociological Review61:908–927.
102.
SchwartzBarry. 1996b. “Rereading the Gettysburg Address: Social Change and Collective Memory.” Qualitative Sociology19:395–422.
103.
SchwartzBarry. 2005. “The New Gettysburg Address: Fusing History and Memory.” Poetics33:63–79.
104.
SchwartzBarry. 2009. Abraham Lincoln in the Post-Heroic Era: History and Memory in Late Twentieth-Century America. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
105.
ScottMarvin B.LymanStanford M.1968. “Accounts.” American Sociological Review33:46–62.
106.
SewellWilliam H.1996. “Historical Events as Transformations of Structures: Inventing Revolution at the Bastille.” Theory and Society25:841–81.
SwidlerAnn. 1986. “Culture in Action: Symbols and Strategies.” American Sociological Review51:273–86.
109.
SykesGresham M.MatzaDavid. 1957. “Techniques of Neutralization: A Theory of Delinquency.” American Sociological Review22:664–70.
110.
TeegerChanaVinitzky-SeroussiVered. 2007. “Controlling for Consensus: Commemorating Apartheid in South Africa.” Symbolic Interaction30:57–78.
111.
TenbruckFriedrich H.1980. “The Problem of Thematic Unity in the Works of Max Weber.” British Journal of Sociology31:316–51.
112.
VidichArthur J.LymanStanford M.1985. American Sociology: Worldly Rejections of Religion and Their Directions. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
113.
Vinitzky-SeroussiVered. 2002. “Commemorating a Difficult Past: Yitzhak Rabin’s Memorials.” American Sociological Review67:30–51.
114.
Vinitzky-SeroussiVeredTeegerChana. 2010. “Unpacking the Unspoken: Silence in Collective Memory and Forgetting.” Social Forces88:1103–1122.
115.
Wagner-PacificiRobin. 1986. The Moro Morality Play: Terrorism as Social Drama. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
116.
Wagner-PacificiRobin. 1994. Discourse and Destruction: The City of Philadelphia versus MOVE. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
117.
Wagner-PacificiRobin. 2010. “Theorizing the Restlessness of Events.” American Journal of Sociology115:1351–86.
118.
Wagner-PacificiRobinSchwartzBarry. 1991. “The Vietnam Veterans Memorial: Commemorating a Difficult Past.” American Journal of Sociology97:376–420.
119.
WeberMax. 1922. The Sociology of Religion. Boston: Beacon Press.
120.
WeberMax. 1946. “The Social Psychology of the World Religions.” Pp. 267–302 in From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology. New York: Oxford University Press.
121.
WeberMax. 1958. The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism. New York: Scribner.
122.
WeissRobert S.1975. Marital Separation. New York: Basic Books.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
