This article explores the national factors that predict bishops’ votes on two of the most contentious issues at the Second Vatican Council. Using data obtained from the Vatican Secret Archive, analyses demonstrate that rational choice oriented theory in the sociology of religion that focuses on competition is limited. While competition is important to religious leaders’ actions, its effects can be understood only in relation to other crucial characteristics of the social environment within which leaders operate. These characteristics, which we derive from Neo-Institutional Theory (NIT), shape leaders’ interests and often lead them to prioritize concerns about their institutions’ legitimacy over the concerns about efficiency and growth rational choice theorists assume are predominant. Most NIT studies examine the population of firms within one organizational field. Because we hold firm constant and examine how variation in the type of organizational field (supplied by the more than 100 countries in our analyses) predicts firm leaders’ actions, this study represents a unique test of NIT.
AlberigoGiuseppeKomonchakJoseph, eds. 1995. History of Vatican II: Volume I: Announcing and Preparing Vatican Council II: Toward a New Era in Catholicism. English ed.Maryknoll, NY: Orbis Books
2.
AlberigoGiuseppeKomonchakJoseph. 1997. History of Vatican II: Volume II: The Formation of the Council’s Identity: First Period and Intersession October 1962 – September 1963. English ed.Maryknoll, NY: Orbis Books.
3.
AlberigoGiuseppeKomonchakJoseph. 2000. History of Vatican II: Volume III: The Mature Council: Second Period and Intersession: September 1963 – September 1964. English ed.Maryknoll, NY: Orbis Books.
4.
AllisonPaul D.1999. Multiple Regression, A Primer. Thousand Oaks, CA: Pine Forge Press.
ArmstrongElizabeth A.2002. Forging Gay Identities: Organizing Sexuality in San Francisco, 1950–1994. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
7.
BaumJoel A. C.IngramPaul. 1998. “Population-Level Learning in the Manhattan Hotel Industry, 1898–1980.” Management Science44:996–1016.
8.
BaumJoel A. C.MeziasStephen J.1992. “Localized Competition and Organizational Failure in the Manhattan Hotel Industry, 1898–1990.” Administrative Science Quarterly37:580–604.
9.
BenderCourtney. 2000. Heaven’s Kitchen: Living Religion at God’s Love We Deliver. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
10.
BergerPeter. 1963. “A Market Model for the Analysis of Ecumenicity.” Social Research30:77–93.
11.
BinderAmy. 2007. “For Love and Money: Organizations’ Creative Responses to Multiple Environmental Logics.” Theory and Society36:547–71.
12.
BlauJudith R.ReddingKentLandKenneth C.1993. “Ethno-cultural Cleavages and the Growth of Church Membership in the United States.” Sociological Forum8:609–637.
13.
BreaultKevin D.1989. “New Evidence on Religious Pluralism, Urbanism, and Religious Participation.” American Sociological Review54:1048–53.
14.
BrownRobert McAfee. 1967. The Ecumenical Revolution: An Interpretation of the Catholic-Protestant Dialogue. Garden City, NY: Doubleday.
15.
BurnsGene. 1992. “Commitments and Non-commitments: The Social Radicalism of U.S. Catholic Bishops.” Theory and Society21:703–733.
16.
BurnsGene. 1990. “The Politics of Ideology: The Papal Struggle with Liberalism.” American Journal of Sociology95:1123–52.
17.
CarrollGlenn R.WadeJames B.1991. “Density Dependence in the Evolution of the American Brewing Industry Across Different Levels of Analysis.” Social Science Research20:271–302.
18.
CasanovaJosé. 1994. Public Religions in the Modern World. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
19.
ChavesMark. 1996. “Ordaining Women: The Diffusion of an Organizational Innovation.” American Journal of Sociology101:840–73.
20.
ChavesMark. 1997. Ordaining Women: Culture and Conflict in Religious Organizations. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
21.
ChavesMarkCannDavid E.1992. “Regulation, Pluralism and Religious Market Structure.” Rationality and Society4:272–90.
22.
ChavesMarkGorskiPhilip. 2001. “Religious Pluralism and Religious Participation.” Annual Review of Sociology27:261–81.
23.
ChavesMarkSchraederPeter J.SprindysMario. 1994. “State Religion and Muslim Religious Vitality in the Industrialized West.” Journal of Politics56:1087–97.
24.
ClemensElisabeth S.1997. The People’s Lobby: Organizational Innovation and the Rise of Interest Group Politics. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago.
25.
