A burgeoning literature considers the consequences of mass imprisonment for the well-being of adult men and—albeit to a lesser degree—their children. Yet virtually no quantitative research considers the consequences of mass imprisonment for the well-being of the women who are the link between (former) prisoners and their children. This article extends research on the collateral consequences of mass imprisonment by considering the association between paternal incarceration and maternal mental health using data from the Fragile Families and Child Wellbeing Study. Results show that recent paternal incarceration increases a mother’s risk of a major depressive episode and her level of life dissatisfaction, net of a variety of influences including prior mental health. The empirical design lends confidence to a causal interpretation: effects of recent incarceration persist even when the sample is limited to mothers attached to previously incarcerated men, which provides a rigorous counterfactual. In addition, the empirical design is comprehensive; after isolating key mechanisms anticipated in the literature, we reduce the relationship between recent paternal incarceration and maternal mental health to statistical insignificance. These results imply that the penal system may have important effects on poor women’s well-being beyond increasing their economic insecurity, compromising their marriage markets, or magnifying their risk of divorce.
Aalto-SetalaT.HaarasiltaL.MarttunenM.Tuulio-HenrikssonA.PoikolaninenK.AroH.LonnqvistJ.2002. “Major Depressive Episode among Young Adults: CIDI-SF versus SCAN Consensus Diagnoses.” Psychological Medicine32:1309–1314.
2.
AllisonPaul D.2002. Missing Data. New York: Sage Publications.
3.
AmatoPaul R.2000. “The Consequences of Divorce for Adults and Children.” Journal of Marriage and Family62:1269–87.
4.
AmatoPaul R.LoomisLaura SpencerBoothAlan. 1995. “Parental Divorce, Marital Conflict, and Offspring Well-Being during Early Adulthood.” Social Forces73:895–915.
5.
AvellarSarahSmockPamela J.2005. “The Economic Consequences of the Dissolution of Cohabiting Unions.” Journal of Marriage and Family67:315–27.
6.
BeckerSascha O.CaliendoMarco. 2007. “Sensitivity Analysis for Average Treatment Effects.” Stata Journal7:71–83.
7.
Bendheim-Thoman Center for Research on Child Wellbeing. 2008. “Introduction to the Fragile Families Public-Use Data: Baseline, One-Year, Three-Year, and Five-Year Telephone Data.” Princeton, NJ: Office of Population Research, Princeton University.
8.
BonczarThomas. 2003. Prevalence of Imprisonment in the U.S. Population, 1974–2001. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice.
9.
BramanDonald. 2004a. Doing Time on the Outside: Incarceration and Family Life in Urban America. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
10.
BramanDonald. 2004b. “Families and the Moral Economy of Incarceration.” Journal of Religion & Spirituality in Social Work: Social Thought23:27–50.
11.
CarlsonMarcia J.McLanahanSara S.Brooks-GunnJeanne. 2008. “Coparenting and Nonresident Fathers’ Involvement with Young Children After a Nonmarital Birth.” Demography45:461–88.
12.
CharlesKerwin KofiLuohMing Ching. 2010. “Male Incarceration, the Marriage Market, and Female Outcomes.” Review of Economics and Statistics92:614–27.
13.
CherlinAndrew J.1999. “Going to Extremes: Family Structure, Children’s Well-Being, and Social Science.” Demography36:421–28.
14.
CherlinAndrew J.2010. “Demographic Trends in the United States: A Review of Research in the 2000s.” Journal of Marriage and Family72:403–419.
15.
ComfortMegan. 2007. “Punishment Beyond the Legal Offender.” Annual Review of Law and Social Science3:271–96.
16.
ComfortMegan. 2008. Doing Time Together: Love and Family in the Shadow of the Prison. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
17.
DanielSally W.BarrettCarol J.1981. “The Needs of Prisoners’ Wives: A Challenge for the Mental Health Professions.” Community Mental Health Journal17:310–22.
18.
DickmanScott J.1990. “Functional and Dysfunctional Impulsivity: Personality and Cognitive Correlates.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology58: 95–102.
19.
DuBoisW.E.B.[1899] 1996. The Philadelphia Negro: A Social Study. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
20.
EdinKathryn. 2000. “Few Good Men: Why Poor Mothers Don’t Marry or Remarry.” American Prospect11:26–31.
21.
EdinKathrynNelsonTimothy J.ParanalRechelle. 2004. “Fatherhood and Incarceration as Potential Turning Points in the Criminal Careers of Unskilled Men.” Pp. 46–75 in Imprisoning America: The Social Effects of Mass Incarceration, edited by PatilloM.WeimanD.WesternB.New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
22.
EllwoodDavid T.JencksChristopher. 2004. “The Uneven Spread of Single-Parent Families: What Do We Know? Where Do We Look for Answers.” Pp. 3–77 in Social Inequality, edited by NeckermanK. M.New York: Russell Sage Press.
