Rational choice approaches to reducing terrorist violence would suggest raising the costs of terrorism through punishment, thereby reducing the overall expected utility of terrorism. In this article, we argue that states should also consider raising the expected utility of abstaining from terrorism through rewards. We test effects of repressive (or punishing) and conciliatory (or rewarding) actions on terrorist behavior using the newly developed GATE-Israel dataset, which identifies events by Israeli state actors toward Palestinian targets on a full range of counterterrorism tactics and policies from 1987 to 2004. Results show that repressive actions are either unrelated to terror or related to subsequent increases in terror, and conciliatory actions are generally related to decreases in terror, depending on the tactical period. Findings also reveal the importance of understanding the role of terrorists’ constituencies for reducing violence.
AndenaesJohannes. 1971. “The Moral or Educative Influence of Criminal Law.” Journal of Social Issues27:17–31.
2.
ArajBader. 2008. “Harsh State Repression as a Cause of Suicide Bombing: The Case of the Palestinian-Israeli Conflict.” Studies in Conflict and Terrorism31:284–303.
3.
BeccariaCesare. [1764] 1983. On Crimes and Punishment. Boston: Branden Books.
4.
BeckerGary S.1968. “Crime and Punishment: An Economic Approach.” Journal of Political Economy76:169–217.
5.
BeckerHoward S.1963. Outsiders: Studies in the Sociology of Deviance. New York: The Free Press.
6.
BeitlerRuth. 2004. The Path to Mass Rebellion: A Tale of Two Intifadas. New York: Lexington Books.
7.
BenmelechEfraimBerrebiClaudeKlorEsteban. 2010. “Counter-Suicide Terrorism: Evidence from Home Demolitions.” Working Paper No. 16493, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.
8.
BenthamJeremy. [1781] 1996. An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
9.
BloomMia. 2004. “Outbidding, Market Share, and Palestinian Suicide Bombing.” Political Science Quarterly119:61–88.
10.
BraithwaiteJohn. 2005. “Pre-empting Terrorism.” Current Issues in Criminal Justice17:96–114.
11.
BrodieBernard. 1959. Strategy in the Missile Age. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
12.
Brophy-BaermannBryanConybeareJohn A. C.1994. “Retaliating against Terrorism: Rational Expectations and the Optimality of Rules versus Discretion.” American Journal of Political Science38:196–210.
13.
BrymRobert J.AndersenRobert. 2011. “Rational Choice and the Political Bases of Changing Israeli Counterinsurgency Strategy.” British Journal of Sociology62:482–503.
14.
BrymRobert J.ArajBader. 2006. “Suicide Bombing as Strategy and Interaction: The Case of the Second Intifada.” Social Forces84:1969–86.
15.
Bueno de MesquitaEthan. 2005. “Conciliation, Concessions, and Patterns of Terrorist Violence.” International Organization59:145–76.
CauleyJonImEric Iksoon. 1988. “Intervention Policy Analysis of Skyjackings and Other Terrorist Incidents.” American Economic Review78:27–31.
18.
ChenowethEricaDuganLaura. 2011. “Exploring Counterterrorism in the Middle East and North Africa: A New Data Set.” Presented at the annual meeting of the American Political Science Association, September 2, Seattle, WA.
19.
ClarkRobert P.1990. Negotiating with ETA: Obstacles to Peace in the Basque Country, 1975–1988. New York: Routledge.
20.
ClausetAaronHegerLindsayYoungMaxwellGleditschKristian Skrede. 2010. “The Strategic Calculus of Terrorism: Substitution and Competition in the Israel-Palestine Conflict.” Cooperation and Conflict45:6–33.
21.
CornellSvante E.2001. “The Land of Many Crossroads: The Kurdish Question in Turkish Politics.” Orbis45:31–46.
22.
CornishDerek B.ClarkeRonald V.1987. “Understanding Crime Displacement: An Application of Rational Choice Theory.” Criminology45:933–47.
23.
CrenshawMartha. 2001. “Theories of Terrorism: Instrumental and Organizational Approaches.” Pp. 13–29 in Inside Terrorism Organizations, edited by RapoportD. C.London: Frank Cass.
24.
CroninAudrey Kurth. 2006. “How al-Qaida Ends.” International Security31:7–48.
25.
Della PortaDonatella. 1995. “Left-Wing Terrorism in Italy.” Pp. 105–159 in Terrorism in Context, edited by CrenshawM.State College, PA: Pennsylvania State University Press.
26.
DuganLaura. 2012. “The Making of the Global Terrorism Database and Its Applicability to Studying the Lifecycles of Terrorist Organizations.” Pp. 175–98 in The Sage Handbook of Criminological Research Methods, edited by GaddD.KarstedtS.MessnerS.Los Angeles, CA: Sage.
