Theory suggests that neighborhood effects depend not only on where individuals live today, but also on where they lived in the past. Previous research, however, usually measures neighborhood context only once and does not account for length of residence, thereby understating the detrimental effects of long-term neighborhood disadvantage. This study investigates effects of duration of exposure to disadvantaged neighborhoods on high school graduation. It follows 4,154 children in the Panel Study of Income Dynamics, measuring neighborhood context once per year from age 1 to 17. The analysis overcomes the problem of dynamic neighborhood selection by adapting novel methods of causal inference for time-varying treatments. In contrast to previous analyses, these methods do not “control away” the effect of neighborhood context operating indirectly through time-varying characteristics of the family; thus, they capture the full impact of a lifetime of neighborhood disadvantage. We find that sustained exposure to disadvantaged neighborhoods has a severe impact on high school graduation that is considerably larger than effects reported in prior research. We estimate that growing up in the most (compared to the least) disadvantaged quintile of neighborhoods reduces the probability of graduation from 96 to 76 percent for black children, and from 95 to 87 percent for nonblack children.
AaronsonDaniel. 1997. “Sibling Estimates of Neighborhood Effects.” Pp. 80–93 in Neighborhood Poverty. Vol. 2, Policy Implications in Studying Neighborhoods, edited by Brooks-GunnJ.DuncanG. J.AberJ. L.New York: Russell Sage.
2.
AaronsonDaniel. 1998. “Using Sibling Data to Estimate the Impact of Neighborhoods on Children’s Educational Outcomes.” Journal of Human Resources33:915–46.
3.
AndersonElijah. 1999. Code of the Street: Decency, Violence, and the Moral Life of the Inner City. New York: Norton.
4.
BarberJennifer S.MurphySusan A.VerbitskyNatalya. 2004. “Adjusting for Time-Varying Confounding in Survival Analysis.” Sociological Methodology34:163–92.
5.
BriggsXavier de SouzaKeysBenjamin J.2009. “Has Exposure to Poor Neighbourhoods Changed in America? Race, Risk and Housing Locations in Two Decades.” Urban Studies46:429–58.
6.
Brooks-GunnJeanneDuncanGreg J.AberJ. Lawrence. 1997. Neighborhood Poverty. Vol. 1, Context and Consequences for Children. New York: Russell Sage.
7.
Brooks-GunnJeanneDuncanGreg J.KlebanovPamela K.SealandNaomi. 1993. “Do Neighborhoods Influence Child and Adolescent Development?”American Journal of Sociology99:353–95.
8.
BrowningChristopher R.BurringtonLori A.LeventhalTamaBrooks-GunnJeanne. 2008. “Neighborhood Structural Inequality, Collective Efficacy, and Sexual Risk Behavior among Urban Youth.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior49:269–85.
9.
BrowningChristopher R.LeventhalTamaBrooks-GunnJeanne. 2005. “Sexual Initiation in Early Adolescence: The Nexus of Parental and Community Control.” American Sociological Review70:758–78.
10.
CairnsRobert B.CairnsBeverley D.NeckermanHolly J.1989. “Early School Dropout: Configurations and Determinants.” Child Development60:1437–52.
11.
CharlesCamille Z.2003. “The Dynamics of Racial Residential Segregation.” Annual Review of Sociology29:167–207.
12.
Clampet-LundquistSusanMasseyDouglas S.2008. “Neighborhood Effects on Economic Self-Sufficiency: A Reconsideration of the Moving to Opportunity Experiment.” American Journal of Sociology114:107–143.
13.
ClarkNina A.DemersPaul A.KarrCatherine J.KoehoornMiekeLencarCornelTamburicLillianBrauerMichael. 2010. “Effect of Early Life Exposure to Air Pollution on Development of Childhood Asthma.” Environmental Health Perspectives118:284–90.
14.
ColeStephen R.HernánMiguel A.2008. “Constructing Inverse Probability of Treatment Weights for Marginal Structural Models.” American Journal of Epidemiology168:656–64.
15.