23.
FishmanLaura T.1990. Women at the Wall: A Study of Prisoners’ Wives Doing Time on the Outside. Albany: State University of New York Press.
24.
FombyPaulaCherlinAndrew J.2007. “Family Instability and Child Well-Being.” American Sociological Review72:181–204.
25.
FosterHollyHaganJohn. 2007. “Incarceration and Intergenerational Social Exclusion.” Social Problems54:399–433.
26.
FosterHollyHaganJohn. 2009. “The Mass Incarceration of Parents in America: Issues of Race/ Ethnicity, Collateral Damage to Children, and Prisoner Reentry.” ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science623:179–94.
27.
GabelStewart. 1992. “Behavioral Problems in Sons of Incarcerated or Otherwise Absent Fathers: The Issue of Separation.” Family Process31:303–314.
28.
GellerAmandaCooperCarey E.GarfinkelIrwinSchwartz-SoicherOfiraMincyRonald B.Forthcoming. “Beyond Absenteeism: Father Incarceration and Child Development.” Demography.
29.
GellerAmandaGarfinkelIrwinCooperCarey E.MincyRonald B.2009. “Parental Incarceration and Child Well-Being: Implications for Urban Families.” Social Science Quarterly90:1186–1202.
30.
GellerAmandaGarfinkelIrwinWesternBruce. 2011. “Paternal Incarceration and Support for Children in Fragile Families.” Demography48:25–47.
31.
GiordanoPeggy C.2010. Legacies of Crime: A Follow-Up of the Children of Highly Delinquent Girls and Boys. New York: Cambridge University Press.
32.
GlazeLauren E.MaruschakLaura M.2008. “Parents in Prison and Their Minor Children.” Bureau of Justice Statistics Special Report. Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Statistics.
33.
GoffmanAlice. 2009. “On the Run: Wanted Men in a Philadelphia Ghetto.” American Sociological Review74:339–57.
34.
GottfredsonMichael R.HirschiTravis. 1990. A General Theory of Crime. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
35.
GrinsteadOlgaFaigelesBonnieBancroftCarrieZackBarry. 2001. “The Financial Cost of Maintaining Relationships with Incarcerated African American Men: A Survey of Women Prison Visitors.” Journal of African American Studies6:59–69.
36.
HaganJohnDinovitzerRonit. 1999. “Collateral Consequences of Imprisonment for Children, Communities, and Prisoners.” Crime and Justice26:121–62.
37.
HairstonCreasie Finney. 2005. “Prisoners and Their Families: Parenting Issues during Incarceration.” Pp. 259–81 in Prisoners Once Removed: The Impact of Incarceration and Reentry on Children, Families, and Communities, edited by TravisJ.WaulM.Washington, DC: Urban Institute Press.
38.
HarrisAlexesEvansHeatherBeckettKatherine. 2010. “Drawing Blood from Stones: Legal Debt and Social Inequality in the Contemporary United States.” American Journal of Sociology115:1753–99.
39.
HeadeyBruceKelleyJonathanWearingAlex. 1993. “Dimensions of Mental Health: Life Satisfaction, Positive Affect, Anxiety and Depression.” Social Indicators Research29:63–82.
40.
JaffeeSara R.MoffittTerrie E.CaspiAvshalomTaylorAlan. 2003. “Life With (or Without) Fathe: The Benefits of Living with Two Biological Parents Depend on the Father’s Antisocial Behavior.” Child Development74:109–126.
41.
JohnsonElizabeth I.WaldfogelJane. 2004. “Children of Incarcerated Parents: Multiple Risks and Children’s Living Arrangements.” Pp. 97–131 in Imprisoning America: The Social Effects of Mass Incarceration, edited by PattilloM.WeimanD.WesternB.New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
42.
KesslerRonald C.2002. “The Categorical Versus Dimensional Assessment Controversy in the Sociology of Mental Illness.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior43:171–88.
43.
KesslerRonald C.AndrewsGavinMroczekDanielUstunBedirhanHans-UlrichWittchen. 1998. “The World Health Organization Composite International Diagnostic Interview Short-Form (CIDI-SF).” International Journal of Methods in Psychiatric Research7:171–85.
44.
KesslerRonaldBerglundPatricia A.FosterCindy L.SaundersWilliam B.StangPaul E.WaltersEllen E.1997. “Social Consequences of Psychiatric Disorders, II: Teenage Parenthood.” American Journal of Psychiatry154:1405–1411.
45.
KesslerRonald C.FosterCindy L.SaundersWilliam B.StangPaul E.1995. “Social Consequences of Psychiatric Disorders, I: Educational Attainment.” American Journal of Psychiatry152: 1026–1032.
46.