27.
DuganLauraHuangJulieLaFreeGaryMcCauleyClark. 2008. “The Armenian Secret Army for the Liberation of Armenia and the Justice Commandos of the Armenian Genocide.” Dynamics of Asymmetric Conflict1:231–49.
28.
DuganLauraLaFreeGaryPiqueroAlex R.2005. “Testing a Rational Choice Model of Airline Hijackings.” Criminology43:1031–1066.
29.
EndersWalterSandlerTodd. 1993. “The Effectiveness of Antiterrorism Policies: A Vector-Autoregression-Intervention Analysis.” American Political Science Review87:829–44.
30.
FarringtonDavid P.1977. “The Effects of Public Labeling.” British Journal of Criminology17:112–25.
31.
FlaniganShawn Teresa. 2010. For the Love of God: NGOs and Religious Identity in a Violent World. Sterling, VA: Kumarian Press.
32.
FlaniganShawn TeresaAbdel-SamadMounah. 2009. “Hezbollah’s Social Jihad: Nonprofits as Resistance Organizations.” Middle East Policy16:122–37.
33.
FreyBruno. 2004. Dealing with Terrorism: Stick or Carrot?Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar.
34.
GelvinJames. 2005. The Israel-Palestine Conflict: One Hundred Years of War. New York: Cambridge University Press.
35.
GibbsJack P.1975. Crime, Punishment, and Deterrence. New York: Elsevier.
36.
GoldkampJohn S.VilcicaE. Rely. 2008. “Targeted Enforcement and Adverse System Side Effects: The Generation of Fugitives in Philadelphia.” Criminology46:371–409.
37.
GoldsteinJoshua S.1992. “A Conflict-Cooperation Scale for WEIS Event Data.” Journal of Conflict Resolution36:369–85.
38.
GottfredsonDenise C.GerstenblighStephanie A.SouleDavid A.WomerShannon C.LuShaoli. 2004. “Do After School Programs Reduce Delinquency?” Prevention Science5:253–66.
HafezMohammed. 2006. “Rationality, Culture, and Structure in the Making of Suicide Bombers: A Preliminary Theoretical Synthesis and Illustrative Case Study.” Studies in Conflict and Terrorism29:165–85.
41.
HafezMohammedHatfieldJoseph. 2006. “Do Targeted Assassinations Work? A Multivariate Analysis of Israel’s Controversial Tactic during the Al-Aqsa Uprising.” Studies in Conflict and Terrorism29:359–82.
42.
HammMark S.2004. “Apocalyptic Violence: The Seduction of Terrorist Subcultures.” Theoretical Criminology8:323–39.
43.
HastieT. J.TibshiraniR. J.1990. Generalized Additive Models. New York: Chapman and Hall.
44.
IannacconeLaurence R.BermanEli. 2006. “Religious Extremism: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly.” Public Choice128:109–129.
45.
IyengarRadhaMontenJonathan. 2008. “Is there an ‘Emboldenment’ Effect? Evidence from the Insurgency in Iraq.” Working Paper No. 13839, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.
46.
JaegerDavid A.PasermanM. Danielle. 2008. “The Cycle of Violence? An Empirical Analysis of Fatalities in the Palestinian-Israeli Conflict.” American Economic Review98:1591–1604.
47.
JamalAmal. 2005. The Palestinian National Movement: Politics of Contention, 1967–2005. Bloomington: Indiana University Press
48.
KadiLeila S., ed. 1969. Basic Political Documents of the Armed Palestinian Resistance Movement. Beirut: Palestine Research Centre.
49.
KalyvasStathis. 2006. The Logic of Violence in Civil War. New York: Cambridge University Press.
50.
KhawajaMarwan. 1993. “Repression and Popular Collective Action: Evidence from the West Bank.” Sociological Forum8:47–71.
51.
KhawajaMarwan. 1994. “Resource Mobilization, Hardship, and Popular Collective Action in the West Bank.” Social Forces73:191–220.
52.
KingMary E.2007. A Quiet Revolution: The First Palestinian Intifada and Nonviolent Resistance. New York: Nation Books.
53.
KocherMatthew AdamKalyvasStathis. 2007. “How Free is ‘Free Riding’ in Civil Wars? Violence, Insurgency, and the Collective Action Problem.” World Politics59:177–216.
54.
KoopmansRuud. 1993. “The Dynamics of Protest Waves: West Germany, 1965 to 1989.” American Sociological Review58:637–58.
55.
KruglanskiArie W.ChenXiaoyanDechesneMarkFishmanShiraOrehekEdward. 2009. “Fully Committed: Suicide Bombers’ Motivation and the Quest for Personal Significance.” Political Psychology30:331–57.