CraneJonathan. 1991. “Effects of Neighborhoods on Dropping Out of School and Teenage Childbearing.” Pp. 299–320 in The Urban Underclass, edited by JencksC.PetersonP. E.Washington, DC: Brookings.
16.
CrowderKyleDowneyLiam. 2010. “Interneighborhood Migration, Race, and Environmental Hazards: Modeling Microlevel Processes of Environmental Inequality.” American Journal of Sociology115:1110–49.
17.
CrowderKyleSouthScott J.2011. “Spatial and Temporal Dimensions of Neighborhood Effects on High School Graduation.” Social Science Research40:87–106.
18.
EnsmingerMargaret E.SlusarcickAnita L.1992. “Paths to High School Graduation or Dropout: A Longitudinal Study of a First-Grade Cohort.” Sociology of Education65:95–113.
19.
EvansWilliam N.OatesWallace E.SchwabRobert M.1992. “Measuring Peer Group Effects: A Study of Teenage Behavior.” Journal of Political Economy100:966–91.
20.
FernandezRoberto M.SuCelina. 2004. “Space in the Study of Labor Markets.” Annual Review of Sociology30:545–69.
GintherDonnaHavemanRobertWolfeBarbara. 2000. “Neighborhood Attributes as Determinants of Children’s Outcomes: How Robust are the Relationships?”Journal of Human Resources35:603–642.
23.
GreenlandSander. 2003. “Quantifying Biases in Causal Models: Classical Confounding vs Collider-Stratification Bias.” Epidemiology14:300–306.
24.
Halpern-MannersAndrewWarrenJohn R.BrandJennie E.2009. “Dynamic Measures of Primary and Secondary School Characteristics: Implications for School Effects Research.” Social Science Research38:397–411.
25.
HardingDavid J.2003. “Counterfactual Models of Neighborhood Effects: The Effect of Neighborhood Poverty on Dropping Out and Teenage Pregnancy.” American Journal of Sociology109:676–719.
26.
HardingDavid J.2009. “Collateral Consequences of Violence in Disadvantaged Neighborhoods.” Social Forces88:757–84.
27.
HardingDavid J.2010. Living the Drama: Community, Conflict, and Culture among Inner-City Boys. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
28.
HernánMiguel A.BrumbackBabette A.RobinsJames M.2002. “Estimating the Causal Effect of Zudovudine on CD4 Count with a Marginal Structural Model for Repeated Measures.” Statistics in Medicine21:1689–1709.
29.
HollandPaul W.1986. “Statistics and Causal Inference.” Journal of the American Statistical Association81:945–60.
30.
HongGuangleiRaudenbushStephen W.2008. “Causal Inference for Time-Varying Instructional Treatments.” Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics33:333–62.
31.
IcelandJohnScopillitiMelissa. 2008. “Immigrant Residential Segregation in U.S. Metropolitan Areas, 1990–2000.” Demography45:79–94.
32.
JacksonMargot I.MareRobert D.2007. “Cross-Sectional and Longitudinal Measurements of Neighborhood Experience and Their Effects on Children.” Social Science Research36:590–610.
33.
JencksChristopherMayerSusan E.1990. “The Social Consequences of Growing Up in a Poor Neighborhood.” Pp. 111–86 in Inner-City Poverty in the United States, edited by LynnL. E.McGrearyM. G. H.Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
34.
KunzJimPageMarianne E.SolonGary. 2003. “Are Point-in-Time Measures of Neighborhood Characteristics Useful Proxies for Children’s Long-Run Neighborhood Environment?”Economics Letters79:231–37.
35.
LaddHelen F.LudwigJens. 1997. “Federal Housing Assistance, Residential Relocation, and Educational Opportunities: Evidence from Baltimore.” American Economic Review87:272–77.
36.
LeventhalTamaBrooks-GunnJeanne. 2000. “The Neighborhoods They Live In: The Effects of Neighborhood Residence on Child and Adolescent Outcomes.” Psychological Bulletin126:309–337.
37.
LittleRoderick J. A.RubinDonald B.2002. Statistical Analysis with Missing Data. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley-Interscience.