KesslerRonald C.UstunT. Bedirham. 2004. “The World Mental Health (WMH) Survey Initiative Version of the World Health Organization (WHO) Composite International Diagnostic Interview.” International Journal of Methods in Psychiatric Research13:93–121.
47.
KesslerRonald C.WaltersEllen E.ForthoferMelinda S.1998. “The Social Consequences of Psychiatric Disorders, III: Probability of Marital Stability.” American Journal of Psychiatry155:1092–1096.
48.
KimHyun Sik. 2011. “Consequences of Parental Divorce for Child Development.” American Sociological Review76:487–511.
49.
KingValarieHeardHolly E.1999. “Nonresident Father Visitation, Parental Conflict, and Mother’s Satisfaction: What’s Best for Child Well-Being?” Journal of Marriage and the Family61:385–96.
50.
LaLondeRobert J.1986. “Evaluating the Econometric Evaluations of Training Programs with Experimental Data.” American Economic Review76:604–620.
51.
LeamerEdward E.1983. “Let’s Take the Con Out of Econometrics.” American Economic Review73: 31–43.
52.
LeuvenEdwinSianesiBarbara. 2003. “PSMATCH2: Stata Module to Perform Full Mahalanobis and Propensity Score Matching, Common Support Graphing, and Covariate Imbalance Testing.” (http://ideas.repec.org/c/boc/bocode/s432001.html).
53.
LiYunfei PaulPropertKathleen J.RosenbaumPaul R.2001. “Balanced Risk Set Matching.” Journal of the American Statistical Association96:870–82.
54.
LiebowElliot[1967] 2003. Tally’s Corner: A Study of Negro Streetcorner Men. Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield.
55.
LinkBruce G.2002. “The Challenge of the Dependent Variable.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior43:247–53.
56.
LopooLeonard M.WesternBruce. 2005. “Incarceration and the Formation and Stability of Marital Unions.” Journal of Marriage and Family67:721–34.
57.
LowensteinAriela. 1984. “Coping with Stress: The Case of Prisoners’ Wives.” Journal of Marriage and the Family46:699–708.
58.
MaguireKathleen, ed. 2011a. Sourcebook of Criminal Justice Statistics[Online], Bureau of Justice Statistics, Table 6.28.2009. Retrieved September 14, 2011 (http://www.albany.edu/sourcebook/pdf/t6282009.pdf).
59.
MaguireKathleen, ed. 2011b. Sourcebook of Criminal Justice Statistics[Online], Bureau of Justice Statistics, Table 6.0009.2009. Retrieved September 14, 2011 (http://www.albany.edu/sourcebook/pdf/t600092009.pdf).
60.
MassogliaMichael. 2008. “Incarceration as Exposure: The Prison, Infectious Disease, and Other Stress-Related Illnesses.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior49:56–71.
61.
McLanahanSara. 2004. “Diverging Destinies: How Children Are Faring Under the Second Demographic Transition.” Demography41:607–627.
62.
McLanahanSaraSandefurGary. 1994. Growing Up with a Single Parent: What Hurts, What Helps. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
63.
MeadowsSarah O.2009. “Family Structure and Fathers’ Well-Being: Trajectories of Mental Health and Self-Rated Health.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior50:115–31.
64.
MeadowsSarah O.McLanahanSarah S.Brooks-GunnJeanne. 2008. “Stability and Change in Family Structure and Maternal Health Trajectories.” American Sociological Review73:314–34.
65.
MiechRichard AllenShanahanMichael J.2000. “Socioeconomic Status and Depression over the Life Course.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior41:162–76.
66.
MirowskyJohnRossCatherine E.2002. “Measurement for a Human Science.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior43:152–70.
67.
MollbornStefanieMorningstarElizabeth. 2009. “Investigating the Relationship between Teenage Childbearing and Psychological Distress Using Longitudinal Evidence.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior50:310–26.
68.
MorrisPauline. 1965. Prisoners and Their Families. Woking, UK: Unwin Brothers.
69.
MurrayJosephFarringtonDavid P.2005. “Parental Imprisonment: Effects on Boys’ Antisocial Behaviour and Delinquency through the Life-Course.” Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry46:1269–78.
70.
MurrayJosephFarringtonDavid P.2008. “The Effects of Parental Imprisonment on Children.” Crime and Justice37:133–206.
71.
NobleCarolyn. 1995. Prisoners’ Families: The Everyday Reality. Ipswich, UK: Ormiston Children and Families Trust.
72.
NurseAnn M.2002. Fatherhood Arrested: Parenting From Within the Juvenile Justice System. Nashville, TN: Vanderbilt University.
73.
Office of Policy Planning and Research, U.S. Department of Labor. 1965. The Negro Family: The Case for National Action. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Labor.
74.
PagerDevah. 2003. “The Mark of a Criminal Record.” American Journal of Sociology108:937–75.