KupermanRanan D.2007. Cycles of Violence: The Evolution of the Israeli Decision Regime Governing the Use of Limited Military Force. Lanham, MD: Lexington.
58.
KyddAndrewWalterBarbara F.2002. “Sabotaging the Peace: The Politics of Extremist Violence.” International Organization56:263–96.
59.
LaFreeGaryAckermanGary. 2009. “The Empirical Study of Terrorism: Social and Legal Research.” Annual Review of Law and Social Science5:347–74.
60.
LaFreeGaryDuganLaura. 2004. “How Does Studying Terrorism Compare to Studying Crime?” Pp. 53–74 in Terrorism and Counter-Terrorism: Criminological Perspectives, edited by DeFlemM.New York: Elsevier.
61.
LaFreeGaryDuganLaura. 2007. “Introducing the Global Terrorism Database.” Terrorism and Political Violence19:181–204.
62.
LaFreeGaryDuganLauraKorteRaven. 2009. “The Impact of British Counterterrorist Strategies on Political Violence in Northern Ireland: Comparing Deterrence and Backlash Models.” Criminology47:501–530.
63.
LandesWilliam. 1978. “An Economic Study of U.S. Aircraft Hijacking, 1961–1976.” Journal of Law and Economics21:1–31.
64.
LapanHarvey E.SandlerTodd. 1988. “To Bargain or Not To Bargain: That Is the Question.” American Economic Review78:16–21.
65.
LevittSteven. 1996. “The Effect of Prison Population Size on Crime Rates: Evidence from Prison Overcrowding Litigation.” Quarterly Journal of Economics111:319–52.
66.
LevittSteven. 1997. “Using Electoral Cycles in Police Hiring to Estimate the Effect of Police on Crime.” American Economic Review87:270–90.
67.
LichbachMark Irving. 1987. “Deterrence or Escalation? The Puzzle of Aggregate Studies of Repression and Dissent.” Journal of Conflict Resolution31:266–97.
68.
LyallJason. 2009. “Does Indiscriminate Violence Incite Insurgent Attacks? Evidence from Chechnya.” Journal of Conflict Resolution53:331–62.
69.
LyallJasonWilsonIsaiah. 2009. “Rage against the Machines: Explaining Outcomes in Counterinsurgency Wars.” International Organization63:67–106.
70.
MalkaHaim. 2007. “Hamas: Resistance and Transformation of Palestinian Society.” Pp. 98–126 in Understanding Islamic Charities, edited by AltermanJ. B.Von HippelK.Washington, DC: Center for Strategic and International Studies.
MarshallRachelle. 2009. “Middle East Leaders Hold Open the Door to Peace—Will the U.S. and Israel Respond?” Washington Report on Middle East Affairs, Special Report, (January-February):7–9.
73.
MatsuedaRoss L.KreagerDerek A.HuizingaDavid. 2006. “Deterring Delinquents: A Rational Choice Model of Theft and Violence.” American Sociological Review71:95–122.
74.
MeesLudger. 2003. Nationalism, Violence, and Democracy: The Basque Clash of Identities. New York: Palgrave Macmillian Ltd.
75.
MooreWilliam H.1998. “Repression and Dissent: Substitution, Context and Timing.” American Journal of Political Science42:851–73.
76.
NaginDaniel S.1998. “Criminal Deterrence Research at the Outset of the Twenty-first Century.” Crime and Justice23:1–42.
77.
NaginDaniel S.PaternosterRaymond. 1993. “Enduring Individual Differences and Rational Choice Theories of Crime.” Criminology27:467–96.
78.
NeumannPeter. 2007. “Negotiating with Terrorists.” Foreign Affairs86:128–38.
79.
NewmanSanford A.FoxJames AllenFlynnEdward A.ChristesonWilliam. 2000. America’s After School Choice: The Prime Time for Juvenile Crime, or Youth Enrichment and Achievement, a research report. Washington, DC: Fight Crime Invest in Kids.
80.
OldsDavid L.HendersonCharles R.Jr.TatelbaumRobertChamberlinRobert. 1986. “Improving the Delivery of Prenatal Care and Outcomes of Pregnancy: A Randomized Trial of Nurse Home Visitation.” Pediatrics77:16–28.
81.
PaternosterRaymond. 1987. “The Deterrent Effect of the Perceived Certainty and Severity of Punishment: A Review of the Evidence and Issues.” Justice Quarterly4:173–217.
82.
PearlmanWendy. 2008/2009. “Spoiling from the Inside Out: Internal Political Contestation and the Middle East Peace Process.” International Security33:79–109.
83.