CrowsonRobert L.BoydWilliam L.MawhinneyHanne B., eds. 1996. The Politics of Education and the New Institutionalism: Reinventing the American School. Washington, DC: Falmer Press.
26.
DemerathNicholas J.HallPeter DobkinWilliamsRhysSchmidtTerry. 1998. Sacred Companies. New York: Oxford University Press.
27.
DillonMichele. 1999. Catholic Identity: Balancing Reason, Faith and Power. New York: Cambridge University Press.
28.
DiMaggioPaul J.PowellWalter W.1983. “The Iron Cage Revisited: Institutional Isomorphism and Collective Rationality in Organizational Fields.” American Sociological Review48:147–60.
29.
DobbinFrank. 1995. “The Origins of Economic Principles: Railway Entrepreneurs and Public Policy in 19th Century America.” Pp. 244–77 in The Institutional Construction of Organizations: International and Longitudinal Studies, edited by ScottW. R.ChristensenS.Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
30.
“Ecumenical Chronicle: Report of the Executive Committee to the Central Committee, At Paris, 1962.”1962. Ecumenical Review15:67–81.
31.
FinkeRoger. 2004. “Innovative Returns to Tradition: Using Core Teachings as the Foundation for Innovative Accommodation.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion43:19–34.
32.
FinkeRogerDoughertyKevin. 2002. “The Effects of Professional Training: The Social and Religious Capital Acquired in Seminaries.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion41:103–120.
33.
FinkeRogerGuestAvery M.StarkRodney. 1996. “Mobilizing Local Religious Markets: Religious Pluralism in the Empire State, 1855 to 1865.” American Sociological Review61:203–218.
34.
FinkeRogerIannacconeLaurence R.1993. “Supply-Side Explanations for Religious Change.” The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science527:27–39.
35.
FinkeRogerStarkRodney. 1988. “Religious Economies and Sacred Canopies: Religious Mobilization in American Cities, 1906.” American Sociological Review53:41–49.
36.
FinkeRogerStarkRodney. 1992. The Churching of America, 1776–1990. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
37.
FinkeRogerStarkRodney. 1998. “Reply to Olson: Religious Choice and Competition.” American Sociological Review63:761–66.
38.
FligsteinNeil. 1996. “Markets as Politics: A Political-Cultural Approach to Market Institutions.” American Sociological Review61:656–73.
39.
FoyFelician A., ed. 1954. 1954 National Catholic Almanac. Paterson, NJ: St. Anthony’s Guild.
40.
FoyFelician A.1955. 1955 National Catholic Almanac. Paterson, NJ: St. Anthony’s Guild.
41.
FoyFelician A.1958. 1958 National Catholic Almanac. Paterson, NJ: St. Anthony’s Guild.
42.
FoyFelician A.1966. 1966 National Catholic Almanac. Paterson, NJ: St. Anthony’s Guild.
43.
GainesDavid P.1966. The World Council of Churches: A Study of its Background and History. Peterborough, NH: Richard R. Smith Co.
44.
GiddensAnthony. 1979. Central Problems in Social Theory: Action, Structure, and Contradiction in Social Analysis. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
45.
GillAnthony. 1999. “Government Regulation, Social Anomie and Protestant Growth in Latin America: A Cross-National Analysis.” Rationality and Society11:287–316.
46.
GreeleyAndrew. 2004. The Catholic Revolution: New Wine, Old Wineskins, and the Second Vatican Council. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
47.
GrimBrian J.FinkeRoger. 2007. “Religious Persecution in Cross-National Context: Clashing Civilizations or Regulated Religious Economies?” American Sociological Review72:633–58.
48.
HageJerald T.1999. “Organizational Innovation and Organizational Change.” Annual Review of Sociology25:597–622.
49.
HambergEva M.PetterssonThorleif. 1994. “The Religious Market: Denominational Competition and Religious Participation in Contemporary Sweden.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion33:205–216.
50.
HannanMichael T.CarrollGlenn R.DundonElizabeth A.TorresJohn Charles. 1995. “Organizational Evolution in a Multinational Context: Entries of Automobile Manufacturers in Belgium, Britain, France, Germany, and Italy.” American Sociological Review60:509–528.
51.
HastingsAdrian. 1994. The Church in Africa, 1450–1950. Oxford, UK: Clarendon Press.
52.
HavemanHeather H.1993. “Organizational Size and Change: Diversification in the Savings and Loan Industry after Deregulation.” Administrative Science Quarterly38:20–50.
53.
HechterMichaelKanazawaSatoshi. 1997. “Sociological Rational Choice Theory.” Annual Review of Sociology23:191–214.