75.
ParkeRoss D.Clarke-StewartK. Allison. 2002. “The Effects of Parental Incarceration on Children.” Prisoners Once Removed: The Effects of Incarceration and Reentry on Children, Families, and Communities, edited by TravisJ.WaulM.Washington, DC: The Urban Institute.
76.
PattersonEvelyn J.PrestonSamuel H.2008. “Estimating the Mean Length of Stay in Prison: Methods and Applications.” Journal of Quantitative Criminology24:33–49.
77.
PattersonOrlando. 1998. Rituals of Blood: Consequences of Slavery in Two American Centuries. Washington, DC: Civitas/Counterpoint.
78.
PettitBeckyWesternBruce. 2004. “Mass Imprisonment and the Life Course: Race and Class Inequality in U.S. Incarceration.” American Sociological Review69:151–69.
79.
ReichmanNancyTeitlerJulienGarinfinkelIrwinMcLanahanSara. 2001. “Fragile Families: Sample and Design.” Children and Youth Services Review23:303–326.
80.
RichardsMartinMcWilliamsBrendaAllcockLucyEnterkinJillOwensPatriciaWoodrowJane. 1994. The Family Ties of English Prisoners: The Results of the Cambridge Project on Imprisonment and Family Ties. Cambridge, UK: Centre for Family Research, Cambridge University.
81.
RoettgerMichael E.SwisherRaymond R.2011. “Associations of Father’s History of Incarceration with Sons’ Delinquency and Arrest among Black, White, and Hispanic Males in the United States.” Criminology49:1109–1147.
82.
RossCatherine E.2000. “Neighborhood Disadvantage and Adult Depression.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior41:177–87.
83.
RoystonPatrick. 2007. “Multiple Imputation of Missing Values: Further Update of ICE, with an Emphasis on Interval Censoring.” Stata Journal7:445–64.
84.
SchnittkerJasonJohnAndrea. 2007. “Enduring Stigma: The Long-Term Effects of Incarceration on Health.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior48:115–30.
85.
SchwartzMary C.WeintraubJudith F.1974. “The Prisoner’s Wife: A Study in Crisis.” Federal Probation38:20–26.
86.
SchwarzNorbertStrackFritz. 1999. “Reports of Subjective Well-Being: Judgmental Processes and Their Methodological Implications.” Pp. 61–84 in Well-Being: The Foundations of Hedonic Psychology, edited by KahnemanD.DienerE.SchwarzN.New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
87.
Schwartz-SoicherOfiraGellerAmandaGarfinkelIrwin. 2011. “The Effect of Paternal Incarceration on Material Hardship.” Social Service Review85:447–73.
88.
StackCarol. 1974. All Our Kin. New York: Basic Books.
89.
SwisherRaymond R.WallerMaureen R.2008. “Confining Fatherhood: Incarceration and Paternal Involvement among Nonresident White, African American, and Latino Fathers.” Journal of Family Issues29:1067–1088.
90.
TeitlerJulien O.ReichmanNancy E.2008. “Mental Illness as a Barrier to Marriage among Mothers with an Out-of-Wedlock Birth.” Journal of Marriage and Family70:770–82.
91.
TurneyKristin. 2011. “Chronic and Proximate Depression among Mothers: Implications for Child Well-Being.” Journal of Marriage and Family73:149–63.
92.
WakefieldSaraUggenChristopher. 2010. “Incarceration and Stratification.” Annual Review of Sociology36:387–406.
93.
WakefieldSaraWildemanChristopher. 2011. “Mass Imprisonment and Racial Disparities in Childhood Behavioral Problems.” Criminology and Public Policy10:791–817.
94.
WesternBruce. 2002. “The Impact of Incarceration on Wage Mobility and Inequality.” American Sociological Review67:526–46.
95.
WesternBruce. 2006. Punishment and Inequality in America. New York: Russell Sage Press.
96.
WesternBruceWildemanChristopher. 2009. “The Black Family and Mass Incarceration.” ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science621:221–42.
97.
WildemanChristopher. 2009. “Parental Imprisonment, the Prison Boom, and the Concentration of Childhood Disadvantage.” Demography6:265–81.
98.
WildemanChristopher. 2010. “Paternal Incarceration and Children’s Physically Aggressive Behaviors: Evidence from the Fragile Families and Child Wellbeing Study.” Social Forces89:285–310.
99.
WildemanChristopherWesternBruce. 2010. “Incarceration in Fragile Families.” Future of Children20:181–201.
100.
WinshipChristopherMareRobert D.1984. “Regression Models with Ordinal Variables.” American Sociological Review49:512–25.
101.
YuYanWilliamsDavid R.1999. “Social Class.” Pp. 151–66 in Handbook of the Sociology of Mental Health, edited by AneshenselC. S.PhelanJ. C.New York: Springer.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