PeroffKathleenHewittChristopher. 1980. “Rioting in Northern Ireland: The Effects of Different Policies.” Journal of Conflict Resolution24:593–612.
84.
PiazzaJames A.WalshJames Igoe. 2009. “Transnational Terrorism and Human Rights.” International Studies Quarterly53:125–48.
85.
PiliavinIrvingGartnerRosemaryThortonCraigMatsuedaRoss L.1986. “Crime, Deterrence, and Rational Choice.” American Sociological Review51:101–119.
86.
PlawAvery. 2008. Targeting Terrorists: A License to Kill?London: Ashgate.
87.
RaslerKaren. 1996. “Concessions, Repression, and Political Protest in the Iranian Revolution.” American Sociological Review61:132–52.
88.
RaslerKaren. 2000. “Shock, Expectancy Revision, and De-escalation of Protracted Conflicts.” Journal of Peace Research37:699–720.
89.
RichThomas F.JacobyKristen. 1999. National Evaluation of Weed and Seed Hartford Case Study, research report. Washington, DC: Office of Justice Programs.
90.
RigbyAndrew. 1991. Living the Intifada. London: Zed.
91.
RossLaurence H.1982. Deterring the Drunk Driver: Legal Policy and Social Control. Lexington, MA: D.C. Health.
92.
SchrodtPhilip A.2001. “Automated Coding of International Event Data Using Sparse Parsing Techniques.” Department of Political Science, University of Kansas, Lawrence, KS. Unpublished manuscript.
93.
SchrodtPhilip A.2006. “Twenty Years of the Kansas Event Data System Project.” Department of Political Science, University of Kansas, Lawrence, KS. Unpublished manuscript.
94.
SchrodtPhilip A.DavisShannon G.WeddleJudith L.1994. “Political Science: KEDS: A Program for Machine Coding Events Data.” Social Science Computer Review12:561–88.
95.
SchrodtPhilip A.GernerDeborah J.1994. “Validity Assessment of a Machine-Coded Event Data Set for the Middle East, 1982–1992.” American Journal of Political Science38:825–54.
96.
SchwartzRichard D.SkolnickJerome H.1962. “Two Studies of Legal Stigma.” Social Problems10:133–42.
97.
SchweinhartLawrence J.2005. The High/Scope Perry Preschool Study through Age 40. Ypsilanti, MI: High/Scope Press.
98.
SharvitKerenKruglanskiArie W.WangMoChenXiaoyanMinacapelliLaurenGanorBoazAzaniEitan. 2012. “The Effects of Israeli Coercive and Conciliatory Policies on Palestinian Terrorist Activity: 2000–2006.” Department of Psychology, University of Haifa, Israel. Unpublished manuscript.
99.
ShellmanStephen M.2008. “Coding Disaggregated Intrastate Conflict: Machine Processing the Behavior of Substate Actors over Time and Space.” Political Analysis16:464–77.
100.
ShellmanStephen M.HatfieldClaireMillsMaggie J.2010. “Disaggregating Actors in Intranational Conflict.” Journal of Peace Research47:83–90.
101.
ShermanLawrence W.1990. “Police Crackdowns: Initial and Residual Deterrence.” Crime and Justice12:1–48.
102.
ShermanLawrence W.1993. “Defiance, Deterrence, and Irrelevance: A Theory of the Criminal Sanction.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency30:445–73.
103.
TesslerMark. 1995. A History of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
104.
TestasAbdelaziz. 2004. “Determinants of Terrorism in the Middle East.” Terrorism and Political Violence16:253–73.
105.
TibbettsStephen G.GibsonChris L.2002. “Individual Propensities and Rational Decision-Making: Recent Findings and Promising Approaches.” Pp. 3–14 in Rational Choice and Criminal Behavior Recent Research and Future Challenges, edited by PiqueroA. R.TibbettsS. G.New York: Routledge.
106.
TylerTom R.2006. “Psychological Perspectives on Legitimacy and Legitimation.” Annual Review of Psychology57:375–400.
107.
WhiteRobert. 1989. “From Peaceful Protest to Guerrilla War: Micromobilization of the Provisional Irish Republican Army.” American Journal of Sociology94:1277–1302.
108.
XiangDong. 2001. “Fitting Generalized Additive Models with the GAM Procedure.” SUGI Proceedings. Cary, NC: SAS Institute, Inc.
109.
YaalonMoshe. 2007. Lessons from the Palestinian “War” Against Israel. Washington, DC: The Washington Institute for Near East Policy.
110.
ZussmanAsafZussmanNoam. 2006. “Assassinations: Evaluating the Effectiveness of an Israeli Counterterrorism Policy Using Stock Market Data.” Journal of Economic Perspectives20:193–206.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