38.
LudwigJensDuncanGreg J.HirschfieldPaul. 2001. “Urban Poverty and Juvenile Crime: Evidence from a Randomized Housing-Mobility Experiment.” Quarterly Journal of Economics116:655–79.
39.
LudwigJensLiebmanJeffrey B.KlingJeffrey R.DuncanGreg J.KatzLawrence F.KesslerRonald C.SanbonmatsuLisa. 2008. “What Can We Learn about Neighborhood Effects from the Moving to Opportunity Experiment?”American Journal of Sociology114:144–88.
40.
MasseyDouglas S.2004. “Segregation and Stratification: A Biosocial Perspective.” Du Bois Review1:7–25.
41.
MasseyDouglas S.DentonNancy A.1993. American Apartheid: Segregation and the Making of the Underclass. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
42.
MoonieSheniz A.SterlingDavid A.FiggsLarryCastroMario. 2006. “Asthma Status and Severity Affects Missed School Days.” Journal of School Health76:18–24.
43.
PearlJudea. 1995. “Causal Diagrams for Empirical Research.” Biometrika82:669–710.
44.
PearlJudea. 2000. Causality: Models, Reasoning, and Inference. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
45.
PonceNinez A.HoggattKatherine J.WilhelmMichelleRitzBeate. 2005. “Preterm Birth: The Interaction of Traffic-Related Air Pollution with Economic Hardship in Los Angeles Neighborhoods.” American Journal of Epidemiology162:140–48.
46.
QuillianLincoln. 2003. “How Long Are Exposures to Poor Neighborhoods? The Long-Term Dynamics of Entry and Exit from Poor Neighborhoods.” Population Research and Policy Review22:221–49.
47.
RobinsJames. 1987. “A New Approach to Causal Inference in Mortality Studies with a Sustained Exposure Period: Application to Control of the Healthy Worker Survivor Effect.” Mathematical Modeling7:1393–1512.
48.
RobinsJames M.1999. “Association, Causation, and Marginal Structural Models.” Synthese121:151–79.
49.
RobinsJames M.HernánMiguel A.BrumbackBabette. 2000. “Marginal Structural Models and Causal Inference in Epidemiology.” Epidemiology11:550–60.
50.
RobinsJames M.RotnitzkyAndreaScharfsteinDaniel O.1999. “Sensitivity Analysis for Selection Bias and Unmeasured Confounding in Missing Data and Causal Inference Models.” Pp. 1–94 in Statistical Models in Epidemiology, the Environment and Clinical Trials, edited by Elizabeth HalloranM.BerryD.New York: Springer.
51.
RosenfeldLindsayRuddRimaChewGinger L.EmmonsKarenAcevedo-GarciaDolores. 2010. “Are Neighborhood-Level Characteristics Associated with Indoor Allergens in the Household?”Journal of Asthma47:66–75.
52.
RoystonPatrick. 2005. “Multiple Imputation of Missing Values: Update.” The Stata Journal5:1–14.
53.
RubinDonald B.1974. “Estimating Causal Effects of Treatments in Randomized and Nonrandomized Studies.” Journal of Educational Psychology66:688–701.
54.
RubinDonald B.1987. Multiple Imputation for Nonresponse in Surveys. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
55.
RumbergerRussell W.1987. “High-School Dropouts: A Review of Issues and Evidence.” Review of Educational Research57:101–121.
56.
RumbergerRussell W.2004. “Why Students Drop Out of High School.” Pp. 131–56 in Dropouts in America, edited by OrfieldG.Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
57.
SampsonRobert J.2001. “How Do Communities Undergird or Undermine Human Development? Relevant Contexts and Social Mechanisms.” Pp. 3–30 in Does It Take a Village? Community Effects on Children, Adolescents, and Families, edited by BoothA.CrouterA. C.New York: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
58.
SampsonRobert J.2008. “Moving to Inequality: Neighborhood Effects and Experiments Meet Social Structure.” American Journal of Sociology114:189–231.
59.