54.
IannacconeLaurence R.1991. “The Consequences of Religious Market Structure: Adam Smith and the Economics of Religion.” Rationality and Society3:156–77.
55.
IannacconeLaurence R.1994. “Why Strict Churches Are Strong.” American Journal of Sociology99:1180–1211.
56.
ImmergutEllen. 1998. “The Theoretical Core of the New Institutionalism.” Politics and Society26:5–35.
57.
IngramPaulClayKaren. 2000. “The Choice-Within-Constraints New Institutionalism and Implications for Sociology.” Annual Review of Sociology26:525–47.
58.
JelenTedWilcoxClyde. 1998. “Context and Conscience: The Catholic Church as an Agent of Political Socialization in Western Europe.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion37:28–40.
59.
JohnsonCurtis D.1995. “Religious Competition and Demand-Side Revivalism? Evaluating the Social Influences on New York State Evangelism in the 1830s.” Social Science History19:1–30.
60.
KinderErnst. 1955. “Protestant–Roman Catholic Encounter: An Ecumenical Obligation.” The Ecumenical Review7:338–46.
61.
KollmanPaul. 2005. The Evangelization of Slaves and Catholic Origins in Eastern Africa. Maryknoll, NY: Orbis Books.
62.
KraatzMatthew S.ZajacEdward J.1996. “Exploring the Limits of New Institutionalism: The Causes and Consequences of Illegitimate Organizational Change.” American Sociological Review61:812–36.
63.
KurtzLester R.1986. The Politics of Heresy: The Modernist Crisis in Roman Catholicism. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
64.
LandKenneth C.DeaneGlennBlauJudith R.1991. “Religious Pluralism and Church Membership: A Spatial Diffusion Model.” American Sociological Review56:237–49.
65.
LaurentinRené. 1964. “The Blessed Virgin at the Council.” Marian Library Studies 109. Dayton, OH: Marian Library of the University of Dayton.
66.
LechnerFrank J.1996. “Secularization in the Netherlands?” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion35:252–65.
67.
LounsburyMichael. 2005. “Institutional Variation in the Evolution of Social Movements: Competing Logics and the Spread of Recycling Advocacy Groups.” Pp. 73–95 in Social Movements and Organization Theory, edited by DavisG. F.McAdamD.ScottW. R.ZaldM. N.New York: Cambridge University Press.
68.
McAdamDougScottW. Richard. 2005. “Organizations and Movements.” Pp. 4–40 in Social Movements and Organization Theory, edited by DavisG. F.McAdamD.ScottW. R.ZaldM. N.New York: Cambridge University Press.
69.
McKennaJoseph. 1997. Finding a Social Voice: The Church and Marxism in Africa. Bronx, NY: Fordham University Press.
MeyerJohn W.1983. “Centralization of Funding and Control in Educational Governance.” Pp. 179–98 in Organizational Environments: Ritual and Rationality, edited by MeyerJ. W.ScottW. R.Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
72.
MeyerJohn W.RamirezFrancisco O.SoysalYasemin Nuhoglu. 1992. “World Expansion of Mass Education, 1870–1980.” Sociology of Education65:128–49.
73.
MeyerJohn W.RowanBrian. 1978. “The Structure of Educational Organizations.” Pp. 78–109 in Environments and Organizations, edited by MeyerM. W.San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
74.
MeziasStephen J.1995. “Using Institutional Theory to Understand For-Profit Sectors: The Case of Financial Reporting Standards.” Pp. 164–98 in The Institutional Construction of Organizations: International and Longitudinal Studies, edited by ScottW. R.ChristensenS.Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
75.
MinkoffDebra C.1994. “From Service Provision to Institutional Advocacy: The Shifting Legitimacy of Organizational Forms.” Social Forces72:943–69.
76.
OlsonDaniel V. A.1998. “Religious Pluralism in Contemporary U.S. Counties.” American Sociological Review63:759–61.
77.
OlsonDaniel V. A.1999. “Religious Pluralism and U.S. Church Membership: A Reassessment.” Sociology of Religion60:149–73.
78.
OlsonDaniel V. A.HadawayC. Kirk. 1999. “Religious Pluralism and Affiliation among Canadian Counties and Cities.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion38:490–508.
79.
PerlPaulOlsonDaniel V. A.2000. “Religious Market Share and Intensity of Church Involvement in Five Denominations.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion39:12–31.
80.
RaoHayagreeva. 1998. “Caveat Emptor: The Constructions of Nonprofit Consumer Watchdog Organizations.” American Journal of Sociology103:912–61.
81.
RowanBrian. 1982. “Organizational Structure and the Institutional Environment: The Case of Public Schools.” Administrative Science Quarterly27:259–79.
82.
RowanBrian. 2006. “The New Institutionalism and the Study of Educational Organizations: Changing Ideas for Changing Times.” Pp. 15–32 in The New Institutionalism in Education, edited by MeyerH. D.RowanB.Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.
83.
RuefMartin W.ScottW. Richard. 1998. “A Multidimensional Model of Organizational Legitimacy: Hospital Survival in Changing Institutional Environments.” Administrative Science Quarterly43:877–904.
84.
RynneXavier. 1968. Vatican Council II. New York: Farrar, Strauss and Giroux.
85.
SchneibergMarc. 2002. “Organizational Heterogeneity and the Production of New Forms: Politics, Social Movements, and Mutual Companies in American Fire Insurance.” Research in the Sociology of Organizations19:39–89.
86.
SchoferEvanMeyerJohn W.2005. “The Worldwide Expansion of Higher Education in the Twentieth Century.” American Sociological Review70:898–920.
87.
ScottW. RichardMeyerJohn W.1991. “The Organization of Societal Sectors: Propositions and Early Evidence.” Pp. 108–140 in The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis, edited by PowellW. W.DiMaggioP. J.Chicago, IL: University of Chicago.
88.
ScottW. RichardRuefMartinMendelPeter J.CaronnaCarol A.2000. Institutional Change and Healthcare Organizations: From Professional Dominance to Managed Care. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago.
89.
SeidlerJohn. 1979. “Priest Resignations in a Lazy Monopoly.” American Sociological Review44:763–83.
90.
SeidlerJohnMeyerKatherine. 1989. Conflict and Change in the Catholic Church. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
91.
SkydsgaardK. E.1957. One in Christ: Protestant and Catholic. Philadelphia, PA: Muhlenberg Press.
92.
SmithChristian. 1991. The Emergence of Liberation Theology: Radical Religion and Social Movement Theory. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
93.
SnowDavid A.BenfordRobert D.1992. “Master Frames and Cycles of Protest.” Pp. 133–55 in Frontiers in Social Movement Theory, edited by MorrisA. D.MuellerC. M.New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
94.
StarkRodney. 1992. “Do Catholic Societies Really Exist?” Rationality and Society4:261–71.
95.
StarkRodney. 1993. “Research Note: Europe’s Receptivity toNew Religious Movements: Round Two.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion32:389–97.
96.
StarkRodneyFinkeRoger. 2000. Acts of Faith: Explaining the Human Side of Religion. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
97.
StarkRodneyFinkeRogerIannacconeLaurence R.1995. “Pluralism and Piety: England and Wales, 1851.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion36:431–44.
98.
StarkRodneyIannacconeLaurence R.1994. “A Supply-Side Reinterpretation of the ‘Secularization’ of Europe.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion33:230–52.
99.
StarkRodneyIannacconeLaurence R.1996. “Response to Lechner: Recent Religious Declines in Quebec, Poland and the Netherlands: A Theory Vindicated.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion35:265–71.
100.
ToddJohn M.1956. Catholicism and the Ecumenical Movement. London, UK: Longmans, Green and Company.
101.
VerweijJohanEsterPeterNautaRein. 1997. “Secularization as an Economic and Cultural Phenomenon: A Cross-National Analysis.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion36:309–324.
102.
Visser’t HooftW. A.1982. The Genesis and Formation of the World Council of Churches. Geneva, Switzerland: World Council of Churches.
103.
WarnerStephen R.1993. “Work in Progress: Toward a New Paradigm for the Sociological Study of Religion in the United States.” American Journal of Sociology98:1044–93.
104.
WholeyDouglas R.ChristiansonJon B.SanchezSusan M.1992. “Organization Size and Failure among Health Maintenance Organizations.” American Sociological Review57:829–42.
105.
WildeMelissa J.2001. “From Excommunication to Nullification: Testing and Extending Religious Competition Theories of Religious Marketing With the Case of Catholic Marital Annulments.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion40:235–49.
106.
WildeMelissa J.2007. Vatican II: A Sociological Analysis of Religious Change. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
WuthnowRobert. 1988. The Restructuring of American Religion. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
109.
YoungLawrence A., ed. 1997. Rational Choice Theory and Religion: Summary and Assessment. New York: Routledge Press.
110.
ZaretDavid. 1985. The Heavenly Contract: Ideology and Organization in Pre-Revolutionary Puritanism. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