SampsonRobert J.LaubJohn H.WimerChristopher. 2006. “Does Marriage Reduce Crime? A Counterfactual Approach to Within-Individual Causal Effects.” Criminology44:465–508.
60.
SampsonRobert J.MorenoffJeffrey D.Gannon-RowleyThomas. 2002. “Assessing ‘Neighborhood Effects’: Social Processes and New Directions in Research.” Annual Review of Sociology28:443–78.
61.
SampsonRobert J.SharkeyPatrick. 2008. “Neighborhood Selection and the Social Reproduction of Concentrated Racial Inequality.” Demography45:1–29.
62.
SampsonRobert J.SharkeyPatrickRaudenbushStephen W.2008. “Durable Effects of Concentrated Disadvantage on Verbal Ability among African-American Children.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences105:845–52.
63.
SchulzAmy J.Kannan, J.SrimathiDvonchTimothyIsraelBarbara A.IllAlex A.JamesSherman A.HouseJames S.LepkowskiJames. 2005. “Social and Physical Environments and Disparities in Risk for Cardiovascular Disease: The Healthy Environments Partnership Conceptual Model.” Environmental Health Perspectives113:1817–25.
64.
SchwartzJoel. 2006. “Long-Term Effects of Exposure to Particulate Air Pollution.” Clinics in Occupational and Environmental Medicine5:837–48.
65.
SharkeyPatrickElwertFelix. 2011. “The Legacy of Disadvantage: Multigenerational Neighborhood Effects on Cognitive Ability.” American Journal of Sociology116:1934–81.
66.
SharkeyPatrickSampsonRobert J.2010. “Destination Effects: Residential Mobility and Trajectories of Adolescent Violence in a Stratified Metropolis.” Criminology48:639–81.
67.
SmallMario L.NewmanKatherine. 2001. “Urban Poverty afterThe Truly Disadvantaged: The Rediscovery of the Family, the Neighborhood, and Culture.” Annual Review of Sociology27:23–45.
68.
SouthScott J.CrowderKyle D.1997a. “Escaping Distressed Neighborhoods: Individual, Community, and Metropolitan Influences.” American Journal of Sociology102:1040–84.
69.
SouthScott J.CrowderKyle D.1997b. “Residential Mobility between Cities and Suburbs: Race, Suburbanization, and Back-to-the-City Moves.” Demography34:525–38.
70.
SouthScott J.CrowderKyle D.1998a. “Avenues and Barriers to Residential Mobility among Single Mothers.” Journal of Marriage and the Family60:866–77.
71.
SouthScott J.CrowderKyle D.1998b. “Housing Discrimination and Residential Mobility: Impacts for Blacks and Whites.” Population Research and Policy Review17:369–87.
72.
SouthScott J.CrowderKyle D.2010. “Neighborhood Poverty and Nonmarital Fertility: Spatial and Temporal Dimensions.” Journal of Marriage and Family72:89–104.
73.
SouthScott J.DeaneGlenn D.1993. “Race and Residential Mobility: Individual Determinants and Structural Constraints.” Social Forces72:147–67.
74.
SpeareAldenGoldscheiderFrances K.1987. “Effects of Marital Status Change on Residential Mobility.” Journal of Marriage and the Family49:455–64.
75.
TimberlakeJeffrey M.2007. “Racial and Ethnic Inequality in the Duration of Children’s Exposure to Neighborhood Poverty and Affluence.” Social Problems54:319–42.
76.
TurleyLópezRuth N.2003. “When Do Neighborhoods Matter? The Role of Race and Neighborhood Peers.” Social Science Research32:61–79.
77.
WilsonWilliam J.1987. The Truly Disadvantaged: The Inner City, the Underclass, and Public Policy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
78.
WilsonWilliam J.1996. When Work Disappears: The World of the New Urban Poor. New York: Vintage Books.
79.
WilsonWilliam J.2009. More Than Just Race: Being Black and Poor in the Inner City. New York: W. W. Norton & Company.
80.
YingerJohn. 1995. Closed Doors, Opportunities Lost: The Continuing Costs of Housing Discrimination. New York: Russell Sage.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
